# Digital Life Act

True Tomorrow Foundation analysis · October 27, 2026

The draft regulates the functions people actually use—connectivity, billing, distribution, advertising and data—rather than treating every digital service as the same kind of business. Its central strength is the connection between usable rights, explicit public resources and limits on official power. Its breadth creates substantial coordination and delivery demands.

Foundation assessment: a substantial policy framework with a coherent commitment to practical access and accountable power. The strongest features are explicit duties, funding limits, prospective transition, editorial firewalls and separation of public spending from claimed economic benefits. Before introduction it needs a current-law crosswalk, official legislative drafting, enrollment and administrative cost estimates, a complete implementation calendar, constitutional review and independent budget scoring. Publication makes the proposal available for scrutiny; it does not establish legislative readiness or stakeholder endorsement.

Foundation analysis published October 27, 2026. This is model legislation, not introduced or enacted law. The supplied annex states that its research runs through October 9, 2026. Selected official-source checks and reproducible arithmetic are not an exhaustive legal audit, a legal opinion, a forecast of outcomes or an official CBO/JCT score.

## Four analytical lenses

### Policy design

Price disclosure, cancellation, portability, payment records and repair rights address the practical cost of leaving a service. Broadband benefits, infrastructure investment and accessible devices address different barriers to participation. A legal right to switch has limited value without an affordable, usable alternative.

### Rights and legal boundaries

The text protects editorial independence, rejects a general content-carriage mandate and distinguishes a service’s own commercial conduct from third-party expression. A narrow digital-replica right supplements existing law. These are substantive design choices; their application still needs First Amendment, copyright, property, federalism and remedies review.

### Fiscal findings

The nine accounts add to $295B in proposed nominal budget authority: $37B annually in program years 1–5 and $22B in years 6–10. These are direct appropriation clauses, not authorizations to seek funding later. There is no new general tax or assumed offset, and the schedule is not an official estimate of outlays or deficit effects.

### Delivery and distribution

FCC, FTC, Commerce, Labor and other institutions would need coordinated enrollment, payments, complaints, standards and oversight. Households, creators and small firms may gain practical agency while providers and public bodies bear implementation costs. Smaller entities receive specific relief, not blanket exemption. Participation, prices, staffing and sustained service determine actual outcomes.

## Proposed mechanisms

### Affordable, usable connections

Titles III, V–X

Standalone open-internet duties accompany scheduled household benefits of $40 per month, or $75 on qualifying Tribal lands. Eligibility generally reaches 200% of the poverty guideline or specified assistance pathways. Deployment, infrastructure access, entrant support and Tribal consent address physical and institutional barriers. Benefits remain limited by actual eligible charges and available funds.

### Honest terms and a practical exit

Titles IV and XVI

Mandatory seller charges belong in the advertised price; renewal requires affirmative consent; online enrollment must have accessible online cancellation. Provider-attributable fixed-service outages over four consecutive hours trigger minimum credits, subject to defined exceptions. Purchased digital works require clear license terms and continuity remedies; the draft does not promise perpetual servers or override copyright.

### Privacy, access and safety

Titles XI–XIV and XX

Risk-based security and accessible emergency communications sit alongside data minimization, sensitive-data protections, advertising choices and usable disability access. Behavioral advertising to known under-18 users is restricted while contextual advertising remains possible. Age assurance should minimize data collection. Government access remains subject to lawful process.

### Creative work and personal identity

Title XVII

Creators receive clearer rights summaries, earnings statements and audit routes. A defined right addresses knowing unauthorized realistic replicas understood as authentic performances or endorsements, with expressive exceptions and a hosting safe harbor. It belongs to living individuals and is not ownership of an artistic style. AI training and fair-use questions remain under copyright law.

