An imagined limestone exchange hall with three independent bronze alcoves, a red stone reading table and accessible shared passages.

Policy Lab / Digital life & public systems

Digital
Life Act

Federal discussion draft · Not introduced or enacted

Published October 27, 2026

Access to connection.
Agency in digital life.

A proposed federal framework connecting affordable broadband, fair subscriptions and media purchases, privacy, accessibility, creator compensation, market competition, independent journalism, repair and public accountability, with $295 billion in direct appropriations over ten program years.

Proposed architecture
30 titles
Operative sections
442
Direct budget authority
$295B
Scheduled funding
10 program years

Proposed nominal appropriations · No assumed offset · No official budget score

Document & publication details
Bill
Discussion draft · no official bill number
Sponsor
No congressional sponsor identified in the supplied packet
Congress
119th Congress, 2d session in source heading · not introduced
Committee referral
Potential communications, judiciary, appropriations, labor and Tribal jurisdiction; no official referral
Filing date
Not filed · Published October 27, 2026
Submission contents
Renamed discussion-draft DOCX, all 30 titles and 442 sections, the supplied research annex and 41 source links, separate Foundation analysis, funding ledger and source integrity record

The source calls this a discussion draft. Its research annex states an October 9, 2026 research cutoff. No official filing or referral is represented.

A guide to this proposal

Start with the idea.
Go as deep as you need.

The proposal would make it easier to connect, understand a bill, cancel a service, protect personal information, receive earned creative income and challenge commercial mistakes. It pairs those rights with capped public investment and limits on government interference in lawful expression.

Affordable connectivityConsumer and creator rightsPrivacy and accessibilityIndependent mediaCompetition and public accountability
Document architecture
30 titles · 442 sections · nonstatutory research annex
Complete source text
67,384 words

Analysis is commentary. Model text is a proposal. Fiscal scenarios, where provided, are illustrative.

Foundation Analysis

Connection should carry practical rights.

The draft regulates the functions people actually use—connectivity, billing, distribution, advertising and data—rather than treating every digital service as the same kind of business. Its central strength is the connection between usable rights, explicit public resources and limits on official power. Its breadth creates substantial coordination and delivery demands.

In plain language: The proposal would make it easier to connect, understand a bill, cancel a service, protect personal information, receive earned creative income and challenge commercial mistakes. It pairs those rights with capped public investment and limits on government interference in lawful expression.

01

Policy design

Price disclosure, cancellation, portability, payment records and repair rights address the practical cost of leaving a service. Broadband benefits, infrastructure investment and accessible devices address different barriers to participation. A legal right to switch has limited value without an affordable, usable alternative.

02

Rights and legal boundaries

The text protects editorial independence, rejects a general content-carriage mandate and distinguishes a service’s own commercial conduct from third-party expression. A narrow digital-replica right supplements existing law. These are substantive design choices; their application still needs First Amendment, copyright, property, federalism and remedies review.

03

Fiscal findings

The nine accounts add to $295B in proposed nominal budget authority: $37B annually in program years 1–5 and $22B in years 6–10. These are direct appropriation clauses, not authorizations to seek funding later. There is no new general tax or assumed offset, and the schedule is not an official estimate of outlays or deficit effects.

04

Delivery and distribution

FCC, FTC, Commerce, Labor and other institutions would need coordinated enrollment, payments, complaints, standards and oversight. Households, creators and small firms may gain practical agency while providers and public bodies bear implementation costs. Smaller entities receive specific relief, not blanket exemption. Participation, prices, staffing and sustained service determine actual outcomes.

Foundation assessment

a substantial policy framework with a coherent commitment to practical access and accountable power. The strongest features are explicit duties, funding limits, prospective transition, editorial firewalls and separation of public spending from claimed economic benefits. Before introduction it needs a current-law crosswalk, official legislative drafting, enrollment and administrative cost estimates, a complete implementation calendar, constitutional review and independent budget scoring. Publication makes the proposal available for scrutiny; it does not establish legislative readiness or stakeholder endorsement.

Foundation analysis published October 27, 2026. This is model legislation, not introduced or enacted law. The supplied annex states that its research runs through October 9, 2026. Selected official-source checks and reproducible arithmetic are not an exhaustive legal audit, a legal opinion, a forecast of outcomes or an official CBO/JCT score.

02 / What the proposal would do

Rights along the whole journey.

01

Connect

A usable connection and affordable service.

§ 501
02

Choose

Clear terms, practical switching and exit.

§ 405
03

Create

Earned income and control of identity.

§ 1707
04

Challenge

Evidence, correction and judicial review.

§ 2709

Titles III, V–X

Affordable, usable connections

Standalone open-internet duties accompany scheduled household benefits of $40 per month, or $75 on qualifying Tribal lands. Eligibility generally reaches 200% of the poverty guideline or specified assistance pathways. Deployment, infrastructure access, entrant support and Tribal consent address physical and institutional barriers. Benefits remain limited by actual eligible charges and available funds.

§ 301 · § 501 · § 507 · § 601 · § 902

Titles IV and XVI

Honest terms and a practical exit

Mandatory seller charges belong in the advertised price; renewal requires affirmative consent; online enrollment must have accessible online cancellation. Provider-attributable fixed-service outages over four consecutive hours trigger minimum credits, subject to defined exceptions. Purchased digital works require clear license terms and continuity remedies; the draft does not promise perpetual servers or override copyright.

§ 402 · § 405 · § 408 · § 1603 · § 1614

Titles XI–XIV and XX

Privacy, access and safety

Risk-based security and accessible emergency communications sit alongside data minimization, sensitive-data protections, advertising choices and usable disability access. Behavioral advertising to known under-18 users is restricted while contextual advertising remains possible. Age assurance should minimize data collection. Government access remains subject to lawful process.

§ 1101 · § 1204 · § 1302 · § 1304 · § 1401 · § 1909

Title XVII

Creative work and personal identity

Creators receive clearer rights summaries, earnings statements and audit routes. A defined right addresses knowing unauthorized realistic replicas understood as authentic performances or endorsements, with expressive exceptions and a hosting safe harbor. It belongs to living individuals and is not ownership of an artistic style. AI training and fair-use questions remain under copyright law.

§ 1701 · § 1703 · § 1707 · § 1710 · § 1714

Titles VIII, XVIII and XIX

Competition with accountable measurement

Targeted bottleneck findings and proportionate commercial-access remedies are paired with advertising fee transparency, enforceable spending controls, invalid-traffic correction and audit access. Measurement must distinguish modeled attribution from evidence of causal impact. The text does not require a single measurement model or turn every editorial selection into a competition violation.

§ 1802 · § 1807 · § 1903 · § 1904 · § 1906

Titles XV, XXI and XXII

Independent local information

The draft proposes a prospective 39% national television reach limit without a UHF discount, alongside reliance and transition rules. Public media and local reporting receive separate funding with editorial firewalls. Journalism support may reimburse up to 50% of eligible expense, subject to annual worker, outlet and controlled-group caps. Funding does not buy favorable coverage or ownership of the reporting.

§ 1501 · § 1507 · § 2111 · § 2202 · § 2204

Titles XXIII–XXV

Platforms, devices and working capacity

Commercial account review, release of undisputed earned funds, usable exports, repair information and limits on unjustified parts locks reduce dependence. The draft preserves lawful editorial discretion and security exceptions. Training and shared resources support implementation; neither a portability rule nor a training appropriation guarantees a working alternative or a job.

§ 2303 · § 2304 · § 2403 · § 2404 · § 2501

Titles I–II and XXVI–XXX

Remedies and public accountability

Concrete injury, causation and specified remedies govern private claims. Courts impose contested civil penalties, while the draft limits duplicate recovery and allows claimants to reject predispute arbitration for covered claims. Federalism rules generally preserve stronger State protections except for defined conflicts. Public registers, independent evaluation and funding expiration rules make delivery inspectable.

§ 107 · § 2613 · § 2709 · § 2713 · § 2812 · § 2911

03 / Follow the proposed funding

$295 billion, explicitly bounded.

Nine accounts. Two annual funding levels. No claimed financing offset.

Title XXIX would directly appropriate the amounts below if enacted. Program year 1 is the first Federal fiscal year beginning after enactment. Nominal budget authority authorizes obligations; it is different from cash outlays, a deficit estimate or measured public benefit.

Proposed total$295B

Years 1–10
Nominal US dollars

Annual direct budget authority · $ billions
  1. 37Y1
  2. 37Y2
  3. 37Y3
  4. 37Y4
  5. 37Y5
  6. 22Y6
  7. 22Y7
  8. 22Y8
  9. 22Y9
  10. 22Y10

$185B through year 5 · $295B through year 10

Proposed appropriation schedule · sections 2902–2910
AccountAnnualProgram yearsTotalSource
Household connectivity$15B1–10$150B§ 2902
Connectivity expansion$12B1–5$60B§ 2903
Resilience and emergency systems$3B1–5$15B§ 2904
Inclusion and accessibility$1.5B1–10$15B§ 2905
Public media access$1B1–10$10B§ 2906
Local journalism$1.5B1–10$15B§ 2907
Workforce and small business$1B1–10$10B§ 2908
Research, preservation and evaluation$0.75B1–10$7.5B§ 2909
Administration and enforcement$1.25B1–10$12.5B§ 2910
Total$37B, then $22B1–10$295B§ 2911

Program administration is included within several account amounts; it is not added on top of this total. Availability and liquidation periods vary, so some funds can be paid after their annual installment period. No automatic extension beyond year 10 is included. § 2913 · § 2916

04 / Explore one funding constraint

How many households could it cover?

The draft schedules a $40 monthly benefit, or $75 on qualifying Tribal lands, limited to the actual eligible bill. This illustration tests full-year demand against the $15B annual household account. Change participation and the mix of rates to see the pressure on a capped appropriation.

At 30 million households and 10% receiving the Tribal rate, full scheduled benefits would require $15.66B per year. After 3% administration, $14.55B is available for benefits. $1.11B exceeds the simplified annual benefit budget. At this mix, that budget supports about 27.87 million full-year households at the scheduled rates.

This is a simplified sensitivity calculation, not a forecast, eligibility determination or promise of benefits. It assumes twelve months at the full scheduled rate for every participating household. Lower actual bills, partial-year participation, reserve needs, carryover, improper payments and future appropriations are not modeled. Zero administration is an assumption, not evidence of costless operation. Section 507’s actual adjustment process includes notice, cost controls and preservation of the ordinary-to-Tribal benefit ratio. § 507

05 / Evidence and its limits

A basis for scrutiny.

Selected official sources checked October 27, 2026. They establish context and constraints; they do not validate the draft’s thresholds, expenditure choices or constitutional treatment. The author’s separate 41-entry register remains intact in the source reader.

Reliable maps and coordinated awards matter

GAO’s April 2025 broadband review identified uncertainty in availability-data quality and incomplete coordination practices. This supports the draft’s location verification and duplicate-funding controls. It does not establish that the additional $60B deployment appropriation is the right amount.

Statutory authority needs an explicit foundation

The Sixth Circuit’s January 2025 opinion held that the FCC could not impose the challenged 2024 open-internet regime through its reading of existing telecommunications-service authority. The draft responds with standalone congressional duties. That is a legislative design response, not a prediction about the validity of every new rule.

Editorial discretion requires analysis by function

Moody v. NetChoice vacated and remanded the judgments after finding inadequate analysis of the challenged laws’ scope. Its treatment of editorial discretion supports examining the particular platform function and burden. It does not approve this draft’s disclosures or account procedures.

Cancellation policy is not an unchanged legal baseline

The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC’s 2024 amended Negative Option Rule in July 2025. The FTC rule page lists a March 11, 2026 advance-notice proceeding. The draft’s cancellation terms should be understood as proposed statutory duties, with their own scope and dates, rather than a claim that the vacated rule is operative.

Identity and copyright require distinct treatment

The Copyright Office’s July 2024 report examines realistic digital replicas separately from other AI copyright questions. It supplies policy context for a personal-identity remedy, not an endorsement of this draft’s commercial-use boundary, term, damages or hosting procedure. The draft leaves training and fair-use questions to copyright law.

06 / Foundation review questions

Resolve the choices before introduction.

These are independent analytical findings. The document has been renamed; its substantive provisions remain as supplied.

01

Test enrollment against a capped benefit account

§§ 501–507, 516, 2902

At the maximum 3% administrative share, $14.55B of the $15B annual account remains for benefits before reserves. That covers about 30.31 million full-year households at $40, or 16.17 million at $75, assuming each receives its full scheduled amount. A mixed population changes capacity. These are arithmetic ceilings, not forecasts of eligibility or take-up. Obtain enrollment, price, churn and reserve estimates before deciding whether the schedule is sufficient. Section 507 requires prospective proportional adjustments and at least 120 days’ notice of a reduction.

02

Make the timetable work across agencies

§§ 210, 412, 516, 1312, 1712, 2312, 2812, 3009–3010

The general private-duty date is 24 months after enactment, but contracts, creator agreements and platform duties have specific 18-month provisions. The enrollment launch is due within twelve months after household funds first become available, not automatically twelve months after enactment. Reconcile title-specific standards, provider testing, safe notices and complaint systems. Agencies’ planning calendars do not amend statutory deadlines.

03

Preserve the boundary between transactions and expression

§§ 107, 1507, 1707–1714, 2303, 2307, 3003

Payment disputes and fraudulent commercial promises can coexist with protected editorial decisions in the same account. Test proposed disclosure, account-restoration and replica orders against the actual function affected. News, parody and satire exceptions require workable notice handling and protection against abusive claims. The narrow Section 230 amendment should be cross-checked against the operative replica claims and the separate copyright safe harbor. A savings clause alone cannot establish constitutionality.

04

Evaluate federalism and the cost of overlapping duties

§§ 105, 113, 806, 1311, 2403, 2801–2804, 3005

A Federal privacy floor retains stronger State protections where simultaneous compliance is possible. Coverage thresholds differ by function; a small firm may be an advertiser, provider, creator distributor and device seller at once. Counsel should produce a duty-by-duty preemption map, while agencies test shared reporting and affordable compliance tools. Infrastructure access also requires property, compensation, local safety and Tribal-sovereignty review.

05

Develop evidence for the broadcast and funding choices

§§ 1501–1512, 2202–2206, 2906–2907

The 39% ownership cap, removal of the UHF discount and reliance treatment are proposed legislative choices. This review does not represent them as current FCC rules. Congress would need evidence on local competition, audience measurement, market viability and transition costs. Reporting grants need an objective allocation method that reaches entrants and underserved communities while testing additional reporting capacity and protecting confidential sources.

06

Map each right to a usable remedy

§§ 2705–2717, 2721

Private actions apply to enumerated titles and require concrete injury and causation. Statutory damages are available for specified violations, with a distinct replica regime; they are not automatic awards for every omission. Check the alignment of title-specific promises, complaint routes, public enforcement, nonmonetary claims against government and court jurisdiction. Model litigation and insurance costs as well as the value of redress.

07

Keep the fiscal categories separate

§§ 2613, 2901–2916

The draft supplies $295B in direct nominal budget authority. Outlays depend on enrollment, awards, carryover and payment timing; debt-service costs, revenues and mandate effects require separate analysis. The text supplies no general new industry assessment and no assumed growth offset. Scheduled appropriations end, while independently continuing rights do not automatically expire. An extension after year 10 would require new legislation and cannot be treated as already funded.

07 / A conditional implementation path

Authority has to become capability.

Every date below is conditional on enactment. None is a currently operative deadline for this proposal.

  1. Upon hypothetical enactment

    Administrative authority and restrictions on public administration generally begin; agencies prepare systems within available appropriations.

    §§ 2812, 3012

  2. 90–180 days

    Public register within 90 days, agency calendar within 120 days, and implementation-capacity assessments within 180 days; prepare the benefit program’s operational rules.

    §§ 210, 516, 3009–3010

  3. First available household funding

    Program year 1 is the first Federal fiscal year beginning after enactment. Open enrollment within twelve months after the household funds first become available; test providers and payment systems before launch.

    §§ 111, 516, 2902

  4. 18–24 months after enactment

    Apply each title’s actual compliance date. Contracts and creator agreements have specific rules; general private duties and privacy take effect at 24 months. Smaller platforms receive limited additional time for export and review systems.

    §§ 412, 1312, 1712, 2312, 2812

  5. Program years 1–10 and beyond

    Direct annual authority is $37B in years 1–5 and $22B in years 6–10. Evaluate outcomes and plan wind-down or reauthorization. Some account balances remain available beyond their installment years; continuing rights have no automatic funding sunset.

    §§ 2615, 2902–2913, 3012

Households and disabled users

May gain lower qualifying bills, usable access, better notices and remedies. Eligibility, actual service quality, accessible interfaces and prospective benefit reductions determine practical value.

Creators and local newsrooms

May gain transparent compensation, identity protections and reporting support. Audit cost, small-claim access, abusive notices and editorial insulation need operational testing.

Small businesses and entrants

May gain service-level clarity, advertising records, switching routes and infrastructure access. The cumulative cost of several covered functions could still favor larger incumbents.

Providers, platforms and public institutions

Receive defined authority, transition and review procedures while taking on compliance and delivery work. Sustainable network operation, security, staffing and vendor independence need evidence beyond announced awards.

Distributional assessments follow the proposed mechanisms. They are not measured incidence estimates or stakeholder endorsements.

Measure what changes in daily use.

Track total household cost, sustained service, restoration time, accessible task completion, switching success, creator payment errors and appeal outcomes. Compare funded construction with verified active service, and reporting grants with additional reporting capacity. Publish methods, counterfactual limits, administrative costs and adverse results. Separate transfers between people from net public benefit. § 2613

08 / Foundation relevance

Practical agency. Accountable systems.

Connectivity supports access to education, healthcare, work and public life. Privacy, disability access, fair payment and reliable information connect this proposal to the Foundation’s commitment to human dignity and durable public systems. Editorial independence and Tribal consent make participation compatible with autonomy. Explore the Foundation’s human-rights work, education agenda and related Information Hygiene and Digital Accountability Act.

The proposal does not establish that the Foundation operates a benefit program, administers public grants or has committed the proposed Federal funds.

09 / Source and working record

An open, inspectable proposal.

The Foundation reviewed the supplied packet’s structure and principal operative mechanisms, reproduced the nine-account appropriation schedule and prepared selected provision-based findings. This edition changes the Act’s name to Digital Life Act in the title, short-title clause, internal cross-reference, research-annex reference and core title metadata. All other document contents, discussion-draft labels, both tables and 41 external hyperlinks are retained. The downloadable DOCX and web reader use the same renamed edition. The source author’s annex and source register are preserved apart from the Act’s name and are not represented as independently verified in full. Six selected official sources were checked separately. No claim is made of a comprehensive legal citator search, verification of every cross-reference, empirical impact model, official score or page-by-page visual certification of the original Word layout.

The complete packet contains 67,384 whitespace-delimited words, 30 titles, 442 unique operative section numbers, two tables and 41 external hyperlinks. The source reader separates the nonstatutory research annex from the bill. The source and artifact records preserve the distinction between the renamed draft, Foundation commentary and illustrative calculations.

The public exchange is original AI-generated conceptual artwork, created for this entry. It depicts an imagined civic space. Artwork prompt and provenance ↓

Independent source register

  1. GAO-25-107207 · Broadband data and coordination ↗

    Official report published April 17, 2025; page and findings checked October 27, 2026.

  2. Sixth Circuit · In re MCP No. 185 ↗

    Official January 2, 2025 opinion; selected statutory-authority reasoning checked October 27, 2026.

  3. Supreme Court · Moody v. NetChoice ↗

    Official July 1, 2024 opinion; scope, remand and editorial-discretion discussion checked October 27, 2026.

  4. Eighth Circuit · Custom Communications v. FTC ↗

    Official July 8, 2025 opinion; vacatur checked October 27, 2026.

  5. FTC · Negative Option Rule proceeding ↗

    Official rule page listing the March 11, 2026 advance notice; checked October 27, 2026.

  6. Copyright Office · Digital Replicas report ↗

    Official July 2024 report; identity/copyright distinctions checked October 27, 2026.

Read the complete legislation

Full Text

Read the legislation.

The complete packet follows under the title Digital Life Act. Titles I–XXX are proposed statutory text. The Research and congressional review annex is the source author’s explanatory material, dated through October 9, 2026; it is not part of the proposed statute. Foundation analysis above is separate. This edition updates the Act’s name and internal self-references; its substantive provisions, document labels, tables and source links are preserved.

Front matter & document guide

119TH CONGRESS

2D SESSION

DISCUSSION DRAFT

Digital Life Act

A BILL

To expand affordable and reliable communications, protect consumers and creators, promote competition and practical access to media and entertainment, preserve freedom of expression, and provide for accountable administration and funding.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

TITLE I—GENERAL PROVISIONS AND RIGHTS

SEC. 101. SHORT TITLE AND PURPOSE.

(a) Short Title.—This Act may be cited as the "Digital Life Act".

(b) Purpose.—The purposes of this Act are to expand affordable and reliable communications; protect freedom of expression and editorial independence; enable competition and entry throughout communications and entertainment markets; establish enforceable rights concerning price, service, privacy, accessibility, and purchases; strengthen local information and emergency communications; support creators and independent businesses; and provide explicit, bounded Federal authority for the administration of those purposes.

(c) Legislative Form.—Except where this Act expressly amends another statute, its provisions establish independent duties and authorities. A duty under this Act applies according to the activity identified in the applicable provision, without regard to whether that activity is classified as a telecommunications service, an information service, cable service, broadcasting, or another category under another Act. Such application does not itself reclassify the activity for any other purpose.

(d) Rule Of Construction.—A statement of purpose does not independently authorize regulation, spending, a civil penalty, compulsory access to property, compulsory publication, or disclosure of personal information. Each such action shall rest on an operative provision of this Act or another applicable law.

SEC. 102. CONGRESSIONAL FINDINGS.

Congress finds that communications networks carry interstate commerce, emergency assistance, education, health services, employment, and cultural expression; that broadcast, cable, streaming, games, recorded music, advertising, and other media increasingly share distribution infrastructure while remaining distinct activities; that availability of a network does not alone establish affordability or practical access; and that reliable communications are indispensable to the operation of small businesses and public institutions.

Congress further finds that competition depends upon usable alternatives, reasonable switching arrangements, access to essential infrastructure, and honest information; that consumers experience recurring charges, fragmented access, and service interruptions across multiple media; that independent journalism and creative expression serve public interests without becoming instruments of government; and that constitutional protection of speech includes expression that officials or members of the public consider objectionable.

Congress further finds that public funding requires measurable obligations, verified expenditures, and continuity planning; that smaller entities face disproportionate fixed compliance costs; and that Federal duties should be sufficiently specific to permit investment, enforcement, and independent judicial review. These findings establish the legislative judgment supporting this Act and shall not be treated as an adjudication that any identified person violated existing law.

SEC. 103. GENERAL DEFINITIONS.

For purposes of this Act, the term "Commission" means the Federal Communications Commission; "Trade Commission" means the Federal Trade Commission; "Secretary" means the Secretary of Commerce; "NTIA" means the National Telecommunications and Information Administration; "NIST" means the National Institute of Standards and Technology; "Attorney General" means the Attorney General of the United States; and "Comptroller General" means the Comptroller General of the United States.

The term "State" includes each State, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and each territory or possession of the United States. The term "Indian Tribe" has the meaning given that term in section 4 of the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act. The term "Tribal government" includes the governing body of such a Tribe, and a consortium acting pursuant to the written authorization of each participating Tribe. Tribal status is not determined by an agency created under this Act.

The term "person" includes an individual, partnership, corporation, cooperative, association, nonprofit organization, and other legal entity. A government is a covered person only to the extent a provision expressly applies to its commercial activity or voluntary participation in a program. The term "control" means the power, directly or indirectly, to direct management or material operational decisions through ownership, contract, financing, or another arrangement, and does not include an ordinary minority investment without such power.

SEC. 104. COVERED SERVICES AND FUNCTIONS.

(a) Connectivity.—"Broadband internet access service" means a mass-market retail service, by wire or radio, that provides capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all internet endpoints, including incidental capabilities enabling that service. The term includes a functional substitute offered to evade this Act, but excludes a private enterprise network, a hosting service, a content delivery service standing alone, and an application whose principal function is producing or selecting information rather than providing general internet connectivity.

(b) Media.—"Covered media service" means a commercial service offering audiovisual programming, audio programming, interactive games, or access to a catalog of such works to persons in the United States. "Distributor" means a person controlling the commercial terms of delivery of such a service. An individual making an occasional uncompensated communication is not a distributor solely for that reason.

(c) Other Functions.—"Advertising intermediary" means a person that commercially arranges, places, auctions, measures, or verifies advertising for another person. "Ticket seller" means a commercial seller or reseller of admission to a live entertainment event. "Covered device" means equipment principally marketed for connectivity, reception, creation, or playback of communications or media. These definitions confer no authority beyond the duties expressly assigned to each function.

SEC. 105. INDIVIDUALS, HOUSEHOLDS, AND SMALL ENTITIES.

(a) Individual.—A protected individual is a natural person in the United States, regardless of citizenship, lawful expression, payment method, or whether the person is a subscriber. Program eligibility may contain residence and income requirements expressly established by this Act. An agency may not add an immigration-status condition absent express statutory authority.

(b) Household.—A household consists of persons who share income and expenses as one economic unit. Persons at the same address may constitute separate households. A shelter, dormitory, group home, correctional facility, or multifamily building is not one household solely because its occupants share an address or connection.

(c) Small Entity.—Unless another threshold is expressly provided, a small entity is an independently controlled person with fewer than 500 full-time-equivalent employees and less than $100,000,000 in average annual United States revenue during the preceding three completed fiscal years. Controlled affiliates shall be aggregated. Seasonal employment shall be annualized. An entity may not divide operations, shift receipts, or use nominal ownership to obtain relief.

(d) Application.—Small-entity status permits only the relief expressly provided. It does not excuse fraud, intentional discrimination, knowing disclosure of protected information, failure to pay earned compensation, or disregard of an imminent and substantial threat to safety.

SEC. 106. TERRITORIAL AND COMMERCIAL NEXUS.

(a) Coverage.—This Act applies to covered conduct in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce with a substantial connection to the United States. A foreign person is covered when purposefully offering the relevant service to persons in the United States, selling advertising directed to that market, or processing covered information obtained through such an offering. Incidental accessibility of a foreign website, without purposeful direction, is insufficient by itself.

(b) Representative.—A covered foreign person with more than 100,000 paying United States customers or $10,000,000 in annual United States covered revenue shall designate an agent for service of process and provide a reliable means of receiving legal notices. Designation does not create substantive liability beyond this Act or displace ordinary requirements of personal jurisdiction and service.

(c) Limits.—An order shall be limited to conduct and relief within United States jurisdiction. No provision requires worldwide removal of expression, disclosure contrary to a controlling court order, or indiscriminate blocking of foreign services. Courts may consider international comity when fashioning relief without permitting foreign incorporation to defeat a duty otherwise applicable.

SEC. 107. FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION AND EDITORIAL INDEPENDENCE.

(a) Prohibition.—No officer, employee, contractor, or recipient administering this Act may condition a license, grant, approval, investigation, enforcement decision, or other governmental benefit or burden on support for or opposition to a political position, government official, religion, ideology, or lawful editorial judgment.

(b) No General Carriage Mandate.—Except for emergency communications and existing carriage obligations expressly preserved or modified, this Act does not require a person to publish, promote, recommend, rank, endorse, or financially support another person's expression. A commercial disclosure requirement shall address objectively verifiable transaction information and shall not require a confession of belief or a disputed ideological statement.

(c) Official Contacts.—A covered agency communication seeking action concerning lawful expression shall identify its legal basis and whether compliance is voluntary. Material contacts concerning a pending license or transaction shall be docketed, subject to lawful confidentiality protections. An informal request is not an alternative to required process.

(d) Remedy.—A person suffering concrete injury from a violation may seek declaratory or injunctive relief under title XXVII. Nothing in this section immunizes true threats, fraud, unlawful discrimination, infringement, or other conduct from a constitutionally valid and otherwise applicable law.

SEC. 108. EQUALITY AND PRACTICAL ACCESS.

(a) Baseline.—Covered connectivity providers shall not intentionally deny, degrade, delay, or impose materially worse terms for substantially equivalent service because of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, or familial status. Sex includes sexual orientation and gender identity. A facially neutral practice may be challenged under the defined disparate-impact standard in title IX, and not under an unbounded inference from demographic differences alone.

(b) Accommodation.—A provider shall offer reasonable modifications necessary for disability access, subject to title XIV. It shall not require a customer to disclose a diagnosis when information establishing the functional need is sufficient. Equivalent access includes the ability to subscribe, use, cancel, complain, and obtain emergency information.

(c) No Mandatory Preference.—This section does not require an employment quota, a viewpoint quota, preferential treatment based solely on a protected characteristic, or provision of a technically infeasible service. It does not excuse a provider from testing a feasible and materially less discriminatory alternative when the applicable statutory standard requires that inquiry.

(a) Consent.—Where this Act requires affirmative consent, the request shall separately identify the material choice, use plain language appropriate to the transaction, and provide a comparably accessible means of refusal. Silence, a preselected box, continuation after an unrelated notice, or acceptance of general terms does not establish the required consent.

(b) Proof.—The person relying on consent bears the burden of producing a dated record identifying the version of the disclosure, the affirmative act, and the scope of permission. A record may use a transaction identifier rather than a copy of identity documents. Consent procured through a material misrepresentation or unlawful conditioning is invalid.

(c) Revocation.—Revocation shall be as accessible as the original choice and shall operate prospectively, except that unlawfully obtained information or charges remain subject to correction. A person shall not characterize a legally required service restriction as the consequence of refusing optional data use.

(d) Clear Disclosure.—Required information shall be reasonably noticeable, understandable, accessible, and available before commitment. Placement in a lengthy agreement alone is insufficient when the information materially determines price, renewal, access, or an exercise of rights.

SEC. 110. RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER LAW.

(a) Savings.—Except as expressly provided, this Act supplements the Communications Act of 1934, the Federal Trade Commission Act, antitrust laws, civil-rights laws, labor laws, disability laws, consumer-protection laws, and title 17, United States Code. Compliance with one law is not a defense to a distinct duty that can simultaneously be performed.

(b) Precise Conflicts.—When simultaneous compliance is impossible, the express conflict rules in titles XXVIII and XXX govern. An agency may not find preemption merely because State law is more protective, a regulated entity prefers uniformity, or Federal law permits conduct that it does not require.

(c) Immunities.—No provision abolishes an immunity, privilege, or limitation on liability by implication. The relationship to section 230 of the Communications Act of 1934 and section 512 of title 17 is governed by the express provisions of this Act. A claim shall identify the defendant's own covered conduct and applicable duty.

(d) Existing Orders.—Final judgments, accrued claims, and lawful preexisting contracts remain subject to the transition provisions. Nothing reopens a final judicial judgment or makes conduct completed before an applicable effective date newly unlawful.

SEC. 111. TIME, NOTICE, AND COMPUTATION.

(a) Time.—Unless otherwise stated, a day is a calendar day. When a deadline falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or Federal holiday, a filing may be made on the next business day. Emergency restoration and security deadlines continue to run when their purpose requires continuous performance. An agency shall identify the rule applicable to each deadline in a public implementation calendar.

(b) Notice.—Notice to a customer shall use a channel reasonably calculated to reach that customer, honor accessibility and safety preferences, and be available without a new purchase or new account. Required notice of a material adverse change shall not be combined with advertising in a manner that obscures its purpose.

(c) Program Years.—"Program year 1" means the first Federal fiscal year beginning after enactment; later program years follow consecutively. A reference to a dollar threshold means nominal dollars at enactment unless an adjustment is expressly required. The first adjustment shall use the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and shall not reduce the stated threshold.

SEC. 112. ACCOUNTABILITY FOR IMPLEMENTATION.

(a) Statutory Responsibility.—A person assigned a duty remains responsible when performance is delegated to an affiliate, billing agent, reseller, contractor, or automated system. Liability for another person's conduct requires control, participation, or an express statutory basis; a contract alone does not make an unrelated party strictly liable.

(b) Avoidance.—An arrangement whose principal purpose is to evade an otherwise applicable duty may be disregarded to the extent necessary to enforce that duty. The enforcing party shall prove the relevant facts, and legitimate differences in products, markets, or corporate functions shall be respected.

(c) Compliance By Design.—Agencies shall permit equivalent methods that achieve a specified statutory outcome without prescribing a favored vendor or business model. A privately developed standard becomes enforceable only through a lawfully adopted rule with publicly accessible requirements and a reasonable transition period.

(d) No Implied Crime.—A violation of this Act is civil unless an express provision of existing criminal law independently applies. No agency may create a criminal offense, imprisonment, or personal criminal liability by regulation under this Act.

SEC. 113. FUNCTIONAL DEFINITIONS AND THRESHOLD CALCULATION.

(a) Providers.—A covered connectivity provider is a person offering broadband internet access service within section 104, including a State, local government, or Tribe when voluntarily acting as a commercial retail provider. A covered person is a person performing the particular function regulated by the provision at issue. Mere ownership of an unrelated investment does not make an investor the provider of that function.

(b) Revenue And Users.—Where a numerical threshold applies, revenue shall be calculated consistently under generally accepted accounting principles, excluding taxes collected for government and amounts merely held for another person. Active users shall be counted as reasonably deduplicated natural persons in the United States, using existing records and privacy-preserving estimates; the calculation shall not require new identity surveillance. Controlled affiliates performing the same function shall be aggregated.

(c) Transition.—An entity newly exceeding a threshold shall have 180 days after reasonably determining that fact to comply with obligations triggered only by the threshold. It remains responsible for duties that apply regardless of size. A decline below a threshold must persist for two consecutive measurement periods before threshold-specific duties cease, unless the administering agency finds permanent cessation of the covered function.

SEC. 114. ACCESSIBLE NOTICE AND RELIABLE DELIVERY.

(a) Methods.—A notice required by this Act shall use a communication method reasonably calculated to reach the intended recipient, considering the person's chosen contact method, disability accommodations, and known inability to access a suspended account. Posting only inside an inaccessible account does not constitute delivery of a material termination or appeal notice.

(b) Content.—The notice shall state the action, date, material financial or service consequence, and means of obtaining assistance or review. It shall not be obscured by marketing. A provider may combine compatible notices if each required disclosure remains understandable and the combined presentation does not shorten a statutory response period.

(c) Record.—Proof of notice may consist of a dated dispatch record and the form used, without proof that the recipient read the notice. When a delivery failure is known and a reasonable alternative is available, the sender shall attempt that alternative. This duty does not require repeated contact that would compromise a survivor's safety or disclose a confidential service location.

SEC. 115. RULES FOR AUTOMATED DECISIONS.

(a) Responsibility.—A person subject to this Act remains responsible for a decision made through software, a statistical model, or an outside contractor when that decision determines compliance with a duty owed by that person. A claim that the system's reasoning cannot be reconstructed does not itself establish a defense.

(b) Review.—Where this Act grants review of a denial, charge, suspension, eligibility determination, or payment calculation, the review shall permit examination by a person with authority and sufficient information to correct a material error. Repeating the same automated output without considering submitted evidence is not meaningful review.

(c) Limits.—This section does not establish a general licensing regime for artificial intelligence, compel publication of source code, or grant access to unrelated trade secrets. The responsible person may protect sensitive methods while disclosing the material facts and reasons needed to contest the particular decision. Records shall be retained only for the period reasonably necessary for that review and applicable legal obligations.

TITLE II—ADMINISTRATION AND PUBLIC PARTICIPATION

SEC. 201. ALLOCATION OF RESPONSIBILITIES.

(a) Commission.—The Commission shall administer duties concerning transmission networks, spectrum, broadcast licensing, infrastructure access, emergency communications, network reliability, and the connectivity-specific provisions of this Act. It shall not acquire general jurisdiction over the substance of internet publications, creative works, or commercial activity merely because the activity uses a communications network.

(b) Trade Commission.—The Trade Commission shall administer duties concerning media subscriptions, ticketing, commercial advertising, device commerce, and covered personal information, except where this Act expressly assigns a matter to another agency. For these duties alone, its jurisdiction extends to nonprofit commercial operators and common carriers notwithstanding the exemptions in section 5(a)(2) of the Federal Trade Commission Act. This extension does not alter those exemptions for unrelated activity.

(c) Other Agencies.—The Secretary shall administer deployment and inclusion grants; the Secretary of Labor shall administer workforce programs; and the Librarian of Congress shall administer preservation programs through existing lawful offices. The Attorney General retains responsibility for Federal civil litigation and criminal enforcement except where this Act expressly permits independent civil litigation by the Trade Commission.

SEC. 202. COORDINATION WITHOUT TRANSFER OF POWER.

(a) Council.—There is established within the Department of Commerce a Communications and Media Implementation Council, chaired by the Secretary and composed of the heads or designees of the agencies assigned responsibilities under this Act. Participation does not establish a new independent agency or alter the appointment, tenure, or removal of an existing officer.

(b) Functions.—The Council shall publish a common implementation calendar, identify duplicative reporting, maintain a referral directory, and coordinate technical definitions. It may recommend legislation and administrative improvements but may not issue binding rules, assess fees, adjudicate claims, allocate appropriations contrary to title XXIX, or reverse another agency's lawful decision.

(c) Public Record.—Material recommendations shall be public. A disagreement over jurisdiction shall be described with the statutory bases asserted by each agency. The Council shall not resolve such disagreement through a confidential memorandum that changes regulated persons' obligations. Pending coordination does not suspend an otherwise applicable customer right or limitations period.

SEC. 203. RULEMAKING STANDARDS.

(a) Procedure.—Rules under this Act shall be promulgated under section 553 of title 5, United States Code, with at least 60 days for public comment unless good cause is specifically demonstrated. The agency shall identify each statutory delegation, the persons covered, the enforceable requirement, the evidence relied upon, the alternatives considered, and the effective date.

(b) Analysis.—For a significant rule, the agency shall assess benefits, compliance expense, effects on investment and entry, distribution across income and geography, and burdens on small entities. Quantification shall be attempted where reliable evidence permits; uncertainty shall be disclosed rather than converted into a zero value for an unquantified benefit or harm.

(c) Response.—The final rule shall address material contrary evidence, explain changes from the proposal, and state why less burdensome alternatives would not adequately achieve the statutory objective. An agency may not avoid these duties by designating a generally applicable binding requirement as guidance, a staff letter, a consent-decree condition, or a technical recommendation.

SEC. 204. PARTICIPATION BY AFFECTED PERSONS.

(a) Access.—Each agency shall provide accessible electronic and nonelectronic means to comment. It shall accept concise submissions, permit reasonable accommodation, and publish plain-language summaries of major proposals. A person shall not be required to retain counsel, use a paid filing service, or create a public profile to submit a comment.

(b) Outreach.—Outreach shall include rural residents, Tribal governments, persons with disabilities, low-income households, consumers who lack reliable internet, independent creators, small advertisers, and small network operators. Participation shall not be conditioned on agreement with the agency's proposed policy.

(c) Integrity.—The agency shall distinguish the number of submissions from the number of independently verified participants and the probative weight of evidence. Identical comments may be grouped but not discarded merely because they are organized. Suspected impersonation or automated flooding shall be investigated through proportionate measures that do not compel public identification of anonymous speakers absent legal necessity.

SEC. 205. TECHNICAL ADVISORY WORK.

(a) Advice.—An agency may convene advisory committees consistent with applicable Federal advisory-committee law. Membership shall reflect relevant expertise and affected interests, with public disclosure of financial interests and funding for participation. No regulated class shall control the selection of its competitors' representatives.

(b) Limits.—A committee may recommend standards, measurement methods, and implementation options. It may not set binding rates, approve grants, determine liability, exclude market entrants, or exercise final governmental authority. An agency shall independently examine and explain its acceptance of a recommendation.

(c) Open Standards.—Where a technical recommendation incorporates intellectual property, the committee shall disclose known licensing requirements, practical alternatives, and risks of vendor dependence. The agency shall favor specifications that are publicly accessible and implementable on reasonable, nondiscriminatory terms. Emergency procurement shall not permanently establish one vendor's proprietary method as the legal standard without subsequent public review.

SEC. 206. PUBLIC INFORMATION AND CONFIDENTIAL MATERIAL.

(a) Disclosure.—Agencies shall publish final decisions, material supporting analysis, compliance guides, aggregate enforcement outcomes, grant awards, and performance results in searchable and accessible form. Records shall identify the applicable version and date so that superseded guidance is not mistaken for current requirements.

(b) Protection.—Personal information, security vulnerabilities, trade secrets, and privileged material shall be protected under applicable law. A request for confidential treatment shall identify the specific information, legal basis, foreseeable injury from disclosure, and duration sought. A blanket confidentiality label is not sufficient.

(c) Segregation.—Agencies shall release reasonably segregable nonconfidential information and provide meaningful public explanations when protected evidence affects a decision. Parties facing an adverse adjudication shall receive access sufficient for a fair defense through protective orders or other lawful procedures. Confidentiality shall not permit a secret rule, conceal agency misconduct, or prevent reporting to an inspector general, Congress, or a court with lawful authority.

SEC. 207. SMALL ENTITY ASSISTANCE.

(a) Office.—Each principal implementing agency shall designate a small-entity assistance officer within existing staff or appropriated positions. The officer shall provide model disclosures, common reporting forms, technical workshops, and a confidential channel for implementation questions. Assistance shall be available without purchase of certification from a private organization.

(b) Reliance.—A published, authorized written interpretation may support mitigation of a civil penalty when an entity fully and accurately disclosed material facts and reasonably relied upon the interpretation. Such reliance does not eliminate restitution, excuse intentional wrongdoing, or bind a court's interpretation of law.

(c) Correction.—For a first, nonwillful paperwork violation causing no material harm, the agency shall ordinarily provide 30 days to correct before seeking a penalty. The opportunity is unavailable for repeated violations, concealment, unlawful charges, privacy breaches, discriminatory denial of service, or a substantial safety risk. Agencies shall record correction outcomes so that leniency does not become an unmonitored exemption.

SEC. 208. PROCUREMENT AND SYSTEM DESIGN.

(a) Requirements.—Systems acquired to administer this Act shall support accessibility, security, data minimization, interoperable export, audit logging, and continuity of operations. Contracts shall specify ownership or licensed access to necessary administrative data, migration assistance, incident reporting, and termination rights sufficient to avoid disabling a public program when a vendor changes.

(b) Testing.—Before deployment, agencies shall test eligibility systems, payment systems, and public portals with representative users and realistic failure conditions. A pilot may not deny an otherwise vested benefit without an alternate application route and review. Procurement schedules shall include maintenance and replacement costs.

(c) Automation.—Automated tools may assist administration but shall not be the sole basis for a final adverse eligibility or enforcement decision without meaningful human review. Agencies shall document error rates and material limitations. Source-code disclosure is not categorically required, but an agency must possess sufficient access to explain and defend the actual basis of its decision.

SEC. 209. OFFICIAL CONTACTS AND CONFLICTS.

(a) Contact Records.—For a contested license, transaction, grant competition, or enforcement matter, an agency shall maintain records of material ex parte contacts consistent with its procedural rules. Public records shall identify the participants, general subject, and any new factual submission, except to the extent disclosure is lawfully restricted.

(b) Recusal.—Officers and employees shall comply with Federal conflict-of-interest law. An agency shall maintain a procedure for requesting disqualification based on a concrete financial interest or demonstrated prejudgment. Mere disagreement with an official's lawful policy views is not sufficient.

(c) Prohibited Conditions.—A decision may not be exchanged for political contributions, favorable news coverage, hiring a favored person, contracting with a favored vendor, or unrelated concessions. A settlement condition shall remedy an identified violation or a reasonably related risk and shall be supported by an explanation available for judicial review.

SEC. 210. IMPLEMENTATION DEADLINES.

(a) Calendar.—Within 120 days after enactment, each implementing agency shall publish a calendar identifying required rules, systems, staffing, consultations, and effective dates. Unless a title specifies otherwise, proposed implementing rules shall issue within 12 months and final rules within 24 months after enactment.

(b) Self-Executing Rights.—A statutory prohibition that supplies a sufficiently definite duty becomes enforceable on its stated effective date notwithstanding agency delay. An agency shall identify provisions requiring technical specifications before compliance is practicable and shall not impose retroactive liability for failure to satisfy a specification not yet lawfully established.

(c) Delay Report.—When a deadline cannot be met, the agency shall notify the appropriate congressional committees at least 30 days before expiration when practicable, explaining the cause, work completed, public consequences, and revised schedule. Such notice does not amend the deadline or authorize noncompliance. Judicial remedies for unlawful withholding or unreasonable delay remain available under applicable law.

SEC. 211. ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS.

(a) Process.—A person adversely affected by a grant, eligibility, certification, or other administrative determination under this Act shall receive written reasons, the principal evidence, the applicable review deadline, and instructions for seeking reconsideration. Review shall be conducted by an official who did not make the initial disputed determination when practicable.

(b) Continuity.—An existing household benefit shall continue during a timely appeal of a termination based on disputed eligibility, for up to 60 days, unless fraud or a duplicate payment is supported by specific evidence. Recovery from a household requires proof of knowing misrepresentation; agency or provider error shall ordinarily be recovered from the responsible administrator or provider.

(c) Record.—An appeal shall permit correction of mistaken identity, address, household composition, and technical records. A person may submit oral information reduced to writing when disability, literacy, or lack of connectivity prevents electronic filing. Agencies shall not impose repeated documentary demands for facts already verified through an authorized source.

SEC. 212. INDEPENDENT OVERSIGHT.

(a) Inspectors General.—Each agency's inspector general may audit programs, contracts, data systems, and enforcement administration under this Act pursuant to existing authority. Agencies and recipients shall provide relevant records, subject to applicable privileges and lawful protections for sensitive information.

(b) Comptroller General.—The Comptroller General shall evaluate implementation in program years 3, 5, and 8, including administrative cost, duplication, outcomes, small-entity burdens, and whether benefits reach intended recipients. The evaluation shall identify limitations in causal inference and distinguish a program's announced commitments from completed and sustained results.

(c) Response.—Within 120 days after receiving a final oversight report, the agency shall publish an action plan accepting recommendations or explaining its disagreement. The plan shall assign accountable officials and measurable milestones. Oversight findings do not by themselves establish private liability, authorize withholding unrelated benefits, or substitute for adjudication of a contested factual allegation.

SEC. 213. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS AND DISTRIBUTIONAL EFFECTS.

(a) Record.—For a significant rule under this Act, the responsible agency shall identify the baseline, regulated population, material compliance costs, expected benefits, feasible alternatives, and substantial uncertainty. It shall separately consider effects on low-income households, remote communities, people with disabilities, small entrants, and established providers.

(b) Method.—An analysis shall distinguish transfers from net social costs, private compliance expenses from public administrative expenses, and demonstrated effects from modeled predictions. The agency shall disclose material assumptions and provide sensitivity analysis where a reasonable change would alter its conclusion. A monetary estimate shall not be fabricated for a benefit that cannot responsibly be quantified.

(c) Decision.—The agency shall explain why the selected approach satisfies the statutory standard in light of the record. Economic analysis may inform implementation choices but shall not authorize an agency to erase an unambiguous right because it disagrees with Congress's policy. Material contrary evidence submitted during comment shall receive a reasoned response rather than dismissal by reference to the number of comments supporting the rule.

SEC. 214. INTERAGENCY CASE ROUTING.

(a) Common Entry.—The Commission and Trade Commission shall maintain a common complaint entry process that routes a complaint to the office with relevant authority. A consumer shall not be required to resolve the legal classification of a converged service before submitting a complaint.

(b) Transfer.—A receiving agency lacking authority shall, with appropriate notice and lawful information sharing, transfer the matter or explain the available forum. It shall preserve the original receipt date for an administrative filing deadline under this Act. Transfer does not determine the merits or toll a separate judicial deadline unless title XXVII or another law provides tolling.

(c) Accountability.—The agencies shall assign a coordinating office for matters involving several covered functions and identify which office will communicate with the complainant. They may conduct a coordinated investigation while preserving each agency's statutory authority, confidentiality obligations, and independent decisional responsibility. A coordination agreement shall not create a new substantive offense or expand investigative access beyond what the participating agencies may lawfully obtain.

SEC. 215. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN TECHNICAL STANDARDS.

(a) Access.—Before incorporating a technical standard into a binding rule, an agency shall make the operative requirements reasonably available for public review without a prohibitive access charge. Where copyright limits publication of the complete standard, the agency shall provide a lawful inspection method and a sufficient public explanation of the obligations proposed.

(b) Representation.—Technical consultation shall include relevant engineering expertise and practical input from smaller entities, disability users, rural operators, security researchers, and affected consumers. Participation shall not depend solely on purchasing membership in a private standards organization.

(c) Updates.—A private organization's future amendment shall not automatically change a Federal legal duty. The agency shall evaluate material revisions and provide the process required by law before incorporating them. Emergency adoption of a temporary technical measure requires an existing legal basis, an explanation of urgency, a defined duration, and subsequent review. This section permits performance-based alternatives that demonstrably meet the statutory objective.

TITLE III—OPEN AND COMPETITIVE INTERNET ACCESS

SEC. 301. EXPRESS BROADBAND AUTHORITY.

(a) Authority.—The Commission shall administer this title with respect to broadband internet access service offered in the United States. The authority is expressly granted by this Act and does not depend upon classifying that service under title II of the Communications Act of 1934 or deriving regulatory power from a statement of deployment policy.

(b) Scope.—The duties apply to fixed, mobile, satellite, and other retail access technologies according to their actual capabilities. A provider shall not evade coverage by bundling access with storage, security, email, entertainment, or another information-processing feature.

(c) Limitation.—This title does not authorize general retail rate setting, prior approval of every service plan, compulsory publication of content, or regulation of lawful editorial choices. Express price-related duties elsewhere in this Act, including subsidy conditions and correction of discriminatory terms, remain effective. A specialized network service is governed by section 307 when it shares facilities with public internet access.

SEC. 302. BLOCKING.

(a) Prohibition.—A broadband provider shall not block lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices requested by a subscriber, subject to reasonable network management, a valid legal order, or a subscriber's affirmative choice of a filtering service.

(b) Security.—Temporary blocking necessary to contain malware, a denial-of-service attack, unauthorized access, or a comparable concrete threat shall be narrowly tailored in duration and scope. The provider shall document the threat, the basis for the measure, available less restrictive methods, and the time of restoration. Disclosure may be delayed when immediate publication would materially assist exploitation.

(c) Customer Choice.—A parental control, enterprise security policy, or user-selected filter shall be described accurately, capable of practical modification by the authorized customer, and separate from a provider's commercial preference. A provider may not disguise blocking of a competitor as a default safety feature when the customer has not requested that restriction.

SEC. 303. THROTTLING.

(a) Prohibition.—A provider shall not impair or degrade lawful traffic because of its source, destination, content, application, ownership, or competitive relationship, except for reasonable network management or a restriction expressly requested by the subscriber.

(b) Differentiated Plans.—A provider may offer transparently described plans with different overall speeds, data allowances, or latency characteristics. Such plans shall apply their stated limits consistently and shall not secretly exempt an affiliated service while impairing a substantially similar unaffiliated service. A disclosed maximum speed does not excuse delivery materially below a separately promised minimum or typical performance level.

(c) Measurement.—The Commission shall establish tests capable of distinguishing congestion, radio conditions, equipment limitations, and intentional application-specific impairment. A finding of throttling shall rest on reproducible evidence and consider provider explanations. The absence of a single universal test does not foreclose proof through multiple reliable measurements or internal operational records.

SEC. 304. PAID PRIORITIZATION.

(a) Prohibition.—A provider shall not favor particular internet traffic over other traffic in exchange for consideration from a third party or to benefit an affiliated content or application service, when such preference operates within the subscriber's general internet access service.

(b) User Control.—The prohibition does not prevent a subscriber from selecting application-neutral quality settings, purchasing greater overall capacity, or configuring a private network. A provider shall not require a content provider to purchase favorable treatment to obtain the performance reasonably represented to subscribers.

(c) Limited Exception.—The Commission may authorize a narrowly defined arrangement only upon clear and convincing evidence that it provides a substantial public-safety or accessibility benefit unavailable through a reasonably feasible alternative, does not materially degrade ordinary access, and is offered on nondiscriminatory terms. The authorization shall identify measurable conditions, last no longer than three years, and be subject to public review and revocation for nonperformance. General revenue enhancement is not a qualifying benefit.

SEC. 305. REASONABLE NETWORK MANAGEMENT.

(a) Standard.—A practice is reasonable network management when principally directed to a legitimate technical need, appropriate to the technology, proportionate to the demonstrated problem, and applied without using the need as a pretext for commercial discrimination. Business convenience or increased bargaining leverage alone is not a technical need.

(b) Factors.—The Commission shall consider congestion duration, available capacity, security risk, emergency circumstances, user expectations, and the feasibility of application-neutral measures. Providers need not operate every technology identically. They shall nevertheless explain why a discriminatory technical measure was necessary when a less restrictive alternative was reasonably available.

(c) Documentation.—Providers shall retain operational descriptions and material changes for three years without retaining browsing histories solely for this purpose. Small providers may use a simplified description. A public summary shall omit exploitable security details but disclose practices materially affecting customer use. Reasonable management does not excuse a misleading service promise or an unlawful charge.

SEC. 306. INTERCONNECTION AND CONGESTION DISPUTES.

(a) Duty.—A broadband provider controlling an interconnection point serving its retail customers shall negotiate in good faith and shall not deliberately permit avoidable congestion principally to coerce payment for traffic already requested and paid for by those customers.

(b) Review.—The Commission may resolve a complaint upon evidence of persistent material impairment, the parties' traffic and capacity obligations, proposed terms, costs, and feasible remedies. It shall distinguish ordinary commercial negotiation from conduct that predictably defeats retail service commitments.

(c) Remedies.—Relief may include disclosure, a capacity-upgrade schedule, nondiscriminatory negotiation, temporary traffic arrangements, and compensation for proven violations under title XXVII. A compulsory price or continuing access term requires findings of substantial market power, an essential bottleneck, and lack of a less restrictive effective remedy under title XVIII. Nothing requires settlement-free interconnection in every circumstance or excuses a requesting party from reasonable engineering and payment obligations.

SEC. 307. SPECIALIZED SERVICES AND NETWORK SLICES.

(a) Permitted Services.—A provider may offer a service optimized for a defined function, including telemedicine, industrial control, or emergency response, when the service is genuinely distinct from general internet access and its terms are accurately described.

(b) Safeguards.—The provider shall not label ordinary internet traffic as specialized to evade this title, materially impair the capacity reasonably promised to retail subscribers, or require an application developer to buy specialized treatment merely to reach subscribers on ordinary terms. A safety-critical service shall identify its reliability limitations and backup arrangements.

(c) Review.—The Commission shall examine actual function, capacity allocation, substitutability, admission criteria, and effects on other traffic. It may require aggregate performance reporting proportionate to risk. A finding that one specialized service is permissible does not approve every service using the same technical label. Innovation trials may receive time-limited reporting relief but not immunity for deception or knowing endangerment.

SEC. 308. DATA ALLOWANCES AND EXEMPTIONS.

(a) Transparency.—A plan with a usage allowance shall disclose the allowance, measurement unit, billing interval, overage price, warning mechanism, and consequences of reaching the limit. Customers shall receive free warnings at 75, 90, and 100 percent of the allowance unless they choose fewer notices.

(b) Accuracy.—A provider shall offer a practical means to inspect and dispute usage measurements, correct meter errors, and prevent charges caused by its own testing or unsolicited maintenance traffic. A customer shall not bear the burden of proving an error in a meter whose relevant records the provider refuses to produce.

(c) Competitive Review.—Exempting selected traffic from an allowance is prohibited when offered for third-party payment or affiliate advantage and reasonably likely to materially foreclose competing services. Application-neutral promotions, emergency information, and disability accommodations may be permitted upon transparent criteria. The Commission shall evaluate actual competitive effects rather than treating all zero-priced traffic as necessarily beneficial or necessarily harmful.

SEC. 309. LAWFUL DEVICES AND CUSTOMER NETWORKS.

(a) Connection.—A subscriber may connect a lawful, technically compatible device of the subscriber's choice without an unnecessary rental, activation, or approval charge. A provider may impose published requirements necessary to prevent network harm, radio interference, fraud, or a demonstrated security risk.

(b) Certification.—Compatibility procedures shall be timely, objective, and available on reasonable terms. A provider may charge the reasonable cost of a necessary individualized test but shall not impose repeated testing already established by an accepted independent process without identifying a material difference.

(c) Information.—The provider shall make configuration information reasonably necessary for lawful connection available to customers and independent installers. It need not disclose credentials belonging to another customer or information that would materially compromise network security. A denial shall identify the failed requirement and a correction or appeal route. Technical access shall not be conditioned on purchase of unrelated content, advertising, or data-processing services.

SEC. 310. PERFORMANCE DISCLOSURES.

(a) Required Measures.—Before sale, a provider shall disclose total recurring price, typical download and upload performance, typical latency, any committed service level, data limits, equipment requirements, and material reliability limitations at the service address when reasonably ascertainable.

(b) Methodology.—The Commission shall specify representative busy-hour measurement, sample adequacy, treatment of outages, and separation of access-network performance from customer equipment and remote endpoints. Providers may explain genuine uncertainty but may not use uncertainty to advertise a maximum as though it were a typical outcome.

(c) Verification.—Independent testing shall be permitted through reasonable technical interfaces that protect other users. Providers shall not preferentially accelerate known measurement traffic in a manner that misrepresents ordinary experience. Published aggregate results shall describe geography and technology sufficiently to avoid concealing poor performance in a particular community within a nationwide average.

SEC. 311. COMPLAINTS AND INTERIM RELIEF.

(a) Complaint.—A subscriber, affected edge provider, or public-interest representative acting with authorization may submit evidence of a violation. The Commission shall provide a streamlined process and ordinarily require an initial response within 15 days. An allegation shall identify the affected service, practice, period, and available evidence.

(b) Interim Order.—After notice and an opportunity to respond, the Commission may order temporary technical measures necessary to prevent substantial ongoing impairment, subject to prompt judicial review. An ex parte emergency order shall expire within seven days unless renewed after a hearing opportunity and findings of continuing necessity.

(c) Limits.—Interim relief shall preserve lawful security measures and avoid unnecessary disclosure of confidential interconnection terms. Monetary penalties shall be sought in court under title XXVII. A complaint process shall not be used to compel carriage of expression by a media publisher or to resolve a copyright dispute outside the agency's authority.

SEC. 312. IMPLEMENTATION AND EVALUATION.

(a) Effective Date.—The prohibitions on blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization take effect one year after enactment. The Commission shall issue implementing rules within that period. Existing contracts shall not authorize prohibited conduct after the effective date, but obligations completed before that date shall not be retroactively penalized.

(b) Evaluation.—Beginning in program year 3, the Commission shall report every two years on consumer complaints, confirmed violations, investment, entry, congestion, service quality, and effects on smaller providers. It shall distinguish correlation from evidence of causal effects and publish methods adequate for independent replication.

(c) Adjustment.—The Commission may refine measurement and reporting requirements within this title but may not waive its core prohibitions for an entire industry or restore them through a different classification after withdrawing them without statutory authority. Material amendments shall follow public rulemaking. A recommendation to Congress shall identify the precise statutory change sought and the evidence supporting it.

SEC. 313. MEASUREMENT OF NETWORK TREATMENT.

(a) Testing.—A provider shall not knowingly identify a standard performance test and give it preferential treatment for the purpose of creating a materially misleading representation of ordinary service. Reasonable protection of a test against fraud or interference remains permissible if disclosed and technically justified.

(b) Records.—In a credible dispute concerning blocking, throttling, or interconnection, the Commission may require proportionate records of network configuration, congestion, capacity planning, and treatment of comparable traffic. The request shall avoid collecting message content where aggregate technical information is sufficient.

(c) Interpretation.—A difference in measured performance does not alone prove unlawful discrimination. The decision maker shall consider endpoint conditions, customer equipment, radio environment, time, route, application behavior, and other relevant causes. A provider relying on congestion or security shall identify evidence connecting that explanation to the challenged practice. Public reports shall describe methodological limitations so that one isolated measurement is not presented as a reliable estimate of an entire network's performance.

SEC. 314. MANAGED SERVICES AND EVASION.

(a) Distinct Function.—A provider offering a specialized managed service over shared facilities shall identify its function, expected resource demand, and safeguards against material degradation of ordinary broadband. A service is not exempt from this title merely because a provider labels it private, premium, enterprise, or a network slice.

(b) Substitution.—The Commission may treat a nominally specialized service as broadband internet access when the service's actual marketed purpose and capability provide access to substantially all internet endpoints and the designation would otherwise evade this title. The Commission shall make that determination through a reasoned order with notice and an opportunity to respond.

(c) Legitimate Uses.—A closed industrial control system, dedicated medical connection, or emergency-priority service may receive distinct technical treatment appropriate to its function. The provider shall not sell equivalent preferential carriage of ordinary applications under an artificial specialized-service designation. Nothing in this section requires a provider to disclose a customer's confidential operational information to competitors or to the public.

SEC. 315. CUSTOMER CONTROL OF NETWORK FEATURES.

(a) Choice.—A provider offering optional filtering, parental controls, malware protection, or traffic-management features shall disclose their material effect and provide practical controls appropriate to the feature. A subscriber's informed selection of lawful filtering does not constitute provider blocking prohibited by section 302.

(b) Default Security.—A provider may activate proportionate security measures against demonstrably malicious traffic without first obtaining individual consent when immediate action is reasonably necessary. It shall provide notice of a material restriction, a correction route for false positives, and a means to seek restoration when safe and technically feasible.

(c) No Commercial Substitution.—Security controls shall not be used principally to suppress a competing lawful service, redirect a customer to an affiliated seller, or insert advertising into communications. A provider shall distinguish a security warning from a paid recommendation. An exception for customer-requested controls does not permit a provider to manufacture apparent consent through an unavoidable default, misleading notice, or condition unrelated to the requested protection.

TITLE IV—CUSTOMER CONTRACTS BILLING AND SWITCHING

SEC. 401. COVERAGE AND NONWAIVABLE RIGHTS.

(a) Coverage.—This title applies to retail connectivity, voice, cable, satellite television, and covered media subscriptions sold to individuals or small-business subscribers. A negotiated enterprise contract with a purchaser employing 500 or more persons is excluded, except from prohibitions on fraud and intentional concealment. A provider shall not characterize a standardized small-business contract as individually negotiated merely because a salesperson discussed it.

(b) Administration.—The Commission shall administer this title for connectivity and voice; the Trade Commission shall administer it for media subscriptions. For a bundle, each agency retains its subject-matter authority and shall coordinate through a single customer complaint record. A customer shall not be required to correctly identify the agency before obtaining assistance.

(c) Rights.—A prospective waiver of a right under this title is unenforceable. A customer may settle an existing, identified dispute after receiving its material terms, subject to title XXVII. A provider shall not require purchase of a dispute-resolution service to exercise a statutory right.

SEC. 402. TOTAL PRICE AT THE POINT OF OFFER.

(a) Display.—An advertised price shall include all mandatory charges imposed by the seller for the advertised service, including equipment required by the seller, administrative charges, broadcast or sports surcharges, activation charges allocated as required by rule, and unavoidable processing fees. Government taxes may be separately stated if their exclusion is disclosed prominently and the actual total is provided before commitment.

(b) Promotions.—A promotional offer shall state its duration, subsequent price or objective method of calculation, eligibility conditions, required bundle, and early termination consequences next to the promotional price. A price shall not be described as permanent when the seller retains an unrestricted right to increase it.

(c) Optional Items.—An item is optional only when the customer can practically obtain the advertised service without it. A preselected add-on or a charge disclosed only after payment information has been submitted is not a valid optional purchase. Comparative prices shall use equivalent periods and disclose any material difference in service.

SEC. 403. CONTRACT SUMMARY AND RECORD.

(a) Summary.—Before commitment, a provider shall furnish a concise transaction summary stating the selected service, total initial and recurring charges, promotion expiration, renewal method, minimum term, cancellation method, equipment ownership, material service limits, and complaint contact. The summary shall be downloadable or provided on paper without charge.

(b) Record.—Within 24 hours after enrollment, the provider shall deliver a durable confirmation and the governing terms in the customer's chosen accessible format. The provider shall retain the accepted version and evidence of authorization for the contract term and three years thereafter, subject to data-minimization requirements.

(c) Inconsistency.—A specific representation in the transaction summary controls over inconsistent boilerplate when the customer reasonably relied on that representation. A provider may correct a genuine typographical error promptly before performance if it offers cancellation and a full refund. It may not use a later website revision to alter the historical agreement or erase evidence of a disputed promise.

(a) Authorization.—Recurring charges require affirmative consent to the amount or ascertainable calculation, frequency, duration, and cancellation method. Consent to one purchase does not authorize an unrelated subscription. A free trial shall identify the first charge date and amount and provide a reminder between three and seven days before conversion when the trial lasts at least seven days.

(b) Reminders.—For an annual or longer renewal, the provider shall give notice between 15 and 45 days before renewal. For a material price increase, notice shall be given at least 30 days in advance. A customer may cancel before the increase without an early termination charge attributable to the change.

(c) Evidence.—The provider bears the burden of establishing authorization. An unauthorized recurring charge shall be refunded within 10 business days after determination, together with related seller-imposed fees. A disputed charge shall not be reported as delinquent while a timely, nonfrivolous dispute is being investigated.

SEC. 405. SIMPLE CANCELLATION.

(a) Method.—A customer who enrolls online or through an application shall be able to cancel through an equally accessible online or application mechanism. Telephone and in-person enrollment shall have a reasonably available cancellation channel. Cancellation shall not require a live conversation, retention offer, survey, or explanation unless the customer voluntarily requests assistance.

(b) Completion.—A clearly labeled cancellation control shall be available from ordinary account settings without a search through unrelated pages. Necessary authentication may prevent fraud but shall not be materially more burdensome than authentication for changing payment details. The provider shall immediately acknowledge receipt and state the effective date.

(c) Effect.—Cancellation stops future renewal charges. Service may continue through a prepaid period at the customer's election. A separate equipment balance shall be disclosed and shall not prevent cancellation of service. A provider shall not treat a failed payment as cancellation unless the customer was given notice and the applicable opportunity to cure.

SEC. 406. REFUNDS AND PRORATION.

(a) Baseline.—When a provider terminates a service without customer breach, materially fails to deliver a specifically purchased event, or imposes an unaccepted material adverse change, the customer is entitled to a refund for the undelivered portion. Refunds shall use the original payment method unless the customer chooses another method.

(b) Connectivity.—For connectivity canceled after the first billing cycle, unused prepaid service shall be prorated by day. A disclosed discounted annual media subscription may provide continued access instead of a midterm convenience refund, but that limitation shall not apply to provider breach, unlawful renewal, or a material adverse change.

(c) Timing.—Refunds shall be initiated within 10 business days and shall not be replaced by expiring credits without consent. A provider may withhold a reasonable, separately documented amount for unreturned equipment after notice and an opportunity to return it. It may not withhold an entire refund because a small equipment dispute remains unresolved.

SEC. 407. BILLING ACCURACY AND DISPUTES.

(a) Bill.—A bill shall separately identify service periods, recurring charges, one-time charges, government taxes, payments, credits, and amounts due. A charge for a third-party product shall identify the actual seller and the authorization relied upon. A provider shall not label its own charge as a government fee.

(b) Dispute.—Customers may dispute a charge within 120 days after a bill reasonably makes the charge apparent, or later when concealment prevented discovery. The provider shall acknowledge the dispute within five business days, investigate within 30 days, and explain the result with supporting transaction information.

(c) Protection.—During review, the customer shall pay undisputed amounts but shall not be disconnected, charged a late fee, or subjected to collection for the disputed amount. A provider may end this protection for a demonstrably abusive repeated dispute after written reasons and an opportunity for independent review. Good-faith disagreement alone is not abuse.

SEC. 408. SERVICE INTERRUPTIONS AND CREDITS.

(a) Credit.—For a provider-attributable interruption of fixed connectivity or voice lasting more than four consecutive hours, the provider shall automatically credit at least one day's recurring service charge for each affected calendar day, without requiring a claim. Multiple affected services shall be credited separately to the extent separately charged.

(b) Exclusions.—A narrowly tailored exclusion may apply to customer equipment failure, customer refusal of necessary access, or a disaster beyond reasonable provider control. The exclusion does not cover inadequate maintenance, preventable software change, failure to maintain promised backup, or unreasonable restoration delay after the external cause ends.

(c) Additional Relief.—A statutory credit is a minimum and does not eliminate a stronger contractual service-level payment or proven compensatory damages available under another provision. Providers shall disclose how a customer can challenge an omitted credit. The Commission may establish equivalent measures for mobile service where location-specific evidence makes a fixed-address test inappropriate.

SEC. 409. SWITCHING AND NUMBER PORTABILITY.

(a) Process.—The receiving provider shall coordinate a customer-authorized switch using secure procedures that minimize interruption and duplicate billing. The losing provider shall not delay a lawful transfer to obtain payment of an unrelated disputed debt or require a retention conversation.

(b) Authentication.—A transfer shall use proportionate identity verification and prompt alerts to the account holder. Customers at risk of domestic violence or stalking may select a safe notification channel. A provider shall maintain emergency procedures to reverse a fraudulent port without automatically restoring an abuser's access.

(c) Continuity.—Where technically feasible, the prior connection shall remain active until the receiving service is confirmed working. A customer shall not be charged beyond a reasonable transition period because of provider coordination failure. Portability duties apply to transferable numbers and identifiers specified by rule; they do not create ownership of a platform's trademarks or require transfer of another person's account.

SEC. 410. EQUIPMENT RETURNS AND INSTALLATION.

(a) Returns.—A provider requiring return of rented equipment shall offer at least one prepaid return method, provide a dated receipt or tracking record, and allow at least 30 days after cancellation. A charge may not exceed the reasonable depreciated replacement value of equipment actually unreturned or materially damaged beyond ordinary wear.

(b) Installation.—An installation appointment shall state a reasonable arrival window. If the provider misses the appointment without timely notice or customer fault, it shall provide a credit established by rule reflecting the inconvenience and shall prioritize rescheduling. The customer shall be told before work begins of any construction charge not included in the original quote.

(c) Verification.—An installer shall test service at the premises, document material limitations, explain the distinction between network and in-home wireless performance, and leave accessible support information. A signature confirming installation does not waive a defect that could not reasonably be discovered during the appointment.

SEC. 411. DEBT COLLECTION AND ESSENTIAL SERVICE.

(a) Notice.—Before disconnecting residential connectivity for nonpayment, a provider shall give at least 15 days' notice identifying the amount, available dispute rights, any affordable plan, and a reasonable payment arrangement. A notice shall be available in the language used to sell the service when practicable.

(b) Hardship.—A customer facing documented temporary hardship shall be offered at least one installment arrangement for arrears over a period of three months. The provider need not forgive valid debt but shall not impose a reconnection fee disproportionate to actual cost or require purchase of a more expensive plan as a condition of restoration.

(c) Safety.—Emergency calling shall be preserved to the extent technically feasible and required by law. The Commission shall establish temporary protections during declared disasters and for medically necessary communications, with objective eligibility and cost controls. Nothing requires unlimited uncompensated service, but essential-service protections shall not be defeated by relabeling a disconnection as an account migration.

SEC. 412. CUSTOMER SUPPORT AND ENFORCEMENT.

(a) Support.—Providers shall maintain a free, accessible means of reaching a human representative for unresolved billing, cancellation, accessibility, and safety problems. Automated assistance may be offered but shall not create an endless loop or falsely represent that no review is available.

(b) Records.—A customer shall receive a case identifier and a summary of material promises made during support. Recordings shall be retained only as necessary, protected against secondary use, and made available to the customer to the extent consistent with others' privacy and applicable law.

(c) Effective Date.—This title takes effect 18 months after enactment for new contracts and renewals, and 24 months after enactment for ongoing performance under existing contracts. Billing accuracy, unauthorized-charge refunds, and prospective cancellation rights apply to all covered customers after the latter date. Agencies shall publish model transaction summaries and cancellation specifications at least six months before the first compliance date. Enforcement and remedies are provided in title XXVII.

SEC. 413. SALES AGENTS AND UNAUTHORIZED TRANSFERS.

(a) Authority.—A provider shall reasonably supervise a person it authorizes to enroll customers, change plans, or initiate transfers. Compensation arrangements shall not reward forged consent, concealment of material terms, or enrollment of a customer who did not request the service.

(b) Confirmation.—Before completing a material account transfer or adding a recurring paid service, the responsible provider shall obtain authenticated customer authorization proportionate to the risk. A seller's assertion that authorization exists is insufficient when the provider knows of a pattern of unreliable enrollment records.

(c) Correction.—Upon finding an unauthorized transfer or charge, the provider shall restore the prior practical service arrangement where feasible, refund resulting unauthorized charges, and correct associated account records. The customer shall not bear a termination or restoration fee caused by the unauthorized act. Providers may allocate responsibility among themselves afterward without delaying the customer's remedy. This section does not make a provider liable for an unrelated impostor with whom it had no agency, contractual, or knowing operational relationship.

SEC. 414. DEPOSITS CREDIT CHECKS AND PAYMENT METHODS.

(a) Disclosure.—Before requiring a security deposit or credit inquiry, a provider shall disclose the amount, purpose, refund conditions, and any reasonably available alternative. It shall not describe a deposit as a government tax or retain it after the stated conditions for return have been satisfied.

(b) Proportionality.—A deposit shall bear a reasonable relationship to expected unpaid service and equipment exposure. A provider offering an essential connectivity plan shall consider a prepaid or spending-limited alternative that avoids a credit inquiry where operationally feasible. This subsection does not require extension of unsecured credit.

(c) Return.—An undisputed refundable deposit shall be returned within 30 days after the conditions for return are met, less documented lawful amounts due. A provider shall offer a reasonably accessible payment method to customers unable to use automatic bank withdrawal. Any payment-method charge shall be disclosed before commitment, reflect a legitimate processing difference, and comply with other applicable limits. A customer shall not be charged for declining optional commercial data sharing.

SEC. 415. DEATH INCAPACITY AND ACCOUNT REPRESENTATION.

(a) Authorized Action.—A provider shall maintain a practical process for a legally authorized representative to terminate, transfer, or manage an account following death or incapacity. Verification shall be proportionate and may rely on documentation accepted under applicable estate, guardianship, or agency law.

(b) Limits.—The process shall distinguish authority over billing from authority to obtain private communications or another person's protected information. An executor's ability to cancel a subscription does not automatically create a right to read all communications associated with the account.

(c) Charges.—After receiving sufficient notice and authorization, a provider shall stop future recurring charges within the period otherwise required for cancellation. It shall not demand payment by a relative who is not legally liable for the debt. Reasonable accommodation shall be available when standard electronic authentication depends on a deceased or incapacitated person's inaccessible device. Records necessary to resolve estate obligations may be retained securely without keeping the subscription active or representing continued billing as a preservation fee.

TITLE V—AFFORDABILITY AND UNIVERSAL SERVICE

SEC. 501. HOUSEHOLD CONNECTIVITY BENEFIT.

(a) Establishment.—The Commission shall establish a Household Connectivity Benefit providing eligible households a monthly reduction in the actual price of qualifying broadband service. The scheduled benefit is $40 per month, or $75 for an eligible household residing on qualifying Tribal lands, subject to the funding limitation and prospective adjustment procedure in section 507.

(b) Choice.—The household may apply the benefit to any qualifying plan offered by a participating provider, including an existing plan. A provider shall not require a household to select a special higher-priced plan, accept a long-term commitment, purchase entertainment, or waive privacy rights to receive the benefit.

(c) Payment.—The benefit shall be paid to the participating provider after verified service, reflected as a distinct credit on the customer's bill, and limited to the actual eligible charge. A provider shall not receive payment for an unactivated account, a disconnected line, or a service not delivered, except for a short restoration period expressly allowed by rule.

SEC. 502. ELIGIBLE HOUSEHOLDS.

(a) Income.—A household is eligible when its annual income does not exceed 200 percent of the applicable Federal poverty guideline, or when a member participates in a qualifying means-tested program identified by the Commission whose income criteria establish equivalent or greater need.

(b) Qualifying Programs.—The Commission shall accept participation in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income, Federal public housing assistance, and qualifying Tribal assistance, subject to verification rules that avoid unnecessary disclosure. Receipt of a Federal Pell Grant during the current award year may establish eligibility for the recipient's household.

(c) Economic Unit.—Only one benefit may be paid per household at a time, but shared addresses shall not create a presumption of ineligibility. A household without a permanent address may designate a safe service location or mailing contact. Documentation shall accommodate homelessness, recent displacement, disability, and loss of employment. A provider shall not demand immigration documents when identity and program eligibility can be established without them.

SEC. 503. ENROLLMENT AND VERIFICATION.

(a) Common Process.—The Commission shall maintain a common eligibility process that permits online, telephone, paper, and assisted applications. With the applicant's authorization, an administrator may obtain a yes-or-no eligibility confirmation from a qualifying program rather than collecting underlying medical, income, or benefit records.

(b) Minimization.—An applicant shall provide only information reasonably necessary to establish household identity, eligibility, duplicate-benefit prevention, and payment. Full Social Security numbers shall not be retained when a less intrusive reliable method is available. Information collected for this program shall not be sold or used for marketing.

(c) Review.—An adverse determination shall identify the reason and correction route. A household shall receive at least 30 days to cure a documentation defect. Automated mismatches shall not be treated as proof of fraud. Recertification shall occur no more than annually absent specific evidence of ineligibility, and existing verified information shall be reused when lawful and reliable.

SEC. 504. PARTICIPATING PROVIDERS.

(a) Qualification.—A provider may participate upon demonstrating legal authority to serve, technical capability, financial responsibility, a functioning complaint process, and ability to comply with program billing and audit requirements. Participation shall not depend on ownership form or incumbent status.

(b) Integrity.—The Commission shall screen controlling persons for material program fraud and outstanding debarment, provide notice of a proposed denial, and allow correction of mistaken identity. It may require a bond or other assurance proportionate to risk, with alternatives for small providers and cooperatives.

(c) Pricing.—A participating provider shall charge benefit recipients no more than similarly situated nonrecipients for the same service and shall not reduce quality because a customer receives assistance. Promotional prices shall remain available on equal terms. A provider may not describe the scheduled Federal benefit as its own discount or conceal the price that applies when the household's benefit changes.

SEC. 505. QUALIFYING SERVICE.

(a) Standard.—A qualifying fixed service shall ordinarily provide at least 100 megabits per second downstream and 20 megabits per second upstream, or a higher benchmark adopted after public review. A lower-performance service may qualify temporarily where no conforming service is actually available and the household knowingly chooses it.

(b) Functionality.—The service shall support ordinary education, employment, health, and communications uses without application-specific restrictions inconsistent with title III. A data allowance shall be sufficient for reasonably expected household needs, and the Commission shall evaluate affordability using total price, equipment, and overage exposure.

(c) Technology.—Qualification shall be technology-neutral and based on measured performance, reliability, and capacity at the location. A theoretical coverage claim does not establish eligibility for payment. Mobile-only service may be chosen by the household when suitable, but an administrator shall not substitute it for fixed service merely because it is cheaper when it materially fails the household's stated connectivity needs.

SEC. 506. COORDINATION WITH EXISTING SUPPORT.

(a) Supplemental Role.—The benefit supplements existing universal-service mechanisms under section 254 of the Communications Act of 1934. Nothing in this title terminates Lifeline, high-cost support, school and library support, or rural health support by implication.

(b) Duplication.—Combined assistance shall not exceed the actual eligible charge. Administrators shall identify which program pays which portion and shall not require a household to surrender a voice benefit when the broadband benefit pays a distinct service cost. Coordination shall preserve customer choice and avoid duplicate provider reimbursement.

(c) Contributions.—This Act does not expand the universal-service contribution base to all online services or advertising revenue. Any contribution-base change requires express legislation. The Commission shall annually report the existing base, contribution burden, pass-through practices, and alternatives, with separate analysis for small providers, household bills, and small advertisers. A report does not authorize a new tax or assessment.

SEC. 507. FUNDING LIMIT AND BENEFIT STABILITY.

(a) Limit.—Payments and administration under this title shall not exceed the amounts appropriated in title XXIX. No officer may create an obligation in excess of available budget authority. Scheduled benefit amounts are subject to this section and do not establish an uncapped entitlement.

(b) Forecast.—Quarterly, the Commission shall publish a 24-month forecast of enrollment, payments, administrative expense, and unobligated balances. If a shortfall is reasonably projected within 12 months, it shall notify Congress and affected households, seek additional authority where appropriate, and adopt a prospective uniform adjustment sufficient to remain within available funds.

(c) Adjustment.—At least 120 days' notice shall precede a reduction. The Commission shall first reduce avoidable administrative cost and improper payments, then adjust benefits proportionately while preserving the ratio between ordinary and Tribal benefits. It shall not abruptly terminate selected households to conceal a shortfall or recover valid prior benefits. Providers shall offer an informed choice to continue, downgrade, or cancel without penalty.

SEC. 508. DEVICES AND ADOPTION SUPPORT.

(a) Device Assistance.—Within the appropriation for digital inclusion, the Secretary may provide a voucher of up to $150 for a suitable computer or accessible device to an eligible household, no more than once every four years, with replacement for verified loss from a disaster. A voucher may cover refurbished equipment meeting durability, warranty, and security standards.

(b) Navigation.—Grants may support trusted local assistance with enrollment, device setup, accessibility, basic security, and use of education or employment services. Assistance shall be voluntary and shall not require disclosure of passwords or surrender of control over personal accounts.

(c) Independence.—A navigator shall disclose any provider compensation and may not steer a household to a plan based on a commission. Performance shall be measured by successful, sustained use and resolved barriers, not merely applications submitted. The Secretary shall provide multilingual and disability-accessible materials without prescribing political or ideological content.

SEC. 509. HIGH COST SUSTAINABILITY.

(a) Review.—The Commission shall evaluate whether supported rural networks can maintain service over the useful life of funded assets, considering operating expense, maintenance, backhaul, power, insurance, workforce, and realistic customer revenue. Construction completion alone is not evidence of sustainable operation.

(b) Conditions.—Any new operating-support award under authority otherwise available shall specify eligible costs, service obligations, financial reporting, related-party transaction controls, and periodic review. A recipient shall not recover the same cost through multiple grants, universal-service support, and an undisclosed customer surcharge.

(c) Transition.—A material reduction in support shall include a service-continuity analysis, adequate notice, and consideration of a staged transition. Continued support is not guaranteed to an inefficient or noncompliant operator. Where a recipient fails, the Commission shall seek a qualified successor through an open process and protect customers from avoidable interruption while preserving lawful creditor and property rights.

SEC. 510. INSTITUTIONS AND COMMUNITY ACCESS.

(a) Coordination.—The Commission and Secretary shall coordinate household support with connectivity for schools, libraries, rural health facilities, shelters, and other eligible institutions. Institutional connectivity shall not be represented as a substitute for reliable home service when hours, travel, privacy, or disability make it impractical.

(b) Shared Facilities.—A funded community access point shall provide reasonable hours, accessible equipment, and clear privacy practices. Users shall not be required to agree to commercial tracking, view targeted advertising, or surrender personal content as a condition of access.

(c) Accounting.—An institution may share capacity with its community where permitted by the governing support program, provided that supported educational or health functions remain adequately served and costs are properly allocated. This section does not expand another program's eligibility without express authority, but the agencies shall identify statutory barriers and recommend narrowly tailored amendments to Congress.

SEC. 511. FRAUD PREVENTION AND HOUSEHOLD PROTECTION.

(a) Providers.—Knowingly enrolling fictitious households, forging consent, splitting one household into false accounts, or billing for unprovided service is a violation enforceable under title XXVII and other applicable law. Providers shall supervise enrollment agents and maintain auditable records of compensation and authorization.

(b) Households.—A household shall not be penalized for a provider's error or an innocent misunderstanding. Recovery from an individual requires notice, an opportunity to contest, and proof of knowing material misrepresentation. Collection shall consider ability to pay and shall not include an unlawful threat to immigration status or unrelated public benefits.

(c) Analytics.—Fraud detection may use proportionate matching and anomaly analysis. Agencies shall test false-positive rates, protect shared-address households, and permit human review. A statistical flag alone is not sufficient to suspend an entire provider's payments without assessing the effect on lawful customers and providing the process required by title XXVII.

SEC. 512. OUTCOMES AND PROGRAM REVIEW.

(a) Measures.—The Commission shall publish enrollment, actual benefit, household contribution, sustained adoption, disconnection, complaint, and improper-payment measures, disaggregated where privacy permits by income, geography, disability access, and Tribal participation. It shall distinguish an approved application from an activated connection and an activated connection from continuing use.

(b) Independent Evaluation.—In program years 3 and 7, the Comptroller General shall assess whether the benefit reduces total household cost, improves sustained access, or is absorbed through price changes. The assessment shall compare relevant nonrecipient prices and identify limitations in the evidence.

(c) Continuation.—At least two years before the final funded program year, the Commission shall submit a reauthorization and transition recommendation. Unless Congress provides further funds, it shall provide orderly notice and wind-down within the appropriation. Providers may not automatically convert a zero-dollar assisted account to a paid account without the household's affirmative agreement to the resulting price.

SEC. 513. BENEFIT TRANSFERS AND CHANGES IN HOUSEHOLD CIRCUMSTANCES.

(a) Transfer.—An eligible household may transfer its benefit to another participating provider through a common process. The administrator shall prevent duplicate payment for the same period while permitting prorated allocation when needed to avoid a gap in service. A provider shall not withhold transfer solely because an unrelated balance remains disputed.

(b) Notice.—A household shall report a material change in eligibility through a simple process. Loss of eligibility shall take effect prospectively after notice and a reasonable opportunity to respond. A temporary administrative delay in confirming continued participation in another assistance program shall not automatically be treated as fraud.

(c) Separation.—When a household divides into separate economic units, each unit may establish eligibility under section 502. The administrator shall use evidence of actual financial arrangements and shall not require disclosure of a survivor's confidential location to a former household member. The process shall include correction of mistaken duplicate records and protection against an unauthorized person transferring a benefit without the household's consent.

SEC. 514. PROVIDER REIMBURSEMENT AND RECONCILIATION.

(a) Claims.—A participating provider shall submit monthly claims using a unique program identifier, the service period, the actual eligible charge, and the credited benefit. The administrator shall not require routine submission of browsing activity, communication content, or a household's medical or immigration records.

(b) Review.—Undisputed complete claims shall ordinarily be paid within 30 days. A questioned portion may be withheld while a documented discrepancy is examined, but unrelated verified claims shall not be delayed solely to increase settlement pressure. The administrator may impose proportionate safeguards when credible evidence shows systemic fraud.

(c) Reconciliation.—Providers shall correct overpayments and underpayments promptly through a traceable reconciliation process. A correction affecting a customer's bill shall be explained in plain language. The Commission shall permit sampling and risk-based audits that protect program integrity without requiring every small provider to purchase a proprietary compliance system. False certifications remain subject to applicable civil and criminal law independently of this Act.

SEC. 515. BENEFICIARY APPEALS AND CONTINUITY.

(a) Appeal.—A household denied enrollment, recertification, or a transfer may request review within 60 days after notice, with extension for good cause. The reviewer shall be independent of the person making the disputed determination and shall consider reliable alternative evidence.

(b) Decision.—The administrator shall ordinarily decide a complete appeal within 30 days and explain the relevant facts, rule, and further review route. Urgent cases involving imminent loss of essential connectivity shall receive expedited consideration. Accessible assistance shall be available without a fee or a requirement to retain counsel.

(c) Continuity.—An enrolled household timely contesting termination may continue to receive the benefit during the initial administrative appeal, within available appropriations, unless specific evidence establishes intentional misuse or duplicate payment. A final adverse decision shall operate prospectively except where lawful recovery for knowing misrepresentation is established. This section does not guarantee payment after the program's appropriated funds are exhausted or override the uniform funding adjustment required by section 507.

SEC. 516. PROGRAM LAUNCH AND ENROLLMENT READINESS.

(a) Launch.—The Commission shall open household enrollment not later than twelve months after funds first become available under section 2902. It shall publish proposed operational requirements within 180 days after enactment and final initial requirements in time to permit provider testing before launch.

(b) Readiness.—Before releasing payments, the Commission shall test eligibility verification, duplicate prevention, provider enrollment, bill credits, appeals, accessibility, and protection of personal information. Testing shall include participating small providers and users who apply without reliable internet access. A material defect shall receive a corrective plan and shall not be concealed by reporting only the number of applications received.

(c) Participation.—Program conditions apply to a provider when it voluntarily accepts participation and reimbursement, notwithstanding the general private-duty transition. The Commission may begin enrollment in operationally ready portions of the program while completing a specific unresolved integration, provided similarly situated households receive a fair opportunity and the phased launch does not become indefinite geographic exclusion. Any delay beyond the statutory launch deadline shall be reported to Congress with its legal basis and corrective schedule.

TITLE VI—DEPLOYMENT INVESTMENT AND PUBLIC ASSETS

SEC. 601. CONNECTIVITY EXPANSION PROGRAM.

(a) Program.—The Secretary shall administer a Connectivity Expansion Program to finance service in locations lacking reliable, affordable broadband and to remedy demonstrable capacity or resilience deficiencies. Awards shall supplement, and not duplicate, legally committed Federal, State, Tribal, or local funding.

(b) Priority.—Priority shall be given first to unserved locations, then underserved locations, then eligible community institutions and resilience projects with substantial public benefit. A location is unserved when no provider can actually deliver reliable 100/20 service within a reasonable standard installation interval; the Secretary may establish a higher threshold prospectively after public review.

(c) Ownership.—Private, cooperative, nonprofit, Tribal, and public providers may apply on equal functional terms. An applicant shall demonstrate lawful authority, financial and technical capacity, and an operating plan. No applicant shall be favored solely because it is an incumbent, uses a particular technology, or promises the lowest construction cost without demonstrating durable performance.

SEC. 602. LOCATION INVENTORY AND CHALLENGES.

(a) Inventory.—Before selecting projects, the Secretary shall reconcile the proposed locations with Federal availability data, existing enforceable deployment commitments, State and Tribal records, and credible local evidence. Each location shall have a stable identifier that does not expose an individual subscriber's identity.

(b) Challenge.—Residents, local governments, Tribes, providers, and institutions may challenge availability or duplication within a period of at least 45 days. Evidence may include failed installation requests, actual quotes, engineering records, and representative measurements. A provider's assertion of coverage shall identify the service it can deliver, installation interval, and ordinary charge.