### Competition with accountable measurement

Titles VIII, XVIII and XIX

Targeted bottleneck findings and proportionate commercial-access remedies are paired with advertising fee transparency, enforceable spending controls, invalid-traffic correction and audit access. Measurement must distinguish modeled attribution from evidence of causal impact. The text does not require a single measurement model or turn every editorial selection into a competition violation.

### Independent local information

Titles XV, XXI and XXII

The draft proposes a prospective 39% national television reach limit without a UHF discount, alongside reliance and transition rules. Public media and local reporting receive separate funding with editorial firewalls. Journalism support may reimburse up to 50% of eligible expense, subject to annual worker, outlet and controlled-group caps. Funding does not buy favorable coverage or ownership of the reporting.

### Platforms, devices and working capacity

Titles XXIII–XXV

Commercial account review, release of undisputed earned funds, usable exports, repair information and limits on unjustified parts locks reduce dependence. The draft preserves lawful editorial discretion and security exceptions. Training and shared resources support implementation; neither a portability rule nor a training appropriation guarantees a working alternative or a job.

### Remedies and public accountability

Titles I–II and XXVI–XXX

Concrete injury, causation and specified remedies govern private claims. Courts impose contested civil penalties, while the draft limits duplicate recovery and allows claimants to reject predispute arbitration for covered claims. Federalism rules generally preserve stronger State protections except for defined conflicts. Public registers, independent evaluation and funding expiration rules make delivery inspectable.

## Funding reproduction

$37B × 5 + $22B × 5 = $295B of proposed direct nominal budget authority. $185B is scheduled through program year 5. Program year 1 is the first Federal fiscal year beginning after enactment. No new general tax or assumed offset is included. This schedule does not estimate outlays, interest, revenues, mandates or deficit effects.

| Account | Annual $B | Years | Total $B | Section |
| --- | ---: | --- | ---: | --- |
| Household connectivity | 15 | 1–10 | 150 | 2902 |
| Connectivity expansion | 12 | 1–5 | 60 | 2903 |
| Resilience and emergency systems | 3 | 1–5 | 15 | 2904 |
| Inclusion and accessibility | 1.5 | 1–10 | 15 | 2905 |
| Public media access | 1 | 1–10 | 10 | 2906 |
| Local journalism | 1.5 | 1–10 | 15 | 2907 |
| Workforce and small business | 1 | 1–10 | 10 | 2908 |
| Research, preservation and evaluation | 0.75 | 1–10 | 7.5 | 2909 |
| Administration and enforcement | 1.25 | 1–10 | 12.5 | 2910 |

The simplified benefit illustration uses 30 million full-year households, a 10% Tribal-rate share and 3% administration. Full scheduled benefits require $15.66B against $14.55B available before reserves, a $1.11B gap. This is not an enrollment forecast or a prediction of the statutory adjustment. Actual eligible charges, reserves, carryover and partial-year use can change payments.

## Review questions

### Test enrollment against a capped benefit account

§§ 501–507, 516, 2902

At the maximum 3% administrative share, $14.55B of the $15B annual account remains for benefits before reserves. That covers about 30.31 million full-year households at $40, or 16.17 million at $75, assuming each receives its full scheduled amount. A mixed population changes capacity. These are arithmetic ceilings, not forecasts of eligibility or take-up. Obtain enrollment, price, churn and reserve estimates before deciding whether the schedule is sufficient. Section 507 requires prospective proportional adjustments and at least 120 days’ notice of a reduction.

### Make the timetable work across agencies

§§ 210, 412, 516, 1312, 1712, 2312, 2812, 3009–3010

The general private-duty date is 24 months after enactment, but contracts, creator agreements and platform duties have specific 18-month provisions. The enrollment launch is due within twelve months after household funds first become available, not automatically twelve months after enactment. Reconcile title-specific standards, provider testing, safe notices and complaint systems. Agencies’ planning calendars do not amend statutory deadlines.