(c) Decision.—Challenges shall receive written decisions and a review route. A provider that successfully excludes a location by committing to serve it shall be bound to the stated deadline and terms, subject to reasonable contingencies. Failure to perform may reopen eligibility and support recovery of costs caused by a knowingly false claim. Challenges shall not become a method of indefinitely delaying competing projects.

SEC. 603. PROJECT APPLICATIONS.

(a) Contents.—An application shall identify locations, technology, capacity, service prices, construction schedule, permits, workforce, maintenance arrangements, environmental obligations, cybersecurity, accessibility, and ten-year operating assumptions. It shall disclose controlling interests, related-party vendors, material litigation affecting performance, and other public support for the same assets.

(b) Financial Plan.—The applicant shall provide construction and operating budgets, contingency allowances, customer-adoption assumptions, financing commitments, insurance, and a sensitivity analysis for cost increases and lower revenue. The Secretary shall not treat a speculative future subsidy as committed financing.

(c) Small Applicants.—A smaller applicant may use standardized forms, pooled technical assistance, and proportionate security arrangements. The Secretary may stage awards so that a capable entrant need not finance an entire regional build before reimbursement. Simplification shall not remove the need to demonstrate that the project can be completed and operated.

SEC. 604. SELECTION AND TECHNOLOGY.

(a) Scoring.—The Secretary shall publish scoring criteria before applications open. Criteria shall include lifecycle cost, measurable capacity, reliability, scalability, affordability, competition, resilience, execution risk, and community need. The scoring record shall explain material judgments and identify why a lower-priced proposal was rejected when relevant.

(b) Technology.—No technology shall be categorically preferred or excluded without a statutory basis or evidence tied to the project's requirements. Satellite and wireless proposals shall establish usable capacity under realistic loading, weather, terrain, and equipment conditions; fiber proposals shall establish construction feasibility and sustainable maintenance rather than relying solely on theoretical performance.

(c) Conflicts.—Evaluators shall disclose conflicts and recuse where required. An applicant may request review of a material scoring error, but disagreement with a disclosed policy preference is not itself proof of error. Award decisions shall remain subject to applicable procurement, grant, and judicial-review law.

SEC. 605. MATCHING FUNDS AND COST SHARING.

(a) Match.—The ordinary non-Federal match is 20 percent of eligible project cost. The Secretary may reduce or waive the match for a Tribe, persistently poor community, remote high-cost location, or applicant demonstrating that the match would prevent a high-value project from proceeding.

(b) Valuation.—In-kind contributions shall be independently supportable, necessary to the project, and valued at no more than reasonable market cost. An applicant may not count the same asset toward multiple matching requirements or inflate an affiliate's charge to manufacture a match.

(c) Conditions.—A waiver shall state the public benefit, financial need, and safeguards. Match relief does not permit a recipient to distribute grant proceeds as dividends or use public funds to acquire unrelated businesses. Reasonable financing expense and working capital may qualify only to the extent expressly allowed in the award and necessary for delivery of the supported service.

SEC. 606. MILESTONES AND DISBURSEMENT.

(a) Agreement.—Each award shall contain measurable construction, activation, performance, affordability, and reporting milestones. The agreement shall identify the evidence required for payment, the responsible official, corrective-action procedures, and consequences of material default.

(b) Payment.—Funds shall be disbursed in stages after verification, with advances allowed where necessary for an otherwise qualified smaller recipient and protected by appropriate controls. At least 10 percent of the construction award shall ordinarily be retained until independent confirmation of service delivery, unless an equivalent assurance protects the Government.

(c) Change Control.—Material changes in technology, locations, ownership, or cost shall require approval supported by a revised public-benefit and sustainability analysis. A recipient shall not quietly replace a promised high-capacity build with a materially inferior service. Reasonable design changes may be approved when they preserve or improve the required outcome and do not disadvantage an unsuccessful bidder through an undisclosed change in competition.

SEC. 607. AFFORDABILITY AND SERVICE COMMITMENTS.

(a) Plan.—For at least ten years after project completion, a recipient shall offer a qualifying affordable plan specified in the award, participate in the Household Connectivity Benefit, and maintain publicly stated service terms. The affordable plan shall be evaluated using total price and actual performance, not a promotional headline.

(b) Adjustment.—A recipient may seek an adjustment for demonstrated cost changes beyond its reasonable control. The Secretary shall require financial evidence, consider less harmful alternatives, and provide notice to affected customers. An adjustment shall not be granted solely to increase the return on a publicly financed asset.

(c) Enforcement.—Service commitments run with the funded assets during the commitment period and shall be disclosed to a proposed purchaser. A transfer may be approved when a qualified successor assumes the obligations. The Government's remedies shall reflect actual nonperformance and public loss, and shall avoid destroying viable service where a corrective plan can adequately protect the public.

SEC. 608. OPEN ACCESS TO PUBLICLY FUNDED INFRASTRUCTURE.

(a) Condition.—An award financing a substantial share of a middle-mile route, conduit system, or other shared bottleneck asset shall require reasonable, nondiscriminatory wholesale access on published terms. The condition shall be stated before acceptance and limited to the funded asset and associated capacity.

(b) Pricing.—Access rates shall permit recovery of efficiently incurred operating and maintenance costs, an appropriate allocation of unreimbursed capital, and a reasonable return on private investment. Publicly paid capital shall not be recovered again as though privately financed. The recipient may impose objective engineering and security requirements.

(c) Capacity.—The recipient shall maintain a fair request queue and provide reasons for denial. An obligation to expand capacity beyond the award requires a separate finding and funding or compensation arrangement. This section does not automatically impose wholesale duties on every privately financed last-mile facility, which remains governed by the targeted standards in titles VII and XVIII.

(a) Competition.—Recipients shall use transparent, commercially reasonable procurement for material project purchases. A sole-source purchase shall be justified by compatibility, urgency, unique capability, or another documented necessity rather than personal affiliation.

(b) Affiliates.—A related-party transaction shall be disclosed before reimbursement and priced no higher than the lower of reasonable market value or allowable documented cost plus a reasonable disclosed margin. The recipient shall maintain records sufficient to identify beneficial ownership and prevent circular invoices.

(c) Integrity.—Kickbacks, undisclosed commissions, false invoices, and substitution of used or defective equipment represented as new are prohibited. A recipient shall maintain a confidential reporting channel and protect workers who report suspected misuse. Debarment shall follow notice and an opportunity to respond, and shall distinguish responsible persons from innocent subcontractors and employees.

SEC. 610. LABOR SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW.

(a) Compliance.—Construction shall comply with applicable wage, occupational safety, environmental, historic-preservation, and land-access law. This Act does not waive Tribal consultation or authorize entry on land without a valid right of access.

(b) Coordination.—The Secretary shall coordinate reviews where multiple agencies consider the same project, identify a lead contact, accept common factual submissions, and set transparent schedules. Coordination shall eliminate duplicative processing without predetermining substantive findings.

(c) Restoration.—Awards shall budget for restoration of disturbed property, traffic control, utility marking, erosion protection, and safe disposal of removed equipment. Contractors shall maintain contact information for affected owners and respond promptly to damage reports. A project's promised completion date shall not justify unsafe trenching, improper pole work, or concealment of a material environmental condition.

SEC. 611. DEFAULT AND CONTINUITY.

(a) Correction.—Upon material default, the Secretary shall issue a notice identifying the failure, supporting evidence, and a reasonable correction period unless immediate action is necessary to protect funds or safety. Remedies may include withheld payments, a revised schedule, replacement of a contractor, proportional repayment, or termination.

(b) Successor.—Where termination would strand a substantially completed network or disconnect customers, the Secretary may solicit a qualified successor and arrange assignment of grant obligations consistent with property, bankruptcy, and contract law. A Federal grant condition does not itself authorize uncompensated seizure of privately owned assets.

(c) Recovery.—Recoveries shall reflect unsupported cost, undelivered benefit, and intentional misconduct, with credit for useful assets and service actually provided where appropriate. A recipient shall not avoid liability through an asset transfer to an affiliate. The Secretary shall publish aggregate defaults and recoveries and refer suspected fraud to the appropriate enforcement authority.

SEC. 612. COMPLETION AND LONG TERM ACCOUNTABILITY.

(a) Certification.—Completion requires independent verification that funded locations can obtain the promised service at the promised terms, not merely that construction invoices have been paid. A sample-based method shall be statistically justified and supplemented by direct investigation of credible complaints.

(b) Monitoring.—Recipients shall report annually for the service-commitment period on active connections, performance, outages, prices, maintenance, and material financial risks. Reporting shall use existing reliable data where possible and avoid collecting individual browsing information.

(c) Evaluation.—The Secretary shall compare awarded cost with actual lifecycle cost and identify whether selection criteria systematically favor bids that later default or require additional support. At least every three years, the Secretary shall revise administrative methods through public process within the statutory limits. No revision may retroactively excuse fraud or erase a customer's existing contractual right.

SEC. 613. APPLICATION COSTS AND FINANCIAL ASSURANCE.

(a) Staged Application.—The Secretary shall use an initial application requiring information sufficient to assess eligibility and project merit, followed by more detailed engineering and financial documentation from applicants reasonably likely to receive an award. An applicant shall not be required to purchase final construction drawings merely to establish preliminary eligibility.

(b) Assurance.—A performance bond, letter of credit, guarantee, or other financial assurance shall be proportionate to the unpaid public exposure and risk of noncompletion. The Secretary shall permit equivalent alternatives, staged reductions after verified milestones, and pooled arrangements that do not conceal correlated risk.

(c) Small Applicants.—Technical assistance may support cooperatives, Tribes, municipalities, and small providers preparing credible applications. Assistance shall not guarantee selection or reimburse lobbying. A requirement imposed for financial assurance shall be publicly explained and shall not be calibrated solely to the balance-sheet characteristics of the largest incumbent. An applicant remains responsible for demonstrating that its proposed construction and operating commitments are financially plausible.

SEC. 614. FIELD VERIFICATION AND ACCEPTANCE.

(a) Verification.—Before final project acceptance, the awarding agency shall verify a risk-based sample of claimed service locations, installation availability, actual performance, and required affordability offers. The sample shall include locations presenting known challenges rather than only easily accessible premises selected by the recipient.

(b) Customer Experience.—Verification shall consider whether a resident can obtain service within the promised installation period at the disclosed standard charge. A passing signal near a road, an unconnected terminal, or theoretical satellite visibility does not alone establish that a location is served as promised.

(c) Correction.—A material deficiency shall result in a corrective schedule, proportionate retention of unpaid funds, or recovery under the award. Minor documentation errors that do not affect service may be corrected without delaying acceptance of independently completed portions. The agency shall publish aggregate verification results and explain sampling limitations. Exact household details, sensitive network configurations, and protected Tribal information shall remain subject to applicable confidentiality safeguards.

SEC. 615. CHANGE ORDERS AND COST OVERRUNS.

(a) Approval.—A recipient shall obtain prior approval for a material change in funded service area, technology, ownership, performance commitment, or total eligible cost. The request shall identify the reason, alternatives, effect on users, and any additional public contribution sought.

(b) Standard.—The agency may approve a change that remains consistent with the original competitive objectives and produces a reasonable public benefit. It shall not use a change order to award materially different work that should fairly be competed. A cost overrun does not create an entitlement to additional Federal money.

(c) Notice And Record.—Affected communities shall receive notice of a proposed material reduction in promised coverage and an opportunity to submit relevant evidence. Emergency repairs may proceed under a documented exception when delay threatens safety or existing service. The agency shall maintain a public summary of approved material changes, protecting confidential cost details as appropriate, and shall recalculate matching funds and assurance requirements consistently with the revised public exposure.

TITLE VII—INFRASTRUCTURE ACCESS AND PERMITTING

SEC. 701. ACCESS TO POLES CONDUITS AND RIGHTS OF WAY.

(a) Duty.—An owner of a pole, duct, conduit, or right-of-way facility used in interstate communications shall provide reasonable and nondiscriminatory access to a qualified communications provider when capacity exists and access can be safely accommodated. This duty applies to investor-owned, municipal, and cooperative owners, subject to the protections in this title.

(b) Qualification.—An applicant shall demonstrate insurance or an equivalent assurance, technical competence, compliance with safety requirements, and ability to pay lawful charges. An owner shall not require an applicant to purchase unrelated services or accept restrictions on lawful competition.

(c) Property.—Access shall provide just and reasonable compensation and preserve legitimate operational needs. A dispute involving a claimed taking may be presented to a court with jurisdiction. Nothing authorizes occupation of property outside the owner's legal interest or displacement of a prior lawful user without the process and compensation required by law.

SEC. 702. APPLICATIONS AND COMPLETENESS.

(a) Standard Form.—The Commission shall establish minimum information reasonably necessary to assess access, including location, proposed loading, equipment, engineering, construction method, and safety qualifications. Owners may request additional information tied to a documented site-specific need.

(b) Response.—Within 15 days after receipt, an owner shall identify any material deficiency with reasonable specificity. If no deficiency is identified, the application is complete for purposes of the decision schedule, but deemed completeness does not establish safety or substantive approval.

(c) No Serial Delay.—An owner may not repeatedly demand information it could reasonably have requested during the initial review. A later request shall explain the new fact or previously unavailable issue requiring it. The decision period may be tolled only for the time reasonably necessary to obtain material information. Both parties shall maintain an accessible record of submissions, responses, and agreed schedule changes.

SEC. 703. SURVEYS AND MAKE READY WORK.

(a) Schedule.—For an ordinary application covering no more than 300 poles, the owner shall ordinarily complete a survey within 45 days and provide a make-ready estimate within 15 additional days. Larger projects may use a published proportionate schedule approved by the Commission.

(b) Estimate.—The estimate shall identify necessary work, cost allocation, anticipated completion, affected attachers, and contingencies. The applicant may request an explanation of a material cost or propose an equivalent safe method. Payment of an estimate does not waive a later challenge to an unsupported charge.

(c) Coordination.—Existing attachers shall cooperate in timely relocation work and provide accurate contact information. A failure by an existing attacher shall not permit indefinite delay. The Commission may authorize qualified third-party work after notice, appropriate insurance, and safeguards for electric safety, service continuity, and damage responsibility. Work involving energized electric space shall remain subject to specialized qualifications and applicable safety law.

SEC. 704. COST ALLOCATION AND REPLACEMENT.

(a) Principle.—An applicant shall pay costs reasonably caused by its attachment, but shall not bear the entire cost of replacing an asset already due for replacement or correcting an owner's preexisting violation. Costs benefiting multiple users shall be allocated according to causation, usable capacity, and remaining asset life.

(b) Documentation.—An owner shall identify the condition of the existing asset, reason for replacement, engineering basis, and allocation method. The Commission shall provide a standardized method for depreciation and betterment without requiring unnecessary disclosure of unrelated utility accounts.

(c) Dispute.—An applicant may pay an undisputed amount and place the contested amount in escrow while a dispute proceeds. The owner shall not withhold otherwise safe access solely to force acceptance of an unsupported charge, provided that adequate security protects its lawful entitlement. A final decision shall address interest and responsibility for delay caused by an unreasonable position.

SEC. 705. MUNICIPAL AND COOPERATIVE OWNERS.

(a) Local Operations.—Rates and terms for municipal and cooperative facilities shall account for public financing restrictions, reliability duties, member obligations, and tax-exempt financing requirements. Those considerations shall be supported by evidence and shall not serve as a blanket exemption from nondiscriminatory access.

(b) State Process.—A State may administer an equivalent dispute process if it certifies that its standards meet or exceed the protections of this title, provides timely decisions, and preserves judicial review. The Commission shall decide certification requests on a public record and may withdraw certification after notice of persistent failure.

(c) Tribal Property.—No provision compels access to Tribal trust land or property owned by a Tribal government without the consent or authority otherwise required by Federal and Tribal law. A Tribe may voluntarily adopt an equivalent process or accept a clearly stated grant condition. Participation does not waive sovereign immunity beyond an express, limited agreement.

SEC. 706. BUILDING ACCESS AND EXCLUSIVITY.

(a) Prohibition.—A provider or building owner shall not enter into or enforce an exclusive arrangement that prevents residents or small-business occupants from obtaining service from another willing qualified provider where access can reasonably be accommodated.

(b) Permitted Arrangements.—A bulk-purchase agreement may offer a discounted service if occupants receive clear notice, retain a practical right to obtain an alternative, and are not charged an undisclosed duplicative connectivity fee. Marketing access and building wiring arrangements shall disclose payments that could influence recommendations.

(c) Physical Access.—Building access may be conditioned on reasonable scheduling, safety, insurance, restoration, and compensation for incremental costs. The Commission shall provide expedited dispute resolution and protect tenants from retaliation for requesting an alternative. This section does not authorize entry into an individual dwelling without consent or require construction that would create an unmitigable safety hazard.

SEC. 707. INSIDE WIRING AND NETWORK DEMARCATION.

(a) Disclosure.—A provider shall identify the demarcation point between its network and customer or building wiring. Charges for maintenance and repair shall reflect actual responsibility and shall be disclosed before purchase of an optional protection plan.

(b) Transfer.—When a customer switches providers, usable wiring owned by the customer shall remain available to the customer. A departing provider shall not remove, disable, or claim exclusive control over customer-owned wiring to prevent a lawful switch.

(c) Shared Systems.—Rules for shared wiring shall protect existing service, permit qualified access, and allocate restoration costs. An owner may require testing before connection but shall not use proprietary connectors or undocumented configuration solely to foreclose competition. A dispute shall consider whether an adapter or other less burdensome method can provide safe access without unnecessary replacement of functioning infrastructure.

SEC. 708. FEDERAL LAND AND FACILITY PERMITS.

(a) Coordination.—For communications projects requiring multiple Federal permissions, the Secretary shall designate a coordinating office and establish a consolidated schedule in consultation with the land-managing agencies. Each agency retains its substantive authority and responsibility.

(b) Deadlines.—Within 30 days after receiving a complete application, the coordinating office shall publish the expected review steps, required consultations, and target decision dates. An agency that misses a target shall explain the reason and the remaining action. Failure to meet a target does not automatically approve a project or extinguish environmental or Tribal obligations.

(c) Data.—Agencies shall maintain inventories of potentially usable Federal structures and corridors, excluding sensitive security information. Standard agreements may address access, restoration, insurance, and cost recovery. Fees shall reflect reasonable processing and use costs and shall not be manipulated to favor a particular provider or communications technology.

SEC. 709. LOCAL SITING AND REVIEW.

(a) Standard.—State and local siting decisions shall be based on objective, published criteria concerning safety, land use, structural capacity, historic resources, environmental effects, and management of public property. A decision shall not prohibit service solely to protect an incumbent from competition.

(b) Schedule.—The Commission shall establish presumptive review periods appropriate to collocation, replacement, and new construction, after consulting local governments and Tribes. An applicant shall provide complete information and pay lawful fees; a review period may be extended for a documented material issue or by agreement.

(c) Remedy.—A missed deadline permits expedited judicial or administrative review, not automatic authorization of unsafe work. The reviewing body may order a prompt decision and, where the record establishes entitlement, appropriate relief. This section does not compel a State legislature or local government to administer a Federal program; direct Federal duties attach to market participants and review of covered applications.

SEC. 710. DIG ONCE AND COORDINATED CONSTRUCTION.

(a) Planning.—Recipients of Federal transportation or communications construction funds under this Act shall evaluate whether installing spare conduit or coordinating excavation would materially reduce future disruption and cost. The evaluation shall consider demand, maintenance, ownership, safety, and public access.

(b) Notice.—For a planned major excavation affecting a public corridor, a recipient shall provide reasonable advance notice to qualified utilities and providers, subject to emergency and security exceptions. Participation costs shall be allocated fairly and shall not be inflated to deter entrants.

(c) Limits.—Coordination shall not delay urgent repair or force installation of economically unjustified facilities. A decision against shared construction shall identify the relevant constraints. Spare capacity financed with public funds shall be inventoried and offered on reasonable terms, with revenue applied as required by the governing grant and local law.

SEC. 711. EXPEDITED INFRASTRUCTURE DISPUTES.

(a) Process.—The Commission shall establish an expedited process for access, make-ready, and cost-allocation disputes. A complaint shall include the application record, disputed terms, requested relief, and evidence of reasonable efforts to resolve the matter.

(b) Decision.—Ordinary disputes should be decided within 90 days after a complete record, with interim relief available for substantial ongoing harm. Complex engineering disputes may require additional time supported by written reasons. Technical experts shall disclose conflicts and use methods open to challenge.

(c) Relief.—Orders may require access, revised terms, reimbursement of unsupported charges, a work schedule, or restoration. Monetary penalties are governed by title XXVII. The Commission shall account for safety and property rights and shall not award speculative lost profits through an expedited administrative process. Courts retain authority to determine compensation and constitutional claims.

SEC. 712. MAINTENANCE AND RECORD ACCURACY.

(a) Inventory.—Facility owners shall maintain reasonably accurate records of occupancy, available capacity, known hazards, and planned replacement, with secure access for qualified applicants. An owner need not warrant perfect historical records but shall correct verified material errors promptly.

(b) Inspection.—Attachers shall identify equipment, maintain it safely, and remove abandoned facilities within a reasonable period after notice. Cost responsibility shall follow ownership and causation. An owner shall not declare active equipment abandoned without reasonable verification and notice to the operator.

(c) Review.—Every four years, the Commission shall assess whether access rules reduce delays and total cost while preserving safety and investment. Reports shall distinguish owner-caused delay, applicant-caused delay, supply shortages, and required public review. A faster approval rate alone is not proof that infrastructure policy is succeeding.

SEC. 713. ATTACHMENT DISPUTES AND INTERIM COST ALLOCATION.

(a) Disputes.—A pole or conduit owner and an applicant shall identify the particular disputed engineering, scheduling, or cost item and exchange reasonably necessary supporting information. A dispute over one item shall not automatically suspend unrelated work that can safely proceed.

(b) Interim Payment.—The Commission or certified State authority may establish an escrow or provisional payment procedure for disputed charges, subject to later reconciliation. The procedure shall protect the owner's legitimate cost recovery and the applicant's ability to contest unsupported charges without financing an entire unrelated replacement program.

(c) Decision.—An expedited decision shall identify the facility, applicable safety requirement, responsible party, reasonable completion period, and review route. Access to another owner's property shall occur only under lawful authority and with adequate notice, qualified workers, insurance proportionate to risk, and protection against service interruption. A finding that an owner delayed an application does not authorize an applicant to bypass electrical safety standards or enter a Tribal right of way without the required consent.

SEC. 714. TENANT CHOICE AND BUILDING AGREEMENTS.

(a) Disclosure.—A landlord or provider marketing connectivity as part of a covered rental or condominium arrangement shall disclose whether residents may choose another provider, whether a charge is mandatory, and whether the owner receives material compensation tied to provider selection. Disclosure shall precede the resident's contractual commitment.

(b) Access.—A building owner subject to section 706 shall apply reasonable, nondiscriminatory access conditions addressing scheduling, workmanship, insurance, restoration, and security. A condition shall not be used as a disguised exclusive arrangement. Reasonable compensation for actual use of space and demonstrable access costs remains permissible.

(c) Resident Protection.—Installation shall respect the resident's consent, privacy, and lawful possession of the premises. A provider shall not require a tenant to authorize alteration of common property beyond the tenant's legal authority. Where a bulk arrangement permits individual cancellation or an alternative service, the cancellation mechanism shall be practical and shall identify which charges remain part of rent or association dues under applicable law.

SEC. 715. CONSTRUCTION COORDINATION AND RESTORATION.

(a) Notice.—A recipient using Federal funds for substantial excavation shall provide reasonable advance notice to relevant infrastructure owners and public authorities, subject to urgent repair needs. Coordination shall consider shared trenching, future capacity, traffic disruption, and opportunities to reduce repeated disturbance.

(b) Cost.—A party requesting additional capacity beyond the funded project's need shall bear the incremental reasonable cost unless another lawful funding source covers it. Coordination does not authorize transfer of a competitor's confidential expansion plans for commercial exploitation or agreement among providers to divide markets.

(c) Restoration.—The responsible contractor shall document preconstruction conditions, restore affected public or private property to the agreed lawful standard, and provide a contact for damage claims. Bonding and inspection requirements shall be proportionate to the work. A public authority shall identify deficiencies within a reasonable inspection period and shall not withhold release of an unrelated deposit to obtain concessions outside the permit or applicable law.

TITLE VIII—SMALL BUSINESSES AND COMPETITIVE ENTRY

SEC. 801. SMALL BUSINESS CONNECTIVITY RIGHTS.

(a) Coverage.—A small-business subscriber is an independently controlled enterprise purchasing a standardized connectivity service primarily for its own operations and meeting the small-entity definition in title I. A provider shall not exclude such a purchaser from consumer billing and cancellation protections merely because the account is labeled business service.

(b) Disclosure.—Before sale, a provider shall explain upload capacity, restoration expectations, static-address availability, backup options, payment-terminal limitations, and whether the service is suitable for the purchaser's disclosed ordinary use. The provider need not guarantee every business outcome but shall not market a residential-grade service as having enterprise continuity when it does not.

(c) Contract.—Material service-level commitments shall be stated in the transaction summary. A disclaimer in general terms shall not negate a specifically purchased reliability or repair commitment. A small-business purchaser may choose a lower-cost service after clear disclosure without waiving protections against deception or unauthorized charges.

SEC. 802. SERVICE LEVEL AGREEMENTS.

(a) Contents.—An agreement promising a service level shall define the measurement period, availability calculation, latency or capacity standard, excluded events, reporting method, restoration target, and credit. Exclusions shall identify concrete circumstances and shall not make the promise illusory.

(b) Verification.—The customer shall have access to relevant aggregate performance records for its connection and a practical method to contest a measurement. A provider may protect other customers and network security but shall furnish sufficient information to evaluate compliance.

(c) Remedy.—A credit shall be paid automatically when the provider's records establish failure. An agreement may limit consequential damages in a genuinely negotiated commercial transaction, but a standardized contract shall not waive restitution, statutory damages expressly available under title XXVII, or liability for intentional misconduct. The agency shall publish model agreements differentiated for ordinary retail operations, remote work, and genuinely critical applications without certifying any provider's product.

SEC. 803. BUSINESS CONTINUITY AND BACKUP.

(a) Information.—A provider selling backup connectivity shall disclose shared points of failure with the primary service, including common power, backhaul, physical route, tower, satellite gateway, or control system when known. Two branded services shall not be described as independent redundancy solely because they use different retail names.

(b) Planning.—The Small Business Administration, in consultation with the Commission and CISA, shall provide voluntary continuity guides addressing payment systems, cloud access, customer communications, backup power, and secure remote operations. Guides shall distinguish a minimum practical plan from a high-cost enterprise architecture.

(c) Support.—Within funds appropriated for small-business assistance, grants may support pooled training and limited resilience equipment for eligible businesses in repeatedly disrupted areas. Assistance shall use objective need criteria and shall not reimburse ordinary losses without express authority. Recipients shall retain choice of qualified vendors and shall not be required to buy a particular carrier's service.

SEC. 804. ENTRANT ACCESS TO INFORMATION.

(a) Public Data.—The Secretary shall provide a consolidated directory of deployment opportunities, available public infrastructure, open wholesale offers, grant deadlines, and technical assistance. Information shall be searchable without a paid subscription and available in reusable formats.

(b) Confidentiality.—The directory shall not disclose sensitive network diagrams, customer lists, or another applicant's trade secrets. Aggregated cost and performance information may be published when it materially improves competition and can be protected against reidentification.

(c) Fair Notice.—A material change in an application requirement shall be announced with sufficient time for smaller applicants to respond. An agency shall not rely on an unpublished interpretation to reject a proposal. Where an error in a public notice materially misled applicants, the agency shall provide a reasonable corrective opportunity consistent with the rights of other applicants and the integrity of the competition.

SEC. 805. FINANCING FOR SMALL PROVIDERS.

(a) Assistance.—The Secretary may use appropriated technical-assistance funds to help small providers prepare engineering, financial, and compliance plans, including cooperative purchasing and shared back-office arrangements. Assistance may support feasibility studies but shall not guarantee a project's commercial success.

(b) Credit.—Any loan guarantee or direct loan requires specific budget authority for its subsidy cost and compliance with Federal credit law. This Act does not create an unlimited guarantee through a general grant authorization. Terms shall reflect project risk, collateral, public benefit, and the applicant's capacity.

(c) Fair Competition.—A publicly assisted financing arrangement shall not require exclusion of competing providers from a community or transfer of editorial control over local media. Recipients shall disclose related-party financing and material liens on publicly supported assets. A default plan shall protect service continuity without promising to reimburse private investors for every loss.

SEC. 806. PROPORTIONATE COMPLIANCE.

(a) Simplification.—Agencies shall provide common definitions, reusable filings, simplified templates, and shared compliance tools for small entities. They shall accept equivalent evidence rather than require a costly certification when direct records establish compliance.

(b) Phasing.—A technical obligation may receive an additional implementation period of up to 12 months for a small entity upon a finding that the delay is necessary, does not create substantial harm, and is accompanied by interim protection. The agency shall state the affected obligation and expiration date.

(c) Core Duties.—No size-based delay applies to intentional discrimination, unauthorized recurring charges, knowing misrepresentation, deliberate misuse of sensitive information, earned compensation, or a readily preventable imminent safety threat. An entity seeking relief shall disclose controlled affiliates and shall not obtain relief by outsourcing a regulated function to a nominally smaller affiliate.

SEC. 807. WHOLESALE TERMS FOR ENTRANTS.

(a) Disclosure.—A provider subject to an express wholesale-access obligation shall publish its standard technical interfaces, ordering process, service intervals, fault-reporting procedure, and commercial terms. Material departures for an affiliate shall be documented and made available to the enforcing agency.

(b) Equivalence.—A wholesale customer shall receive service quality, repair priority, and provisioning information reasonably equivalent to that afforded to the owner's comparable retail operation, accounting for genuine technical differences. An owner may require credit assurance proportionate to actual exposure.

(c) Disputes.—A small entrant may seek expedited review without financing a full-scale antitrust case when the complaint alleges breach of an existing access obligation. The reviewing agency shall not create a new general wholesale mandate through that expedited process. Relief shall identify the precise obligation, evidence of differential treatment, and corrective measure.

SEC. 808. ADVERTISING PURCHASERS.

(a) Information.—A small advertiser shall receive intelligible statements identifying purchased inventory or placement category, charges, platform and intermediary fees, material optimization objectives, and available evidence of delivery. A seller shall not describe an estimated attribution result as verified incremental sales.

(b) Control.—The advertiser shall be able to set a binding expenditure limit, pause future spending through an accessible control, and exclude unlawful or materially misrepresented inventory. A platform may require reasonable processing time but shall disclose it and correct charges caused by its failure to honor a timely instruction.

(c) Support.—Disputes over account suspension, unauthorized spend, or withheld balances shall receive a human review route. This section protects commercial account administration and does not require a publisher to accept an advertisement it lawfully declines. Refunds for undelivered or fraudulent inventory are governed by title XIX and the applicable contract.

SEC. 809. CREATOR AND SELLER ACCOUNT PORTABILITY.

(a) Export.—A commercial platform serving independent creators or sellers shall permit export of the user's own uploaded works, transaction records, earnings statements, and consenting customer contacts in a reasonably usable format. It shall not disclose another person's private information or transfer a copyright the user does not own.

(b) Continuity.—Before permanently closing a commercial account for a reason other than urgent fraud, illegality, or security risk, the platform shall provide a reasonable opportunity to obtain the export. A disputed suspension does not authorize withholding earned undisputed compensation indefinitely.

(c) Limits.—Portability does not guarantee transfer of rankings, followers who have not consented, recommendation placement, or proprietary platform software. A platform may impose proportionate authentication and rate limits to prevent abuse, but shall not charge a prohibitive fee for a routine export or degrade it to make switching impracticable.

SEC. 810. PROCUREMENT OPPORTUNITIES.

(a) Access.—Agencies and recipients procuring communications or media services under this Act shall consider whether a contract can be divided into commercially practical components that permit qualified small firms to compete. They shall not divide a contract to evade competition, oversight, or labor requirements.

(b) Evaluation.—Past performance may be established through comparable private, cooperative, Tribal, or local projects and not solely through prior Federal contracts. Financial assurances shall correspond to actual risk. A solicitation shall identify objective acceptance criteria and payment schedules.

(c) Payment.—Prime contractors shall pay undisputed amounts to small subcontractors within 30 days after receiving payment for the corresponding work, unless a shorter applicable period governs. A dispute shall identify the contested work and shall not justify withholding unrelated amounts. Subcontractors shall have a confidential means to report retaliation or false certification of payment.

SEC. 811. ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND SHARED RESOURCES.

(a) Programs.—Within appropriated funds, the Secretary may support shared testing laboratories, accessible production facilities, cooperative distribution infrastructure, and business training for independent media and communications enterprises. Selection shall use objective readiness, need, and public-benefit criteria.

(b) Neutrality.—No award shall depend on the political or cultural viewpoint of lawful work, agreement to promote government policy, or affiliation with a favored trade association. A recipient may maintain ordinary professional and safety standards consistent with this requirement.

(c) Sustainability.—An application shall explain ongoing operating costs, access terms, management, and replacement of equipment. Publicly supported facilities shall disclose prices and eligibility and provide reasonable access to qualified users. An award shall not finance an exclusive private club under the label of a community resource. Evaluation shall consider business survival and useful access rather than attendance counts alone.

SEC. 812. SMALL BUSINESS IMPACT REVIEW.

(a) Report.—Every two years, the Small Business Administration, Commission, and Trade Commission shall jointly report on connectivity cost, outages, advertising-market access, platform dependence, and compliance burdens affecting small enterprises. The report shall distinguish service purchasers, network operators, creators, publishers, and advertising intermediaries.

(b) Evidence.—The agencies shall obtain representative evidence from operating businesses and shall not treat a trade association's position as the preference of every member. Surveys shall disclose sampling, response rates, sponsorship, and material limitations.

(c) Response.—Where a rule creates a material fixed-cost barrier without commensurate protection, the administering agency shall consider a lawful simplification. It shall identify the harm the original rule addressed and explain how the revised method preserves the statutory outcome. This review does not authorize an exemption from a duty Congress expressly made nonwaivable.

SEC. 813. STANDARD BUSINESS SERVICE DISCLOSURES.

(a) Comparability.—A provider marketing a standard connectivity plan to a small business shall state whether advertised speed is shared or dedicated, whether performance is guaranteed, the support hours, the restoration target, and the basis for any credit. The provider shall distinguish a target from an enforceable commitment.

(b) Dependencies.—A seller offering backup connectivity shall disclose known material common points of failure, including shared power, last-mile facilities, backhaul, or provider control. It shall not describe two retail subscriptions as fully independent solely because they carry different brand names.

(c) Risk.—A small business may purchase a lower-cost service without a service-level guarantee after clear disclosure. The absence of a guarantee does not excuse deception or an obligation otherwise imposed by this Act. A provider shall not advertise suitability for a critical business function while concealing a known technical restriction that predictably prevents that function. Reasonable security restrictions and ordinary network limitations may be explained without disclosure of exploitable configuration details.

SEC. 814. COMMERCIAL RECORDS AND ACCOUNT EXIT.

(a) Export.—Upon a small business's authenticated request, a covered service shall provide reasonably available invoices, payment records, campaign reports, and the business's own uploaded materials in a commonly usable format. A standard export shall not require payment of a punitive termination charge.

(b) Limits.—Export does not include another person's confidential information, a platform's proprietary audience model, or intellectual property the business lacks permission to receive. Where a record mixes permitted and protected information, the service shall provide a reasonably separable version rather than rejecting the entire request without explanation.

(c) Timing.—The service shall ordinarily complete an export within 30 days and shall give at least 30 days' notice before routine deletion following account closure, unless a security or legal requirement necessitates earlier action. Earned funds and records necessary to contest a charge shall not be withheld as leverage to obtain a new exclusive agreement. A bankruptcy proceeding or lawful preservation order remains governed by its applicable rules.

SEC. 815. COMPLIANCE ASSISTANCE WITHOUT IMMUNITY.

(a) Materials.—The Small Business Administration, Commission, and Trade Commission shall prepare concise compliance materials organized by business function, including retail connectivity, advertising purchases, creative distribution, device repair, and benefit participation. Materials shall identify which duties apply to the business and which protections it may invoke as a customer.

(b) Technical Help.—Assistance may include model contract summaries, sample privacy notices, accessible complaint forms, and shared technical resources. Use of a model shall be voluntary. A model shall not be represented as guaranteeing compliance where actual business practices differ from the description.

(c) Reliance.—In determining a penalty, a court may consider reasonable good-faith reliance on applicable current agency guidance, together with the person's actual conduct and efforts to correct an error. Reliance does not excuse knowing deception, concealment of material facts, or failure to return money unlawfully obtained. An agency withdrawing material guidance shall explain the change and ordinarily provide a reasonable prospective transition consistent with the statute.

TITLE IX—RURAL TRIBAL AND EQUITABLE ACCESS

SEC. 901. COMMUNITY ACCESS PLANS.

(a) Plans.—The Secretary shall assist rural communities, Tribal governments, and underserved urban neighborhoods in preparing voluntary access plans identifying availability, price, reliability, disability barriers, public institutions, and practical alternatives. A plan shall distinguish residents who lack infrastructure from those who cannot afford or effectively use an available service.

(b) Participation.—Planning shall include residents, local businesses, schools, health facilities, emergency officials, and potential providers. Meetings shall be accessible and shall offer nonelectronic participation. A plan shall not be valid merely because a consultant copied a regional template without investigating local conditions.

(c) Use.—Plans may support grant applications and infrastructure coordination but do not independently authorize construction, tax collection, compulsory acquisition, or restriction of competing service. An agency evaluating a plan shall respect local knowledge while independently verifying claims material to a Federal award.

(a) Consultation.—Before an agency adopts a policy or approves a project with substantial direct effects on Tribal lands, resources, or governmental interests, it shall engage in timely government-to-government consultation. Consultation shall begin while meaningful alternatives remain available.

(b) Consent.—Nothing in this Act diminishes a consent requirement under applicable Federal or Tribal law. An award involving access to Tribal land shall identify the permissions required and shall not treat a provider's contract with a third party as a substitute for Tribal authorization.

(c) Resources.—Appropriated technical-assistance funds may support Tribal engineering, legal review, data governance, and participation expenses. A Tribe shall not be required to waive sovereign immunity broadly, disclose sacred information publicly, or transfer control of its data as a condition of ordinary consultation. Any limited waiver associated with a voluntary commercial agreement shall be explicit and confined to that agreement.

SEC. 903. TRIBAL DATA GOVERNANCE.

(a) Agreements.—An agency collecting information about Tribal infrastructure or residents for a program under this Act shall establish an agreement addressing purpose, access, security, publication, correction, retention, and permitted sharing. The agreement shall distinguish public accountability information from sensitive community and infrastructure information.

(b) Public Records.—Federal transparency obligations remain applicable, but the agency shall consult on lawful protection of sensitive locations, cultural resources, and security details. Aggregate reporting shall be used where it provides accountability without unnecessary exposure.

(c) Control.—A contractor shall not commercialize Tribal data obtained through a Federal project or use it to develop unrelated products without lawful authority and required consent. Upon termination, data shall be returned or securely deleted as the agreement provides, subject to necessary Federal record retention. The agency remains responsible for its own legal duties and may not delegate final disclosure decisions to a private contractor.

SEC. 904. INTENTIONAL DISCRIMINATION.

(a) Prohibition.—A covered connectivity provider shall not intentionally discriminate in availability, installation, price, quality, maintenance, or termination because of a protected characteristic specified in section 108. The prohibition applies to decisions made through employees, contractors, automated systems, and facially neutral proxies deliberately used to achieve prohibited discrimination.

(b) Evidence.—Liability may be established through direct or circumstantial evidence, including materially different treatment of similarly situated locations, statements, inconsistent explanations, or a pattern supported by reliable analysis. A difference in population composition alone is insufficient.

(c) Justification.—A provider may explain a difference through verifiable engineering, cost, safety, capacity, or other legitimate factors. A asserted reason shall be evaluated for actual consistency and shall not be accepted when pretextual. Remedies shall address the discriminatory practice and resulting injury without requiring a racial quota or government control of lawful expression.

SEC. 905. DEFINED DISPARATE IMPACT STANDARD.

(a) Authority.—Congress expressly authorizes the Commission to prohibit a specific, facially neutral connectivity practice that causes a substantial unjustified disparity in access based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, familial status, or household income.

(b) Elements.—The claimant or enforcing agency shall identify the challenged practice, establish a robust causal connection to the disparity, use a relevant comparison accounting for material geographic and engineering conditions, and demonstrate that the disparity is substantial rather than a product of random variation.

(c) Defense And Alternative.—The provider may demonstrate that the practice is necessary to achieve a substantial, legitimate technical or economic objective. The claimant may then establish a reasonably available alternative that achieves that objective with materially less discriminatory effect and without imposing disproportionate cost or risk. Liability shall not rest solely on a failure to equalize outcomes.

(d) Relief.—Initial relief shall ordinarily be prospective correction and monitoring. Compensatory or punitive monetary relief requires the additional elements specified in title XXVII; statistical disparity alone does not establish intentional misconduct.

SEC. 906. FEASIBILITY AND FINANCIAL EVIDENCE.

(a) Record.—A provider asserting infeasibility shall identify the relevant engineering constraints, incremental and lifecycle costs, available capacity, expected revenue, and alternatives considered. It may submit confidential supporting information under a protective process, but shall provide a public explanation sufficient to understand the claim.

(b) Review.—The Commission shall assess whether the constraint is genuine, whether the provider applies it consistently, and whether public support or a different design would materially change the result. The agency shall not require an economically irrational build merely to produce equal statistical coverage.

(c) Public Support.—Where a disparity can reasonably be remedied only through subsidy, the agency may refer the matter for a competitive grant or operating-support review. Such referral does not establish an entitlement to funding or excuse intentional discrimination. A provider that accepts support shall be bound by the resulting service commitments.

SEC. 907. PUBLIC AND COOPERATIVE NETWORKS.

(a) Authority.—A State or political subdivision may, through its own lawful decision, provide or support broadband service. No State law may prohibit a political subdivision from offering broadband solely because the provider is publicly owned, or impose a barrier whose purpose or effect is to protect a private incumbent from such competition.

(b) Savings.—This express limitation does not require a State or locality to create a network, borrow money, tax residents, pledge credit, or administer a Federal program. Neutral laws governing public debt, procurement, audits, public meetings, and conflicts of interest remain applicable if not used as discriminatory entry barriers.

(c) Accountability.—A public or cooperative network receiving Federal support shall maintain transparent accounts, disclose cross-subsidies, comply with this Act's customer rights, and operate without viewpoint-based restrictions. A publicly owned provider is not exempt from competition review simply because its ownership is public.

SEC. 908. REMOTE AND EXTREME COST LOCATIONS.

(a) Design.—For remote locations, the Secretary shall evaluate a portfolio of technologies and service arrangements based on actual household and institutional needs, transport cost, energy, weather, maintenance access, and available skilled labor.

(b) Exception.—A project may receive a time-limited exception from a standard performance threshold only when no reasonable conforming proposal exists and the selected alternative materially improves service. The award shall identify the limitation, expected upgrade path, and information given to customers.

(c) Continuity.—A short equipment warranty or promotional capacity allocation is insufficient for a long-term public award. The recipient shall plan for replacement, spare parts, seasonal access, and failure of a sole backhaul or power source. Annual review shall determine whether new feasible alternatives justify an upgrade, without automatically stranding useful equipment or imposing unnecessary replacement expense.

SEC. 909. HOUSING AND LOW INCOME ACCESS.

(a) Buildings.—Projects serving affordable housing shall address internal wiring, equipment placement, accessible enrollment, landlord charges, and maintenance. A nominally served building shall not be treated as fully connected when residents cannot obtain service in their units on practical terms.

(b) Tenants.—A landlord receiving assistance under this Act shall disclose any connectivity charge, permit lawful provider choice under title VII, and avoid retaliation against a tenant who complains. A tenant shall not be required to surrender browsing information to the landlord.

(c) Shared Service.—A shared connection may be supported when it provides reliable capacity, individual privacy, fair allocation, and clear responsibility for faults. Each household shall be informed of material limits. The operator shall not use shared infrastructure to expose one resident's devices or communications to another, and shall maintain a safe process for changing credentials when occupants leave.

SEC. 910. AGRICULTURE AND RURAL ENTERPRISE.

(a) Coordination.—The Secretary shall coordinate with the Department of Agriculture concerning rural connectivity for farms, processing facilities, cooperatives, and local businesses. Planning shall include upload needs, seasonal demand, remote equipment, and backup communications.

(b) Data.—A publicly supported connectivity arrangement shall not require a producer to grant a carrier or equipment vendor unrelated rights in farm production data. Device interoperability and repair rights remain governed by title XXIV and applicable safety law.

(c) Performance.—A project marketed for precision agriculture or remote operations shall be evaluated using relevant field coverage, latency, reliability, and device capacity rather than household download speed alone. A provider shall disclose where the service is unsuitable for safety-critical control. Public support may facilitate shared infrastructure but shall not guarantee revenue from a particular agricultural technology or force farmers into an exclusive equipment ecosystem.

SEC. 911. LANGUAGE ACCESS AND COMMUNITY NAVIGATION.

(a) Information.—Agencies and funded providers shall furnish essential enrollment, price, safety, and complaint information in languages reasonably necessary to serve the affected community, considering population, actual customers, available resources, and the consequence of misunderstanding.

(b) Assistance.—A customer may use a qualified interpreter or trusted representative without surrendering account ownership. Authentication shall protect against fraud while accommodating persons who cannot use the provider's default language or interface.

(c) Quality.—Translated information shall accurately convey material rights and obligations. Machine translation may assist but shall receive appropriate human review for safety-critical and legally consequential notices. Agencies shall evaluate whether assistance actually resolves barriers rather than counting translated pages. Nothing authorizes regulation of the language or viewpoint of editorial content beyond specific accessibility and emergency obligations established elsewhere in this Act.

SEC. 912. EQUITY REVIEW AND REMEDIES.

(a) Review.—Every three years, the Commission shall evaluate differences in availability, actual price, service quality, and complaint outcomes across communities. It shall use privacy-protective data and distinguish technical cost differences, public-investment gaps, and potentially unlawful practices.

(b) Remedies.—A corrective order shall identify the conduct to change, the affected locations, feasible alternatives, milestones, and a review date. The order shall not impose indefinite supervision without findings of continued need. Courts retain authority over damages and constitutional claims.

(c) Effective Date.—The intentional-discrimination prohibition takes effect one year after enactment. The disparate-impact standard takes effect 24 months after enactment, following rules specifying evidence and defenses. Earlier conduct may inform prospective analysis but shall not itself create retroactive liability under the new standard. Existing civil-rights remedies remain available according to their own terms.

SEC. 913. EVIDENCE IN ACCESS DISCRIMINATION MATTERS.

(a) Comparators.—A comparison of service areas shall account for materially relevant differences in construction cost, terrain, density, existing facilities, customer demand, available funding, and legally required approvals. A provider may not invoke a difference without evidence that it materially relates to the challenged decision.

(b) Information.—The Commission may require proportionate planning and service data necessary to evaluate a specific practice. It shall protect confidential business information and avoid demanding individual browsing histories or unrelated customer characteristics. A complainant shall have access to a meaningful nonconfidential explanation of the provider's asserted justification.

(c) Remedy.—A finding under section 905 shall identify the practice, causal relationship, feasible alternative, and expected corrective effect. A remedy shall not require an unsupported demographic quota or technically impossible construction. It may require reconsideration under lawful criteria, a practicable service expansion, correction of discriminatory terms, or other relief authorized by title XXVII. Cost shall be assessed honestly, including available public support and reasonable alternatives, rather than presumed either prohibitive or irrelevant.

SEC. 914. TRIBAL CONSORTIA AND DIRECT PARTICIPATION.

(a) Authorization.—A consortium applying on behalf of several Tribes shall identify each participating government, its written authorization, the property and functions involved, and the allocation of responsibilities. Participation in a consortium shall not transfer a Tribe's sovereign authority by implication.

(b) Access.—A Tribe may apply directly to an eligible Federal program without obtaining permission from a State unless the program's governing statute expressly requires State administration. The Secretary shall provide a practical direct route for programs created by this Act and shall not require a Tribe to incorporate under State law merely to receive assistance.

(c) Disputes.—An award shall identify procedures for withdrawal, ownership of shared assets, data access, and continued service if consortium members disagree. Federal assistance shall not be conditioned on a general waiver of Tribal immunity or surrender of treaty rights. A limited contractual waiver concerning specified award obligations must be express, informed, and approved under the Tribe's own law before it can be relied upon.

SEC. 915. DISPLACED AND TEMPORARILY HOUSED USERS.

(a) Access.—Programs created by this Act shall accommodate eligible persons living in shelters, temporary disaster housing, vehicles, or other arrangements without a conventional street address. An agency may accept a reliable contact, geographic service description, or authorized institution's confirmation where suitable to the program.

(b) Privacy.—An application shall permit a confidential mailing address or contact when disclosure of the service location could create a material safety risk. Program staff shall not disclose that location to a former household member, landlord, or commercial marketer without a lawful basis.

(c) Continuity.—Where technically feasible and within an existing award, a recipient may move an assisted connection or provide temporary equipment to a displaced beneficiary. It shall document the change and prevent duplicate reimbursement without imposing unnecessary requalification. Temporary accommodation does not establish a permanent entitlement to construction at a location that lacks the approvals or physical conditions necessary for service. The administrator shall explain available alternatives when the preferred accommodation cannot lawfully or practically be provided.

TITLE X—SPECTRUM SATELLITES AND SHARED RESOURCES

SEC. 1001. SPECTRUM PLANNING.

(a) Plan.—The Commission and NTIA shall maintain a coordinated five-year spectrum plan identifying Federal and non-Federal needs, opportunities for licensed and unlicensed use, sharing, interference protection, public safety, research, and international coordination.

(b) Evidence.—Recommendations shall consider actual utilization, technical feasibility, transition cost, competition, consumer benefit, and security. Auction proceeds shall be reported separately from broader economic benefits and shall not be the sole measure of public value.

(c) Authority.—This title does not independently extend an expiring auction authority, reallocate a frequency band without required process, or override a treaty obligation. Agencies shall identify the statutory authority for each action. Classified requirements may be considered through lawful procedures, but a public explanation shall describe nonclassified reasons and material consequences sufficiently to permit meaningful oversight.

SEC. 1002. LICENSED ENTRY AND SMALL PROVIDERS.

(a) Design.—When designing an auction within existing authority, the Commission shall consider license size, geographic scope, aggregation limits, financing, and deployment obligations that permit effective participation by qualified smaller providers.

(b) Safeguards.—A bidding credit or reserved opportunity shall use objective eligibility rules and aggregate controlled affiliates. The Commission shall prevent a large incumbent from obtaining a small-business benefit through a nominal intermediary while preserving legitimate investment in an independently controlled entrant.

(c) Performance.—An award shall identify buildout milestones and consequences for warehousing. Extensions require specific evidence of circumstances beyond reasonable control and a credible completion plan. A license holder shall not retain scarce rights indefinitely through token deployment unrelated to the population or area the license was intended to serve. Enforcement shall respect notice, hearing, and judicial-review rights.

SEC. 1003. UNLICENSED AND SHARED USE.

(a) Evaluation.—The Commission shall evaluate opportunities for unlicensed and shared spectrum that support household connectivity, enterprise networks, research, and new services. It shall protect incumbents through technically justified rules rather than categorical assumptions about a technology.

(b) Access Systems.—Where access depends on a database or coordination system, the operator shall provide nondiscriminatory access, transparent fees, reliable service, and a process to correct erroneous denial. The Commission shall retain final authority over binding requirements and shall not delegate public spectrum policy to a private operator.

(c) Security.—Coordination data shall be limited to what is necessary, protected against commercial misuse, and disclosed only as authorized. A sharing system shall be tested for failure modes, erroneous exclusion zones, and concentrated control. A pilot shall identify its expiration and transition arrangements so that users do not mistake an experimental permission for permanent rights.

SEC. 1004. INTERFERENCE DISPUTES.

(a) Process.—The Commission shall maintain a timely process for reporting and resolving harmful interference. A report shall identify the affected service, location, frequency, time, and available measurements without requiring an ordinary consumer to perform specialized engineering.

(b) Evidence.—An order restricting operations shall rely on reliable technical evidence, consider equipment compliance and receiver characteristics, and distinguish harmful interference from ordinary competitive inconvenience. A temporary protective measure may issue in a genuine emergency, subject to prompt review.

(c) Responsibility.—A person causing unlawful interference shall correct the condition and cooperate with testing. A person knowingly submitting false interference claims to exclude a competitor is subject to title XXVII. Good-faith reporting shall not create liability merely because the initial hypothesis proves incorrect. Rules shall address reasonable cost allocation for testing and remediation.

SEC. 1005. SATELLITE LICENSING AND COORDINATION.

(a) Process.—The Commission shall publish application requirements, milestones, and target review periods for satellite systems within its jurisdiction. It shall coordinate with Federal spectrum, aviation, space-safety, and national-security authorities without merging their distinct legal responsibilities.

(b) Information.—An applicant shall disclose system capacity, interference analysis, collision-avoidance arrangements, end-of-life disposal, ground-segment dependencies, and financial responsibility to the extent relevant to Commission authority. Requests for additional information shall identify the legal and technical basis.

(c) Limits.—A streamlined process shall not deem a system safe through agency silence or waive obligations assigned to another agency. A license shall identify conditions, reporting, material modification procedures, and consequences of nonperformance. The Commission may permit staged deployment where evidence supports it, while reserving review of expansion that changes risk or interference assumptions.

SEC. 1006. SATELLITE CONSUMER SERVICE.

(a) Disclosure.—A retail satellite provider shall disclose expected capacity, latency, weather sensitivity, equipment costs, installation needs, geographic restrictions, power requirements, and material limits on emergency use. Performance representations shall account for realistic network loading and customer location.

(b) Continuity.—The provider shall disclose circumstances in which service may be interrupted because of gateway failure, orbital capacity limits, equipment obstruction, or regulatory restrictions. It shall provide a practical equipment-return and cancellation process when service cannot be delivered as represented.

(c) Public Support.—A publicly supported satellite connection shall be verified as usable at the funded location and shall include a sustainable equipment and replacement plan. A provider shall not receive support solely because a coverage map includes the location. Emergency deployment may use expedited verification followed by a documented review when immediate testing is impracticable.

SEC. 1007. ORBITAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITY.

(a) Conditions.—Within its existing licensing authority, the Commission shall require applicants to address debris mitigation, collision coordination, disposal reliability, and financial assurance appropriate to the risk of the licensed activity. Conditions shall be based on evidence and coordinated with agencies possessing relevant expertise.

(b) Observation.—The Commission shall consider interference with radio astronomy and other protected uses within its jurisdiction. It may require reasonable operational coordination where legally authorized, but this Act does not create general Commission authority over all visual effects of objects in space.

(c) Reporting.—Material failures, loss of control, and departures from an approved disposal plan shall be reported promptly. Public summaries shall avoid disclosing exploitable command information. An applicant shall not treat a planned future technical capability as an existing mitigation without evidence of feasibility and a contingency if the capability is not delivered.

SEC. 1008. UNDERSEA CABLES AND LANDING INFRASTRUCTURE.

(a) Coordination.—The Commission and relevant executive agencies shall coordinate licensing and security review of undersea cable systems and landing facilities under their respective authorities. Requirements shall identify the risk addressed and avoid duplicative submissions.

(b) Resilience.—Operators shall maintain plans for cable faults, repair access, spare capacity, landing-station security, and dependency on shared terrestrial routes. A representation of route diversity shall disclose material shared facilities when relevant to a customer's purchased resilience.

(c) Confidentiality.—Detailed route and vulnerability information shall receive appropriate protection. Aggregate public reporting shall describe resilience gaps without creating a map for sabotage. Security conditions shall be reviewable through lawful procedures and shall not be used to obtain unrelated commercial concessions or suppress lawful communications. This section does not authorize interception of cable traffic.

SEC. 1009. SPECTRUM TRANSITION COSTS.

(a) Plan.—A relocation or sharing transition financed under this Act shall include an independently reviewed cost estimate, schedule, performance criteria, and responsibility for overruns. The plan shall distinguish necessary relocation from optional modernization.

(b) Reimbursement.—Eligible reimbursement shall cover reasonable, documented costs caused by the transition, including testing and service continuity. It shall not provide a windfall for replacing fully depreciated equipment with substantially greater capability unless the improvement is necessary or the beneficiary pays the incremental cost.

(c) Accountability.—Payments shall be tied to milestones and subject to audit. An agency shall not count receipts already committed under another law as a new offset for this Act. A transition shall preserve critical public-safety and national-defense functions through tested alternatives before discontinuing the prior capability, except where a lawful emergency decision requires otherwise.

SEC. 1010. SPECTRUM LEASING AND SECONDARY MARKETS.

(a) Transparency.—The Commission shall maintain accessible information about spectrum available for lawful lease, transfer, or shared use, subject to confidentiality and security limits. A small provider shall have a practical means to identify relevant opportunities.

(b) Review.—Leases shall identify responsibility for interference, buildout, reporting, emergency obligations, and compliance. A licensee remains responsible for nondelegable license duties. An arrangement shall not evade an aggregation limit or conceal control through a series of nominally separate leases.

(c) Experimentation.—Temporary experimental use may be authorized with clear boundaries and incumbent protection. Successful experimentation does not create a perpetual exclusive right. The Commission shall provide predictable transition procedures so that a legitimate trial can inform a permanent application without exposing users to avoidable service interruption.

SEC. 1011. INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION.

(a) Coordination.—The Secretary of State, Commission, and NTIA shall coordinate United States participation in international spectrum and communications negotiations within their respective authorities. Positions shall reflect technical evidence, competition, security, accessibility, and the ability of smaller enterprises to enter international markets.

(b) Limits.—An international recommendation shall not become binding domestic law without the procedure and authority otherwise required. Agencies shall publish nonclassified summaries of material commitments and identify any legislation necessary for implementation.

(c) Rights.—Cooperation shall not authorize censorship, generalized surveillance, or transfer of personal information contrary to United States law. Technical interoperability shall be pursued without requiring adoption of a foreign government's content-control system. The agencies shall assess dependencies that could permit coercive denial of critical communications and recommend proportionate diversification rather than indiscriminate exclusion based solely on nationality.

SEC. 1012. PUBLIC ACCOUNTING AND REVIEW.

(a) Report.—Every two years, the Commission and NTIA shall report on deployment, utilization, entry, interference, sharing performance, auction receipts, transition spending, and security implications of major spectrum actions. Reports shall identify data gaps and avoid equating a license award with actual service.

(b) Evaluation.—The Comptroller General shall examine whether public resources are being warehoused, whether transition costs were reasonably estimated, and whether smaller providers can practically access spectrum. It shall distinguish structural barriers from an applicant's failure to meet objective technical requirements.

(c) Recommendations.—Recommendations for additional auction authority, statutory relocation funding, or changes in agency jurisdiction shall be submitted to Congress with specific proposed policy choices. No reporting duty in this title constitutes an appropriation, a new spectrum tax, or authority to alter the ownership of a license without due process.

SEC. 1013. SPECTRUM UTILIZATION AND PERFORMANCE EVIDENCE.

(a) Information.—In evaluating a spectrum policy or license condition, the Commission shall consider actual utilization, service coverage, congestion, interference experience, equipment availability, and the feasibility of sharing. It shall distinguish a license footprint from deployed usable service.

(b) Protection.—Utilization studies shall protect sensitive Federal operations, customer location information, and exploitable network details. Public findings may use aggregate measurements, geographic generalization, or other methods that permit informed policy review without exposing protected operations.

(c) Consequences.—A finding of low utilization shall not automatically establish license forfeiture. Any enforcement shall apply the license's lawful terms, relevant statutory authority, notice, and opportunity to respond. Conversely, a licensee shall not satisfy a genuine service obligation through a nominal transmission that does not provide the required practical service. Recommendations for new sharing conditions shall address existing reliance interests, interference remedies, transition expense, and technical evidence, and shall not assume that every frequency band supports the same operating arrangement.

SEC. 1014. SATELLITE CAPACITY AND CONSUMER EXPECTATIONS.

(a) Marketing.—A satellite provider shall distinguish geographic visibility from orderable capacity and shall disclose material restrictions caused by congestion, mobility limits, obstructions, weather, or equipment requirements. A deposit for a future service shall state whether it is refundable and whether an installation date is guaranteed.

(b) Verification.—A public subsidy claim shall identify the capacity reasonably available to supported locations during expected busy periods. A provider shall not count the same finite capacity as fully available to incompatible commitments in multiple programs.

(c) Transition.—When a material constellation, terminal, or service change requires replacement of customer equipment, the provider shall give reasonable advance notice and explain compatibility, cost, return, and cancellation options. A customer shall not be charged an undisclosed upgrade fee solely to continue the service level promised for a prepaid period, except as clearly authorized by a lawful agreement. This section does not guarantee uninterrupted service during every atmospheric or astronomical condition.

SEC. 1015. CABLE ROUTE RESILIENCE AND REPAIR COORDINATION.

(a) Planning.—An operator receiving a new Federal award for undersea cable or landing infrastructure shall identify material route concentration, landing-station power dependencies, and repair arrangements. The plan shall consider feasible geographic diversity and lawful access to repair resources.

(b) Information Sharing.—The Secretary and Commission may facilitate protected sharing of repair needs and infrastructure dependencies among authorized operators and public authorities. Shared information shall be used for resilience and security, not to coordinate prices, divide customers, or exclude lawful competitors.

(c) Limits.—This section does not expand foreign intelligence collection, authorize interception of communications, or displace environmental, maritime, defense, or Tribal approvals. A public summary shall explain the resilience measures without disclosing precise vulnerabilities. Grant conditions shall be proportionate to the funded project and shall not require an operator to redesign unrelated worldwide infrastructure as a condition of repairing a particular domestic landing facility. Material unavoidable dependencies shall be documented rather than concealed behind an unsupported claim of complete redundancy.

TITLE XI—NETWORK SECURITY AND RESILIENCE

SEC. 1101. RISK BASED SECURITY DUTY.

(a) Duty.—A covered connectivity provider shall maintain reasonable security for the network functions it controls, proportionate to the sensitivity of information, scale of operations, foreseeable threats, and consequences of failure. The duty applies to design, procurement, operation, maintenance, and retirement.

(b) Baseline.—The Commission, in consultation with CISA and NIST, shall establish minimum outcomes for asset management, identity and access control, secure configuration, change management, monitoring, recovery, and supplier risk. Rules shall permit equivalent technical methods and shall distinguish a small local operator from a national carrier without exempting essential safeguards.

(c) Limitation.—A breach is evidence relevant to compliance but does not by itself establish a violation. Conversely, possession of a certificate is not conclusive proof of reasonable security. Liability shall depend on the applicable duty, known or reasonably foreseeable risk, available measures, and the provider's actual conduct.

SEC. 1102. ASSET AND CONFIGURATION MANAGEMENT.

(a) Inventory.—Providers shall maintain an inventory of material network assets, supported software, privileged accounts, and external management interfaces. The inventory shall identify responsibility for updates and dependencies whose failure could impair emergency or widespread service.

(b) Configuration.—Default credentials shall be changed before production use; unnecessary exposed services shall be disabled; administrative access shall use strong authentication appropriate to risk; and unsupported equipment shall have a documented replacement or compensating-control plan.

(c) Verification.—Material configuration changes shall be reviewed, tested, logged, and capable of rollback where feasible. An emergency change may proceed without ordinary preapproval when necessary to prevent imminent harm, but shall receive prompt retrospective review. Providers shall not retain sensitive customer traffic solely to satisfy asset-management documentation, and inventory access shall be limited to authorized operational and oversight needs.

SEC. 1103. PRIVILEGED ACCESS AND LAWFUL INTERCEPTION SYSTEMS.

(a) Separation.—Access to core routing, subscriber databases, interception interfaces, and security controls shall be limited according to function, periodically reviewed, and promptly revoked when no longer needed. Shared privileged credentials shall be prohibited unless a documented technical necessity is accompanied by equivalent accountability.

(b) Monitoring.—Providers shall maintain tamper-resistant logs of material privileged actions and investigate anomalous access. Logs shall avoid unnecessary capture of communication content and shall be retained for a period justified by risk and applicable law.

(c) Rights.—This section does not expand lawful-interception authority, require a new decryption capability, or authorize a vulnerability or access mechanism for government convenience. Compliance with a lawful order shall use the least information and access necessary. Security controls shall protect interception-related systems against unauthorized access, including access by a person falsely claiming governmental authority.

SEC. 1104. VULNERABILITY MANAGEMENT.

(a) Process.—Providers shall maintain a channel for good-faith vulnerability reports, acknowledge a material report, assess severity, and track remediation. They shall prioritize vulnerabilities actively exploited or capable of causing widespread service or sensitive-data compromise.

(b) Research.—A provider shall publish reasonable authorization boundaries for security testing and shall not threaten a researcher solely for a good-faith report made within those boundaries. This provision does not authorize extortion, destructive testing, access to unrelated personal information, or conduct otherwise prohibited by law.

(c) Disclosure.—Coordinated disclosure may be delayed for a limited period necessary to implement a remedy, with reasons recorded. A provider shall not require indefinite silence as a condition of receiving a report. Public summaries shall explain affected products and corrective steps without unnecessarily disclosing an exploit before users have a practical opportunity to protect themselves.

SEC. 1105. INCIDENT REPORTING.

(a) Material Incident.—A provider shall report to the Commission and the designated Federal cyber coordination channel a confirmed incident materially impairing critical network functions, compromising privileged control, or exposing sensitive subscriber information, within 72 hours after a reasonable determination that the threshold is met.

(b) Coordination.—A timely report satisfying an equivalent Federal incident-reporting requirement shall satisfy this section to the extent it contains the required information. Agencies shall establish secure sharing arrangements and shall not require repeated submission of identical facts in incompatible forms.

(c) Contents.—The initial report may state known facts, uncertainty, affected functions, mitigation, and a contact. It shall be supplemented as material information becomes available. Reporting does not require speculation presented as fact. A temporary law-enforcement delay of public notice shall be separately justified and shall not excuse confidential reporting necessary for network protection.

SEC. 1106. CUSTOMER NOTICE AND ASSISTANCE.

(a) Notice.—Affected customers shall receive timely notice of a material incident when they can take protective action or when their sensitive information was exposed. Notice shall explain the known effect, practical steps, assistance, and how updates will be provided.

(b) Timing.—Notice shall occur without unreasonable delay and ordinarily within 30 days after confirmation, subject to a documented, time-limited law-enforcement request or a finding that immediate notice would create a substantial additional security risk. The agency shall review extensions and require notice when the basis ends.

(c) Assistance.—A provider responsible for exposure of authentication credentials or sensitive identity information shall provide reasonable remediation appropriate to the actual risk. It shall not condition assistance on release of claims or enrollment in unrelated marketing. Notices shall be accessible, avoid misleading reassurance, and distinguish facts established from matters still under investigation.

SEC. 1107. PHYSICAL RESILIENCE AND POWER.

(a) Plan.—Providers shall assess material physical risks including wildfire, flood, heat, earthquake, severe weather, power loss, sabotage, and loss of access to facilities. Plans shall identify critical nodes, backup power, fuel or energy replenishment, spare equipment, and restoration priorities.

(b) Standards.—The Commission shall establish risk-tiered minimum continuity requirements for critical facilities, considering geography, network architecture, and feasible alternatives. A uniform number of backup hours shall not substitute for analysis of actual restoration conditions.

(c) Customer Equipment.—Where a service depends on premises power for emergency calling, the provider shall clearly disclose that dependence, available backup options, expected operating duration, and testing needs. It shall not represent an unpowered internet-based voice service as equivalent to a line-powered service without explaining the difference.

SEC. 1108. CHANGE MANAGEMENT AND OUTAGE PREVENTION.

(a) Controls.—A provider shall use staged testing, peer review, rollback planning, and monitoring for changes capable of causing widespread outage. The rigor shall correspond to the potential impact and shall include interactions among software, routing, authentication, and emergency-call handling.

(b) Authority.—Operational personnel shall have a clear escalation path and authority to stop a change presenting an imminent material risk. Incentive systems shall not penalize a worker for a good-faith safety escalation merely because it delays a commercial deadline.

(c) Review.—After a major outage, the provider shall perform a root-cause review that examines organizational and technical causes, corrective actions, and verification. A public summary shall describe lessons and customer effects while protecting security and personal information. The review shall not be replaced by a statement that human error occurred without examining the controls intended to prevent such error.

SEC. 1109. SUPPLIER AND CLOUD DEPENDENCIES.

(a) Assessment.—Providers shall identify material dependence on equipment suppliers, managed-service vendors, cloud systems, and software components. Contracts shall allocate incident reporting, patching, access control, audit rights, and exit assistance.

(b) Concentration.—A resilience plan shall consider common-mode failures where nominally separate services depend on one supplier or control plane. Diversification shall be proportionate to risk and shall not require inefficient duplication when another mitigation provides equivalent protection.

(c) Procurement.—A supplier restriction shall rest on lawful authority and evidence of a material risk, with procedures for correction and review where national-security law permits. This Act does not create a general nationality-based exclusion. Providers remain responsible for reasonable oversight of outsourced functions and may not disclaim all security responsibility through a vendor contract.

SEC. 1110. INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT.

(a) Requirement.—Providers designated by rule as critical because of scale, emergency functions, or systemic dependence shall obtain periodic independent assessments of compliance with specified security outcomes. Smaller providers may use pooled assessments or Commission-approved technical assistance.

(b) Independence.—Assessors shall disclose conflicts, possess appropriate expertise, and document testing limitations. A provider shall not select an assessor on the condition that material findings remain unreported to the responsible agency. The agency shall retain authority to examine evidence and challenge conclusions.

(c) Effect.—An assessment may support compliance evidence but shall not confer immunity. Findings shall produce a prioritized corrective plan with deadlines proportionate to severity. Public reporting shall provide meaningful assurance without publishing exploitable details. Fees shall not be set by a private certification monopoly empowered to exclude competitors from the market.

SEC. 1111. EMERGENCY COORDINATION AND MUTUAL AID.

(a) Coordination.—The Commission shall facilitate voluntary mutual-aid arrangements for restoration personnel, equipment, roaming, and temporary capacity during a declared disaster or major outage. Agreements shall identify safety, compensation, liability allocation, and termination.

(b) Fair Access.—A provider shall not refuse reasonable emergency coordination solely to gain a competitive advantage when participation is feasible and the requesting party accepts reasonable costs and safeguards. Any mandatory temporary arrangement requires specific findings of necessity, proportionality, and compensation where required.

(c) Limits.—Emergency authority shall not permit indefinite control of a network, suppression of lawful communications, or collection of unrelated personal data. An order shall identify its geographic and temporal scope, receive prompt review, and expire when the emergency basis ends. Post-event reports shall assess effectiveness and unintended effects on smaller operators.

SEC. 1112. IMPLEMENTATION AND PROTECTED REPORTING.

(a) Phasing.—Baseline rules shall issue within 18 months and take effect no earlier than six months after publication, except for an emergency measure supported by a concrete threat. Major capital replacement may receive a longer schedule with interim protection and a funded plan where public assistance is authorized.

(b) Reporting Protection.—An employee or contractor may report a reasonably believed violation to an agency, inspector general, Congress, or a court without retaliation. Protection does not authorize public release of classified information or unnecessary disclosure of customer content.

(c) Enforcement.—Corrective orders shall address specific failures and permit equivalent safeguards. Civil penalties shall be sought under title XXVII. An agency shall distinguish concealment and reckless disregard from a provider's good-faith response to an unforeseeable incident. Nothing permits use of a cybersecurity investigation as a pretext to influence news coverage or lawful political activity.

SEC. 1113. COORDINATED VULNERABILITY DISCLOSURE.

(a) Channel.—A covered connectivity provider shall maintain a reliable channel for receiving good-faith reports of a security vulnerability and shall acknowledge a sufficiently specific report within seven days. It shall identify a practical means of following the report's status without requiring public disclosure of the vulnerability.

(b) Handling.—The provider shall assess severity, coordinate a reasonable remediation schedule, and avoid disclosing a researcher's identity without consent or lawful necessity. It may reject unsupported or abusive reports but shall explain the reason sufficiently to permit correction.

(c) Legal Limits.—This section does not authorize access to another person's system, alter criminal computer-access law, or require payment of a bounty. A provider may publish a lawful testing authorization specifying permitted systems and methods. It shall not misrepresent that authorization after a researcher reasonably relied upon it. Disclosure timing shall consider active exploitation, user protection, and the need for effective correction; it shall not be used solely to suppress a truthful report of an unresolved material risk.

SEC. 1114. INCIDENT RESTORATION AND CUSTOMER ASSISTANCE.

(a) Plan.—A material incident response plan shall assign authority for containment, restoration, evidence preservation, external reporting, and customer assistance. It shall identify critical dependencies and procedures for operation when ordinary management systems are unavailable.

(b) Restoration.—Restoration shall prioritize emergency communications and essential functions under objective criteria. A provider shall test that a recovery action does not reintroduce a known compromise or materially impair lawful customer access. Where complete restoration requires time, the provider shall communicate the available temporary service and its limitations.

(c) Assistance.—When an incident foreseeably exposes customers to account takeover or payment fraud, the provider shall offer proportionate protective assistance, such as secure credential reset, account locking, or replacement of compromised authentication methods. It shall not require customers to purchase an affiliated protection product to obtain a remedy otherwise owed. Assistance shall protect survivors and persons sharing accounts from disclosure of a confidential new contact or credential to the suspected abuser.

SEC. 1115. SECURITY ASSESSORS AND CONFLICTS.

(a) Independence.—An assessor performing a required independent review shall disclose material ownership, consulting, and contingent-fee relationships with the assessed entity. A person responsible for designing the specific control shall not be the sole independent evaluator of that control.

(b) Scope.—The assessment shall identify systems examined, methods used, exclusions, material findings, and limitations. It shall distinguish verification of a document from testing whether a control operates. A certification shall not imply review of an entire enterprise when only a limited service or facility was examined.

(c) Followup.—The provider shall prepare a risk-prioritized corrective plan and document closure of material findings. Regulators may require verification of correction where the risk warrants it. An assessment does not provide immunity for a violation or shift all operational responsibility to the assessor. Public disclosure shall communicate material assurance limitations while protecting information whose release would create a substantial security vulnerability. Knowingly false certification is enforceable under this Act and any other applicable law.

TITLE XII—EMERGENCY AND PUBLIC SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS

SEC. 1201. EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS CONTINUITY.

(a) Duty.—A provider offering voice or another service represented as capable of emergency calling shall maintain reasonable measures to route emergency communications accurately, preserve essential location information, and restore failures promptly. Representations shall identify material limitations of nomadic, satellite, application-based, or power-dependent service.

(b) Coordination.—The Commission shall coordinate with emergency-call authorities, States, Tribes, public-safety agencies, and relevant Federal offices to establish interoperable requirements within their respective authority.

(c) Limits.—This title does not authorize the Federal Government to command State personnel or assume routine control of local emergency operations. Federal grants and direct duties on interstate service providers shall be administered with clear conditions. A local agency's participation in a grant shall not constitute consent to unrelated Federal control of its records, staffing, or law-enforcement policy.

SEC. 1202. NEXT GENERATION EMERGENCY CALLING.

(a) Grants.—Within the amount appropriated in title XXIX, the Secretary shall provide grants for interoperable next-generation emergency-call systems, including secure routing, accessible text and video capabilities where operationally supported, cybersecurity, training, and continuity.

(b) Plan.—An applicant shall identify existing capabilities, interoperability standards, migration phases, staffing, operating costs, vendor dependencies, and agreements with neighboring jurisdictions. A capital purchase without a sustainable operating plan is insufficient.

(c) Conditions.—A recipient shall test the system before migration, maintain a rollback or alternate-routing plan, and protect emergency-service fees from diversion as required by applicable law. Grants shall not require purchase from a single vendor. A recipient shall demonstrate that dispatchers can use new functions safely and that the public receives accurate information about which functions are available.

SEC. 1203. LOCATION ACCURACY AND PRIVACY.

(a) Accuracy.—Providers shall furnish emergency location information using the most reliable reasonably available method appropriate to the service, including a process for correcting registered addresses and identifying material uncertainty.

(b) Testing.—Rules shall establish representative testing across indoor, rural, urban, multistory, and accessible-use conditions. A national average shall not conceal systematic failure in a particular environment. Providers and emergency authorities shall coordinate correction of misrouting discovered through actual calls.

(c) Privacy.—Emergency location information shall be used for emergency response, necessary quality assurance, and other uses expressly authorized by law. It shall not be sold or used for advertising. Retention and access shall be limited, logged, and subject to audit. This section does not create a general authority to track a person outside an emergency or bypass legal process otherwise required for law-enforcement access.

SEC. 1204. ACCESSIBLE EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS.

(a) Equivalence.—Emergency systems funded under this Act shall provide practical access for persons who are deaf, hard of hearing, blind, have speech disabilities, or cannot use a standard voice interface. Design shall include accessible initiation, communication, confirmation, and error recovery.

(b) Compatibility.—Agencies shall coordinate real-time text, relay, assistive devices, and other feasible methods. A transition shall not withdraw a functioning accessible method before an effective replacement is available to the affected users.

(c) Training.—Personnel shall receive training appropriate to the supported methods and shall not treat a communication as nonurgent solely because it arrives through an accessibility channel. Testing shall include actual users and shall protect their privacy. A publicly advertised capability shall be operationally supported, rather than merely present in a vendor's product specification.

SEC. 1205. EMERGENCY ALERTS.

(a) Performance.—Covered alerting participants shall maintain the ability to receive, authenticate, and distribute authorized emergency alerts within their technical role. Rules shall address geographic targeting, timeliness, accessibility, language needs, and correction of erroneous alerts.

(b) Authority.—An alert shall originate from an authorized source and concern an emergency purpose established by law. Alert systems shall not be used for campaign messages, political advocacy, commercial promotion, or retaliation against a community.

(c) User Control.—Mandatory alert categories shall be narrowly defined. Other categories shall permit meaningful user controls without confusing users about critical warnings. Testing shall be clearly identified and coordinated to avoid unnecessary panic. After a material false or failed alert, responsible agencies shall publish a corrective analysis while protecting sensitive operational information.

SEC. 1206. BROADCAST AND MULTIPLATFORM WARNING ACCESS.

(a) Continuity.—The Commission shall assess the complementary roles of broadcast radio, television, mobile alerts, satellite, and internet distribution in reaching people during power and network failures. Policy shall preserve practical redundancy rather than assume one platform reaches everyone.

(b) Information.—A manufacturer marketing a device as an emergency receiver shall accurately disclose required connectivity, power, subscription, geographic coverage, and supported alert functions. A software update shall not silently remove a specifically advertised emergency feature during its promised support period.

(c) Study.—The Commission and transportation authorities shall evaluate reliable access to emergency information in vehicles and recommend technically neutral requirements within existing authority. This section does not itself mandate a particular radio band in every vehicle. Any future mandate shall account for coverage, interference, cost, accessibility, and alternative resilient reception.

SEC. 1207. PUBLIC SAFETY INTEROPERABILITY.

(a) Standards.—Grant-supported public-safety networks shall use interoperable interfaces and documented coordination procedures sufficient for mutual aid across jurisdictions. Security and authentication shall be integrated into interoperability rather than treated as an optional later addition.

(b) Procurement.—Contracts shall preserve access to operational data, reasonable switching, and compatibility information. A vendor shall not use proprietary lock-in to prevent lawful coordination or impose an undisclosed fee during an emergency.

(c) Authority.—This Act does not amend the statutory duration or governance of the First Responder Network Authority by implication. The Secretary shall identify any reauthorization or conforming legislation necessary to coordinate new grants with existing public-safety systems. Existing obligations remain in force according to their terms unless expressly amended by Congress.

SEC. 1208. OUTAGE NOTICE TO EMERGENCY AUTHORITIES.

(a) Notice.—A provider aware of an outage materially affecting emergency-call delivery shall promptly notify affected emergency authorities through a reliable channel, providing the area, functions affected, known alternatives, and estimated restoration when supportable.

(b) Updates.—The provider shall update material changes and confirm restoration after verification. It shall distinguish a partial technical recovery from full restoration of emergency routing and location functions.

(c) Public Communication.—Affected customers shall receive practical instructions through available channels without creating unnecessary alarm or disclosing exploitable network details. A provider shall not delay notice merely to protect its reputation. An emergency authority shall protect confidential technical information while sharing what responders and the public need to avoid harm. Rules shall coordinate this duty with existing outage-reporting systems.

SEC. 1209. DISASTER ROAMING AND TEMPORARY ACCESS.

(a) Arrangements.—The Commission may require reasonable, temporary roaming or access arrangements during a declared disaster when necessary to restore essential communications, technically feasible, and consistent with network safety. An order shall identify affected providers, locations, capacity limits, compensation, and duration.

(b) Priority.—Public-safety traffic and essential public communications may receive priority under transparent, lawful criteria. Priority shall not be sold as an undisclosed advantage or used to favor an official's political supporters.

(c) Termination.—Temporary arrangements shall end when the emergency need ends, with notice and a safe transition. A provider may seek modification upon evidence that the arrangement materially threatens its own customers' emergency access. Disputes over compensation shall not justify abrupt termination of a court- or agency-ordered emergency arrangement while review is pending.

SEC. 1210. COMMUNICATIONS IN CONFINEMENT.

(a) Access.—The Commission shall exercise its authority over incarcerated persons' communications to ensure just and reasonable charges, accessible service, and protection from unjustified ancillary fees. This Act expressly authorizes regulation of provider-imposed deposit, refund, account-maintenance, and payment-processing charges associated with covered communications.

(b) Costs.—Rates may recover efficiently incurred service and lawful security costs, with transparent allocation. Payments to a facility unrelated to the reasonable cost of communications shall not be shifted to users as a mandatory service charge. The Commission shall preserve lawful security screening while rejecting unsupported cost claims.

(c) Rights.—Providers shall offer clear prices, usable refunds, disability access, and confidential attorney-client channels as required by law. They shall not condition a family member's access on unrelated data commercialization. Nothing grants a right to unmonitored communication where lawful monitoring applies, but monitoring shall not be misrepresented or used to defeat legally privileged communication.

SEC. 1211. SURVIVORS AND SAFE ACCOUNT SEPARATION.

(a) Process.—A provider shall maintain a confidential, expedited process for separating a survivor's line or account from a shared plan when authorized by the account user and supported by reasonable evidence under applicable law. Evidence requirements shall avoid forcing disclosure to the alleged abuser.

(b) Safety.—Notifications, billing addresses, authentication, and device-location settings shall be reviewed with the survivor's safety preferences. A provider shall not disclose a new address or contact channel to another account holder without lawful necessity.

(c) Continuity.—The provider shall explain remaining equipment obligations, available assistance, and any service interruption risk. It shall not require payment of another person's disputed debt as a condition of a legally required separation. This section supplements existing survivor-protection law and shall be implemented without weakening stronger protections or creating an unsafe universal notification requirement.

SEC. 1212. TESTING AND PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY.

(a) Exercises.—Agencies and recipients shall conduct periodic exercises addressing cyber disruption, power loss, misrouting, accessibility, and cross-jurisdiction coordination. Exercises shall include corrective-action tracking and shall not be satisfied solely by a tabletop discussion when operational testing is reasonably necessary.

(b) Metrics.—Reports shall measure failed emergency attempts, routing accuracy, restoration time, accessibility, and readiness, while protecting callers' identities. An absence of reported complaints is not proof that a system works for persons unable to reach it.

(c) Review.—The Comptroller General shall evaluate grant sustainability and interoperability in program year 4. Agencies shall identify remaining unfunded operating needs and statutory barriers. Permanent public-safety funding shall require explicit appropriations or other lawful financing; an agency may not quietly finance unrelated purposes through a charge labeled an emergency-service fee.

SEC. 1213. FRAUDULENT CALL ORIGINATION AND AUTHENTICATION.

(a) Duty.—A provider originating or transmitting voice communications shall comply with lawful caller-authentication requirements and take reasonable steps, proportionate to its role and available evidence, to prevent knowing facilitation of materially fraudulent caller identification. Authentication shall not be represented as proof that the caller's message is truthful or lawful.

(b) Traceback.—The Commission may require timely cooperation with a legally authorized traceback concerning suspected unlawful calling, subject to privacy, security, and due-process safeguards. A provider shall maintain relevant routing records for the period reasonably required by an applicable rule, without retaining call content merely for this purpose.

(c) Limits.—A person shall not be treated as an unlawful caller solely because it uses a synthetic voice, an unfamiliar number, or an accessibility aid. Existing consent requirements and prohibitions on deception remain applicable. Any new blocking requirement shall include correction procedures for erroneously blocked lawful callers and shall consider risks to emergency, health, school, and other time-sensitive communications.

SEC. 1214. CALL BLOCKING LABELS AND REDRESS.

(a) Accuracy.—A provider or commercial service supplying fraud-risk labels shall use reasonable methods to evaluate accuracy and correct documented errors. It shall not sell removal of a false fraud designation as a substitute for examining the designation's validity.

(b) Review.—A person whose lawful calls are materially blocked or mislabeled shall have an accessible process to provide relevant evidence, receive a tracking identifier, and obtain a reasoned response. An urgent route shall be available where a credible error materially impairs emergency or essential institutional communications.

(c) Security.—The process need not reveal a detection method whose disclosure would materially enable evasion. It shall nevertheless provide enough information to identify the affected numbers and nature of the concern. Correction does not require unconditional delivery of demonstrably fraudulent calls or immunity from subsequent reassessment. The Commission shall measure both successful prevention of unlawful calls and false-positive harm, rather than treating the number of blocked calls alone as proof of effectiveness.

SEC. 1215. EMERGENCY SYSTEM TESTING AND PROCUREMENT.

(a) End-To-End Tests.—A recipient of next-generation emergency communications funds shall test call receipt, location transfer, accessibility, interconnection, failover, and restoration across the participating systems before accepting a material upgrade. Testing shall include realistic loss of power or connectivity without creating an avoidable risk to live emergency operations.

(b) Contracts.—A funded procurement shall include interoperability documentation, data export, maintenance responsibilities, security updates, and a practical transition route to another qualified vendor. Proprietary features may be purchased, but the contract shall identify their effect on interoperability and future operating cost.

(c) Accountability.—Acceptance shall be based on documented performance against published requirements. A vendor's representation that a product is next generation is insufficient. A material failure shall trigger correction and proportionate retention of unpaid amounts under the contract. Public reports shall identify whether a project is procured, installed, tested, or operational, and shall not describe an awarded contract as a completed emergency capability.

TITLE XIII—COMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA PRIVACY

SEC. 1301. COVERED INFORMATION AND ENTITIES.

(a) Information.—"Covered information" means information linked or reasonably linkable to an individual or household and collected through a covered connectivity, media, advertising, ticketing, or device function. It includes communication metadata, viewing and listening histories, precise location, device identifiers, account records, and inferences derived from such information.

(b) Sensitive Information.—Sensitive information includes communication content, precise location, authentication credentials, biometric identifiers, health information, financial account credentials, information revealing sexual life or orientation, and information concerning a known minor. Public availability of one fact does not eliminate protection for a materially revealing aggregation.

(c) Exclusions.—Properly deidentified information is excluded only when reasonable technical and contractual measures prevent reidentification and the holder does not attempt reidentification. Publicly available expression is not itself subject to an erasure right that overrides lawful journalism or another person's speech. Duties attach to the covered processing function, not to an entity's label.

SEC. 1302. DATA MINIMIZATION AND PURPOSE LIMITS.

(a) Collection.—A covered entity shall collect, use, retain, and disclose only information reasonably necessary and proportionate to provide a service requested by the individual, complete an authorized transaction, maintain security, comply with law, or perform another purpose affirmatively permitted by this title.

(b) Necessity.—A purpose shall be specific enough to evaluate necessity. General references to improving services, personalization, research, or business interests do not authorize unlimited processing. The entity shall distinguish information essential to a requested function from information used for an optional commercial purpose.

(c) Secondary Use.—Materially incompatible secondary use requires separate lawful authority and, where applicable, affirmative consent. An entity shall not retroactively expand permission through a changed privacy notice. Data collected to provide connectivity shall not be used to infer sensitive traits for advertising merely because the provider can technically observe the traffic.

SEC. 1303. SENSITIVE INFORMATION.

(a) Consent.—Processing sensitive information beyond what is strictly necessary for a requested service, security, or legal obligation requires specific affirmative consent. Consent shall identify the category, purpose, recipient class, and retention period.

(b) Prohibited Uses.—A covered entity shall not sell precise location revealing visits to sensitive facilities, sell authentication credentials, or use communication content to target advertising without the separate consent required by this title. Sensitive information shall not be used to deny a protected person equal access through unlawful discrimination.

(c) Exceptions.—Necessary emergency assistance, fraud prevention, accessibility, and compliance with valid legal process are permitted within narrow limits. An exception shall not be used as a pretext for unrelated surveillance or monetization. A person receiving sensitive information under an exception shall be bound to the permitted purpose and shall delete or deidentify it when that purpose ends, subject to a lawful retention requirement.

SEC. 1304. ADVERTISING CHOICES.

(a) Choice.—An individual may decline cross-context behavioral advertising and sale or sharing of covered information for such advertising through a clear account control and a recognized universal preference signal meeting technical standards adopted by the Trade Commission.

(b) Contextual Advertising.—An entity may offer contextual advertising based on the immediate content or service requested, without constructing a persistent cross-service profile. Fraud prevention and aggregate measurement remain permitted when proportionate and designed to prevent reidentification.

(c) Fair Terms.—An entity shall not misrepresent a paid ad-free plan as reducing data collection if it does not. A discount tied to optional data use shall clearly state its terms and shall not require surrender of sensitive-information protections. Refusal of optional tracking shall not disable functions unrelated to that tracking. This section does not require every service to be offered without charge.

SEC. 1305. ACCESS CORRECTION DELETION AND PORTABILITY.

(a) Rights.—An individual may obtain a meaningful description and copy of covered information, correct material inaccuracies, request deletion, and export information the individual provided or generated through use in a reasonably usable format.

(b) Response.—The entity shall respond within 30 days, with one additional 30-day extension for a complex request explained before the initial period expires. Requests shall ordinarily be free. A reasonable fee may be imposed for demonstrably excessive repetitive requests, with an explanation and appeal route.