### Preserve the boundary between transactions and expression

§§ 107, 1507, 1707–1714, 2303, 2307, 3003

Payment disputes and fraudulent commercial promises can coexist with protected editorial decisions in the same account. Test proposed disclosure, account-restoration and replica orders against the actual function affected. News, parody and satire exceptions require workable notice handling and protection against abusive claims. The narrow Section 230 amendment should be cross-checked against the operative replica claims and the separate copyright safe harbor. A savings clause alone cannot establish constitutionality.

### Evaluate federalism and the cost of overlapping duties

§§ 105, 113, 806, 1311, 2403, 2801–2804, 3005

A Federal privacy floor retains stronger State protections where simultaneous compliance is possible. Coverage thresholds differ by function; a small firm may be an advertiser, provider, creator distributor and device seller at once. Counsel should produce a duty-by-duty preemption map, while agencies test shared reporting and affordable compliance tools. Infrastructure access also requires property, compensation, local safety and Tribal-sovereignty review.

### Develop evidence for the broadcast and funding choices

§§ 1501–1512, 2202–2206, 2906–2907

The 39% ownership cap, removal of the UHF discount and reliance treatment are proposed legislative choices. This review does not represent them as current FCC rules. Congress would need evidence on local competition, audience measurement, market viability and transition costs. Reporting grants need an objective allocation method that reaches entrants and underserved communities while testing additional reporting capacity and protecting confidential sources.

### Map each right to a usable remedy

§§ 2705–2717, 2721

Private actions apply to enumerated titles and require concrete injury and causation. Statutory damages are available for specified violations, with a distinct replica regime; they are not automatic awards for every omission. Check the alignment of title-specific promises, complaint routes, public enforcement, nonmonetary claims against government and court jurisdiction. Model litigation and insurance costs as well as the value of redress.

### Keep the fiscal categories separate

§§ 2613, 2901–2916

The draft supplies $295B in direct nominal budget authority. Outlays depend on enrollment, awards, carryover and payment timing; debt-service costs, revenues and mandate effects require separate analysis. The text supplies no general new industry assessment and no assumed growth offset. Scheduled appropriations end, while independently continuing rights do not automatically expire. An extension after year 10 would require new legislation and cannot be treated as already funded.

## Selected independent evidence

### Reliable maps and coordinated awards matter

GAO’s April 2025 broadband review identified uncertainty in availability-data quality and incomplete coordination practices. This supports the draft’s location verification and duplicate-funding controls. It does not establish that the additional $60B deployment appropriation is the right amount.

[GAO-25-107207 · Broadband data and coordination](https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-107207)

### Statutory authority needs an explicit foundation

The Sixth Circuit’s January 2025 opinion held that the FCC could not impose the challenged 2024 open-internet regime through its reading of existing telecommunications-service authority. The draft responds with standalone congressional duties. That is a legislative design response, not a prediction about the validity of every new rule.

[Sixth Circuit · In re MCP No. 185](https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/25a0002p-06.pdf)

### Editorial discretion requires analysis by function

Moody v. NetChoice vacated and remanded the judgments after finding inadequate analysis of the challenged laws’ scope. Its treatment of editorial discretion supports examining the particular platform function and burden. It does not approve this draft’s disclosures or account procedures.

[Supreme Court · Moody v. NetChoice](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/22-277_d18f.pdf)

### Cancellation policy is not an unchanged legal baseline

The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC’s 2024 amended Negative Option Rule in July 2025. The FTC rule page lists a March 11, 2026 advance-notice proceeding. The draft’s cancellation terms should be understood as proposed statutory duties, with their own scope and dates, rather than a claim that the vacated rule is operative.

[Eighth Circuit · Custom Communications v. FTC](https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/25/07/243137P.pdf) · [FTC · Negative Option Rule proceeding](https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/rules/negative-option-rule)

### Identity and copyright require distinct treatment

The Copyright Office’s July 2024 report examines realistic digital replicas separately from other AI copyright questions. It supplies policy context for a personal-identity remedy, not an endorsement of this draft’s commercial-use boundary, term, damages or hosting procedure. The draft leaves training and fair-use questions to copyright law.