(c) Exceptions.—Deletion may be limited to preserve a requested transaction, security evidence, legal claims, mandatory records, or lawful expression and public-interest research subject to safeguards. The entity shall identify the specific exception and restrict retained information to that purpose. A refusal shall not rely on an indefinite possibility of future litigation. Portability shall protect the rights and privacy of other persons.

SEC. 1306. AUTHENTICATION AND AUTHORIZED AGENTS.

(a) Proportionality.—Verification shall be proportionate to the sensitivity of the request and risk of unauthorized access. An entity shall not demand a government identity document for a routine opt-out when a less intrusive method is adequate.

(b) Agents.—An individual may use an authorized agent. The entity may verify authority and identity as necessary but shall not impose burdens designed to defeat collective or assisted exercise of rights. An agent shall not sell information obtained through the request or exceed the individual's authorization.

(c) Safety.—Special procedures shall protect persons facing stalking, domestic violence, or identity theft. A privacy request shall not automatically notify another household member whose knowledge could create danger. Records collected solely for verification shall be deleted when no longer needed, except for a minimal audit record that does not recreate the sensitive document.

SEC. 1307. PROCESSORS AND SERVICE PROVIDERS.

(a) Contract.—A controller engaging a processor shall specify instructions, data categories, purposes, security, retention, subcontracting, audit, and return or deletion. A processor shall not use information for its own unrelated advertising or sale merely because it received access to perform a service.

(b) Responsibility.—The controller shall exercise reasonable diligence and respond to known material violations. A processor is independently liable for processing outside lawful instructions or for its own security duties. Neither party is automatically liable for every unforeseeable act of an independent party without an applicable basis.

(c) Subprocessors.—Material subcontracting shall be disclosed to the controller and subject to equivalent protections. Contractual labels do not control when actual conduct shows independent determination of purposes. A nominal processor that builds its own commercial profiles is a controller for that activity and shall satisfy the corresponding duties.

SEC. 1308. RETENTION AND DELETION SCHEDULES.

(a) Schedule.—A covered entity shall maintain a documented retention schedule by category and purpose, with deletion or deidentification when the purpose ends. Indefinite retention for unspecified future use is prohibited.

(b) Backups.—Information in protected backups may be deleted on an ordinary rotation schedule when immediate selective deletion is technically impracticable, provided it is not restored for ordinary use without reapplying valid deletion requests and is not used for secondary purposes.

(c) Records.—An entity may retain minimal evidence of consent, transactions, compliance, and legal obligations for a justified period. It shall not retain complete viewing histories or communication content when an aggregate record would establish the relevant fact. The Trade Commission shall provide proportionate guidance for smaller entities and shall not require retention that conflicts with a more protective lawful obligation without express authority.

SEC. 1309. IMPACT ASSESSMENTS.

(a) High Risk Processing.—A large covered entity shall assess processing involving sensitive information at scale, systematic profiling with material consequences, or a new technology presenting substantial privacy risk. A large covered entity is one processing covered information concerning more than 1,000,000 individuals annually or deriving more than $100,000,000 in annual covered revenue.

(b) Contents.—The assessment shall identify purpose, necessity, data flows, affected persons, foreseeable misuse, safeguards, alternatives, and residual risk. It shall examine whether a less intrusive design can achieve the legitimate objective.

(c) Oversight.—The Trade Commission may obtain assessments through lawful process and require a public summary that protects trade secrets and security. An assessment does not create immunity or require publication of proprietary source code. Smaller entities conducting comparably dangerous processing may be required by rule to perform a simplified assessment tied to the actual risk.

SEC. 1310. GOVERNMENT ACCESS.

(a) Process.—A covered entity shall disclose protected communications or records to government only pursuant to valid legal authority, an individual's lawful authorization, or a narrowly applicable emergency exception. This Act does not lower a warrant, subpoena, court-order, or other threshold established by existing law.

(b) Commercial Acquisition.—A Federal agency may not purchase covered information from a commercial source to obtain substantially the same information about an identified person that would require judicial process if compelled directly from the provider, unless Congress has expressly authorized the purchase notwithstanding that requirement.

(c) Accountability.—Agencies shall document the legal basis and permissible use of acquired information, restrict access, and provide oversight records. Exceptions for an imminent threat to life shall be documented and reviewed promptly. This section does not alter foreign-intelligence authorities by implication, but no general authority in this Act authorizes domestic surveillance or access to encrypted content.

SEC. 1311. ENFORCEMENT AND STATE PROTECTION.

(a) Lead Agency.—The Trade Commission shall enforce this title, with Commission technical assistance for network functions. State attorneys general may enforce the same Federal duties under title XXVII. More protective State privacy and breach-notification laws are preserved except where simultaneous compliance is impossible.

(b) Private Action.—An individual suffering concrete injury from a violation may seek the relief specified in title XXVII. A bare procedural omission without concrete injury does not by itself establish Article III standing. Nothing narrows standing that otherwise exists under the Constitution and applicable law.

(c) Authority.—Congress expressly authorizes the rules necessary to implement this title notwithstanding the restriction on reissuing a substantially similar rule following the 2017 congressional disapproval of the Commission's broadband-privacy rule. This authorization applies only to rules within this title and does not generally repeal chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code.

SEC. 1312. EFFECTIVE DATE AND TRANSITION.

(a) Date.—This title takes effect 24 months after enactment. Agencies shall publish implementation guidance and model rights-request procedures at least six months before that date. A smaller entity may receive limited technical phasing under title VIII, but not permission to continue a prohibited sale of sensitive information.

(b) Existing Data.—After the effective date, continued processing of previously collected information shall satisfy this title. An entity shall not be penalized under this Act solely for a completed pre-effective-date collection, but shall assess continued retention, use, and disclosure and delete information lacking a lawful continuing purpose.

(c) Review.—Every four years, the Trade Commission shall evaluate whether rights are practically usable, preference signals function, privacy choices are respected, and compliance costs unnecessarily favor incumbents. It may update technical methods through rulemaking but may not erase a statutory right through an industry code or private certification arrangement.

SEC. 1313. HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNTS AND CONFIDENTIAL USE.

(a) Separate Interests.—A provider shall distinguish the account holder's legitimate billing and security information from another individual's private communications, precise location, and separately protected activity. Payment for a shared account does not by itself authorize disclosure of every user's sensitive information.

(b) Controls.—Where a service supports separate user profiles, it shall provide reasonably available controls for access, recovery, and notification that reflect the users' lawful authority. A change to account management shall not silently defeat an existing confidentiality protection.

(c) Safety.—A request concerning suspected coercion, stalking, or unauthorized monitoring shall receive a process that avoids notifying the suspected wrongdoer where notice would create a material safety risk and may lawfully be withheld. The provider may seek proportionate verification without demanding unnecessary details of abuse. This section does not override a valid court order, a lawful guardian's authority, or another person's constitutional rights; the provider shall identify the controlling legal basis when denying a requested confidentiality measure.

SEC. 1314. DATA TRANSFERS AND SUBSEQUENT USE.

(a) Conditions.—A covered person transferring protected information to another commercial recipient shall identify the lawful purpose, categories transferred, retention conditions, and restrictions on subsequent use. A contract shall prohibit uses inconsistent with the individual's valid choice and the duties of this title.

(b) Diligence.—The transferring person shall use reasonable diligence proportionate to the sensitivity and volume of information and to credible evidence of recipient misuse. A paper promise is insufficient where the transferor knows that the recipient materially disregards the restriction.

(c) Correction.—Upon learning of material unauthorized use, the transferor shall take reasonable steps within its control to stop further transfer, seek deletion or correction, and notify affected persons when required. The recipient remains independently responsible for its own conduct. This section does not impose strict liability for an unforeseeable independent breach by another person, but delegation or sale does not extinguish a duty concerning information the transferor continues to control or knowingly supplies for an unlawful purpose.

SEC. 1315. PRIVACY REQUEST ABUSE AND LAWFUL RETENTION.

(a) Verification.—A recipient of a privacy request may use proportionate authentication and may refuse a request reasonably shown to be fraudulent. It shall explain the reason and provide a correction route without revealing information that would assist account takeover.

(b) Repetition.—A person may charge a reasonable cost-based fee for a manifestly excessive repetitive request after explaining the basis, but the first reasonable exercise of a right during a twelve-month period shall be free. A request is not excessive merely because it requires correction of a provider's recurring error.

(c) Retention.—Information lawfully retained for a specific legal obligation, security investigation, or pending claim shall be segregated where practicable and unavailable for unrelated marketing. The person shall identify the retention category and review its continuing necessity. A general possibility of future litigation does not justify indefinite retention of all user activity. Deletion duties shall accommodate secure backup rotation when the information is not restored to ordinary use or newly exploited.

TITLE XIV—DISABILITY ACCESS AND USABLE SERVICES

SEC. 1401. EQUIVALENT ACCESS DUTY.

(a) Duty.—A covered provider, distributor, or device manufacturer shall make its covered functions accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities when readily achievable, and shall provide compatibility with commonly used assistive technology when direct accessibility is not readily achievable. More protective duties under existing disability law remain applicable.

(b) Assessment.—Readily achievable shall be assessed in light of the nature and cost of the action, the entity's overall resources, the affected function, available alternatives, and the importance of access. An entity shall not assess only the resources of a nominally separate affiliate when the controlling enterprise provides substantial support.

(c) Equivalence.—Equivalent access concerns practical ability to obtain information, operate controls, complete transactions, communicate, and receive the same material benefit. It does not require identical technical design. A separate alternative is inadequate when it introduces unreasonable delay, additional cost, loss of privacy, or dependence on another person.

SEC. 1402. ACCESSIBLE ENROLLMENT AND SUPPORT.

(a) Transactions.—Subscription, authentication, payment, cancellation, privacy controls, complaint forms, and benefit applications shall be operable through accessible interfaces. A provider shall not offer accessible entertainment while leaving the transaction required to obtain it inaccessible.

(b) Support.—Customers shall have access to effective communication assistance through appropriate text, relay, voice, or other channels. A representative shall not refuse an authorized relay call or require a person with a disability to use a channel that the provider knows is unusable for that person.

(c) Documentation.—Instructions, contracts, and notices shall be available in accessible electronic formats and, when reasonably necessary, alternative formats. A surcharge for a required accommodation is prohibited. The provider may verify a functional need when necessary but shall not demand unrelated medical history or condition ordinary support on disclosure of a diagnosis.

SEC. 1403. CAPTIONING.

(a) Coverage.—Professional audiovisual programming distributed commercially through a covered media service shall include accurate, synchronized, complete, and appropriately placed captions according to a phased schedule established by the Commission. The schedule shall address newly produced programming first and establish feasible requirements for substantial back catalogs.

(b) Live Content.—Live programming shall use methods reasonably capable of timely and intelligible captioning. The Commission shall distinguish unavoidable live-production limitations from failure to provide reasonable staffing, testing, or correction. Emergency information shall receive priority.

(c) Responsibility.—Producers shall supply available caption files to authorized distributors; distributors shall preserve and render them correctly; device and application providers shall make controls accessible. Contracts shall allocate performance duties without eliminating statutory responsibility for functions under each party's control. An individual user posting occasional noncommercial content is not subject to a professional caption-production mandate solely because a platform hosts the content.

SEC. 1404. AUDIO DESCRIPTION AND TRANSCRIPTS.

(a) Expansion.—The Commission shall establish a phased increase in audio description for professionally produced audiovisual programming, considering audience reach, production resources, availability of description tracks, and the needs of blind and low-vision users.

(b) Distribution.—A distributor receiving an authorized description track shall preserve it and make it reasonably discoverable without an additional charge. A licensing agreement shall not prohibit use of an available accessibility track within the licensed distribution merely to create a separate accessibility fee.

(c) Alternatives.—For audio-only programming and essential informational content, accessible transcripts or equivalent methods shall be provided where readily achievable. A transcript shall identify speakers and material nonverbal information necessary to understand the content. Rules shall preserve expressive integrity and shall not require an accessibility provider to insert government-approved interpretations of a work.

SEC. 1405. INTERFACES AND REMOTE CONTROLS.

(a) Design.—Covered devices and applications shall provide accessible navigation, volume, captions, description, playback, search, and purchase controls. Frequently needed accessibility functions shall not be buried in a sequence materially more difficult than comparable ordinary controls.

(b) Compatibility.—Interfaces shall support assistive input and output methods through documented standards where feasible. Updates shall not remove a working accessibility function without an equivalent replacement and reasonable notice.

(c) Testing.—Manufacturers and large distributors shall test representative tasks with users having relevant disabilities and maintain records of identified barriers and corrections. Compliance shall be evaluated by actual task completion, not solely by a vendor's automated score. An agency shall permit an equivalent accessible design when it achieves the statutory outcome without adhering to a particular proprietary implementation.

SEC. 1406. REAL TIME COMMUNICATIONS.

(a) Functions.—Covered voice, video, and messaging services shall support accessible communication through interoperable text, captioning, relay, or other appropriate methods to the extent readily achievable. Security and privacy protections shall apply equally to accessible communications.

(b) Interoperability.—The Commission shall coordinate standards that permit communication across providers without forcing a person with a disability to subscribe to multiple services solely to reach others. Requirements shall account for technical feasibility and shall not compel disclosure of encryption keys or degradation of secure communications.

(c) Quality.—An accessible channel shall provide reliability and support reasonably comparable to the underlying service. Providers shall investigate recurrent delay, missing text, or relay failure and shall not treat accessibility complaints as optional feature requests. Rules shall identify the responsible party when a failure arises at an interconnection or application boundary.

SEC. 1407. EMERGENCY AND SAFETY INFORMATION.

(a) Priority.—Visual emergency information shall have an effective nonvisual equivalent, and audible emergency information shall have an effective visual equivalent, subject to narrowly tailored technical exceptions. The information shall be conveyed with comparable urgency and essential detail.

(b) Testing.—Broadcasters, distributors, and device providers shall test the full delivery chain, including captions, secondary audio, overlays, application controls, and alert interfaces. A functioning upstream file does not establish compliance when downstream equipment suppresses it.

(c) Correction.—A material accessibility failure affecting safety shall receive expedited correction and notice to affected users through an accessible channel. An entity may temporarily use a practical alternative while repairing the primary method. A temporary workaround shall not become a permanent substitute without evidence that it provides equivalent access.

SEC. 1408. GAMES AND INTERACTIVE MEDIA.

(a) Information.—A commercial game or interactive service shall accurately disclose material accessibility features before purchase, including relevant text, audio, input, contrast, timing, and communication options. A seller shall not claim full accessibility based on one limited feature.

(b) Development.—Large publishers shall assess accessibility during development and provide readily achievable options for core navigation, purchases, account management, and communications. Requirements shall account for the expressive and mechanical characteristics of the work and shall not require changing its story or artistic viewpoint.

(c) Remedy.—When a specifically advertised accessibility feature is materially absent or inoperative, the purchaser may obtain correction or a refund under title XVI. Publishers shall provide a channel for reporting barriers and shall distinguish compatibility problems from unsupported claims that disability access is inherently impossible.

SEC. 1409. EXEMPTIONS AND ALTERNATIVE COMPLIANCE.

(a) Petition.—An entity seeking a limited exemption shall identify the specific requirement, cost, technical barrier, resources, alternatives considered, and proposed duration. A generalized claim that accessibility is expensive is insufficient.

(b) Decision.—The Commission shall provide public notice, protect legitimate confidential information, consult affected users, and issue a reasoned decision. An exemption shall be no broader or longer than necessary and shall ordinarily include interim measures and a review date.

(c) Limits.—An exemption shall not excuse misrepresentation, failure to distribute an already available accessibility track, or refusal to provide a low-cost accommodation. An entity shall reassess an exemption when a material change in technology or resources makes compliance feasible. A purchaser shall receive notice of a material limitation before commitment.

SEC. 1410. ACCESSIBILITY IN PUBLICLY FUNDED PROJECTS.

(a) Condition.—A recipient of funding under this Act shall include accessibility in procurement, design, testing, training, and maintenance. The award shall identify measurable requirements appropriate to the funded function.

(b) Acceptance.—A recipient shall not accept a system solely on a vendor's assurance when reasonable testing shows that persons with disabilities cannot use essential functions. Contracts shall provide correction, documentation, and remedies for material nonconformance.

(c) Assistance.—The Secretary may finance shared accessibility testing and technical assistance within the relevant appropriation. Assistance shall be available to smaller producers and providers without requiring membership in a private association. Publicly funded accessibility resources shall be reusable where licensing permits, and their use shall not convey a government endorsement of the political or artistic content of a work.

SEC. 1411. COMPLAINTS AND PARTICIPATION.

(a) Process.—The Commission shall maintain an accessible complaint channel and ordinarily seek an initial provider response within 15 days. A complainant may describe the failed task and need not identify the technical cause or statutory subsection.

(b) Representation.—An individual may authorize an advocate or organization to assist. The process shall protect medical and personal information and shall not require public disclosure of a disability diagnosis when a functional description is sufficient.

(c) Remedies.—Relief may include correction, accessible alternative service, refund, prospective compliance, and judicial remedies under title XXVII. Systemic complaints may be consolidated when doing so improves resolution without eliminating individual needs. The agency shall report recurring barriers and the time required to resolve them, rather than treating closure of a complaint record as proof that access was restored.

SEC. 1412. STANDARDS AND PERIODIC REVIEW.

(a) Rules.—The Commission shall consult the Access Board, affected users, producers, distributors, and technical experts in adopting performance standards. A standard incorporated by reference shall be publicly accessible and accompanied by an explanation of the legally binding requirements.

(b) Transition.—New technical requirements shall provide reasonable implementation time, with earlier deadlines for readily achievable corrections and longer periods for substantial capital changes. Existing stronger obligations remain in force.

(c) Review.—At least every four years, the Commission shall examine emerging interfaces, immersive media, artificial intelligence, and changes in distribution. It may update technical implementation within express statutory authority but shall not define an entire new class of expressive activity as a regulated communications utility merely because accessibility concerns arise. Recommendations requiring broader authority shall be submitted to Congress.

SEC. 1413. ACCESSIBILITY TESTING WITH USERS.

(a) Evaluation.—A covered person implementing a material interface or communications redesign shall evaluate whether the change impairs required accessibility. The evaluation shall include relevant assistive technologies and, where proportionate, participation by users with the disabilities affected.

(b) Record.—The person shall document significant barriers found, corrective steps, unresolved limitations, and the basis for an asserted exception. Automated testing may assist but shall not be represented as a complete assessment where the relevant barrier requires human evaluation.

(c) Correction.—A material regression that prevents users from performing a core function shall receive priority correction and an effective temporary alternative where feasible. A provider shall not direct all disabled users to a slower or more expensive channel merely because maintaining the ordinary interface requires reasonable effort. Nothing requires disclosure of a participant's diagnosis or public identification. Testing records may use functional categories and anonymized observations sufficient to assess whether the legal duty has been met.

SEC. 1414. CAPTION AND DESCRIPTION QUALITY COMPLAINTS.

(a) Specificity.—A complaint may identify the program, approximate time, service, and nature of a captioning or audio-description failure without requiring the complainant to produce a recording the person cannot lawfully or technically obtain.

(b) Responsibility.—The receiving distributor shall investigate the portion within its control and route a production-related issue to the responsible party. It shall not repeatedly redirect the user without retaining responsibility for explaining the disposition of the complaint.

(c) Remedy.—The responsible person shall correct a reproducible technical failure, address recurring quality defects, and explain a lawful exception. An isolated unavoidable error in live production shall be distinguished from a systemic failure to provide the required service. Accessibility information supplied with a program shall be preserved through ordinary distribution and device interfaces where technically feasible. A distributor shall not advertise captions or description as available when a known defect prevents customers from activating or receiving them on the marketed service.

SEC. 1415. AFFORDABLE ACCESSIBILITY FEATURES.

(a) Pricing.—A covered provider shall not impose a surcharge solely for a feature necessary to meet its legal accessibility obligation. It may charge for an optional premium product offering additional independent functionality, provided an effective compliant alternative is available without the surcharge.

(b) Compatibility.—Before a material equipment migration, the provider shall disclose known effects on commonly used assistive devices and provide a practical route for compatibility questions. A consumer shall not be required to purchase replacement equipment because the provider concealed a known incompatibility at the time of sale.

(c) Assistance.—Public accessibility grants may support testing, accessible equipment, training, and implementation by small entities, subject to appropriations. A grant shall supplement compliance capacity and shall not purchase a waiver of rights. Agencies shall prioritize measures that enable independent use, while recognizing that an individual may prefer personal assistance. The preference for independent access shall not justify removal of an assistance channel needed by users who cannot effectively operate the available interface.

TITLE XV—BROADCAST OWNERSHIP LOCALISM AND INDEPENDENCE

SEC. 1501. STATUTORY NATIONAL TELEVISION LIMIT.

(a) Limit.—Beginning two years after enactment, no person may acquire attributable interests in commercial full-power television stations whose aggregate national audience reach exceeds 39 percent of television households in the United States. For this purpose, households shall be counted without a discount based on use of an ultra-high-frequency channel.

(b) Attribution.—The Commission shall adopt rules identifying ownership and actual control, including agreements conferring decisive influence over programming, finances, or station operations. Ordinary network affiliation, arm's-length financing, or a noncontrolling investment shall not be attributed without evidence satisfying the rule.

(c) Authority.—The numerical limit is established by Congress and may not be repealed or increased by the Commission. The Commission may correct measurement methods and prevent evasion but may not convert the limit into unrestricted case-by-case discretion. This section supersedes inconsistent administrative rules for transactions occurring after its effective date.

SEC. 1502. EXISTING HOLDINGS AND TRANSITION.

(a) Grandfathering.—A station interest lawfully held on the date of enactment may be retained notwithstanding section 1501, subject to disclosure and the prohibition on additional acquisitions increasing nonconforming reach. A pending transaction not finally consummated before enactment does not qualify solely because an application was filed.

(b) Transfer.—A transfer of control of a grandfathered group shall require a plan to comply with section 1501 within three years after closing, unless a court orders otherwise. Internal reorganizations that do not change ultimate control may preserve grandfathering but shall not enlarge it.

(c) Protection.—This Act does not reopen a final judicial judgment or require immediate uncompensated divestiture of lawfully held property. The Commission shall prevent use of nominal trustees, side agreements, or temporary transfers to evade the limit. A hardship extension shall be limited to one year and require evidence that a diligent sale process could not reasonably be completed.

SEC. 1503. LOCAL TELEVISION COMPETITION.

(a) Review.—The Commission shall maintain local ownership rules that protect independently controlled sources of local news, competition for advertising, and bargaining with distributors. Rules shall use current market evidence and shall not measure diversity by whether officials approve particular viewpoints.

(b) Baseline.—A transaction combining two of the four most-viewed full-power stations in a local market shall be presumptively prohibited. The applicant may rebut the presumption only by demonstrating a failing-station necessity or extraordinary, verifiable public benefit unavailable through a less concentrating alternative, together with enforceable safeguards.

(c) Evidence.—A claim that digital platforms compete for advertising is relevant but does not by itself establish that they replace local reporting or emergency coverage. The Commission shall examine actual substitution, audience behavior, revenue, entry barriers, and the likely effect on local service. A waiver shall be narrow, reasoned, and subject to review.

SEC. 1504. RADIO OWNERSHIP AND COMMUNITY ENTRY.

(a) Review.—The Commission shall review local radio ownership limits using evidence of audience concentration, advertising markets, independent local output, and opportunities for entry. It shall preserve meaningful independent ownership and shall not automatically equate a national streaming service with a locally staffed station.

(b) Entry.—Licensing and transfer procedures shall provide practical opportunities for qualified small, nonprofit, cooperative, and Tribal applicants. Technical requirements shall protect interference and safety without imposing unnecessary fixed costs.

(c) Waivers.—A waiver based on financial distress shall require credible evidence, consideration of independent purchasers, and conditions tied to continued service. A licensee shall not deliberately reduce local operations to manufacture a failing-station claim. This section does not establish a racial ownership quota or permit viewpoint-based selection among qualified applicants.

SEC. 1505. SHARED SERVICES AND DE FACTO CONTROL.

(a) Disclosure.—A station shall disclose material agreements governing shared news production, sales, personnel, financing, facilities, and operational control. Public summaries shall identify the nature and extent of shared functions without exposing protected commercial details unnecessarily.

(b) Attribution.—The Commission shall attribute control when an agreement effectively transfers decisive authority over a station's core operations, applying published criteria. A shared engineering or back-office arrangement shall not automatically establish common editorial control.

(c) Safeguards.—A station represented as independently controlled shall retain genuine authority over its editorial decisions, budget, and compliance. An agreement shall not be used to circumvent an ownership limit while preserving the same practical control. Enforcement shall rely on actual rights and conduct rather than a contract's label or the mere existence of cooperation between stations.

SEC. 1506. LOCAL SERVICE DISCLOSURES.

(a) Record.—Commercial broadcast stations shall publish an annual factual report describing locally originated programming, local emergency capability, community information services, staffing devoted to local production, and material shared-production arrangements.

(b) Neutrality.—The report shall not require ideological balance, endorsement of government policy, or a government judgment that a news story is sufficiently favorable or accurate. Quantitative categories shall be defined objectively, and a station may explain its service model.

(c) Public Access.—Reports shall be accessible without charge and retained for at least five years. A knowingly false statement is enforceable under applicable law, but a disagreement about editorial value is not a reporting violation. The Commission may use the reports to assess market conditions and compliance with specific commitments, not to punish lawful criticism of officials.

SEC. 1507. LICENSE RENEWAL AND EDITORIAL PROTECTION.

(a) Standard.—A renewal decision shall apply statutory licensing criteria through a public, reasoned process. A station's lawful political commentary, criticism, satire, choice of interview guests, or refusal to carry a government-preferred viewpoint shall not constitute grounds for denial, shortening, or extraordinary early review.

(b) Complaints.—A complaint shall identify a specific legal violation and supporting facts. Mass disagreement with a program's viewpoint is not evidence of a licensing violation. Agencies shall distinguish legally cognizable deception or unlawful conduct from protected editorial judgment.

(c) Process.—Before an adverse decision, the licensee shall receive notice, an opportunity to respond, and the hearing or review required by law. A settlement shall not require unrelated changes in newsroom leadership or editorial policy. Courts may provide relief for concrete injury from unlawful viewpoint retaliation under title XXVII.

SEC. 1508. TRANSACTION REVIEW.

(a) Record.—An applicant seeking approval of a broadcast transaction shall disclose ownership, financing, attributable interests, local overlaps, material public-service commitments, and anticipated effects on competition and local operations.

(b) Conditions.—A condition shall address a transaction-specific harm within the Commission's authority and be enforceable, measurable, and time-limited where appropriate. The Commission shall not demand unrelated charitable payments, favorable coverage, or concessions benefiting a politically connected entity.

(c) Coordination.—Commission approval does not immunize a transaction from antitrust law. Agencies shall coordinate factual review while preserving their separate legal standards. A proposed divestiture shall identify a viable independent purchaser and resources sufficient to operate, rather than merely transferring a license to a nominal owner dependent on the seller for decisive control.

SEC. 1509. POLITICAL ADVERTISING RECORDS.

(a) Disclosure.—Broadcast political-file obligations shall be administered through accessible, searchable records identifying the purchaser, legally required sponsor information, date, amount, and covered placement, subject to existing statutory definitions and privacy protections.

(b) Accuracy.—A station shall exercise reasonable diligence in obtaining required purchaser information and shall preserve corrections with an audit trail. It shall not be required to adjudicate the truth of every political claim as a condition of accepting a lawful advertisement.

(c) Equality.—The Commission shall apply statutory candidate-access and rate provisions according to their text. This Act does not silently extend a candidate's statutory entitlement to a party, committee, or outside group. A change in the scope of such entitlement requires express authority and public process. Editorial coverage remains distinct from a paid advertisement.

SEC. 1510. EMERGENCY AND FREE RECEPTION.

(a) Continuity.—A broadcast licensee shall maintain the emergency-alert and technical operations required by law, with reasonable backup and restoration planning appropriate to its role. A station shall not disable emergency distribution to gain leverage in a private carriage dispute.

(b) Reception.—When a technical transition materially affects ordinary free reception, the licensee shall provide advance, accessible notice explaining equipment, rescanning, coverage, and alternatives. A transition shall not misleadingly describe an encrypted or subscription-dependent signal as freely receivable on existing equipment.

(c) Review.—The Commission shall evaluate consumer equipment cost, coverage loss, accessibility, and emergency performance before authorizing a major transition. It may establish a phased simulcast or consumer-assistance requirement within its authority. A transition shall not be approved solely because it creates a new advertising or data-collection opportunity for licensees.

SEC. 1511. COMMUNITY AND TRIBAL BROADCASTING.

(a) Opportunities.—The Commission shall identify technically feasible opportunities for low-power, community, noncommercial, and Tribal broadcasting and provide understandable application guidance. Procedures shall protect existing lawful operations and manage interference through evidence.

(b) Support.—Appropriated public-media and resilience funds may assist eligible stations with emergency capability, accessibility, technical modernization, and training. Awards shall be based on objective service and need criteria and shall not depend on political or religious agreement with the Government.

(c) Accountability.—A recipient shall maintain financial records and comply with the conditions of the award. Government support does not authorize control of programming beyond the specific, constitutionally permissible public function funded. An entity shall not use a community designation as a front for undisclosed commercial control or private distribution of grant proceeds.

SEC. 1512. OWNERSHIP REVIEW AND JUDICIAL SCRUTINY.

(a) Review.—Every four years, the Commission shall review local ownership rules and report on national concentration, local information, advertising competition, employment, entry, and consumer prices. The statutory national limit may be changed only by Congress.

(b) Evidence.—The review shall publish methodologies, consider contrary evidence, and distinguish scale efficiencies from unverified promises. It shall examine whether divestiture remedies remained independent and whether public-service commitments were performed.

(c) Savings.—Nothing requires a court to defer to an agency's legal interpretation beyond the standard required by law. Rules and transaction decisions remain subject to constitutional and statutory review. If a particular ownership provision is invalidated, the editorial-independence protections, reporting duties, and otherwise valid competition provisions shall continue according to title XXX.

SEC. 1513. OWNERSHIP ATTRIBUTION AND CONTROL RECORDS.

(a) Records.—A broadcast licensee shall maintain accurate records of persons exercising attributable ownership or operational control under lawful Commission rules, including relevant voting arrangements and contractual powers. The Commission may require information necessary to determine whether nominally separate licensees are subject to common control.

(b) Substance.—Attribution shall consider actual power over management, programming decisions, sales, budgets, and essential operations. An ordinary arm's-length vendor relationship shall not be treated as control solely because the vendor provides a useful shared service.

(c) Process.—Before changing an attribution determination in a manner materially affecting lawful holdings, the Commission shall provide notice, the factual basis, and an opportunity to respond. A remedy shall distinguish deliberate concealment from a reasonable dispute about a newly adopted standard. Public ownership information shall identify controlling interests without unnecessarily exposing private contact information of noncontrolling individuals. Rules shall prevent sham arrangements while preserving legitimate cooperation that does not defeat statutory ownership limits.

SEC. 1514. VOLUNTARY BROADCAST TECHNOLOGY TRANSITIONS.

(a) Information.—A broadcaster participating in a voluntary transition to a different transmission standard shall provide clear information about reception equipment, accessible features, available simulcasting, and any foreseeable loss of service. Advertising shall not imply that viewers must buy equipment before that equipment is needed.

(b) Free Access.—Where a license condition requires free over-the-air service, a transition shall not silently convert the required service into a subscription or require unnecessary collection of personal information for basic reception. Lawful optional interactive services may have separate commercial terms.

(c) Coordination.—The Commission shall consider interference, local coverage, emergency alerts, disability access, device availability, and effects on smaller stations before approving a material transition framework. It shall not mandate a particular proprietary receiver or permit an intellectual-property arrangement to defeat a statutory reception obligation. A transition order shall explain the evidence, timetable, treatment of households unable to upgrade, and available review, without guaranteeing permanent support for every obsolete device.

SEC. 1515. LICENSE PUBLIC FILES AND COMMUNITY RESPONSE.

(a) Usability.—Information required in a broadcast public file shall be searchable and accessible in a reasonably usable format. An agency shall eliminate obsolete duplication where lawful while retaining records necessary to examine ownership, sponsorship, political advertising obligations, and material public-service commitments.

(b) Responses.—A licensee shall maintain a public contact for operational complaints, including reception, accessibility, emergency alerts, and public-file availability. It may use a shared service if the contact can identify the responsible station and obtain a meaningful response.

(c) Editorial Limits.—A complaint process shall not require a broadcaster to justify its political viewpoint, disclose confidential sources, or provide equal time outside the circumstances established by law. The Commission shall distinguish a complaint about an enforceable operational duty from disagreement with lawful programming. It may publish aggregate operational complaint information with appropriate qualification, but shall not create a government rating of whether a station's news coverage is sufficiently favorable to public officials or prevailing public opinion.

TITLE XVI—CABLE STREAMING AND ENTERTAINMENT PURCHASES

SEC. 1601. MEDIA SUBSCRIPTION BASELINE.

(a) Rights.—A covered media service shall comply with title IV concerning total price, recurring consent, cancellation, billing, and refunds. A service shall disclose material differences among advertising-supported, advertising-free, live, on-demand, and bundled plans before purchase.

(b) Catalogs.—A distributor may change a general catalog in the ordinary course, but shall not make a specific material promise about access to a work or event that it lacks reasonable grounds to fulfill. Material restrictions concerning geography, devices, simultaneous streams, downloads, and household use shall be conspicuous.

(c) Limits.—This title does not require a distributor to acquire or retain a particular work, impose a government-approved catalog, or offer every title on every service. It regulates commercial representations, payments, and performance while preserving lawful editorial and licensing choices.

SEC. 1602. MATERIAL SERVICE CHANGES.

(a) Notice.—A distributor shall provide at least 30 days' notice before a material reduction in a specifically purchased service feature, addition of advertising to a plan sold as advertising-free, or material restriction on supported devices, unless an urgent legal or security reason prevents notice.

(b) Choice.—An affected subscriber may cancel without an early termination charge and obtain a proportionate refund for undelivered prepaid service. A distributor may offer an equivalent replacement, but the customer shall not be required to accept a materially different product.

(c) Exceptions.—Ordinary rotation of a general catalog is not automatically a material reduction. The determination shall consider the seller's representations, the prominence of a promised feature, the purchase period, and reasonable customer expectations. A broad reservation of rights shall not permit the seller to retain payment for a substantially different service.

SEC. 1603. DIGITAL PURCHASES AND LICENSES.

(a) Disclosure.—A seller using "buy," "purchase," or a similar representation for digital media shall clearly disclose before payment whether the transaction provides a perpetual downloadable copy, a revocable license, time-limited access, or access dependent on an account or service continuing to operate.

(b) Durability.—A specifically promised permanent copy shall remain usable according to the disclosed terms without a new subscription. A seller that cannot continue a promised access right shall provide a lawful download or transfer when available, an equivalent alternative accepted by the customer, or a reasonable refund.

(c) Rights.—This section does not transfer copyright, authorize circumvention prohibited by law, or expand a license beyond its stated lawful scope. It prohibits misleading sale language and establishes commercial remedies. A seller shall not characterize an ordinary customer backup as infringement when the license expressly permits that backup.

SEC. 1604. CONTENT REMOVAL AND ACCOUNT CLOSURE.

(a) Purchased Content.—Before closing a service or removing access to separately purchased content for reasons unrelated to customer breach, the seller shall give reasonable notice and identify available download, migration, or refund options.

(b) Breach.—An account closure for alleged breach shall identify the material contractual basis and provide review of a disputed factual error, subject to urgent fraud, security, and legal restrictions. The seller may protect other users without publicly disclosing sensitive evidence.

(c) Payments.—Earned refunds and unused balances shall not be forfeited solely because an account is closed. A seller may offset a documented lawful debt after notice but shall not use an allegation of misconduct to confiscate unrelated purchased value without a reasonable process. These protections do not require a publisher to continue an expressive association it lawfully chooses to end.

SEC. 1605. LIVE EVENTS AND SPORTS PACKAGES.

(a) Information.—A package marketed for a team, league, season, or named event shall disclose material blackout rules, geographic restrictions, excluded games, required additional subscriptions, device limits, and whether schedule changes can affect access.

(b) Failure.—When a separately purchased live event is not delivered because of the seller's material failure, the customer shall receive an automatic refund or meaningful election of a substitute. A replay is not automatically equivalent to promised live access.

(c) Competition.—The Trade Commission and Department of Justice shall study fragmentation and exclusive distribution where evidence suggests market power or deception. This section does not guarantee every sporting event free of charge or override a valid copyright license. Any compulsory licensing proposal shall require separate legislation addressing compensation, rights, and constitutional limits.

SEC. 1606. RETRANSMISSION AND CARRIAGE DISPUTES.

(a) Notice.—A distributor and broadcaster shall provide accurate, timely information about a reasonably imminent carriage interruption, including affected programming and available lawful alternatives. Neither party shall falsely attribute the entire dispute to the other while concealing a material fact about its own conduct.

(b) Customer Credit.—A distributor shall provide a proportionate credit when a separately priced channel or material expressly promised component becomes unavailable for more than 24 hours because of a carriage dispute. The Commission shall establish a reasonable allocation method for bundled offerings.

(c) Bargaining.—Existing good-faith bargaining obligations remain applicable. The Commission may facilitate voluntary mediation and address a proven violation within its authority. This section does not compel agreement on a price, create a general compulsory license, or require distribution of programming without lawful rights. Emergency information shall remain subject to applicable continuity duties.

SEC. 1607. BUNDLES AND STANDALONE OPTIONS.

(a) Transparency.—A seller shall disclose the total bundle price, the role of each component, renewal changes, and the consequence of canceling one component. A discount shall not be advertised by comparing unlike service periods or hiding a required separate purchase.

(b) Choice.—Where a seller already offers a component separately, it shall make that option reasonably discoverable and shall not falsely state that purchase of the bundle is legally or technically required. This section does not require every service to be unbundled absent a separate competition order.

(c) Remedy.—If a component is materially discontinued, the customer may cancel the affected bundle without an early termination charge or accept a clearly priced replacement. The seller shall not use the change to restart a minimum term without affirmative consent. Competition concerns involving coercive tying are governed by title XVIII and antitrust law.

SEC. 1608. ADVERTISING LOAD AND INTERRUPTIONS.

(a) Disclosure.—A paid media plan containing advertising shall disclose its typical advertising load or an intelligible range, whether advertisements may interrupt content, and material exceptions for live events or sponsorships. A plan sold as advertising-free shall identify any limited promotional material included.

(b) Changes.—A material increase in advertising load during a prepaid fixed term shall be treated as a material service change unless clearly contemplated by a specific disclosed range. A vague reservation to change anything does not establish informed consent.

(c) Control.—A service shall provide accessible volume and playback controls and comply with applicable loudness and accessibility requirements. It shall not use intentionally misleading controls to cause accidental purchases or ad interactions. This section does not authorize government review of an advertisement's lawful viewpoint or require a numerical advertising limit for every expressive service.

SEC. 1609. GAMES VIRTUAL ITEMS AND PAID FEATURES.

(a) Terms.—A seller of a game, virtual item, downloadable feature, or in-game currency shall disclose the actual price, material use restrictions, expiration, transferability, and dependency on continuing server operation. Currency bundles shall not conceal the real cost of a purchase.

(b) Consent.—A charge shall require affirmative authorization through controls designed to distinguish a purchase from ordinary play. A minor's purchase shall be subject to the protections in title XX and applicable law. A seller shall provide a practical process for correcting unauthorized or accidental transactions.

(c) Closure.—Before ending essential server support, a seller shall provide reasonable notice and identify feasible offline, export, or refund options for specifically promised functions. It need not operate a game forever, disclose protected source code, or transfer intellectual property, but shall not retain payment through a materially false promise of continuing availability.

SEC. 1610. TICKETING TRANSPARENCY.

(a) Total Price.—A ticket offer shall display the total mandatory price at the first price presentation and throughout checkout. Optional insurance, delivery, or donations shall require separate choice. A seller shall identify whether it is the primary seller or a reseller.

(b) Inventory.—A seller shall not falsely imply that it possesses a ticket, conceal that an offer is speculative, or use a fictitious scarcity timer. Material seat, view, age, accessibility, and entry restrictions shall be disclosed before payment.

(c) Changes.—For a canceled event, the purchaser shall receive a prompt refund, including mandatory seller fees, unless the purchaser affirmatively chooses a credit. For a materially rescheduled event, the purchaser shall have a reasonable refund window. This section supplements existing Federal fee and ticketing law and does not authorize evasion of lawful anti-bot restrictions.

SEC. 1611. TICKET TRANSFER AND ACCESSIBILITY.

(a) Transfer.—A seller shall disclose transfer and resale restrictions before purchase. A restriction shall not be represented as an artist's requirement unless that representation is accurate. A customer shall have a practical means to transfer a legitimately transferable ticket without surrendering unrelated account information.

(b) Accessible Seating.—Accessible tickets shall be offered through comparably usable channels and shall not carry a surcharge solely because of accessibility. Verification may prevent misuse but shall not demand unnecessary medical information.

(c) Entry.—A venue requiring a mobile ticket shall provide a reasonable alternative for a purchaser lacking a compatible device or connectivity, with safeguards against duplication. Device failure at entry shall have a practical resolution process. Competition restrictions in exclusive ticketing, promotion, and venue arrangements remain subject to title XVIII and antitrust law.

SEC. 1612. IMPLEMENTATION AND CONSUMER RESEARCH.

(a) Date.—This title takes effect 18 months after enactment for new offers and renewals and 24 months after enactment for ongoing commercial practices. It does not retroactively alter a completed copyright transfer or authorize use beyond a lawful license.

(b) Research.—The Trade Commission shall study actual household media spending, cancellation friction, digital-purchase losses, event-delivery failures, and small-creator distribution costs. Research shall distinguish consumer preference for aggregation from support for a particular merger or mandatory bundle.

(c) Enforcement.—Rules shall focus on verifiable commercial representations and usable remedies. The agency shall coordinate with the Commission where cable or broadcast authority overlaps. Civil relief is provided in title XXVII; a service's lawful editorial decision alone does not establish a violation of this title.

SEC. 1613. TRIALS PROMOTIONS AND BUNDLED BILLING.

(a) Trial Terms.—Before a free or discounted trial begins, the seller shall disclose its duration, the amount and frequency of subsequent charges, material catalog or feature differences, and the cancellation method. Consent to the trial does not establish consent to an undisclosed additional service.

(b) Billing Responsibility.—Where an intermediary bills for a media subscription, the seller and intermediary shall identify which person receives cancellation requests and issues refunds. They may allocate responsibilities by agreement, but shall not leave the customer without an effective route because each directs the customer to the other.

(c) Bundle Changes.—Before removal of a material bundled component, the seller shall explain the continuing price and available choices under section 1602. A discount may lawfully depend on maintaining specified services if that condition was clearly disclosed. A seller shall not retroactively recapture a promotional discount through a fee that was absent from the agreed terms or materially misrepresented at enrollment.

SEC. 1614. DIGITAL LIBRARY CONTINUITY.

(a) Records.—A seller of individually purchased digital works shall provide a record identifying the work, date, price, relevant license terms, and account to which access is attached. Customers shall be able to retain the record outside the seller's application.

(b) Discontinuance.—When a seller plans to discontinue the system needed to access purchased works, it shall provide reasonable advance notice and available lawful alternatives, such as download, transfer to a successor service, or a proportionate refund where the promised access cannot be supplied. The remedy shall account for the representation made at purchase and the access already provided.

(c) Limits.—This section does not promise perpetual operation of every server or authorize circumvention of copyright protections. A seller shall not market an expiring or revocable license as permanent ownership while withholding the material limitation. A customer who lawfully downloaded a work shall not be required to delete it merely because an unrelated subscription ends, unless the download was expressly licensed only for that subscription period.

SEC. 1615. CANCELED POSTPONED AND MATERIALLY CHANGED EVENTS.

(a) Refund.—A commercial ticket seller shall provide a refund of the ticket price and mandatory seller-controlled fees when the event is canceled and the purchaser does not affirmatively accept a clearly described alternative. A seller may recover amounts from another responsible party without delaying a refund it owes to the purchaser.

(b) Material Change.—For a material postponement or relocation, the seller shall disclose the new terms and provide a reasonable period to request a refund when the change substantially defeats the purchased admission. An event's ordinary lineup variation shall not automatically be treated as cancellation unless a specific performance was materially represented as the object of the purchase.

(c) Process.—Refund eligibility, timing, and contact information shall be communicated directly where customer contact information is available. The seller shall not substitute a credit with restrictive expiration or resale conditions without informed agreement. A claim that the seller acted only as an intermediary shall not excuse its own misleading promise, retained fee, or failure to pass through a refund actually received for the purchaser.

TITLE XVII—CREATORS COMPENSATION AND DIGITAL IDENTITY

SEC. 1701. CREATOR CONTRACT TRANSPARENCY.

(a) Coverage.—This title applies to commercial agreements for distribution, monetization, or licensed use of an individual's creative work or performance in interstate commerce. It supplements copyright and labor law without determining employee status or transferring ownership by implication.

(b) Summary.—Before obtaining a material grant of rights from an individual creator, a commercial counterparty shall provide a concise summary identifying rights granted, territory, duration, exclusivity, compensation, recoupment, accounting, termination, and any authorization for a digital replica.

(c) Interpretation.—The summary does not replace the complete agreement but shall not materially contradict it. A broad reference to future technology shall not alone establish consent to synthesize a person's voice or likeness for an unrelated performance. A creator may obtain independent advice and shall not be told falsely that a nonnegotiable commercial preference is required by law.

SEC. 1702. EARNINGS STATEMENTS.

(a) Statement.—A person contractually responsible for paying creator royalties or revenue shares shall provide statements at least semiannually, or more frequently when the agreement requires. Statements shall identify the covered works, period, relevant usage or revenue, rate or formula, deductions, recoupment balance, and amount payable.

(b) Clarity.—A deduction shall be described sufficiently to permit verification and shall not be hidden within an unexplained net figure. Related-party transactions affecting compensation shall be identified, with confidential details available through an appropriate audit process.

(c) Payment.—Undisputed earned amounts shall be paid within the contractual period, which shall not be extended unilaterally after earnings accrue. A good-faith dispute over one work or deduction shall not justify withholding unrelated undisputed compensation. This section does not set a universal royalty rate or override a valid collective bargaining agreement providing equal or greater protection.

SEC. 1703. AUDIT AND CORRECTION RIGHTS.

(a) Audit.—An individual creator shall have a reasonable opportunity, no more than once annually absent evidence of material error, to examine records necessary to verify compensation through a qualified representative bound by confidentiality.

(b) Cost.—The creator ordinarily bears the audit cost, but the paying party shall reimburse reasonable cost when the audit establishes an underpayment exceeding five percent of the amount due for the audited period, or intentional misstatement. Smaller claims may use a streamlined document-review procedure.

(c) Correction.—An established underpayment shall be corrected with interest at the rate applicable to Federal civil judgments, unless a more protective lawful contract rate applies. Records shall be retained for at least six years after the relevant statement. A contract shall not shorten the period so severely that a creator cannot practically discover and challenge an error.

SEC. 1704. RIGHTS METADATA AND ATTRIBUTION.

(a) Records.—Commercial distributors shall preserve rights and attribution metadata reasonably necessary to identify creators, route compensation, and distinguish works, subject to technical feasibility and the rights holder's instructions.

(b) Correction.—A creator or authorized representative may submit a documented correction. The distributor shall acknowledge the request, investigate conflicting claims, and update verified errors without charging a prohibitive fee. A disputed ownership claim shall not be resolved solely by whichever claimant is commercially larger.

(c) Limits.—Metadata preservation does not establish ownership, eliminate fair use, or require public disclosure of private contact information. A distributor may use standardized identifiers but shall provide an accessible route for creators who lack an identifier. Intentional removal of legally protected rights-management information remains subject to title 17, United States Code.

SEC. 1705. UNMATCHED AND UNCLAIMED COMPENSATION.

(a) Diligence.—A commercial entity holding compensation because the entitled creator cannot be identified or located shall maintain reasonable matching efforts, searchable claim procedures, and records of the amount and source.

(b) Distribution.—This section does not alter statutory distribution rules governing the mechanical licensing collective or other legally established collectives. For compensation outside such a regime, a holder shall not transfer unclaimed sums to itself or favored partners before at least three years of reasonable identification efforts and compliance with applicable unclaimed-property law.

(c) Claims.—A later claimant shall have a practical means to establish entitlement and contest rejection. Verification shall prevent fraud without requiring an independent creator to obtain expensive documentation unrelated to ownership. The Trade Commission, in consultation with the Copyright Office, shall report on gaps and recommend targeted amendments rather than treating all music, performance, and audiovisual rights as one interchangeable royalty.

SEC. 1706. COLLECTIVE REPRESENTATION AND LABOR RIGHTS.

(a) Savings.—Nothing in this Act narrows rights under labor law, lawful collective bargaining, antitrust exemptions, or protections against retaliation. Classification of a worker shall be determined under the applicable statute, not by a contract's use of the word creator or partner.

(b) Information.—A platform or distributor shall not misrepresent a creator's legal ability to consult counsel, join a lawful association, discuss compensation where protected by law, or report an alleged violation.

(c) Study.—The Secretary of Labor and Attorney General shall study barriers faced by independent creative workers, including bargaining imbalance, delayed payment, and classification uncertainty. A recommendation to permit collective negotiation by otherwise independent businesses shall identify the necessary antitrust boundaries and consumer safeguards. This section does not create a broad new cartel exemption by implication.

SEC. 1707. UNAUTHORIZED DIGITAL REPLICAS.

(a) Right.—An individual has a civil right against knowing commercial creation or distribution of a materially realistic digital replica of that individual's voice or visual likeness, without authorization, where a reasonable person would understand the replica as an authentic performance or endorsement by the individual.

(b) Definitions.—A digital replica is electronically generated or materially altered audio or visual material depicting an identifiable individual performing or speaking words the individual did not actually perform or speak. Ordinary editing that does not materially misrepresent a performance is excluded.

(c) Exceptions.—Liability does not attach to news reporting, documentary use, criticism, commentary, scholarship, parody, satire, or other constitutionally protected expression when the use is reasonably related to that purpose and is not a materially deceptive commercial endorsement. A conspicuous disclosure is relevant but not conclusive where the overall use remains deceptive.

(d) Relief.—An injured individual may seek actual damages, attributable profits without double recovery, and appropriately tailored injunctive relief in Federal district court. Statutory damages of $1,000 to $50,000 per substantially distinct replica may be awarded for knowing violation, subject to proportionality and title XXVII. Repeated views of one replica are not separate violations.

SEC. 1708. DIGITAL REPLICA AUTHORIZATION.

(a) Consent.—Authorization shall be in a signed writing or authenticated electronic record identifying the individual, permitted uses, duration, compensation, and whether sublicensing is allowed. An authorization for one production does not permit unrelated political, sexual, or commercial uses.

(b) Duration.—For an individual acting outside a collective bargaining agreement, an exclusive authorization shall not exceed five years without a renewed, separate agreement supported by consideration. A nonexclusive authorization for continued distribution of a completed authorized work may last for the agreed distribution period.

(c) Minors.—A minor's authorization shall require the protections applicable to child-performer contracts under State law, including court approval where required. A guardian may not grant an unlimited perpetual right to fabricate future performances. This section does not disturb lawful archival distribution of an actual performance or permit a person to revoke another's independently established copyright merely because the work depicts that person.

SEC. 1709. HOSTING SERVICES AND REPLICA NOTICES.

(a) Notice.—A hosting service receiving a sufficiently specific notice of an allegedly unauthorized replica shall provide a prompt, accessible process to assess the notice and notify the uploader where safe and lawful. The notice shall identify the material, claimant, asserted right, and good-faith basis, with a declaration of accuracy.

(b) Safe Harbor.—A service shall not be liable for monetary relief under section 1707 solely for third-party hosting if the service does not materially participate in creating the unlawful replica, complies with section 1713, and either lacks actual knowledge of the material's illegality or acts expeditiously upon acquiring that knowledge. It shall provide a counter-notice process and restore disputed lawful material after a reasonable period unless the claimant seeks judicial relief, subject to urgent safety exceptions.

(c) Abuse.—Knowingly material misrepresentation in a notice or counter-notice causing injury is actionable for actual damages and reasonable costs. No general monitoring duty is created.

(d) Express Relationship.—Section 230 shall not bar the narrowly defined claim under sections 1707 through 1709, subject to this safe harbor. Section 3003 supplies the conforming amendment. Other claims and immunities remain governed by their own terms.

SEC. 1710. GENERATIVE SYSTEMS AND CREATIVE WORKS.

(a) Disclosure.—A distributor commercially presenting a materially synthetic performance as an authentic human performance shall disclose that fact when omission would materially mislead a reasonable purchaser. The disclosure shall describe the relevant synthetic feature without requiring a creator to reveal every production tool.

(b) Rights.—Nothing in this Act resolves whether a particular training use is fair use, creates copyright in material lacking human authorship, or grants a compulsory license for training. Those questions remain governed by title 17 and applicable judicial decisions.

(c) Contracts.—A commercial agreement seeking permission to use a creator's work to train a generative system shall identify that use separately from ordinary distribution and shall state any compensation and sublicensing terms. A platform shall not retroactively claim such permission through an obscure change to general terms when the original agreement did not reasonably authorize it.

SEC. 1711. INDEPENDENT DISTRIBUTION AND DISCOVERY.

(a) Commercial Terms.—A distributor offering paid promotional placement to creators shall disclose the charge, placement method, material limitations, and whether the payment affects royalty calculations. It shall not describe paid placement as an independent editorial recommendation.

(b) No Guaranteed Ranking.—This section does not entitle a creator to recommendation, playlist inclusion, catalog acquisition, or a particular ranking. It prohibits deceptive commercial promises and undisclosed self-dealing in a paid service.

(c) Portability.—Creators may export their own works and earnings records under title VIII. A distributor shall not withhold undisputed earned compensation to compel acceptance of new exclusive rights. Competition complaints involving coercive exclusivity, discriminatory commercial access, or retaliation shall be evaluated under title XVIII without converting every editorial selection into an antitrust violation.

SEC. 1712. IMPLEMENTATION AND LIMITS.

(a) Administration.—The Trade Commission shall administer commercial transparency and payment provisions, in consultation with the Copyright Office and Secretary of Labor. Federal courts shall adjudicate the replica right. The Copyright Office may provide technical advice but shall not adjudicate damages under this title.

(b) Effective Date.—The title applies to agreements entered into or materially renewed 18 months after enactment and to prohibited replica conduct occurring after that date. Existing completed works and licenses remain subject to their lawful terms, except for prospective commercial misrepresentation.

(c) Review.—Within four years, the Comptroller General shall assess payment accuracy, notice abuse, effects on independent creators, and burdens on lawful expression. The review shall distinguish protection of identity from ownership of style, ideas, or a genre. No person obtains an exclusive right in a general artistic style through this title.

SEC. 1713. REPLICA NOTICE AND COUNTER NOTICE PROCEDURE.

(a) Valid Notice.—A notice under section 1709 shall identify the claimed individual, the specific material and its reasonably locatable address, the asserted lack of authorization, contact information for lawful process, and a statement made under penalty of perjury that the factual assertions are accurate to the claimant's knowledge. A representative shall identify the basis of authority.

(b) Timing.—A service seeking the hosting safe harbor shall acknowledge a complete notice within three business days and ordinarily remove or disable the specifically identified material within five business days after determining that the notice establishes an apparent violation. It shall promptly inform the uploader, subject to a documented safety or legal restriction.

(c) Counter Notice.—An uploader may submit a signed counter-notice identifying authorization, mistaken identity, or an applicable exception, with contact information and consent to service in a competent United States court. The service shall forward the counter-notice and restore the material between ten and fourteen business days afterward unless it receives evidence that the claimant has sought a court order concerning the identified material. A court order controls, and this schedule does not override a separate lawful safety duty or the service's independent editorial discretion to decline hosting.

SEC. 1714. SCOPE OF THE PERSONAL IDENTITY RIGHT.

(a) Holder.—The Federal right in section 1707 belongs to the depicted living individual and may be enforced by a legally authorized representative on that individual's behalf. It is not a transferable ownership right in a voice, face, artistic style, or ordinary biographical fact.

(b) Survival.—A claim arising from conduct during the individual's life survives to the estate under ordinary procedural rules. This Act does not create a new Federal postmortem right for conduct first occurring after death. Otherwise applicable State rights remain subject to their own scope and constitutional limitations.

(c) Commercial Element.—A use does not become a deceptive commercial endorsement merely because a lawful expressive work is sold or supported by advertising. The claimant must establish the elements of section 1707 in context. Newsworthiness is not defeated solely because reporting is critical or unwelcome. An injunction shall identify the unlawful use with specificity and shall not prohibit every future depiction of an individual or lawful discussion of the underlying controversy.

SEC. 1715. CREATOR PAYMENTS AND INSOLVENCY RISK DISCLOSURE.

(a) Terms.—A commercial distributor holding accrued creator earnings shall disclose the ordinary payment schedule, threshold, permitted reserves, and circumstances in which funds may be withheld. A reserve shall reflect a documented risk, such as refunds or a genuine rights dispute, and shall be reviewed periodically.

(b) Reconciliation.—When the basis for a reserve ends, the undisputed amount shall be released within the next ordinary payment cycle. A distributor shall not increase a reserve retroactively to finance unrelated operations or compel a creator to accept broader rights terms.

(c) Financial Status.—If the arrangement does not segregate creator funds from the distributor's general assets, that fact shall be disclosed before the creator materially commits earnings to the arrangement. This subsection does not create a trust, alter bankruptcy priorities, or guarantee payment from an insolvent enterprise. Knowingly misleading a creator about segregation, insurance, or creditor priority is prohibited. Records shall permit identification of accrued obligations if control of the distribution business changes.

TITLE XVIII—COMPETITION AND FAIR COMMERCIAL ACCESS

SEC. 1801. ANTITRUST SAVINGS AND COORDINATION.

(a) Savings.—The Sherman Act, Clayton Act, Federal Trade Commission Act, and other antitrust laws remain applicable. A license, grant, certification, or regulatory approval under this Act does not confer immunity from those laws.

(b) Coordination.—The Commission, Trade Commission, and Attorney General shall coordinate review of communications and media markets, share information as lawfully permitted, and avoid inconsistent factual demands. Each shall identify its own legal standard and authority.

(c) Limits.—Size, success, possession of intellectual property, or unpopular expression alone does not establish unlawful market power or exclusion. Enforcement shall identify a relevant market or other legally sufficient competitive framework, conduct, effects, and an authorized remedy. This title shall not be used to regulate an editorial viewpoint under the label of competition.

SEC. 1802. TARGETED BOTTLENECK DESIGNATION.

(a) Designation.—After notice and an evidentiary hearing opportunity, the Commission may designate a connectivity facility as an essential bottleneck when the owner has durable substantial market power, duplication is not reasonably feasible, denial of access materially impairs competition, and a targeted remedy is likely to produce net consumer benefit.

(b) Evidence.—The analysis shall consider actual alternatives, capacity, cost, entry prospects, investment incentives, geographic conditions, and the effect of public financing. A facility shall not be designated merely because a competitor would prefer cheaper access.

(c) Duration.—A designation shall last no more than five years without renewed findings and shall identify the particular facility and conduct. It shall not automatically extend to unrelated assets or all activities of the owner. Judicial review shall be available under title XXVII, including review of compensation and constitutional claims.

SEC. 1803. WHOLESALE REMEDIES.

(a) Terms.—For a designated bottleneck, the Commission may require reasonable, nondiscriminatory access, technical information, service-level equivalence, and a dispute process. The order shall identify the problem each requirement remedies.

(b) Price.—Rates shall permit recovery of efficiently incurred costs and a reasonable return, account for risk and unreimbursed capital, and avoid double recovery of publicly financed investment. The Commission shall consider negotiated benchmarks and less intrusive remedies before imposing a rate.

(c) Investment.—An order shall address capacity expansion, maintenance, congestion, credit risk, and responsibility for damage. It shall not require unlimited expansion without a lawful cost-recovery mechanism. A requesting party shall satisfy objective technical and financial requirements. The Commission may terminate or narrow the remedy when effective competition develops or when evidence shows the remedy is causing material harm disproportionate to its benefits.

SEC. 1804. DISCRIMINATORY SELF PREFERENCING.

(a) Covered Conduct.—A vertically integrated provider controlling a connectivity facility designated under section 1802 shall not materially disadvantage a competing downstream service through discriminatory technical access, hidden fees, delayed provisioning, or use of confidential rival information when the conduct is reasonably likely to substantially lessen competition.

(b) Justification.—The provider may demonstrate a legitimate security, quality, efficiency, or integration justification. The agency shall evaluate whether a reasonably available less restrictive method would achieve that objective and shall account for benefits to consumers.

(c) Expression.—A publisher's selection, ranking, or recommendation of lawful expressive content is not subject to a compelled-neutrality obligation under this section. Paid commercial infrastructure, billing, and noneditorial access may be examined on their own facts. An enforcement action shall not collapse these distinct functions merely because one enterprise performs both.

SEC. 1805. EXCLUSIVITY AND MOST FAVORED TERMS.

(a) Review.—The Trade Commission and Attorney General may challenge an exclusive distribution, ticketing, advertising, or platform agreement under applicable competition law when it materially forecloses rivals or suppresses entry without sufficient justification.

(b) Evidence.—Review shall consider duration, market coverage, switching cost, alternative channels, investment supported by the agreement, and practical ability to terminate. An exclusive right necessary to finance a particular creative work shall not be presumed unlawful solely because it is exclusive.

(c) Remedy.—A remedy may limit duration, prohibit retaliation, require a practical exit, or address a coercive condition. It shall be tailored to the proven competitive harm and shall not compel a copyright license without specific authority. A most-favored-nation clause shall be evaluated for whether it protects a legitimate bargain or prevents lower prices and innovative distribution elsewhere.

SEC. 1806. MERGER REMEDY VIABILITY.

(a) Review.—When an agency accepts a divestiture or behavioral commitment in a communications or media transaction, it shall assess whether the remedy creates a viable independent competitor or otherwise addresses the identified harm.

(b) Conditions.—A divestiture plan shall identify assets, personnel, financing, intellectual-property rights, transitional services, and the purchaser's ability to operate without continuing decisive control by the seller. A remedy shall not rely on an unqualified buyer whose principal function is to make the transaction appear less concentrated.

(c) Monitoring.—Material commitments shall have measurable milestones, a monitor where appropriate, and consequences for failure. Agencies shall publish nonconfidential compliance reports. A failure shall permit the remedies lawfully reserved in the order; it shall not automatically authorize reopening every aspect of a final judgment without the required judicial process.

SEC. 1807. ADVERTISING MARKET CONFLICTS.

(a) Disclosure.—An advertising intermediary acting for a buyer or seller shall disclose material ownership interests and roles in the transaction, including whether it operates an exchange, competes as a bidder, or sells its own inventory.

(b) Duty.—A person contractually acting as an agent shall honor that role, protect confidential client information, and disclose material conflicts. It shall not secretly use a client's bid information to favor an affiliated seller or manipulate an auction contrary to represented rules.

(c) Structure.—The Trade Commission and Attorney General may seek structural relief when authorized by antitrust law and supported by the evidence. This section does not mandate universal separation of every advertising function. A proposed remedy shall consider measurement, fraud prevention, small-advertiser access, and whether a less restrictive enforceable measure would adequately address the harm.

SEC. 1808. TICKETING AND VENUE ACCESS.

(a) Conduct.—A dominant ticketing or promotion enterprise shall not use unlawful retaliation, coercive tying, or exclusionary control of essential venue access to prevent artists, venues, or consumers from using a competing service.

(b) Data.—Contracts shall clearly allocate access to event sales and settlement data necessary for an artist or venue to verify compensation and performance. Personal attendee information shall be shared only with lawful authority and appropriate privacy protection.

(c) Review.—An exclusivity restriction shall be evaluated under section 1805. A lawful security or fraud-control requirement may be maintained if applied objectively and not used as a pretext for exclusion. No provision adjudicates liability in a pending case or modifies an existing consent decree without the court process required by law.

SEC. 1809. RETALIATION AGAINST COMMERCIAL COMPLAINANTS.

(a) Prohibition.—A covered provider or intermediary shall not terminate, materially worsen, or threaten a commercial relationship because a person in good faith reported a suspected violation to an agency, participated in an investigation, or exercised a statutory audit or portability right.

(b) Legitimate Action.—A provider may act for a documented independent reason, including nonpayment, fraud, security, or material contract breach. It shall not fabricate such a reason after learning of the protected activity.

(c) Remedy.—A court may order restoration of a commercial account or terms where necessary and constitutionally permissible, compensate proven loss, and enjoin retaliation. Relief shall not compel an expressive publisher to endorse or recommend the complainant's content. The distinction between commercial administration and editorial association shall be addressed expressly in the order.

SEC. 1810. MARKET STUDIES AND INFORMATION.

(a) Studies.—Agencies may conduct market studies concerning connectivity, media distribution, advertising, ticketing, and creator compensation within their jurisdiction. A demand for information shall be relevant, proportionate, and subject to review.

(b) Publication.—Studies shall publish methods, aggregate findings, and limitations while protecting confidential business and personal information. An allegation contained in a submission shall not be reported as an adjudicated fact.

(c) Burden.—Agencies shall coordinate requests, use existing reliable data, and provide reasonable time for smaller entities. A study shall not impose a de facto licensing requirement or require a person to justify lawful speech. Findings may inform legislation or enforcement but do not independently create binding obligations beyond those authorized by statute.

SEC. 1811. INTERIM PROTECTION AND DUE PROCESS.

(a) Relief.—An agency may seek a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction in Federal district court to prevent substantial threatened competitive harm under the standards otherwise applicable to the claim. This Act does not dispense with proof of the elements required for such relief.

(b) Administrative Orders.—A temporary administrative access order within express Commission authority shall provide notice, a prompt hearing opportunity, a defined duration, and judicial review. Monetary penalties shall be imposed only through title XXVII.

(c) Security.—A court may require security and safeguards appropriate to the risk of an erroneous order. Relief shall preserve legitimate security controls and protect confidential information. The prospect of a future market study is not sufficient justification for indefinite compulsory access or restraint of a transaction.

SEC. 1812. PERIODIC REMEDY REVIEW.

(a) Review.—Every continuing remedy under this title shall identify a review date and measurable conditions for modification or termination. The reviewing agency shall consider entry, price, quality, investment, innovation, and unintended effects on smaller firms.

(b) Continuation.—A remedy may continue when the original harm or a materially related risk persists and the remedy remains proportionate. It shall not become permanent solely because regulated persons have adapted to it.

(c) Savings.—Expiration of a particular remedy does not legalize fraud, unlawful discrimination, or conduct independently prohibited by antitrust law. A recommendation for new structural legislation shall explain the evidence, affected rights, transition cost, and alternative approaches. Congress retains responsibility for policy choices beyond the agencies' express delegated authority.

SEC. 1813. BOTTLENECK DESIGNATION PROCEDURE.

(a) Petition.—A person requesting designation under section 1802 shall identify the market, connectivity facility, alleged durable control, evidence of entry barriers, proposed remedy, and expected effect on investment and consumers. A conclusory claim that a firm is large is insufficient.

(b) Record.—The Commission shall provide notice to the affected person, an opportunity to submit economic and technical evidence, and appropriate access to nonconfidential material. It shall examine feasible substitutes, likely entry, contractual alternatives, capacity constraints, and whether another remedy would address the demonstrated harm with less burden.

(c) Order.—A designation order shall state its geographic and functional scope, duration, review conditions, and the connection between each required obligation and the findings. It shall not designate an entire corporate group where the evidence concerns a separable facility or function. A material change in market conditions may support modification or termination through an expedited petition. The petitioner and regulated person remain entitled to the judicial review provided by title XXVII.

SEC. 1814. WHOLESALE QUALITY AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION.

(a) Equivalence.—Where a lawful order requires wholesale access, the obligated provider shall disclose the technical interface, ordering process, maintenance standard, outage information, and service-level commitments necessary for practical use. It shall not defeat access through avoidable delays or undisclosed degradation while providing materially better equivalent inputs to its own retail operation.

(b) Costs.—Rates and charges shall be established under the applicable order using relevant cost, risk, capacity, and reasonable-return evidence. Access does not require free use, uncompensated expansion, or disclosure of unrelated proprietary systems.

(c) Disputes.—The administering authority shall provide a prompt process for disputes concerning an existing access obligation, including proportionate interim relief when authorized. The process shall distinguish a contractual disagreement from violation of an enforceable public duty. A small entrant's dependence on a facility shall not excuse unsafe installation or nonpayment of an undisputed lawful charge, and an incumbent's billing dispute shall not justify unnecessary interruption of end users who can be protected through escrow or another reasonable arrangement.

SEC. 1815. COMPETITION REMEDY MONITORING.

(a) Measures.—An order imposing a competition remedy shall identify observable outcomes, responsible reporting, a review date, and conditions for modification. Measures shall include practical entry, price, quality, switching, and service availability as relevant, rather than merely the execution of a divestiture document.

(b) Monitors.—A required independent monitor shall have a defined mandate, conflict safeguards, proportionate access, confidentiality duties, and a reasonable budget. The monitor may report noncompliance but shall not exercise unsupervised governmental power or alter the remedy by private agreement.

(c) Exit.—A remedy shall be reduced or terminated when its statutory basis no longer exists, through a reasoned decision accounting for reliance and transition. Failure of a remedy shall prompt examination of its design, compliance, and market assumptions. An agency shall not perpetuate a demonstrably ineffective measure solely because it is administratively familiar, or remove a necessary measure solely because the regulated person has complied while the measure was in force.

TITLE XIX—ADVERTISING MEASUREMENT AND COMMERCIAL TRUST

SEC. 1901. COMMERCIAL ADVERTISING TRANSPARENCY.

(a) Identification.—A paid advertisement shall be reasonably identifiable as advertising, and a materially sponsored endorsement shall disclose the commercial relationship when omission would mislead a reasonable audience member. The form of disclosure shall fit the medium and be accessible.

(b) Responsibility.—Advertisers, publishers, and intermediaries are responsible for their own representations and conduct according to their knowledge and control. This title does not impose strict liability on an ordinary publisher for every false statement by an unrelated advertiser.

(c) Expression.—Requirements concern the commercial nature and source of a paid placement, not government approval of its viewpoint. Political-advertising obligations established by other law remain applicable. A factual sponsorship disclosure shall not be expanded into a requirement to repeat an official judgment about the merits of a product or political position.

SEC. 1902. ADVERTISER VERIFICATION AND IMPERSONATION.

(a) Risk Based Verification.—A large advertising platform shall use reasonable measures to verify the identity and payment authority of commercial advertisers presenting elevated fraud risk, including impersonation of government, financial institutions, established brands, or known individuals.

(b) Response.—Upon credible notice of a materially deceptive impersonation advertisement, the platform shall promptly assess the notice, preserve relevant transaction evidence, and take appropriate action within its control. It shall provide a correction route for wrongly restricted legitimate advertisers.

(c) Limits.—Verification shall minimize personal data, protect small advertisers from unnecessary barriers, and avoid requiring public disclosure of private residential addresses. General awareness that fraud exists does not establish knowledge of every unlawful advertisement. Liability shall be based on the platform's own failure to perform an expressly applicable duty, subject to title XXIII and section 230 as amended only to the extent expressly stated.

SEC. 1903. CAMPAIGN TERMS AND EXPENDITURE CONTROL.

(a) Terms.—Before accepting a campaign, a seller shall disclose the charging event, budget, bidding method, material optimization objective, refund conditions, and whether delivery may occur on third-party inventory. Terms shall distinguish impressions, views, clicks, leads, attributed conversions, and verified transactions.

(b) Control.—An advertiser shall be able to set a binding maximum expenditure and pause future delivery. The seller shall disclose a reasonable processing interval and reimburse charges caused by failure to honor the limit or timely pause instruction.

(c) Changes.—A material change in billing method or inventory scope requires notice and, when it increases authorized spending or risk, affirmative consent. An automated recommendation is not authorization to raise a budget. A seller shall not design a control so that a reasonable advertiser unintentionally opts into recurring expansion of spending.

SEC. 1904. MEASUREMENT DEFINITIONS.

(a) Accuracy.—A measurement seller shall describe the event measured, counting method, attribution window, deduplication, modeled share, known limitations, and material changes in methodology. A modeled estimate shall be identified as such.

(b) Claims.—A claim of incremental impact shall have a reasonable basis in an appropriate experimental or causal method. Correlation, last-touch assignment, or a platform's internal attribution model shall not be represented as proof that the advertisement caused every credited sale.

(c) Comparability.—The Trade Commission may establish common disclosure terminology and require correction of materially misleading metrics. It shall not mandate one commercial measurement model for all media. Standards shall permit independent verification, protect privacy, and account for differences among channels, devices, and campaign objectives.

SEC. 1905. INVALID TRAFFIC AND DELIVERY FRAUD.

(a) Duty.—A seller shall use reasonable measures to detect and exclude known bots, fabricated engagement, unauthorized placements, and other invalid traffic from billable delivery when the seller represents that such delivery reaches real users under specified conditions.

(b) Correction.—When material invalid delivery is confirmed, the seller shall notify affected advertisers and provide a refund or credit at the advertiser's election for the undelivered value. A seller shall not conceal an error by silently revising historical reports without an audit trail.

(c) Evidence.—The advertiser shall receive sufficient information to understand the correction, subject to protection of fraud-detection methods and other users. A disputed claim may be reviewed by an independent assessor. The existence of sophisticated fraud does not establish strict liability for every undetected event, but deliberate blindness or knowingly billing invalid traffic violates this section.

SEC. 1906. AUCTION AND INTERMEDIARY FEES.

(a) Disclosure.—An intermediary shall disclose its material fees, whether it retains a spread, the principal auction method, and conflicts arising from affiliated buying, selling, or exchange operations. A contractual promise to act solely for a client shall be honored.

(b) Fair Process.—An operator shall not secretly alter auction rules, use confidential bids to favor an affiliate, fabricate competing bids, or misrepresent the price paid to a publisher. Legitimate quality and fraud adjustments shall be documented and consistently applied.

(c) Audit.—Large intermediaries shall permit qualified independent examination of material auction and fee practices under confidentiality safeguards. Public summaries shall identify the scope and principal findings. An audit shall not require disclosure of individual users' browsing histories when aggregate or controlled methods can establish compliance.

SEC. 1907. PRIVACY PRESERVING MEASUREMENT.

(a) Permitted Methods.—Aggregate measurement, contextual analysis, controlled experimentation, and other methods designed to avoid individual cross-context profiling may be used consistent with title XIII. A claim that information is anonymous shall have a reasonable technical basis.

(b) Limits.—A measurement purpose does not authorize collection of sensitive information unrelated to the campaign, indefinite retention, or reidentification of an aggregate dataset. An intermediary shall not combine separate clients' information for its own commercial profiles without lawful authority.

(c) Small Advertisers.—The Trade Commission and NIST shall provide guidance on practical privacy-preserving methods accessible to smaller advertisers. Guidance shall distinguish legal requirements from recommended practices and shall not require purchase of a favored product. A privacy choice shall not be represented as incompatible with all useful measurement when less intrusive alternatives are reasonably available.

SEC. 1908. SENSITIVE TARGETING AND DISCRIMINATION.

(a) Prohibition.—An advertiser or intermediary shall not use covered sensitive information to facilitate discrimination prohibited by law in housing, employment, credit, or another protected opportunity. A platform shall provide reasonable controls and investigate credible evidence that its own delivery system defeats those controls.

(b) Evidence.—Enforcement shall examine the actual objective, data, delivery, and effects, and shall distinguish unlawful exclusion from a lawful campaign directed to a relevant audience. A statistical difference alone does not establish every element of a civil-rights claim.

(c) Choice.—Political, health, religious, and sexuality-related inferences shall receive the protections in title XIII. Contextual placement next to relevant lawful content is not automatically equivalent to building a persistent sensitive profile. Rules shall preserve that distinction and shall not prohibit protected advocacy merely because it addresses a sensitive subject.

SEC. 1909. MINORS AND ADVERTISING.

(a) Prohibition.—A covered entity shall not direct behavioral advertising to a person it knows is under 18 using cross-context profiles or sensitive information. Contextual advertising appropriate to the immediate service remains permitted, subject to consumer-protection and child-privacy law.

(b) Knowledge.—Actual knowledge includes reliable age information supplied in the ordinary course and circumstances in which an entity deliberately avoids confirming a known minor status. This section does not require universal collection of identity documents or inference of age from sensitive traits.

(c) Design.—Purchase and sponsorship disclosures directed to children shall be understandable in context. A paid endorsement shall not be disguised as independent personal advice. An entity shall not use a minor's vulnerability or private communications to pressure a purchase. Rules shall focus on commercial conduct and shall not establish a government-approved list of permissible ideas for minors.

SEC. 1910. ADVERTISING COMPLAINTS AND ACCOUNT REVIEW.

(a) Process.—Large platforms shall provide an accessible process for reporting fraudulent advertisements, unauthorized spending, and material account errors. A report shall receive acknowledgment and a meaningful status or decision within a reasonable period tied to risk.

(b) Appeal.—A legitimate advertiser whose account is restricted shall receive the commercial basis for the decision and an opportunity to correct a factual error, except where disclosure would materially aid fraud or violate law. Undisputed prepaid balances shall be returned promptly after lawful offsets.

(c) Editorial Rights.—Review of account administration does not require a publisher to accept an advertisement it lawfully declines. A publisher may maintain content standards and brand preferences, but shall not retain payment for an advertisement it refuses to deliver or misrepresent a commercial suspension as legally compelled when it is not.

SEC. 1911. RECORDS AND INDEPENDENT ACCESS.

(a) Retention.—A large advertising intermediary shall retain transaction and methodology records reasonably necessary to verify billing and investigate fraud for three years, using minimization and separation from personal browsing data. Longer retention requires a documented legal or operational need.

(b) Access.—An advertiser or publisher may obtain its own transaction records and aggregate performance data in a usable format. The intermediary may protect other parties' confidential information and security methods through redaction or controlled access.

(c) Research.—Qualified public-interest research may receive privacy-protective aggregate data under voluntary agreements or lawful agency process. No researcher obtains unrestricted access to personal data or proprietary systems through this section. Agencies shall evaluate whether reporting can expose systemic fraud and discrimination without creating new surveillance infrastructure.

SEC. 1912. ADMINISTRATION AND REMEDIES.

(a) Agency.—The Trade Commission shall administer this title through express rulemaking authority under section 553 of title 5. Rules shall define materiality, risk-based verification, and proportionate obligations for smaller intermediaries.

(b) Relief.—Restitution shall return charges for unauthorized or materially undelivered advertising. Civil penalties require the process and standards in title XXVII. A customer shall not recover twice for the same loss under overlapping contract and statutory theories.

(c) Review.—Every three years, the Trade Commission shall assess fraud losses, fee transparency, small-advertiser access, privacy effects, and measurement reliability. It shall distinguish adoption of a disclosure from evidence that the disclosure improves decisions. Recommendations for structural market changes shall be supported by competitive analysis and shall not be implemented through an unrelated consumer-disclosure rule.

SEC. 1913. LARGE ADVERTISING SERVICES AND THRESHOLDS.

(a) Definition.—For this title, a large advertising service is an advertising intermediary or advertising platform that, together with controlled affiliates, receives at least $100,000,000 in annual United States revenue from the covered advertising function or delivers paid advertising to at least 10,000,000 active United States users in an average month over the preceding six months.

(b) Application.—A reference in this title to a large advertising platform or large intermediary uses this definition. Ordinary advertisers do not become intermediaries merely because they purchase advertising for their own goods. Threshold-specific verification and independent-access duties apply after the transition in section 113.

(c) Baseline.—Smaller services remain subject to duties against deceptive pricing, unauthorized expenditure, material misrepresentation, unlawful sensitive targeting, and failure to return money owed. The Trade Commission shall permit proportionate methods of compliance and shared verification services without treating an industry certification as conclusive proof. A service may not evade a threshold by artificially dividing one controlled advertising operation among nominally separate sellers.

SEC. 1914. CAMPAIGN RECONCILIATION AND EVIDENCE.

(a) Statement.—After a campaign ends or at least monthly for a continuing campaign, an intermediary shall provide the advertiser a statement showing authorized budget, amount spent, material fees, purchased units, delivered units, and known adjustments for invalid traffic or undelivered service.

(b) Dispute.—A small advertiser may contest a material discrepancy within 120 days after receiving sufficient information to identify it. The intermediary shall acknowledge the dispute within five business days and ordinarily provide a reasoned determination within 30 days. A documented complex review may receive one additional 30-day period with explanation.

(c) Records.—The intermediary shall provide information reasonably necessary to verify the disputed transaction, using aggregation or a qualified confidential reviewer where direct disclosure would expose protected data. A vague assertion of proprietary measurement shall not excuse refusal to explain what was sold and charged. Conversely, an advertiser is not entitled to another customer's identity or a system's entire source code merely because a campaign performed poorly.

SEC. 1915. PAID ENDORSEMENTS AND SYNTHETIC TESTIMONIALS.

(a) Material Connection.—A covered seller or intermediary presenting a paid endorsement shall disclose a material commercial connection when omission would mislead a reasonable audience about the endorsement's independence. The disclosure shall be understandable in the medium used and reasonably close to the endorsement.

(b) Authenticity.—A person shall not fabricate a testimonial by a nonexistent customer or falsely attribute a statement to an identifiable individual in order to induce a commercial transaction. A dramatization may be used if its nature is clear and it does not falsely represent actual experience, results, or authorization.

(c) Limits.—This section concerns deceptive commercial representations. It does not require a disclosure for every ordinary fictional character, artistic performance, satire, or unsolicited personal opinion. Existing endorsement, advertising, and consumer-protection law remains applicable. The Trade Commission shall coordinate guidance so that a small business can identify the material disclosure without being required to use a single favored phrase, technology vendor, or certification service.

TITLE XX—CHILDREN FAMILIES AND DIGITAL EDUCATION

SEC. 2001. CHILDREN'S COMMERCIAL PROTECTION.

(a) Purpose And Scope.—This title protects minors from specified commercial exploitation, unauthorized purchases, and misuse of personal information while preserving lawful access to expression, education, health information, and community participation.

(b) No General Censorship Duty.—No provision creates a general duty to prevent exposure to ideas an official considers harmful, requires viewpoint-based moderation, or authorizes an agency to establish a list of approved beliefs. Duties shall be tied to the defined commercial or data practice.

(c) Existing Law.—The Children's Online Privacy Protection Act and other applicable protections remain in force. This title supplements those protections where expressly stated and does not reduce their coverage. A person shall not infer that compliance with this title excuses an independent violation concerning child sexual exploitation, unlawful threats, consumer fraud, or disability access.

SEC. 2002. PRIVACY BY DEFAULT.

(a) Settings.—For an account known to belong to a minor, a covered service shall default to the more protective available settings for public exposure of precise location, unsolicited commercial contact, cross-context tracking, and commercial disclosure of personal information.

(b) Explanation.—Settings shall be explained in age-appropriate language and shall not be reversed through a misleading interface. A change shall require an affirmative act appropriate to the user's age and applicable parental-consent law.

(c) Limits.—A service need not collect additional sensitive information merely to determine age. Reliable information already supplied may be used proportionately, and deliberate evasion of known minor status is prohibited. Privacy defaults shall not prevent access to lawful information concerning health, identity, religion, or civic participation solely because an official or advertiser objects to that information.

SEC. 2003. AGE ASSURANCE MINIMIZATION.

(a) Principle.—When age assurance is legally required for a particular function, the method shall collect no more information than necessary, minimize retention, and avoid disclosing identity to the content provider when a reliable age-range confirmation is sufficient.

(b) Alternatives.—The Trade Commission shall evaluate privacy-preserving methods, error rates, accessibility, security, and risks to persons lacking conventional identification. A universal government-identity upload shall not be required under this Act for ordinary access to lawful general-audience media.

(c) Use.—Information collected for age assurance shall not be used for advertising, unrelated profiling, or sale. A provider shall offer correction of a mistaken determination and a safe deletion process. This section does not invalidate a separate age-verification law otherwise constitutionally enforceable, but it establishes privacy duties for covered entities using such systems within this Act's scope.

SEC. 2004. PARENTAL AND YOUTH CONTROLS.

(a) Controls.—Covered services shall offer understandable controls for purchases, contact permissions, time reminders, and privacy settings appropriate to the service. Controls shall be optional except where another law requires parental authorization.

(b) Safety.—A control shall not automatically disclose a minor's sensitive communications, health inquiries, or precise location to an adult without considering the applicable legal authority and foreseeable safety risk. A service shall provide information about what a guardian can see before the feature is enabled.

(c) Evolving Capacity.—Rules shall distinguish young children from older adolescents and shall consider their privacy, expression, and practical ability to understand choices. The agency shall not treat every person under 18 as having identical needs. A control shall not require a family to purchase an expensive premium plan to obtain a basic legally required protection.

SEC. 2005. PURCHASES AND VIRTUAL CURRENCY.

(a) Authorization.—A purchase charged to an adult's payment instrument through a known minor's account shall require authorization consistent with applicable law and clearly stated account settings. A prior small purchase shall not be treated as unlimited consent to future charges.

(b) Design.—Interfaces shall distinguish play, browsing, and purchase actions. Virtual currency shall display the reasonably ascertainable real-money equivalent at purchase. A service shall not use confusing buttons, concealed subscription conversion, or intentionally ambiguous confirmation to obtain payment.

(c) Correction.—A provider shall maintain a practical process for reporting unauthorized purchases and shall investigate using relevant transaction records. It may consider demonstrable abuse but shall not reject every claim through a categorical no-refund policy. Refunds shall not require surrender of unrelated purchased content unless necessary to reverse the specific transaction.

SEC. 2006. RANDOMIZED PAID REWARDS.

(a) Disclosure.—A commercial game offering a paid randomized reward shall disclose the nature of the mechanism, material probabilities or an intelligible explanation when probabilities vary, spending controls, and whether the reward can be exchanged for money or transferable value.

(b) Minors.—A service known to be used by a minor shall provide a default spending limit of zero for paid randomized rewards unless a lawful authorized adult affirmatively enables a stated limit. The service shall provide a transaction history and an accessible means to restore the limit.

(c) Savings.—This section does not determine whether a particular mechanism constitutes gambling under another law or legalize a prohibited gambling product. The Trade Commission shall study actual spending and design effects without treating all games or voluntary play as inherently harmful. Rules shall target the commercial mechanism rather than a game's story, characters, or viewpoint.

SEC. 2007. COMMERCIAL DESIGN AND USER CONTROL.

(a) Prohibitions.—A covered service shall not knowingly misrepresent the consequence of a minor's commercial choice, make a paid cancellation materially harder than enrollment, or use a private communication to exploit a specific known vulnerability for a purchase.

(b) Features.—Services shall offer accessible controls for autoplay, nonessential notifications, and reminders where such features are provided and controls are technically feasible. The user shall be able to find and retain the selected setting.

(c) Evidence.—An agency rule restricting a design shall identify the commercial harm, evidence, affected users, and less restrictive alternatives. It shall not infer illegality solely from time spent, popularity, or emotional engagement. A general obligation to maximize well-being is not created; enforceable duties must remain specific enough for a provider and court to determine compliance.

SEC. 2008. EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY.

(a) Limitation.—A provider receiving student information through a school or publicly funded educational program shall use it only for the authorized educational function, security, necessary administration, or another lawful purpose expressly permitted by the governing agreement and law.

(b) Prohibitions.—The provider shall not use student information for behavioral advertising, sell it, or condition an essential educational function on optional commercial tracking. A school shall not be asked to consent on behalf of families to unrelated commercial exploitation.

(c) Records.—Contracts shall address access, correction, deletion, security, subcontractors, and transition when the service ends. Existing educational privacy laws remain applicable. A provider may improve a product using genuinely deidentified aggregate information with safeguards, but shall not label identifiable longitudinal student profiles as aggregate merely because names have been removed.

SEC. 2009. MEDIA AND DIGITAL LITERACY.

(a) Grants.—Within appropriated inclusion funds, the Secretary may support voluntary instruction on privacy, advertising recognition, source evaluation, cybersecurity, accessible technology, and responsible participation in digital commerce.

(b) Neutrality.—Instruction shall develop practical skills and shall not require endorsement of a political viewpoint, religious belief, or government-approved news source. Participants may examine evidence, distinguish opinion from factual claims, and understand sponsorship without being instructed that lawful dissent is misinformation.

(c) Evaluation.—Programs shall use transparent curricula, qualified educators, accessible materials, and measures of practical skill. Funding shall not depend on a participant's political attitudes. A recipient shall disclose commercial sponsorship and shall not use the program to collect marketing profiles or promote a particular platform as the exclusive safe choice.

SEC. 2010. RESEARCH INVOLVING MINORS.

(a) Safeguards.—Research funded under this Act involving minors shall comply with applicable human-subject protections, obtain required consent or assent, minimize risk, and protect confidentiality. Research access shall not become a channel for acquiring sensitive commercial profiles.

(b) Quality.—Studies shall distinguish association from causation, report age differences, disclose funding and methods, and identify limitations. An agency shall not generalize from a narrow convenience sample to all children without a reasonable evidentiary basis.

(c) Publication.—Findings shall be published in accessible form with privacy-protective data where lawful. A sponsor may review confidential information but may not suppress unfavorable results. Policy recommendations shall compare benefits, risks, and feasible alternatives and shall respect the constitutional rights of both minors and adults.

SEC. 2011. FAMILY COMPLAINTS AND SAFETY.

(a) Process.—A service shall provide accessible channels for reporting unauthorized purchases, privacy misuse, impersonation, and threats affecting a minor. Urgent safety reports shall receive priority according to objective risk criteria.

(b) Protection.—Reporting shall not require public exposure of a child's identity. A service shall preserve evidence necessary for lawful investigation while limiting access and retention. Reports of illegal material shall follow applicable law; this Act does not require a user to download or redistribute such material to obtain assistance.

(c) Review.—A person affected by an erroneous account or age restriction shall have a meaningful correction process. A complaint shall not automatically trigger disclosure to a potentially abusive household member. The service may refer imminent danger to appropriate authorities under existing law, but shall not represent that every disagreement or controversial conversation constitutes an emergency.

SEC. 2012. IMPLEMENTATION AND CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW.

(a) Date.—Commercial and privacy duties take effect 24 months after enactment, with model guidance available at least six months earlier. Existing stronger protections remain enforceable according to their terms.

(b) Rules.—The Trade Commission shall administer this title and consult child-development, privacy, disability, civil-liberties, and technical experts. A rule shall identify the specific statutory duty implemented and its effects on lawful access to information.