[Copyright Office · Digital Replicas report](https://www.copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-and-Artificial-Intelligence-Part-1-Digital-Replicas-Report.pdf)

## Conditional implementation

### Upon hypothetical enactment

Administrative authority and restrictions on public administration generally begin; agencies prepare systems within available appropriations.

§§ 2812, 3012

### 90–180 days

Public register within 90 days, agency calendar within 120 days, and implementation-capacity assessments within 180 days; prepare the benefit program’s operational rules.

§§ 210, 516, 3009–3010

### First available household funding

Program year 1 is the first Federal fiscal year beginning after enactment. Open enrollment within twelve months after the household funds first become available; test providers and payment systems before launch.

§§ 111, 516, 2902

### 18–24 months after enactment

Apply each title’s actual compliance date. Contracts and creator agreements have specific rules; general private duties and privacy take effect at 24 months. Smaller platforms receive limited additional time for export and review systems.

§§ 412, 1312, 1712, 2312, 2812

### Program years 1–10 and beyond

Direct annual authority is $37B in years 1–5 and $22B in years 6–10. Evaluate outcomes and plan wind-down or reauthorization. Some account balances remain available beyond their installment years; continuing rights have no automatic funding sunset.

§§ 2615, 2902–2913, 3012

## Distribution

### Households and disabled users

May gain lower qualifying bills, usable access, better notices and remedies. Eligibility, actual service quality, accessible interfaces and prospective benefit reductions determine practical value.

### Creators and local newsrooms

May gain transparent compensation, identity protections and reporting support. Audit cost, small-claim access, abusive notices and editorial insulation need operational testing.

### Small businesses and entrants

May gain service-level clarity, advertising records, switching routes and infrastructure access. The cumulative cost of several covered functions could still favor larger incumbents.

### Providers, platforms and public institutions

Receive defined authority, transition and review procedures while taking on compliance and delivery work. Sustainable network operation, security, staffing and vendor independence need evidence beyond announced awards.

## Method

The Foundation reviewed the supplied packet’s structure and principal operative mechanisms, reproduced the nine-account appropriation schedule and prepared selected provision-based findings. This edition changes the Act’s name to Digital Life Act in the title, short-title clause, internal cross-reference, research-annex reference and core title metadata. All other document contents, discussion-draft labels, both tables and 41 external hyperlinks are retained. The downloadable DOCX and web reader use the same renamed edition. The source author’s annex and source register are preserved apart from the Act’s name and are not represented as independently verified in full. Six selected official sources were checked separately. No claim is made of a comprehensive legal citator search, verification of every cross-reference, empirical impact model, official score or page-by-page visual certification of the original Word layout.

## Selected official sources

- [GAO-25-107207 · Broadband data and coordination](https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-107207) — Official report published April 17, 2025; page and findings checked October 27, 2026.

- [Sixth Circuit · In re MCP No. 185](https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/25a0002p-06.pdf) — Official January 2, 2025 opinion; selected statutory-authority reasoning checked October 27, 2026.

- [Supreme Court · Moody v. NetChoice](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/22-277_d18f.pdf) — Official July 1, 2024 opinion; scope, remand and editorial-discretion discussion checked October 27, 2026.

- [Eighth Circuit · Custom Communications v. FTC](https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/25/07/243137P.pdf) — Official July 8, 2025 opinion; vacatur checked October 27, 2026.

- [FTC · Negative Option Rule proceeding](https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/rules/negative-option-rule) — Official rule page listing the March 11, 2026 advance notice; checked October 27, 2026.

- [Copyright Office · Digital Replicas report](https://www.copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-and-Artificial-Intelligence-Part-1-Digital-Replicas-Report.pdf) — Official July 2024 report; identity/copyright distinctions checked October 27, 2026.