(c) Severability.—A court's invalidation of a particular design or age-related requirement shall not invalidate independent billing, privacy, or fraud protections capable of functioning separately. No agency may respond to invalidation by imposing substantially the same restriction through an unrelated licensing or grant condition without lawful authority.

SEC. 2013. GUARDIAN AUTHORITY AND YOUTH PRIVACY.

(a) Verification.—A service requiring guardian authorization shall use a method reasonably designed to verify lawful authority while minimizing collection of identity documents. Verification shall not be sold or reused for advertising. An age estimate alone does not establish that a person is the child's lawful guardian.

(b) Disputes.—The service shall maintain a process for conflicting claims of authority and shall respect applicable custody orders and law. It shall not decide a family-law dispute by automatically granting access to the first adult who submits a request.

(c) Confidentiality.—Controls shall distinguish supervision of purchases and account settings from access to confidential communications. Disclosure shall comply with applicable law and account for a credible risk of abuse. This section does not create a general Federal right for a minor to evade lawful guardianship, nor a general right for an adult to obtain all records associated with a minor. Agencies shall provide clear implementation guidance grounded in specific statutory duties.

SEC. 2014. VIRTUAL CURRENCY BALANCES AND REFUNDS.

(a) Information.—Before a minor's authorized purchase of virtual currency, the seller shall display the real-money cost and explain whether unused balances are refundable, transferable, or subject to expiration. A presentation shall not intentionally conceal the monetary value of a transaction through unnecessary conversion steps.

(b) Unauthorized Purchases.—A seller shall provide a practical process to contest purchases made without the authorization required by this title. It may examine device access, consent records, delivery, and evidence of abuse, but shall not treat a child's repeated button presses as proof of a guardian's informed agreement.

(c) Closure.—When a seller permanently discontinues the paid system before the promised usable period, it shall provide an appropriate refund or equivalent agreed remedy for unused purchased value, subject to lawful terms and title XVI. Promotional value may be treated differently if clearly identified. A seller shall not retroactively characterize purchased value as promotional merely to avoid an otherwise applicable refund obligation.

SEC. 2015. YOUTH SAFETY RESEARCH AND LIMITS ON CONTENT CONTROL.

(a) Evidence.—An agency evaluating a proposed youth-protection rule shall distinguish evidence of commercial exploitation, privacy injury, compulsive spending, or a specific design effect from disagreement with the ideas expressed in lawful content. It shall disclose material uncertainty and consider less restrictive alternatives.

(b) Testing.—Research supported under this Act may evaluate age-appropriate controls, interruption options, notification settings, and purchase safeguards. Participation shall comply with applicable human-subject protections and shall not expose children to unnecessary risk merely to measure engagement.

(c) Limits.—No agency may require a platform to suppress lawful discussion of politics, religion, health, identity, or other protected subjects based solely on an assertion that the subject is controversial or unsuitable. A particular unlawful threat, exploitative transaction, or other independently prohibited conduct remains subject to applicable law. The Government shall not use a youth-protection grant or procurement condition to impose editorial restrictions it could not constitutionally enact directly.

TITLE XXI—PUBLIC MEDIA LIBRARIES AND CULTURAL ACCESS

SEC. 2101. PUBLIC MEDIA ACCESS PROGRAM.

(a) Establishment.—The Secretary shall administer a Public Media Access Program within the appropriation in title XXIX to support noncommercial communications infrastructure, emergency capability, accessibility, educational production facilities, and community access.

(b) Eligibility.—Eligible applicants include nonprofit public-media organizations, libraries, educational institutions, Tribal governments, and public entities performing the funded function. Eligibility shall not depend on affiliation with a particular national network or membership organization.

(c) Independence.—Awards shall use objective criteria concerning service, need, readiness, and stewardship. No official may select recipients based on favorable coverage, political agreement, or a preferred artistic viewpoint. This program does not assume the continued existence of any particular intermediary corporation and does not amend the governance of an existing public-media institution by implication.

SEC. 2102. ELIGIBLE USES.

(a) Uses.—Funds may support transmitters, distribution equipment, accessible production tools, emergency power, secure network connections, preservation, training, and shared facilities. A recipient may support production only within an objectively defined educational, informational, accessibility, or cultural-access purpose stated in the award.

(b) Exclusions.—Funds shall not be used for campaign contributions, lobbying expenditures prohibited by law, private dividends, or unrelated commercial acquisitions. The exclusion of campaign activity shall not prohibit ordinary journalism about elections or lawful editorial discussion.

(c) Costs.—Awards shall distinguish capital, operating, and administrative expense and shall include maintenance and replacement assumptions. A recipient shall not purchase equipment without a practical plan for staffing and use. Publicly supported facilities shall publish reasonable access terms and shall not be reserved primarily for insiders while represented as community resources.

SEC. 2103. FORMULA AND COMPETITIVE ALLOCATION.

(a) Allocation.—The Secretary shall allocate at least 60 percent of annual program funds through objective formulas reflecting population served, rural and remote cost, disability-access needs, and lack of alternative public communications infrastructure. The remaining funds may support competitive projects with clearly stated criteria.

(b) Limits.—No controlled group may receive more than 10 percent of annual program funds, except a temporary emergency award supported by public findings. Administrative costs at the Federal level shall not exceed five percent of the program appropriation.

(c) Review.—Formula inputs shall be published and corrected when materially erroneous. Competitive decisions shall explain scoring and conflicts of interest. An applicant may seek review of a procedural or factual error, but the process shall not become an opportunity to demand a grant based on the perceived virtue of its political or artistic expression.

SEC. 2104. LIBRARY CONNECTIVITY AND PRIVACY.

(a) Support.—Eligible libraries may receive assistance for connectivity, accessible devices, digital navigation, and secure public workspaces. Assistance shall complement existing school and library mechanisms without reimbursing the same cost twice.

(b) Privacy.—A library receiving funds shall not be required to maintain identifiable records of patrons' reading, viewing, or lawful internet activity as a condition of the grant. Necessary security logs shall be minimized and retained only for a documented purpose.

(c) Access.—Library policies may address lawful safety, time, and resource management, consistent with constitutional and statutory obligations. This Act does not impose a new Federal viewpoint filter or require a library to purchase a particular title. Grant evaluation shall focus on practical access, accessibility, and stewardship rather than officials' approval of the collection.

SEC. 2105. DIGITAL LICENSING FOR PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS.

(a) Transparency.—A seller offering a digital license to a public library or institution shall clearly disclose permitted users, lending or access limits, expiration, renewal, accessibility, archival rights, and material restrictions on transfer or migration.

(b) Contracts.—A seller shall not represent that an institution owns a permanent copy when it has purchased a time-limited license. Material unilateral changes during a prepaid term shall permit an appropriate refund or termination.

(c) Copyright.—This section does not create a compulsory license, override title 17, or require a rights holder to sell to every institution. The Librarian of Congress shall study lawful models for affordable institutional access and preservation, including negotiated collective arrangements, and report specific recommendations to Congress. A recommendation shall address compensation and the effect on authors and independent publishers.

SEC. 2106. PRESERVATION OF PUBLICLY FUNDED WORKS.

(a) Deposit.—An award primarily financing production of a work shall specify a preservation deposit and access license proportionate to the Federal contribution. The condition shall be disclosed before acceptance and shall respect preexisting third-party rights.

(b) Archives.—Deposited materials shall include available accessibility tracks, technical metadata, and documentation necessary for future lawful use. Repositories shall use sustainable formats and maintain migration plans without altering the historical record.

(c) Limits.—Preservation does not automatically place all rights in the public domain or authorize commercial exploitation beyond the agreed license. Sensitive personal information, culturally restricted Tribal material, and confidential sources shall receive appropriate protection. A repository shall distinguish a preservation copy from a public-access copy and shall document any restriction and its legal basis.

SEC. 2107. COMMUNITY PRODUCTION FACILITIES.

(a) Access.—A funded facility shall provide reasonable opportunities for community members to use production equipment, training, and distribution resources under published, content-neutral operational rules consistent with the forum the facility lawfully creates.

(b) Safety.—Rules may address scheduling, equipment care, harassment, unlawful conduct, and technical competence. They shall not exclude a person merely because of lawful criticism of officials or a viewpoint unpopular with management.

(c) Sustainability.—A facility shall maintain insurance, maintenance, staffing, accessibility, and a fee schedule that does not defeat the stated public purpose. Commercial use may be permitted when it supports the facility and does not displace the promised community access. Revenue shall be accounted for and applied according to the award rather than distributed privately without authorization.

SEC. 2108. CULTURAL AND LANGUAGE ACCESS.

(a) Projects.—The Secretary may support technical and accessibility projects serving communities whose language, geography, or disability substantially limits access to existing communications resources. Selection shall focus on documented access barriers and the practical service proposed.

(b) Autonomy.—A project may preserve and distribute cultural expression without surrendering editorial control to the Government. Tribal projects shall follow the data and cultural protections in title IX.

(c) Rights.—Grant conditions shall identify permissions needed for recorded performances, archival materials, translations, and distribution. A recipient shall not assume that a work is free to exploit merely because it is culturally significant or publicly funded in part. Participants shall receive clear information about recording, reuse, compensation, and withdrawal where applicable.

SEC. 2109. PUBLIC INTEREST EMERGENCY CAPACITY.

(a) Resilience.—Public-media recipients serving as important emergency-information sources may receive support for backup power, alternate distribution, accessible alerts, and restoration equipment. The award shall identify the emergency function and verification requirements.

(b) Coordination.—Recipients shall coordinate with authorized emergency officials while retaining editorial independence for ordinary programming. An emergency arrangement shall not authorize officials to dictate unrelated news coverage.

(c) Testing.—Equipment shall be tested under realistic conditions and maintained throughout the commitment period. A recipient shall document whether backup power can actually sustain transmission, studio operations, and necessary connectivity together. Reports shall identify failures and corrective actions without exposing detailed vulnerabilities that would facilitate sabotage.

SEC. 2110. GOVERNANCE AND FINANCIAL INTEGRITY.

(a) Governance.—A recipient shall maintain conflict-of-interest policies, documented financial controls, and a governing process adequate to oversee the award. Material related-party transactions shall be disclosed and justified.

(b) Public Accountability.—Annual reports shall identify award amounts, uses, outputs, access, and financial condition. Editorial deliberations, confidential sources, and protected personal information need not be disclosed merely because the entity receives funds.

(c) Correction.—The Secretary may require corrective action for misuse, false certification, or material failure to provide the funded service. A funding decision shall not be based on disapproval of lawful content. Before termination, the recipient shall receive notice and a review opportunity, except for narrowly necessary temporary protection of funds or safety.

SEC. 2111. NO GOVERNMENT EDITORIAL CONTROL.

(a) Prohibition.—An officer may not direct a recipient to publish a favorable story, suppress criticism, hire or fire an editor for political reasons, or adopt a prescribed ideological balance as a condition of this program.

(b) Complaints.—A complaint concerning viewpoint retaliation shall be referred to an independent agency review official and, where appropriate, an inspector general. A person with concrete injury may seek judicial relief under title XXVII.

(c) Legitimate Conditions.—This prohibition does not excuse fraud, unlawful discrimination, failure to provide a specifically funded accessibility or emergency function, or breach of a lawful grant condition. The Government shall identify the objective condition and supporting facts rather than using a vague public-interest assertion as a substitute for proof.

SEC. 2112. EVALUATION AND CONTINUATION.

(a) Measures.—The Secretary shall assess service reach, practical access, accessibility, emergency readiness, preservation quality, and financial sustainability. Audience size alone shall not determine success for a project serving a small or remote community.

(b) Review.—The Comptroller General shall review allocation and independence safeguards in program years 4 and 8. It shall identify whether formulas unintentionally favor established institutions or exclude capable entrants.

(c) Continuation.—The program may obligate funds only within title XXIX. Expiration of an appropriation does not authorize continued spending, and the Secretary shall provide orderly notice of changes. Grant recipients shall maintain a transition plan that protects archives, equipment, and ongoing public commitments without presuming perpetual Federal support.

TITLE XXII—LOCAL JOURNALISM AND COMMUNITY INFORMATION

SEC. 2201. LOCAL JOURNALISM SUPPORT PROGRAM.

(a) Establishment.—The Secretary shall administer a Local Journalism Support Program to expand original local reporting through objective reimbursement of eligible reporting expense, subject to the appropriation in title XXIX.

(b) Eligible Outlet.—An eligible outlet regularly produces original reporting concerning a geographically identifiable community in the United States, maintains a publicly identified responsible editor, discloses controlling ownership, and has operated for at least one year or demonstrates a credible new-outlet plan. Print, broadcast, audio, video, and digital formats shall receive equal consideration.

(c) Exclusions.—A political campaign committee, a governmental propaganda office, or a business principally distributing paid advertising without original reporting is ineligible. An outlet is not ineligible merely because it publishes opinion, has an identifiable editorial perspective, is religiously affiliated, or criticizes the Government, provided the funded activity satisfies the objective program requirements.

SEC. 2202. ELIGIBLE REPORTING EXPENSE.

(a) Expense.—Eligible expense includes compensation and necessary benefits for personnel substantially engaged in original local reporting, editing, verification, data reporting, photography, audio, video, accessibility, or direct supervision of those functions.

(b) Limits.—Advertising sales, lobbying, campaign activity, unrelated entertainment production, executive compensation unrelated to reporting, and distributions to owners are excluded. A mixed-function employee's expense shall be allocated using reasonable records.

(c) Reimbursement.—The program may reimburse up to 50 percent of eligible expense, not exceeding $50,000 per worker annually, $500,000 per outlet annually, or $5,000,000 per controlled group annually. These limits shall be adjusted for inflation beginning in program year 3. Reimbursement shall not exceed actual expense or duplicate another Federal payment for the same cost.

SEC. 2203. OBJECTIVE ALLOCATION.

(a) Application.—Applicants shall identify service area, reporting staff, eligible expense, ownership, existing public support, and the proposed increase or preservation of local reporting capacity. They shall not submit political loyalty statements or samples selected for ideological approval.

(b) Oversubscription.—If eligible requests exceed funds, awards shall be allocated by a published formula considering lack of local reporting alternatives, population served, rural or remote cost, and the applicant's independently controlled status. The formula shall not rank outlets by agreement with official positions.

(c) New Entrants.—A reserved share of not less than 15 percent shall support qualified new or substantially expanding independent outlets, with staged payment and appropriate financial controls. The Secretary shall avoid a design that permanently rewards only incumbents with the largest historical payroll.

SEC. 2204. EDITORIAL FIREWALL.

(a) Prohibition.—No official administering this program may approve stories, require favorable coverage, demand advance review of unpublished work, or evaluate an outlet's political balance. Award staff shall not communicate editorial preferences as conditions of funding.

(b) Records.—The Secretary may verify that paid work constitutes original local reporting through objective employment and publication records, but shall not require disclosure of confidential sources or unpublished investigative material absent independent lawful authority.

(c) Remedy.—An outlet facing a viewpoint-based condition may seek prompt administrative correction and judicial relief under title XXVII. The Government shall bear the burden of identifying an objective, lawful basis for an adverse program decision when the record establishes a credible claim of retaliatory conditioning. This burden does not require payment to an otherwise ineligible applicant.

SEC. 2205. INDEPENDENCE AND OWNERSHIP DISCLOSURE.

(a) Disclosure.—An applicant shall disclose persons exercising control, material government ownership, significant funding relationships, and related-party arrangements relevant to the award. Public disclosure may use business contact information rather than a private residence.

(b) Independence.—A claimed independent outlet shall retain meaningful editorial and financial decision-making. A nominal separate corporation controlled through management, financing, or mandatory content agreements shall be aggregated with its controlling group.

(c) Limits.—Disclosure does not authorize exclusion because an owner holds unpopular beliefs. Foreign funding may be considered where it creates a legally relevant control or security issue, with due process and applicable law. The Secretary shall not impose an unsupported nationality test on reporters or sources as a condition of a local reporting grant.

SEC. 2206. NONDISPLACEMENT AND ADDITIONALITY.

(a) Plan.—An applicant shall explain whether support adds reporting capacity, prevents a documented imminent loss, or enables coverage of an underserved area. It shall maintain records sufficient to evaluate the claimed effect.

(b) Prohibition.—A recipient shall not dismiss existing eligible workers and replace them solely to manufacture reimbursable positions, or transfer ordinary payroll among affiliates to claim multiple awards. Legitimate reorganization and ordinary turnover remain permissible with documentation.

(c) Review.—The Secretary shall compare reporting capacity before and during support, accounting for changes in revenue and community need. A program shall not be judged successful merely because reimbursement was paid. A recipient that materially misrepresented additionality shall be subject to proportional recovery and other remedies, with protection for workers who did not participate in the misrepresentation.

SEC. 2207. PUBLIC ACCESS TO FUNDED REPORTING.

(a) Access Plan.—An applicant shall state how the community can obtain the reporting supported by the award, including subscriptions, free access periods, library arrangements, broadcasts, or other practical methods. A paywall is not categorically prohibited.

(b) Emergency Information.—Material public-safety information produced with program support shall be made available without a paywall during the relevant emergency, to the extent the recipient holds the necessary rights and can do so safely.

(c) Copyright.—The program does not transfer copyright in all reporting to the Government or require unlimited commercial reuse by competitors. Any specific license required for preservation or public access shall be stated before acceptance and proportionate to the award. The Secretary shall not use copyright conditions to obtain editorial control or suppress later distribution.

SEC. 2208. COLLABORATIVE REPORTING.

(a) Eligibility.—Eligible outlets may form collaborations for costly investigations, data infrastructure, translation, accessibility, or shared reporting in underserved areas. Agreements shall allocate expense, rights, attribution, and editorial responsibility.

(b) Competition.—Collaboration shall not be used to fix unrelated subscription or advertising prices, divide markets unlawfully, or exclude independent competitors. Existing antitrust law remains applicable.

(c) Records.—A collaboration shall identify which recipient claims each expense and shall prevent duplicate reimbursement. A shared project may preserve distinct editorial judgments. Funding shall not require every participant to publish the same conclusion or permit one politically favored outlet to control the reporting of all participants.

SEC. 2209. SAFETY AND SOURCE PROTECTION.

(a) Support.—Eligible expense may include reasonable security training, secure communications, protective equipment for lawful field reporting, and measures protecting confidential sources, when directly related to the funded reporting function.

(b) Limits.—This section does not create a general privilege overriding all subpoenas or immunize unlawful conduct. Existing privileges, shield laws, constitutional protections, and court orders remain applicable.

(c) Government Access.—Program administrators shall not obtain source identities or unpublished notes merely to verify a payroll reimbursement when less intrusive evidence is sufficient. An agency requesting such material shall identify an independent legal basis and provide the process required by law. A recipient shall not be penalized for asserting a good-faith privilege claim through lawful channels.

SEC. 2210. COMMUNITY INFORMATION GAPS.

(a) Mapping.—The Secretary shall maintain a public, methodology-based inventory of communities with limited original local reporting. The inventory shall consider actual coverage, geographic relevance, language access, and continuity, rather than counting every registered website as a functioning newsroom.

(b) Correction.—Outlets and communities may correct factual errors. The inventory shall not rate the ideological quality of reporting or establish an official list of trustworthy opinions.

(c) Use.—The inventory may inform grant allocation and research. It shall not determine whether a person is legally entitled to publish or obtain ordinary access to public records. A community's inclusion shall not automatically justify government operation of a newsroom. The preferred remedy is enabling independent capacity through neutral and accountable assistance.

SEC. 2211. AUDITS AND ENFORCEMENT.

(a) Audit.—The Secretary may verify payroll, eligible work, ownership, and use of funds through proportionate audits. An audit shall protect confidential sources and personal employment information and shall avoid unnecessary intrusion into editorial deliberation.

(b) Correction.—A recipient shall have an opportunity to correct a nonwillful accounting error. Intentional false claims, concealed control, or diversion of funds may result in recovery, suspension, debarment, and referral under applicable law.

(c) Independence.—Audit selection shall use objective risk factors and documented random sampling, not criticism of officials or controversial coverage. The inspector general shall review credible allegations that audits are being used as retaliation. A recipient's refusal to alter lawful editorial content shall not be treated as failure to cooperate with a financial audit.

SEC. 2212. EVALUATION AND SUNSET OF FUNDING.

(a) Evaluation.—The Comptroller General shall evaluate the program in years 3 and 7, including original reporting capacity, community access, market entry, financial sustainability, displacement, and administrative independence.

(b) Evidence.—Evaluators shall distinguish increased publication volume from meaningful local reporting and shall disclose uncertainty. They shall not evaluate success by the political views expressed, the popularity of the Government, or agreement among outlets.

(c) Funding.—The program may operate only within the amounts and years provided in title XXIX. Before the final funded year, the Secretary shall provide a transition plan and recommendations for continuation, modification, or termination. The expiration of funding shall not impair accrued lawful payments or authorize government seizure of editorial assets, archives, or intellectual property.

SEC. 2213. GRANT SCORING AND EDITORIAL INSULATION.

(a) Scoring.—A competitive award shall use published criteria addressing eligible expense, underserved community need, financial integrity, practical access, and the applicant's ability to perform the proposed reporting activity. Scorers shall not award points for agreement with a government policy or subtract points for criticism of a public official.

(b) Conflicts.—A scorer shall disclose material financial, employment, or personal relationships with an applicant and recuse where the relationship would reasonably impair impartial evaluation. Recusal shall not be used to exclude a person merely because of a lawful viewpoint or professional membership.

(c) Review.—An unsuccessful applicant may request the nonconfidential basis for its score and correction of a material factual or procedural error. Review shall not require the applicant to submit unpublished editorial plans beyond information reasonably needed to assess the funded activity. A grant officer may verify that eligible reporting occurred and public funds were properly spent, but may not require advance approval of a story, source, headline, or conclusion. A retaliatory funding decision is subject to section 2721.

TITLE XXIII—PLATFORM ACCOUNTABILITY AND LAWFUL EXPRESSION

SEC. 2301. FUNCTIONAL SCOPE.

(a) Coverage.—This title applies to commercial online services that host, distribute, recommend, or facilitate transactions involving third-party content, to the extent of the specific duties stated. A service's technical architecture does not alone determine whether a function is editorial, transactional, or infrastructural.

(b) Distinctions.—The Trade Commission shall distinguish a service's own advertising, billing, data processing, and contractual representations from its publication or moderation of another person's expression. An enforcement action shall identify the conduct and legal duty at issue.

(c) Savings.—Nothing creates a general duty to host all lawful expression, guarantee a particular audience, eliminate every risk of user misconduct, or verify the truth of every statement. Existing criminal, intellectual-property, civil-rights, and consumer laws remain applicable according to their terms and applicable immunities.

SEC. 2302. COMMERCIAL TERMS AND MATERIAL PROMISES.

(a) Terms.—A service selling a commercial account, distribution tool, or monetization program shall disclose material eligibility, fees, payment timing, suspension grounds, export rights, and termination consequences in understandable terms.

(b) Promises.—The service shall not knowingly make a material false promise about payment, account access, or purchased distribution. A general aspiration concerning community or fairness is not automatically an enforceable guarantee of editorial outcome.

(c) Changes.—Material changes to paid commercial terms require reasonable notice and an opportunity to decline future performance or obtain an appropriate refund for undelivered prepaid value. A service may change editorial policies, subject to its lawful contracts, but shall not conceal a new financial charge within a moderation-policy update.

SEC. 2303. COMMERCIAL ACCOUNT DECISIONS.

(a) Notice.—When a service suspends billing access, withholds earned compensation, or terminates a paid commercial account, it shall provide the material contractual or legal basis and an accessible review route, except to the extent disclosure would materially facilitate fraud, create a safety risk, or violate law.

(b) Review.—A review shall permit correction of mistaken identity, compromised credentials, payment errors, and material factual misunderstandings. It shall be conducted by a person or system capable of addressing the asserted error, with human review for a substantial unresolved financial deprivation.

(c) Limits.—The remedy may require correction of commercial records, payment, refund, or data export. It shall not require the service to endorse, recommend, or continue an expressive association contrary to the First Amendment. A court shall identify this distinction when ordering restoration of an account containing both commercial and expressive functions.

SEC. 2304. EARNED FUNDS AND RESERVES.

(a) Payment.—A service holding funds earned by a creator or seller shall pay undisputed amounts according to the disclosed schedule. A reserve for chargebacks, fraud, or legal obligations shall be reasonably related to documented risk and shall have a review date.

(b) Explanation.—The service shall identify the amount reserved, general reason, release conditions, and means to contest a material error. It may protect investigative details but shall not withhold all information indefinitely.

(c) Property.—A terminated account does not by itself forfeit earned funds. Lawful offsets shall be documented, and remaining funds returned. This section does not require release of funds subject to a valid court order or independently applicable financial law. It prohibits using unrelated earnings as leverage to obtain new rights, silence a complaint, or compel a creator's political or commercial endorsement.

SEC. 2305. USER DATA AND CONTENT EXPORT.

(a) Export.—A commercial user may obtain the user's own submitted content, transaction records, and authorized customer data in a reasonably usable format, subject to intellectual-property and privacy rights of others.

(b) Process.—A service shall provide an export opportunity before ordinary permanent account closure and a secure request process after closure for at least 90 days, unless retention itself would be unlawful or create a substantial security risk. Urgent restrictions may occur immediately with later access to lawful records.

(c) Limits.—The service need not transfer another user's personal information without authority, disclose proprietary recommendation systems, or guarantee migration of social relationships. It shall not intentionally corrupt an export or impose a fee unrelated to reasonable cost to prevent switching. Title XIII governs personal-data rights independently of commercial account status.

SEC. 2306. AGGREGATE TRANSPARENCY.

(a) Large Services.—A service with more than 10,000,000 monthly active United States users shall publish semiannual aggregate information about commercial account restrictions, payment holds, appeals, reversals, and response times under this title.

(b) Contents.—The report shall define categories and methods, identify material limitations, and avoid disclosure of personal information or exploitable enforcement methods. It shall not require the service to characterize a political viewpoint as harmful or to justify its editorial philosophy to the Government.

(c) Verification.—The Trade Commission may examine supporting records through lawful process to assess materially false reporting. A report is not a government approval of moderation decisions. Smaller services may voluntarily use the same format, and agencies shall not treat nonparticipation in a voluntary report as evidence of wrongdoing.

SEC. 2307. GOVERNMENT REQUESTS CONCERNING CONTENT.

(a) Record.—A covered Federal agency requesting a platform to restrict identifiable lawful expression shall record the legal basis, requesting office, whether the request is compulsory, and any threatened or offered governmental consequence.

(b) Prohibition.—An official shall not use regulatory, licensing, procurement, or grant power to coerce suppression of protected expression outside lawful authority. A request for voluntary assistance shall not be accompanied by an unlawful threat.

(c) Transparency.—Agencies shall publish aggregate request information and disclose individual requests when lawful, with protection for valid investigations, safety, and classified information. This section does not prohibit government speech, lawful persuasion, or notification of apparent illegal conduct. Courts shall assess the actual context and coercive effect rather than treating every government-platform communication as either categorically lawful or categorically prohibited.

SEC. 2308. NOTICES OF ILLEGAL MATERIAL.

(a) Process.—A service shall maintain a reasonably accessible channel for notices invoking a specific legal right or order relevant to material it hosts. The notice shall identify the material and asserted basis with sufficient specificity to permit assessment.

(b) Safeguards.—A service may request additional information, reject a facially deficient notice, and use measures appropriate to urgency. It shall preserve applicable counter-notice and appeal rights and shall not require public disclosure of a victim's sensitive identity as a routine condition of reporting.

(c) Savings.—This section does not create a new substantive prohibition on content or a general removal duty. Duties under the TAKE IT DOWN Act, title 17, and other applicable statutes remain governed by their own requirements. A notice does not establish illegality merely because the sender asserts it.

SEC. 2309. FRAUDULENT NOTICES AND PROCESS ABUSE.

(a) Prohibition.—A person shall not knowingly make a materially false representation of legal authority, ownership, identity, or court process in a notice intended to deprive another person of commercial account access, earned funds, or lawful distribution.

(b) Claim.—A person suffering concrete injury may recover actual damages and reasonable costs caused by the misrepresentation under title XXVII. Good-faith legal disagreement, an innocent identification error, or a reasonable report of suspected danger is not a knowing misrepresentation.

(c) Platform Response.—A service may suspend access to its reporting tools for demonstrated abuse after proportionate review, while preserving a route for legitimate urgent notices. It shall not treat a high volume of reports as proof of validity or invalidity without examining context. Automated notices shall identify an accountable sender and permit correction.

SEC. 2310. SECTION 230 AND INDEPENDENT CONDUCT.

(a) Preservation.—Except for the express digital-replica exception in section 3003, this Act does not repeal or generally amend section 230 of the Communications Act of 1934.

(b) Construction.—A duty concerning a service's own billing, payment, data processing, or contractual representation shall be evaluated according to the actual conduct alleged and the law governing section 230. A claimant may not evade an applicable immunity by relabeling a claim directed at publication of third-party content as a billing or product-design claim.

(c) No Monitoring.—No provision creates a general obligation to monitor all user content. A service's voluntary good-faith safety measures shall not, solely by their existence, establish knowledge of every unlawful act or create a universal duty to prevent harm. Specific statutory duties remain enforceable according to their terms.

SEC. 2311. RESEARCH ACCESS AND USER SAFETY.

(a) Program.—The Trade Commission may support privacy-protective research on commercial account administration, fraud, advertising, and user understanding of platform terms. Research shall use aggregate or consented data where feasible.

(b) Access.—Compulsory access to nonpublic information requires lawful process, relevance, security safeguards, and protection of trade secrets and personal information. A researcher shall not obtain unrestricted access to private communications under a general public-interest claim.

(c) Independence.—Research findings shall disclose methods, sponsorship, and limitations. The Government shall not condition funding on a predetermined conclusion about a platform or political viewpoint. A platform may challenge unlawful access demands without being presumed obstructive. Lawful security research and public reporting remain subject to applicable protections and responsibilities.

SEC. 2312. EFFECTIVE DATE AND REVIEW.

(a) Date.—This title takes effect 18 months after enactment, with an additional six months for small entities to implement export and review systems. Core prohibitions on knowingly false commercial representations remain subject to existing law before that date.

(b) Review.—The Trade Commission shall evaluate whether commercial review procedures correct errors, release earned funds, and permit switching, and whether compliance unnecessarily burdens small services. It shall not rate platforms according to whether their editorial choices favor a political party.

(c) Judicial Protection.—A court shall tailor relief to the unlawful commercial conduct and protect lawful editorial discretion. Invalidation of a particular disclosure or procedure shall not eliminate independent payment and refund duties capable of operating separately. No agency may use this title to restore a content-carriage mandate rejected on constitutional grounds.

TITLE XXIV—DEVICES INTEROPERABILITY AND REPAIR

SEC. 2401. DEVICE INFORMATION.

(a) Disclosure.—Before sale, a manufacturer or seller shall disclose material connectivity requirements, supported services, recurring charges, expected security-support period, repair availability, and any essential function dependent on a remote service.

(b) Accuracy.—A device shall not be marketed as permanently functional when the seller knows that an essential server-dependent function is scheduled to end within the ordinary expected use period without disclosing that limitation.

(c) Coverage.—This title applies to covered communications and media devices, including routers, modems, receivers, smart televisions, streaming devices, and equipment principally used to create or play covered media. It does not establish a general safety code for all electronics. Medical, aviation, and other specialized equipment remain subject to their governing laws, with this title applying only where simultaneous compliance is possible.

SEC. 2402. SECURITY SUPPORT.

(a) Period.—A manufacturer shall state a minimum security-support period before sale and honor that commitment. For a newly sold consumer router or connected media device, the stated period shall ordinarily extend at least five years after the final retail sale of that model by the manufacturer, subject to a narrowly justified rule for a materially different product class.

(b) Updates.—Necessary security updates shall be provided without a separate charge and shall not intentionally disable unrelated lawful functionality. The manufacturer shall provide clear installation information and identify material compatibility consequences.

(c) End Of Support.—At least one year before support ends, the manufacturer shall notify users through reasonably available channels and explain the risk and alternatives. An unsupported device shall not be falsely represented as secure because it still powers on. A manufacturer may offer extended support or a reasonable replacement program without compelling a new subscription unrelated to security.

SEC. 2403. REPAIR INFORMATION AND PARTS.

(a) Access.—During the promised support period, a manufacturer shall make parts, diagnostic information, repair instructions, and necessary tools reasonably available to owners and qualified independent repair providers on fair and nondiscriminatory terms.

(b) Limits.—Access may protect safety, trade secrets, cybersecurity, and intellectual property through proportionate safeguards. A generalized assertion of security is insufficient to prohibit every independent repair when a secure authentication or certification method is feasible.

(c) Warranty.—A warranty shall not be voided solely because an owner used an independent repairer or compatible part. The manufacturer may deny coverage for damage actually caused by an improper repair or incompatible part, with an explanation. This section does not require disclosure of encryption keys belonging to users or authorize circumvention otherwise prohibited by title 17.

SEC. 2404. PARTS PAIRING AND SOFTWARE LOCKS.

(a) Prohibition.—A manufacturer shall not use software pairing solely to prevent a lawful repair, disable a compatible replacement part, or force an unnecessary purchase from the manufacturer when the repair can be performed safely with reasonable authentication.

(b) Safety.—A safety-critical pairing requirement may be maintained when supported by evidence and accompanied by a practical process for an owner or qualified repairer to restore lawful functionality. The process shall not require disclosure of unrelated personal data.

(c) Information.—The manufacturer shall disclose material pairing restrictions before purchase and provide a reasoned denial when a repair cannot be authorized. A dispute may be submitted to the Trade Commission's designated process. The agency shall distinguish a legitimate anti-theft control from a commercial restriction whose principal function is to prevent competition in repair.

SEC. 2405. INTEROPERABILITY AND OPEN INTERFACES.

(a) Duty.—Where a device is marketed as compatible with a published standard or another service, the manufacturer shall provide the represented compatibility and shall not secretly impair it to favor an affiliated service.

(b) Targeted Orders.—A compulsory interoperability order requires express authority, evidence of a substantial competitive or accessibility barrier, feasible technical means, protection of security and intellectual property, and a proportionate remedy. This section does not mandate disclosure of every proprietary interface.

(c) Updates.—A material change that breaks a specifically promised interface shall receive advance notice and a reasonable migration or refund option. Emergency security changes may proceed immediately, with an explanation and restoration of equivalent lawful functionality where feasible. The agency shall avoid freezing a standard in a manner that prevents beneficial innovation.

SEC. 2406. CUSTOMER CONTROL AND DEFAULT SETTINGS.

(a) Control.—A user shall be able to review and change material privacy, microphone, camera, automatic-content-recognition, and advertising settings through an accessible interface. Optional surveillance features shall not be enabled through a misleading setup sequence.

(b) Local Function.—A device capable of a useful local function shall not require an unrelated cloud account solely to collect data or sell additional services when that function was marketed as locally available. Necessary activation and security requirements shall be disclosed.

(c) Reset.—A device shall provide a practical method to erase personal information before resale, return, or disposal. A factory reset shall not falsely indicate deletion while leaving readily accessible account credentials or recordings. Manufacturers shall document any information that cannot be removed through the ordinary reset and provide a safe alternative.

SEC. 2407. OWNERSHIP AND REMOTE DISABLING.

(a) Limit.—A seller shall not remotely disable a purchased device's essential lawful functions solely because the owner declined an unrelated subscription, used a lawful repairer, or exercised a statutory right.

(b) Permitted Action.—A narrowly tailored remote action may address theft, fraud, a valid legal order, a material safety risk, or nonpayment under a clearly disclosed lawful financing agreement. The action shall preserve emergency functions where feasible and provide notice and review when safe and lawful.

(c) Remedy.—If a wrongful disabling occurs, the responsible entity shall promptly restore functionality, correct associated charges, and compensate proven loss under title XXVII. A contract shall not grant an unrestricted right to disable all functions for any disagreement. This section does not require operation of a remote service forever, but closure remains subject to disclosure and transition duties.

SEC. 2408. REFURBISHMENT AND REUSE.

(a) Standards.—A refurbished device supported by a Federal program shall meet stated performance, safety, accessibility, data-erasure, and warranty requirements. The seller shall disclose that the device is refurbished and identify material limitations.

(b) Support.—A manufacturer shall provide accurate support-status information that allows a purchaser to evaluate remaining useful life. A refurbisher shall not misrepresent a device as receiving current security updates when support has ended.

(c) Public Programs.—Agencies may favor reuse when it provides reliable value and reduces waste, but shall consider maintenance, energy, replacement parts, and security over the expected use period. A low acquisition price shall not justify distributing equipment that cannot practically perform the funded function. Recipients shall provide a safe channel for repair and eventual recycling.

SEC. 2409. ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION.

(a) Disclosure.—For covered devices, manufacturers shall provide accurate energy-use information and reasonable power-management controls where applicable standards exist. Claims of environmental benefit shall have a reasonable basis and identify material limitations.

(b) Procurement.—Federal purchases under this Act shall consider lifecycle energy, repairability, expected support, and disposal costs. Agencies shall not prescribe a favored brand or disregard accessibility and performance merely to satisfy a single environmental metric.

(c) Disposal.—Recipients replacing equipment with Federal funds shall use responsible recycling or reuse methods and protect stored information. This section does not preempt stronger hazardous-waste or environmental law. The Trade Commission may address deceptive environmental marketing within its authority but shall not create a comprehensive emissions regime through a device-label rule.

SEC. 2410. DEVICE LOCKING AND CARRIER CHOICE.

(a) Unlocking.—A carrier shall unlock a compatible device after payment of the disclosed financing obligation or completion of a lawful lock period not exceeding 60 days after activation for a fully paid device, subject to a specific fraud or theft concern.

(b) Process.—Unlocking shall be free, timely, and available through an accessible request method. A denial shall identify the reason and correction route. A carrier shall not require payment of an unrelated disputed service charge to unlock a fully paid device.

(c) Disclosure.—Before sale, the seller shall explain any lock, financing, and compatibility limitations. Unlocking does not guarantee compatibility with every network, and that distinction shall be stated accurately. Military deployment and other hardship exceptions under existing law are preserved. A provider shall not relock a lawfully unlocked device through an ordinary software update.

SEC. 2411. TESTING AND CERTIFICATION CLAIMS.

(a) Claims.—A claim that a device is certified, secure, accessible, or interoperable shall identify the scope and basis when material to a purchase. A certification shall not be represented as a government guarantee against every failure.

(b) Independence.—Assessors shall disclose material conflicts and use reproducible tests appropriate to the claim. Manufacturers shall correct a known material false certification representation and notify affected purchasers when necessary.

(c) Access.—Qualified independent testing shall be permitted within lawful boundaries and reasonable safety conditions. This section does not authorize unauthorized access to another person's device or network. The Trade Commission may require supporting evidence for a commercial claim and may coordinate technical questions with the Commission, NIST, and other competent agencies.

SEC. 2412. IMPLEMENTATION AND EXCEPTIONS.

(a) Date.—This title applies to devices first offered for sale 24 months after enactment, except that disclosure and anti-deception duties apply to new sales after 18 months. Existing contractual support promises remain enforceable.

(b) Exceptions.—A specific repair or interface requirement may receive a limited exception upon evidence of an unavoidable safety, security, or legal conflict. The exception shall identify alternatives, duration, and consumer notice. A business preference for exclusive repair is not sufficient.

(c) Review.—The Trade Commission shall report every four years on repair access, support duration, waste, security, competition, and accessibility. Rules shall address actual barriers without compelling disclosure of unrelated intellectual property or undermining effective anti-theft protections.

SEC. 2413. REPAIR DISPUTES AND SECURITY EXCEPTIONS.

(a) Request.—An independent repairer or device owner requesting information, tools, or parts under this title shall identify the model and repair function. The manufacturer shall provide the required access or a specific explanation of a claimed exception within 30 days, with expedited handling where delay would foreseeably disable an essential accessibility function.

(b) Exception.—A security-based refusal shall identify the material risk and whether a less restrictive method, such as authenticated access or limitation to the particular component, would address it. A general assertion that all independent repair is unsafe is insufficient. A manufacturer need not disclose an unrelated trade secret or credential that would permit unauthorized access to other users' devices.

(c) Review.—The Trade Commission shall provide an administrative complaint route and may obtain confidential technical evidence. Public explanations may protect exploitable details while describing the legal basis for the result. A repairer remains responsible for its own workmanship and shall not falsely claim manufacturer certification. A manufacturer shall not void unrelated warranty coverage solely because a lawful independent repair occurred.

TITLE XXV—WORKFORCE TRANSITIONS AND RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION

SEC. 2501. COMMUNICATIONS WORKFORCE PROGRAM.

(a) Program.—The Secretary of Labor, in consultation with the Secretary, shall administer grants within title XXIX for training in network construction, maintenance, cybersecurity, accessibility, media production technology, and other skills directly necessary to implement this Act.

(b) Eligibility.—Eligible recipients include community colleges, registered apprenticeship sponsors, labor-management partnerships, Tribal institutions, nonprofit training organizations, and qualified employer consortia. Selection shall consider demonstrated demand, completion, placement quality, and capacity to serve workers facing barriers.

(c) Limits.—A grant shall not merely reimburse an employer for routine training it would otherwise provide without additional public benefit. The recipient shall identify the skill, credential where relevant, training cost, employer participation, and pathway to actual work. No political or ideological test may be imposed on trainees.

SEC. 2502. APPRENTICESHIPS AND PRACTICAL TRAINING.

(a) Quality.—Supported training shall include supervised practical experience, safety instruction, qualified instructors, and assessment of actual competence. A certificate shall not be issued solely for attendance when the work requires demonstrated skill.

(b) Compensation.—Work performed by trainees shall comply with applicable wage and labor law. A program shall not displace regular workers with unpaid labor under the label of education.

(c) Portability.—Credentials shall be reasonably portable across employers and technologies where the underlying skills are transferable. A recipient shall disclose whether a credential is recognized by employers and whether additional licensing is required. It shall not impose an unreasonable repayment clause that traps a worker in employment after completion, and any lawful training repayment shall reflect actual, disclosed cost rather than a penalty for leaving.

SEC. 2503. SAFETY IN DEPLOYMENT AND MAINTENANCE.

(a) Requirements.—Recipients and contractors shall comply with applicable occupational safety standards for pole work, excavation, confined spaces, electrical hazards, traffic, heat, and remote operations. Safety costs shall be included in project budgets.

(b) Authority To Stop.—Workers shall have a clear process to report and stop work presenting an imminent serious hazard, consistent with applicable law. A contractor shall not retaliate for a good-faith safety report.

(c) Oversight.—Grant administrators shall verify safety qualifications and investigate credible patterns of violations. A serious violation may support corrective action or suspension after appropriate process. Procurement shall not reward an unrealistically low bid made possible by omitting legally required safety measures. Agencies shall coordinate with the competent labor authority rather than creating conflicting technical standards without expertise.

SEC. 2504. DISPLACEMENT AND TECHNOLOGY TRANSITIONS.

(a) Planning.—A recipient undertaking a publicly financed transition that materially changes workforce needs shall prepare a plan addressing retraining, redeployment, notice, and continuity of essential operational knowledge.

(b) Support.—Eligible workers may receive training, career counseling, and limited supportive services within the workforce appropriation. Assistance shall not depend on agreement with an employer's position concerning a labor dispute.

(c) Limits.—This section does not guarantee every existing job indefinitely or prohibit productivity-enhancing technology. It requires responsible planning for publicly financed change and preserves applicable collective bargaining and worker-notice rights. An employer shall not claim a public training subsidy while concealing that the corresponding positions are scheduled for elimination without a credible alternative placement plan.

SEC. 2505. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN COVERED OPERATIONS.

(a) Accountability.—A covered entity remains responsible for compliance when using an automated system for billing, eligibility, network management, advertising, or customer support. The system's output is not a defense to a violation that the entity's reasonable controls should have prevented.

(b) Review.—High-impact uses shall have documented testing, error correction, human escalation, and monitoring proportionate to risk. A customer shall be told when an automated process makes a material commercial decision and how to contest a factual error.

(c) Limits.—This section does not regulate every use of artificial intelligence or require disclosure of proprietary model weights. It addresses the covered function and outcome. Creative use of artificial intelligence remains subject to the specific disclosure, identity, copyright, and contract provisions of this Act and other law.

SEC. 2506. EMPLOYMENT AND CONTRACTOR DATA.

(a) Minimization.—A recipient shall collect worker information only as reasonably necessary for employment, safety, training, grant verification, or another lawful purpose. Program reporting shall use aggregate data where individual records are unnecessary.

(b) Monitoring.—A publicly funded workplace-monitoring system shall disclose its purpose, information collected, access, retention, and material consequences. It shall not be used to retaliate against protected labor activity or to infer unrelated sensitive traits.

(c) Rights.—Workers shall have a reasonable means to correct material errors in records used to deny training, payment, or placement. Existing employment privacy, labor, and civil-rights laws remain applicable. This section does not authorize access to private communications merely because a person uses a device supplied through a workforce program.

SEC. 2507. REGIONAL TRAINING CAPACITY.

(a) Planning.—The Secretary of Labor shall identify regions where deployment, resilience, and accessibility projects face a documented shortage of qualified workers. Grants may support shared training equipment, instructors, travel, childcare, and other necessary participation costs.

(b) Coordination.—Training shall be coordinated with actual project schedules and employers without guaranteeing a particular employer a captive workforce. Smaller providers and independent production businesses shall have a practical opportunity to participate.

(c) Evaluation.—A recipient shall report completion, credential attainment, placement, wages, retention, and participant experience, with privacy safeguards. Placement in unstable or unrelated work shall not be represented as successful placement in the trained occupation. The agency shall adjust funding when repeated evidence shows a program is not producing useful skills or employment opportunities.

SEC. 2508. INCLUSIVE ACCESS TO TRAINING.

(a) Access.—Programs shall provide reasonable accommodation, accessible materials, and recruitment that reaches rural, Tribal, low-income, displaced, and disabled workers. Selection shall use job-related criteria and comply with civil-rights law.

(b) Barriers.—A recipient shall evaluate whether unnecessary degree requirements, inaccessible testing, transportation, or scheduling excludes capable applicants. It may use competency-based admission and prior-learning assessment where appropriate.

(c) Protection.—Participants shall receive clear information about cost, stipends, time commitment, credential value, and expected employment. A program shall not charge an undisclosed fee or require purchase from an affiliated vendor without justification. Complaints shall be available outside the immediate instructor or employer when that person is the subject of the complaint.

SEC. 2509. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT SUPPORT.

(a) Projects.—Within the research appropriation, the Secretary may support communications resilience, accessible interfaces, privacy-preserving measurement, efficient deployment, open technical standards, and other applied research directly related to this Act.

(b) Selection.—Awards shall use peer review and conflict safeguards, with opportunities for small firms, universities, nonprofits, and Tribal institutions. A proposal shall identify technical milestones, potential public benefit, and a realistic path to use.

(c) Rights.—Award terms shall allocate intellectual-property and data rights before acceptance, consistent with applicable Federal research law. Public funding shall not automatically transfer all background intellectual property to the Government. Conversely, a recipient shall not conceal a publicly financed result through a contract inconsistent with the agreed dissemination and access requirements.

SEC. 2510. PILOTS AND LIMITED REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY.

(a) Pilot.—An agency may authorize a time-limited pilot within its statutory authority to test a technical compliance method. The pilot shall identify participants, duration, safeguards, metrics, and termination conditions.

(b) Nonwaivable Duties.—A pilot may not waive fraud prohibitions, privacy rights, civil-rights duties, earned payments, or essential safety protections. Participation shall not immunize conduct outside the approved scope.

(c) Public Record.—The agency shall publish a nonconfidential explanation and results, including failures. A successful pilot does not automatically amend a rule or statute. Permanent adoption shall follow the required process and consider effects on nonparticipants. A pilot shall not become an indefinite exclusive market opportunity for a favored company.

SEC. 2511. WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION.

(a) Protected Activity.—A person performing work under a program or covered operation may report a reasonably believed violation, refuse an unlawful instruction, cooperate with an authorized investigation, or provide information to Congress without retaliation.

(b) Process.—A complaint of retaliation may be filed with the Secretary of Labor within 180 days after the person discovers the adverse action, subject to equitable tolling. The Secretary shall investigate and provide a hearing process consistent with existing whistleblower procedures adopted by rule.

(c) Relief.—Available relief includes reinstatement where appropriate, back pay, correction of records, compensatory damages, and reasonable fees, subject to judicial review. Protected activity does not authorize public release of classified information, theft of unrelated records, or disclosure of personal information beyond what is reasonably necessary for the lawful report.

SEC. 2512. PROGRAM REVIEW AND SAVINGS.

(a) Review.—The Comptroller General shall evaluate workforce and research programs in program years 4 and 8, including employment outcomes, safety, small-firm participation, and whether public support produced additional useful capacity.

(b) Savings.—Nothing in this title diminishes collective bargaining agreements, minimum wage, overtime, occupational safety, anti-discrimination, or worker-classification law. A recipient shall not characterize Federal funding as permission to disregard State labor protections that can simultaneously be satisfied.

(c) Funding.—Programs shall operate only within title XXIX. A training or research grant shall identify its end date and any continuing obligations. An agency shall not promise indefinite operating support to an institution merely because a capital grant was awarded, and recipients shall plan for sustainable use of equipment and results after the award ends.

TITLE XXVI—DATA EVALUATION AND PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY

SEC. 2601. COMMON PERFORMANCE FRAMEWORK.

(a) Framework.—The Secretary, Commission, and Trade Commission shall establish a common performance framework for programs and duties under this Act. The framework shall distinguish infrastructure availability, practical serviceability, subscription, sustained use, affordability, reliability, accessibility, competition, privacy, and public expenditure.

(b) Definitions.—A location shall not be counted as connected merely because a grant was awarded, a cable passes nearby, or a provider claims theoretical coverage. A subscriber shall not be counted as a successful long-term adoption solely because an account was opened. A complaint shall not be counted as resolved solely because it was administratively closed.

(c) Publication.—Definitions, collection methods, revisions, and limitations shall be published before the corresponding measures are used to evaluate performance. Agencies shall retain comparable historical series where feasible and explain breaks in methodology. The framework shall not create new substantive duties beyond this Act through a reporting definition.

SEC. 2602. BASELINES AND TARGETS.

(a) Baseline.—Before a major program begins disbursement, the administering agency shall establish a baseline using the best reasonably available evidence. Where reliable data are unavailable, the agency shall identify the gap and a plan to correct it rather than invent a precise baseline.

(b) Targets.—Program targets shall specify the outcome, population, period, measurement method, and responsible office. Targets shall account for geography, technology, and starting conditions and shall not encourage recipients to avoid the hardest-to-serve persons merely to improve an average.

(c) Review.—A target may be revised when evidence materially changes, but the agency shall preserve the original target and explain the revision. A missed target shall prompt diagnosis and corrective action rather than automatic concealment, arbitrary punishment, or repeal of unrelated rights. A target is not itself a private entitlement unless another provision expressly creates one.

SEC. 2603. PRICE AND AFFORDABILITY DATA.

(a) Collection.—The Commission shall collect representative information on actual total prices paid for connectivity, including mandatory equipment, fees, promotional expiration, and usage charges. The Trade Commission shall collect comparable evidence for covered media and entertainment transactions where necessary to evaluate this Act.

(b) Methods.—Collection may use anonymized billing samples, representative surveys, provider filings, and controlled market observations. Agencies shall distinguish advertised offers from actual payments and shall disclose whether a sample is representative or voluntary.

(c) Protection.—No public dataset shall identify an individual household's account, precise viewing history, or financial hardship. Provider-specific aggregate data may be published when necessary for accountability and consistent with lawful confidentiality protections. An agency shall assess reidentification risk before releasing granular geographic information and shall not assume removal of names alone makes a record anonymous.

SEC. 2604. RELIABILITY AND OUTAGE MEASURES.

(a) Measures.—Reliability reporting shall include affected users or locations, duration, customer-minutes of interruption where appropriate, emergency-call impact, restoration time, cause, and recurrence. Reports shall distinguish planned maintenance from unplanned failure and shall identify material exclusions.

(b) Comparability.—The Commission shall adopt methods that permit comparison across providers without ignoring differences in technology and geography. A national average shall be accompanied by information sufficient to identify concentrated local failure.

(c) Validation.—Material outage claims shall be checked against operational records and credible customer evidence. A provider shall not reset an outage clock through a brief, nonfunctional restoration or exclude affected customers because they could not submit a complaint. Public reports shall protect sensitive network details while permitting assessment of whether the provider maintained and restored the service it promised.

SEC. 2605. COMPETITION AND CHOICE.

(a) Practical Alternatives.—Competition measures shall identify independently controlled alternatives actually available at the customer's location, including installation cost, performance, switching barriers, and material shared bottlenecks. Multiple reseller brands dependent on one essential facility shall not automatically be counted as equivalent to independent facilities competition.

(b) Entry.—Agencies shall measure entry, exit, expansion, wholesale access, and the durability of remedies. A merger divestiture shall not be counted as successful solely because assets changed legal ownership.

(c) Limits.—A concentration measure is evidence, not a complete legal conclusion. Reports shall consider substitution, efficiencies, innovation, local conditions, and the relevant legal standard. Agencies shall not equate a broad audience with unlawful market power or use a market study to penalize a publisher's editorial popularity.

SEC. 2606. PRIVACY AND ACCESSIBILITY OUTCOMES.

(a) Privacy.—Evaluation shall examine whether individuals can exercise rights, whether preference signals are honored, whether sensitive information is minimized, and whether incidents lead to effective remediation. Counting privacy notices alone is insufficient.

(b) Accessibility.—Evaluation shall include completion of representative tasks by persons with relevant disabilities, quality of captions and descriptions, accessible emergency delivery, and time to correct barriers. An automated conformance score shall not substitute for functional testing when it fails to capture practical access.

(c) Participation.—Affected individuals shall have opportunities to contribute evidence without exposing unnecessary medical or personal information. Agencies may compensate research participants reasonably within appropriations. Findings shall distinguish isolated defects from systemic failures and shall identify the responsible function when a barrier arises across multiple providers or devices.

SEC. 2607. DATA QUALITY AND CORRECTION.

(a) Responsibility.—Each agency shall designate a data-quality official responsible for validation, documentation, correction, and coordination. The official shall maintain a public correction process and an internal record of material changes.

(b) Errors.—When a material error affects a grant, enforcement decision, or public report, the agency shall assess the consequence, correct the record, and notify affected persons. A correction shall not erase the historical version without an audit trail.

(c) Provider Filings.—A person submitting required information shall use reasonable controls to ensure accuracy and certify that material representations are supported. Innocent error shall receive a proportionate correction opportunity; knowing falsification is subject to title XXVII and other applicable law. Agencies shall not demand precision beyond what a method can reasonably produce without disclosing uncertainty.

SEC. 2608. RESEARCH INDEPENDENCE.

(a) Design.—An evaluation shall use methods appropriate to the question, including comparison groups, longitudinal analysis, experiments where ethical and feasible, and qualitative evidence where needed. The method shall be selected before results are known when practicable.

(b) Disclosure.—Reports shall identify funding, conflicts, sample design, response rates, assumptions, missing data, and limitations. A conclusion about causation shall state the basis for that inference. A stakeholder submission shall be identified as advocacy or supplied evidence rather than independently verified fact unless verification occurred.

(c) Publication.—An agency shall not suppress a completed evaluation because its findings are unfavorable to the program or an official. Lawful confidentiality review may protect sensitive information but shall not alter the substantive conclusion. Researchers shall retain the ability to report methodological disagreement through appropriate channels.

SEC. 2609. DATA ACCESS FOR OVERSIGHT.

(a) Access.—The Comptroller General and inspectors general shall receive timely access to records necessary for authorized oversight, subject to applicable privileges and lawful handling requirements. A contract shall not prevent a Federal agency from providing records it is legally required to produce.

(b) Secure Environments.—Sensitive data may be examined through controlled environments, deidentification, or protective agreements when those methods permit effective oversight. A claim of confidentiality shall not categorically bar examination of the evidence underlying public payments.

(c) Accountability.—Access shall be logged and limited to the authorized purpose. Oversight bodies shall avoid unnecessary public disclosure of personal information, exploitable vulnerabilities, and trade secrets. Disputes over access shall follow applicable law rather than being resolved by a private vendor's unilateral refusal.

SEC. 2610. PUBLIC DASHBOARDS.

(a) Contents.—Agencies shall maintain accessible public dashboards showing appropriations, obligations, disbursements, completed projects, verified outcomes, defaults, recoveries, and major implementation milestones. Each measure shall identify its date, definition, and limitations.

(b) Usability.—Dashboards shall provide downloadable data and plain-language explanations. They shall function on ordinary devices and low-bandwidth connections and shall not require commercial tracking or account creation for public information.

(c) Integrity.—An agency shall not present an obligated amount as money already spent, a completed construction segment as an activated customer, or a preliminary estimate as an audited result. Material revisions shall be visible. A visually attractive dashboard does not satisfy a reporting duty when the underlying information is incomplete, incomparable, or misleading.

SEC. 2611. CONFIDENTIALITY AND REIDENTIFICATION.

(a) Assessment.—Before publishing granular data, an agency shall assess whether combination with reasonably available information could identify a household, reveal sensitive activity, or expose a critical vulnerability.

(b) Methods.—The agency may aggregate, suppress small cells, perturb data, or provide controlled access, provided it explains the effect on utility and avoids falsely representing altered data as exact observations. Privacy methods shall be documented sufficiently for informed interpretation.

(c) Prohibition.—A recipient of restricted research data shall not attempt reidentification or use the data for advertising, eligibility denial, law enforcement, or unrelated commercial purposes unless separately authorized by law and the governing agreement. Violations may result in loss of access, recovery, and civil remedies under title XXVII. Lawful whistleblowing and oversight are preserved.

SEC. 2612. REPORTING BURDEN AND REUSE.

(a) Coordination.—Agencies shall inventory required reports and eliminate duplicative requests where one reliable submission can satisfy multiple lawful needs. A shared definition shall not be adopted merely for administrative convenience if it obscures an important substantive distinction.

(b) Small Entities.—Reporting frequency and detail shall be proportionate to size and risk. Small entities may use standardized templates, reasonable estimates identified as such, and shared technical services, except where precise transaction records are necessary to verify payments or remedy harm.

(c) Review.—Every three years, agencies shall evaluate whether collected fields are actually used. Unused sensitive fields shall be removed unless a documented legal or operational need remains. A reporting requirement shall not become an indefinite data collection simply because a legacy system contains the field.

SEC. 2613. FISCAL EVALUATION.

(a) Separation.—Reports shall distinguish Federal budget effects, private compliance cost, consumer savings, transfers among parties, and broader economic benefits. A transfer from a provider to a customer is not automatically a net social gain, and a productivity benefit is not automatically a Federal revenue offset.

(b) Time.—Estimates shall state the price year, nominal or real basis, discount method where used, horizon, and sensitivity to participation, inflation, technology, and behavior. A 30-year arithmetic extension shall not be presented as a precise forecast.

(c) Score.—Official congressional scoring remains the responsibility of the Congressional Budget Office and, where appropriate, the Joint Committee on Taxation. An agency estimate does not substitute for those scores. This Act does not direct either office to assume savings unsupported by its independent analysis.

SEC. 2614. PUBLIC PREFERENCE RESEARCH.

(a) Surveys.—Agencies evaluating public preferences shall use representative methods where feasible and disclose wording, sampling, weighting, and uncertainty. A survey of users of one service shall not automatically represent all residents.

(b) Distinctions.—Research shall distinguish preference for lower prices, privacy, local news, convenience, or advertising-supported service from endorsement of a particular regulatory classification, ownership limit, or funding mechanism.

(c) Use.—Public preferences may inform implementation within statutory authority but shall not override constitutional rights or serve as a plebiscite on whether unpopular expression should be protected. Agencies shall consider the needs of groups poorly represented in ordinary online surveys, including persons without reliable connectivity, without treating anecdotal testimony as statistically representative evidence.

SEC. 2615. INDEPENDENT FIVE YEAR REVIEW.

(a) Review.—At the end of program year 5, the Comptroller General shall submit a comprehensive evaluation of this Act to Congress. The evaluation shall assess outcomes, implementation, spending, legal disputes, market effects, and distribution of benefits and burdens.

(b) Questions.—The evaluation shall ask whether total cost fell, reliable access expanded, switching improved, public funds produced sustained service, smaller firms could comply, and lawful expression remained protected. It shall identify provisions that did not operate as intended and explain why.

(c) Response.—Within 180 days, implementing agencies shall respond with actions within existing authority and recommendations requiring legislation. Failure of one program shall not automatically suspend unrelated consumer rights. A recommendation to repeal or expand a duty shall address the consequences for persons who rely on it.

SEC. 2616. RECORD PRESERVATION AND PUBLIC MEMORY.

(a) Records.—Agencies shall preserve final rules, material versions, award decisions, evaluation methods, and public datasets according to Federal records law. Records shall remain identifiable when a website or contractor changes.

(b) Access.—Historical records shall be labeled with their operative period and shall not be confused with current guidance. A correction shall preserve the original record where legally appropriate and explain the change.

(c) Limits.—Preservation shall not require indefinite retention of unnecessary personal information. Agencies shall distinguish institutional records from raw personal data and apply lawful disposal schedules. A program's termination shall include transfer of necessary records to an authorized custodian so that future oversight can determine what was funded, promised, delivered, and corrected.

TITLE XXVII—ENFORCEMENT REMEDIES AND JUDICIAL REVIEW

SEC. 2701. GENERAL ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY.

(a) Allocation.—Each agency assigned administration of a title may investigate violations, issue rules within the express delegation, seek voluntary correction, and initiate the civil enforcement authorized by this title. The agency shall identify the specific provision violated and shall not derive an independent penalty from a statement of purpose.

(b) Commission.—The Commission may issue prospective compliance orders within its technical and licensing jurisdiction after required process. It shall refer actions seeking civil penalties or compulsory monetary relief under this Act to the Attorney General for filing in Federal district court.

(c) Trade Commission.—The Trade Commission may bring a civil action in Federal district court to enforce duties expressly assigned to it, including seeking the remedies authorized here, notwithstanding limitations that would otherwise prevent recovery of such monetary relief under a general provision of the Federal Trade Commission Act. This authority is specific to violations of this Act.

SEC. 2702. INVESTIGATIVE PROCESS.

(a) Demands.—An agency may require relevant documents, written responses, and testimony through a civil investigative demand identifying the investigation, statutory basis, categories sought, reasonable response period, and right to petition to modify or set aside the demand.

(b) Proportionality.—A demand shall be reasonably related to a suspected violation, proportionate to the matter, and coordinated with other agency demands where feasible. It shall not require disclosure of unrelated editorial deliberations, privileged communications, or personal information unnecessary to the investigation.

(c) Enforcement.—A contested demand shall be enforced only by a court with jurisdiction. The respondent may assert privilege, undue burden, relevance, and constitutional objections. Preservation of relevant evidence may be required, but an agency shall not use a broad preservation demand to impose indefinite retention of all customer activity without a particularized basis.

SEC. 2703. NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND.

(a) Notice.—Before issuing a final adverse administrative order, an agency shall provide the alleged violation, material facts, proposed relief, legal basis, and a reasonable opportunity to respond. A person shall have access to evidence necessary for a fair defense, subject to protective procedures.

(b) Hearing.—Where material adjudicative facts are genuinely disputed and the proposed order substantially affects a license, access right, or continuing business operation, the agency shall provide the hearing required by applicable law and this Act. A staff conclusion is not a substitute for a reasoned decision by an authorized official.

(c) Decision.—The final order shall address material defenses, identify findings and evidence, explain the remedy, and state review rights. A settlement involving one person shall not silently impose binding obligations on nonparties. Agencies shall publish nonconfidential decisions sufficient to provide fair notice of their interpretation.

SEC. 2704. CORRECTION AND VOLUNTARY RESOLUTION.

(a) Opportunity.—For a first nonwillful technical or paperwork violation causing no material injury, an agency shall ordinarily offer a reasonable correction period before seeking a civil penalty. The period shall identify the required correction and evidence of completion.

(b) Exclusions.—No mandatory correction opportunity applies to intentional deception, discrimination, concealment, unauthorized charges, misuse of sensitive information, retaliation, repeated violations, or a substantial safety threat. Correction does not eliminate restitution for money unlawfully obtained.

(c) Settlement.—A settlement shall identify the conduct resolved, relief, compliance obligations, and scope of any release. It shall not require political contributions, favorable publicity, or unrelated editorial concessions. A confidential settlement may protect lawful interests but shall not conceal the existence of a material public enforcement resolution when disclosure is required by law.

SEC. 2705. CIVIL ACTIONS AND COURT AUTHORITY.

(a) Jurisdiction.—The district courts of the United States have jurisdiction over civil actions authorized by this title, without regard to the amount in controversy. Venue lies where a defendant resides or transacts substantial relevant business, or where a substantial part of the conduct or injury occurred, subject to ordinary jurisdictional requirements.

(b) Relief.—A court may grant declaratory and injunctive relief, restitution, refunds, compensatory damages where authorized, disgorgement of net profits attributable to a violation, and civil penalties as specified. Relief shall be causally connected to the violation and shall not duplicate recovery for the same loss.

(c) Jury.—The right to trial by jury shall be preserved to the extent required by the Seventh Amendment or other law. Contested civil penalties under this Act shall be imposed by a court, not finally adjudicated by an agency. Nothing directs a court to treat a legal claim as equitable merely because the complaint uses that label.

SEC. 2706. PUBLIC CIVIL PENALTIES.

(a) Amounts.—For a violation occurring after the applicable effective date, a court may impose a civil penalty not exceeding $25,000 per material violation, or $100,000 for a knowing or reckless violation. The amounts shall be adjusted annually for inflation beginning two years after enactment.

(b) Unit.—A substantially continuous course of the same conduct affecting the same person during one billing period shall ordinarily constitute one violation. Each impression, packet, view, or automated repetition is not automatically a separate violation. A court may treat distinct affected persons or independently chosen acts separately when proportionate to the conduct.

(c) Factors.—The court shall consider gravity, duration, culpability, injury, benefit obtained, ability to pay, cooperation, correction, prior violations, and deterrence. A penalty shall not be imposed solely because an interpretation was reasonably disputed before adequate notice. Constitutional limits on excessive fines and due process apply.

SEC. 2707. AGGREGATE PENALTY LIMITS.

(a) Ordinary Limit.—For a single coordinated course of conduct in one civil action, aggregate penalties shall not exceed the greater of $10,000,000 or two percent of the defendant's United States revenue from the affected covered function during the preceding fiscal year.

(b) Small Entities.—For a small entity, the ordinary aggregate limit is $500,000 or two percent of such covered revenue, whichever is greater. The court may exceed that limit up to the general limit upon clear and convincing evidence of intentional fraud, knowing exploitation of sensitive information, or deliberate conduct creating a substantial threat to life.

(c) Other Relief.—These limits do not cap restitution, proven compensatory damages, or relief under another independently applicable statute. They do prevent agencies from dividing one coordinated action into multiple proceedings principally to evade the limit. A court shall coordinate overlapping public penalty claims where necessary to avoid disproportionate duplication.

SEC. 2708. RESTITUTION AND DISGORGEMENT.

(a) Restitution.—A court may order return of money or property obtained through a violation, including unauthorized subscription charges, unsupported fees, undelivered advertising payments, and withheld earned compensation. The order shall identify eligible recipients and a practical distribution method.

(b) Disgorgement.—Disgorgement shall be limited to net profits causally attributable to the violation, with reasonable deductions established by the defendant, except that illegitimate expenses need not be credited. It shall not become an unrelated revenue-based punishment.

(c) Distribution.—Recovered consumer funds shall be distributed promptly where feasible. Administrative costs shall be reasonable and disclosed. Unclaimed amounts shall be handled according to a court-approved plan and applicable law; they shall not be donated to a favored organization without a lawful basis. Defendants shall receive credit for verified refunds already paid for the same injury.

SEC. 2709. PRIVATE RIGHTS OF ACTION.

(a) Authorization.—A person suffering concrete injury from violation of an individual right under titles III, IV, VIII, IX, XIII, XIV, XVI, XVII, XIX, XX, XXIII, or XXIV may bring a civil action against the responsible covered person. This authorization concerns duties owed to the plaintiff, not general agency reporting, grant-selection, or policy-planning duties.

(b) Relief.—The plaintiff may seek actual damages, appropriate declaratory or injunctive relief, and statutory damages where section 2710 or another specific provision permits. The plaintiff shall establish causation and the elements of the underlying duty.

(c) Limits.—A procedural omission without concrete injury does not alone establish Federal standing. An individual may not sue merely because the individual disagrees with lawful editorial content or a public policy choice. This section does not waive sovereign immunity of the United States, a State, or a Tribe for monetary damages.

SEC. 2710. PRIVATE STATUTORY DAMAGES.

(a) Eligible Violations.—For an unauthorized monetary charge, knowing denial of a cancellation or refund right, knowing unlawful disclosure of sensitive information, or intentional denial of an accessibility or nondiscrimination right, an injured plaintiff may elect statutory damages in place of actual damages for the same injury.

(b) Range.—The court may award $250 to $2,500 per materially distinct violation, considering harm, culpability, duration, correction, and proportionality. Aggregate statutory damages for one plaintiff arising from the same substantially continuous practice during a 12-month period shall not exceed $10,000, except as provided for digital replicas in section 1707.

(c) Safeguards.—Statutory damages require concrete injury and shall not be multiplied by individual packets, views, or automated repetitions. They shall not be added to actual damages for the same injury. A court may award up to three times actual damages for intentional fraud or discrimination when necessary to deter serious misconduct, but shall not stack that enhancement with statutory damages for the same loss.

SEC. 2711. ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS.

(a) Prevailing Plaintiff.—A court may award reasonable attorney fees and costs to a prevailing private plaintiff where necessary to make enforcement practical, considering degree of success and the reasonableness of the litigation.

(b) Defendant.—A prevailing defendant may receive fees only upon a finding that the action was frivolous, brought in bad faith, or continued after the plaintiff should reasonably have known it lacked a basis. Mere failure to prevail on a difficult legal question is insufficient.

(c) Access.—A contract shall not require a customer to pay a provider's fees automatically whenever the customer loses a statutory claim. Courts retain authority to sanction abusive litigation under otherwise applicable rules. Fee awards shall not reward unnecessary duplication of work or create a disproportionate recovery unrelated to the effort reasonably required.

SEC. 2712. STATE AND TRIBAL ENFORCEMENT.

(a) States.—A State attorney general may bring a civil action in Federal district court on behalf of residents to enforce the same substantive duties and seek relief authorized for public enforcement. The State shall notify the responsible Federal agency before filing, except where delay would materially prejudice emergency relief.

(b) Coordination.—The Federal agency may intervene and be heard but may not extinguish an otherwise lawful State action merely by opening an investigation. Courts may coordinate proceedings to avoid inconsistent orders and duplicate recovery.

(c) Tribes.—A Tribal government may bring an action on behalf of persons within its lawful jurisdiction to the same extent authorized here, subject to ordinary jurisdictional requirements. Participation does not waive Tribal immunity in unrelated matters. This section does not authorize a State to enforce its law against a Tribe where otherwise barred by Federal law.

SEC. 2713. ARBITRATION AND CONTRACTUAL WAIVERS.

(a) Election.—Notwithstanding chapter 1 of title 9, United States Code, a predispute arbitration agreement or predispute waiver of joint, class, or representative proceedings is not enforceable at the election of a person asserting a claim under this Act arising from a consumer, small-business, or individual-creator contract.

(b) Postdispute Agreement.—After a dispute arises, parties may voluntarily agree to arbitration or settlement through a separate informed agreement identifying the dispute and material procedures. A refusal shall not result in retaliation or loss of an unrelated service.

(c) Scope.—This section applies only to claims under this Act and does not broadly invalidate an agreement for unrelated claims. A court shall decide applicability notwithstanding a delegation clause. A contract shall not waive substantive rights, shorten limitations periods below this title, or impose a distant forum principally to make an otherwise valid claim impracticable.

SEC. 2714. LIMITATIONS PERIODS.

(a) Private Claims.—A private action shall be filed within four years after the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should discover the violation and injury, and no later than eight years after the conduct, except for fraudulent concealment, incapacity, or another applicable tolling rule.

(b) Public Penalties.—An action for a civil penalty shall be filed within five years after the violation, subject to tolling for concealment and other applicable law. A continuing violation does not revive a completed, independently time-barred act merely because its effects remain.

(c) Administrative Process.—A timely required administrative complaint tolls the relevant period while review is pending and for 90 days after final disposition. Voluntary customer support does not require exhaustion before a private suit unless a specific provision expressly requires it. The court may encourage informal resolution without depriving a party of timely judicial relief.

SEC. 2715. EMERGENCY AND INTERIM ORDERS.

(a) Standard.—An agency may issue an interim technical order only where a specific title authorizes it and evidence shows an imminent substantial threat to safety, essential service, or the effective preservation of a lawful remedy.

(b) Process.—An ex parte order shall state its factual basis, scope, and expiration and shall provide a hearing opportunity within seven days. Continued relief requires findings after an opportunity to respond. The affected person may seek immediate judicial review.

(c) Limits.—An interim order shall be the least restrictive effective measure reasonably available, protect lawful expression, and preserve security. It may not impose a final monetary penalty, seize unrelated property, or compel permanent publication. A court may stay, modify, or dissolve the order under the applicable legal standard and may require protection against foreseeable harm from an erroneous order.

SEC. 2716. JUDICIAL REVIEW OF RULES AND ORDERS.

(a) Review.—Final Commission rules and orders under this Act shall be reviewed under the otherwise applicable provisions of section 402 of the Communications Act of 1934 and chapter 158 of title 28, United States Code, unless a specific provision assigns district-court review. Final actions of other agencies shall be reviewable under the Administrative Procedure Act and applicable jurisdictional statutes.

(b) Law.—Courts shall exercise independent judgment on questions of statutory interpretation as required by law. Nothing requires deference to an agency solely because the statute contains an ambiguity.

(c) Record And Relief.—The agency shall provide the administrative record, including material contrary evidence. Courts retain authority to grant appropriate stays and relief. A procedural error shall be assessed under applicable prejudicial-error principles. This Act does not direct a court to uphold an unconstitutional provision or to disregard a controlling judgment.

SEC. 2717. GOVERNMENT DEFENDANTS AND SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY.

(a) Federal Action.—Existing waivers of sovereign immunity for nonmonetary review of Federal agency action remain available. This Act authorizes no private monetary damages against the United States or its officers absent another express waiver.

(b) States And Tribes.—No general abrogation of State or Tribal sovereign immunity is enacted. A State or Tribe accepting a new grant may agree expressly to a limited contractual forum and repayment process stated before acceptance, but acceptance shall not imply consent to unrelated private damages actions.

(c) Prospective Relief.—Otherwise available prospective relief against an official for an ongoing violation of Federal law is preserved. Commercial duties expressly applicable to a public provider may be enforced through lawful Federal mechanisms without requiring an unauthorized private damages action. A court shall determine immunity and jurisdiction before awarding relief.

SEC. 2718. RETALIATION AND EVIDENCE PRESERVATION.

(a) Retaliation.—A covered person shall not materially disadvantage an individual for making a good-faith complaint, exercising a right, participating in an investigation, or providing lawful testimony. Legitimate action for an independent reason remains permissible.

(b) Evidence.—After receiving a credible notice of a dispute, a person shall preserve relevant existing records for a reasonable period while the dispute is pending. The duty shall be proportionate and shall not require creation or indefinite retention of unrelated personal data.

(c) Sanctions.—Intentional destruction or falsification of material evidence may support appropriate judicial sanctions and remedies under existing law. A routine deletion completed before a preservation duty arose is not automatically spoliation. Agencies shall provide clear preservation instructions and shall not exploit uncertainty to impose disproportionate penalties.

SEC. 2719. COORDINATION AND DOUBLE RECOVERY.

(a) Coordination.—Agencies and public enforcers shall coordinate claims concerning the same conduct, identify overlapping relief, and notify the court of related proceedings. A defendant shall not be required to pay the same restitution twice.

(b) Distinct Harms.—Relief for distinct injuries, separate victims, or independently prohibited conduct may coexist. A civil penalty serves a different purpose from compensation, but aggregate sanctions remain subject to proportionality and constitutional limits.

(c) Settlements.—A public settlement shall not release a private claim without lawful authority and appropriate process. A private settlement shall not extinguish the Government's independent enforcement power. Courts shall examine whether a proposed class settlement fairly compensates affected persons and does not exchange a broad release for illusory coupons or inaccessible procedures.

SEC. 2720. ENFORCEMENT TRANSPARENCY.

(a) Report.—Each enforcing agency shall publish annual aggregate data on complaints, investigations, corrections, court actions, penalties assessed and collected, restitution distributed, repeat violations, and unresolved matters, with confidentiality safeguards.

(b) Quality.—The report shall distinguish an allegation from a finding, an assessed penalty from a collected amount, and a closed complaint from a corrected harm. It shall identify material resource constraints and delays.

(c) Review.—The inspector general shall periodically review consistency, conflicts, retaliation claims, and use of discretion. Enforcement priorities shall be tied to statutory harm, evidence, and resources rather than partisan advantage. An agency's failure to bring a particular case does not by itself establish a private right to compel prosecution, but unlawful withholding of a nondiscretionary duty remains reviewable under applicable law.

SEC. 2721. NONMONETARY RELIEF AGAINST UNLAWFUL GOVERNMENT ACTION.

(a) Right Of Action.—A person suffering a concrete injury from government action violating section 107, the editorial-independence protections of titles XV, XXI, or XXII, or another express individual right in this Act may seek appropriate declaratory or prospective injunctive relief against the responsible Federal agency or officer. The United States waives sovereign immunity for that nonmonetary relief to the same extent and subject to the same limitations as section 702 of title 5, United States Code.

(b) Forum.—A challenge to a final Commission rule or order shall proceed in the reviewing court designated by section 2716. Other claims under this section may proceed in Federal district court with jurisdiction, subject to applicable exhaustion, finality, standing, and equitable requirements. This section does not authorize duplicative litigation to evade an exclusive statutory review route.

(c) Limits.—No monetary damages against a government are authorized by this section. Prospective relief concerning State officials remains subject to the Constitution and otherwise applicable immunity doctrine. A remedy shall address the unlawful condition or action without directing a preferred editorial outcome or granting the claimant an automatic entitlement to a discretionary license, grant, or contract.

TITLE XXVIII—FEDERALISM TRANSITION AND CONTINUITY

SEC. 2801. FEDERAL FLOOR.

(a) General Rule.—Except where this Act expressly establishes an exclusive Federal standard, a State or local law providing equal or greater protection for consumers, privacy, civil rights, workers, accessibility, property, or public safety is preserved.

(b) Conflict.—A State requirement is preempted only to the extent simultaneous compliance with an express Federal duty is impossible or Congress has expressly displaced the particular requirement. The existence of Federal regulation, permission to engage in conduct, or a preference for national uniformity is not alone sufficient.

(c) Application.—A party asserting preemption shall identify the specific conflicting duties and the scope of displacement sought. An agency shall not issue a general statement that all communications or media regulation is occupied by Federal law. Courts retain authority to determine the meaning and constitutional reach of the applicable statutes.

SEC. 2802. EXCLUSIVE TECHNICAL MATTERS.

(a) Spectrum.—Federal authority over radio-frequency allocation, harmful interference, and technical transmission standards remains governed by existing law and the express provisions of this Act. State and local governments may not impose a conflicting technical standard where Federal law validly occupies that field.

(b) Savings.—This section does not displace ordinary land-use, contract, consumer, environmental, or safety requirements merely because a facility uses radio. A local rule shall be evaluated according to its actual subject and effect.

(c) Coordination.—Agencies shall provide technical assistance to local governments and Tribes so that legitimate review can proceed without inconsistent engineering demands. A provider claiming technical preemption shall supply the relevant Federal standard and explain the conflict. A vague assertion that a facility is federally licensed is insufficient to resolve every local issue.

SEC. 2803. STATE ENFORCEMENT AND COOPERATION.

(a) Agreements.—Federal and State agencies may enter agreements for complaint referral, data sharing, joint investigations, and equivalent administration where authorized. Agreements shall identify responsibilities, confidentiality, costs, and termination.

(b) Limits.—An agreement shall not transfer legislative power, waive a statutory right, or make State participation mandatory without constitutional authority. A State may decline to administer a Federal program while remaining subject to valid direct regulation of its covered commercial conduct.

(c) Public Notice.—Material agreements shall be public except for protected operational details. Customers shall not be required to understand the agreement to identify where to complain. Agencies shall forward a complaint to the appropriate office and preserve the original receipt date for a deadline that would otherwise be prejudiced by reasonable misfiling.

SEC. 2804. TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY.

(a) Savings.—Nothing in this Act diminishes Tribal sovereignty, treaty rights, trust responsibilities, jurisdiction, or immunity except through an express provision unmistakably addressing the specific matter.

(b) Participation.—A Tribe may participate directly in programs for which it is eligible and need not route an application through a State unless the governing statute expressly requires that route. Consultation shall be government-to-government and shall not be replaced by a general public-comment notice.

(c) Agreements.—A voluntary agreement may specify a limited forum, access right, or repayment obligation. It shall identify the scope and duration of any waiver and shall not be construed as a general waiver. Agencies shall provide sufficient time and technical assistance for informed review, particularly where a proposed project affects land, cultural resources, or long-term infrastructure control.

SEC. 2805. EXISTING CONTRACTS.

(a) Prospective Application.—Except where expressly stated, this Act applies to conduct after the applicable effective date and to contracts entered into, renewed, or materially modified after that date. A continuing billing, privacy, or service practice is conduct occurring when performed, even if authorized by an earlier contract.

(b) Transition.—A provider shall notify affected customers of changes necessary to comply and shall not use compliance as a pretext to impose unrelated price increases or restart a minimum term. A lawful existing obligation may continue where this Act expressly preserves it.

(c) Property.—No provision transfers a vested intellectual-property right, reopens a final judgment, or cancels a completed lawful transaction by implication. Where a prospective duty materially affects a continuing arrangement, courts shall apply the express transition rule and constitutional protections. An agency shall not manufacture retroactivity through a new definition.

SEC. 2806. EXISTING GRANTS AND AWARDS.

(a) Preservation.—An award made before enactment remains governed by its lawful terms unless the recipient voluntarily accepts a modification or another statute authorizes the change. This Act does not silently add new conditions to money already accepted.

(b) Coordination.—New funds may supplement an existing project when the agency verifies distinct costs, public benefit, and compatibility with the earlier award. The recipient shall maintain an accounting that prevents duplicate reimbursement.

(c) Modification.—A voluntary modification shall identify added funds, new obligations, changed milestones, and remedies. The agency shall not threaten unrelated lawful benefits to coerce acceptance. Fraud, false claims, and breaches of existing conditions remain enforceable under the law applicable to those acts, independent of this transition protection.

SEC. 2807. COPPER RETIREMENT AND SERVICE MIGRATION.

(a) Plan.—Before retiring a network element that materially supports residential or small-business service, a provider shall assess affected customers, replacement availability, emergency calling, power dependence, accessibility, alarm and medical-device compatibility, and price.

(b) Notice.—Customers shall receive at least 180 days' notice of a planned retirement materially affecting their service, unless an emergency makes that period impracticable. Notice shall describe the replacement and assistance rather than merely state that modernization is occurring.

(c) Continuity.—A provider shall not disconnect an affected customer before a reasonably equivalent lawful substitute is available and a practical migration opportunity has been offered, subject to Commission approval of a necessary exception. The duty does not require permanent maintenance of obsolete plant, but the transition shall not leave a customer without essential service through administrative oversight.

SEC. 2808. MIGRATION ASSISTANCE.

(a) Support.—A provider undertaking a required technology transition shall offer reasonable assistance with equipment, configuration, number transfer, accessibility, and testing. It shall identify which costs are borne by the provider, customer, or an available assistance program.

(b) Testing.—The provider shall test functions specifically represented as preserved, including emergency calling and any supported legacy device. It shall not guarantee compatibility with an untested third-party device, but shall disclose known limitations and practical alternatives.

(c) Disputes.—A customer may seek expedited review of a threatened disconnection based on a materially inadequate substitute. The Commission may require temporary continuity or an alternative arrangement where feasible. Relief shall account for safety, actual costs, and the need to retire failing infrastructure rather than impose an indefinite blanket prohibition on modernization.

SEC. 2809. BUSINESS FAILURE AND SERVICE CONTINUITY.

(a) Plan.—A provider serving more than 100,000 subscribers or holding a material public-support award shall maintain a plan for orderly transfer or wind-down in the event of insolvency or cessation. The plan shall identify customer notice, data protection, number portability, emergency service, and public assets.

(b) Notice.—A planned cessation shall be reported to the relevant agency with enough time for lawful continuity measures. Confidential financial distress may receive appropriate protection, but customers shall not be misled into prepaying for service the provider knows it is unlikely to deliver.

(c) Bankruptcy.—Nothing overrides the jurisdiction of a bankruptcy court or alters creditor priorities by implication. Agencies may participate in proceedings, enforce valid grant conditions, and seek a qualified successor through lawful means. A successor shall receive clear information about obligations attached to acquired assets.

SEC. 2810. DISASTER AND EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES.

(a) Flexibility.—An agency may temporarily extend a reporting or technical deadline when a declared disaster or comparable extraordinary event makes timely compliance impracticable. The extension shall identify the affected persons, requirement, duration, and interim safeguards.

(b) Limits.—An extension shall not authorize fraud, exploitation of sensitive information, viewpoint discrimination, or retention of money for knowingly undelivered service. Core safety duties may be adapted only to the extent necessary to address the emergency.

(c) Record.—The agency shall publish a nonconfidential explanation and review the extension at least every 90 days. A temporary waiver shall expire when its factual basis ends. A provider shall not rely on an expired disaster declaration to avoid ordinary maintenance or consumer obligations indefinitely.

SEC. 2811. INTERNATIONAL AND CROSS BORDER SERVICES.

(a) Application.—Covered foreign providers shall comply with duties applicable to their purposeful United States commercial activity. Agencies shall coordinate with foreign counterparts where lawful and useful for fraud, privacy, security, and consumer redress.

(b) Conflicts.—A person facing a genuine conflict with foreign law may seek a narrowly tailored adjustment or judicial determination. It shall identify the conflicting obligation, affected information, and feasible alternatives. Foreign incorporation alone is not a defense.

(c) Rights.—An adjustment shall not authorize conduct that Congress made nonwaivable without express authority. Agencies shall avoid unnecessary extraterritorial orders and shall protect lawful expression. International cooperation shall not become a means to obtain information or suppress content that the United States Government could not lawfully obtain or restrict directly.

SEC. 2812. GENERAL EFFECTIVE DATE.

(a) Default.—Unless a provision states another date, administrative authority takes effect on enactment, rulemaking duties begin on enactment, and substantive duties on private persons take effect 24 months after enactment.

(b) Preparation.—Agencies may prepare systems, hire within appropriations, consult, issue rules, and enter conditional agreements before a substantive compliance date. They may not impose a penalty for failure to comply before that date.

(c) Notice.—An agency shall maintain a consolidated effective-date table identifying statutory dates, rule-dependent specifications, and any lawful extension. The table is informational and may not alter the statute. A conflict between an agency table and an enacted date shall be corrected promptly, with reasonable reliance considered in penalty mitigation where the person acted in good faith.

(d) Public Actors And Awards.—Unless a more specific date applies, statutory restrictions on the administration of this Act by government officials take effect upon enactment. Conditions of a new voluntary grant, contract, or benefit participation agreement apply when accepted, and shall be disclosed before acceptance. Direct commercial duties imposed on a public provider take effect on the same schedule as equivalent duties imposed on a private provider. The timing of a program launch is governed by its specific provision and available appropriations.

SEC. 2813. CONTINUITY OF LAWFUL AGENCY ACTION.

(a) Existing Rules.—A valid existing rule remains effective to the extent consistent with this Act until lawfully amended or repealed. A vacated rule is not revived merely because this Act addresses the same subject.

(b) New Authority.—When Congress supplies new authority for a previously invalidated approach, the agency shall issue a new rule under that authority and the required procedure rather than assume that the old rule automatically returns to force.

(c) Orders.—Existing licenses, adjudications, and consent decrees remain governed by their terms and applicable review mechanisms. The agency shall identify genuine conflicts and propose lawful conforming action. It shall not use a general housekeeping order to erase accrued rights or reopen final judicial decisions.

SEC. 2814. TRANSITION REVIEW.

(a) Report.—At 18, 36, and 60 months after enactment, the Council shall report on transition progress, customer disruption, implementation cost, small-entity readiness, and unresolved conflicts.

(b) Correction.—Agencies shall prioritize corrections that prevent loss of essential service, unlawful charges, inaccessible systems, or misuse of personal information. A delayed technical rule shall not justify postponing an unrelated self-executing right.

(c) Legislative Recommendations.—Where a conflict cannot be resolved within existing authority, the Council shall identify the precise statutes and policy choice requiring Congress. It shall not invent a broad power to harmonize all laws. The report shall distinguish an administrative inconvenience from a genuine legal incompatibility.

TITLE XXIX—APPROPRIATIONS AND FISCAL ADMINISTRATION

SEC. 2901. FUNDING STRUCTURE.

(a) Appropriations.—The amounts expressly appropriated in this title are appropriated out of money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated for the stated purposes and periods. They constitute budget authority only to the extent expressly stated and are not merely authorizations for future appropriations.

(b) Limits.—No program, grant, contract, benefit, or administrative action under this Act may obligate more than the available amount for its account and purpose. General program authority elsewhere in this Act does not establish an uncapped entitlement or an implied appropriation.

(c) Budget Treatment.—Amounts shall be recorded under applicable Federal budget law. This Act does not assert that the spending is deficit-neutral, provide an offset from speculative economic growth, or count previously committed auction receipts as new financing. Congressional budget enforcement and official scoring shall apply according to law.

SEC. 2902. HOUSEHOLD CONNECTIVITY ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Commission $15,000,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10 for benefits and administration under title V. Each year's amount shall remain available through the end of the following program year, subject to section 2913.

(b) Administration.—Not more than three percent of each annual amount may be used for eligibility systems, payment administration, outreach, audits, and program integrity. The Commission shall prioritize use of existing reliable systems while correcting demonstrated privacy and access defects.

(c) Benefits.—The balance shall pay verified household benefits. Scheduled benefit amounts remain subject to section 507. The Commission shall maintain a reserve sufficient to provide orderly notice of a projected shortfall, but shall not accumulate an excessive reserve while eligible households receive unnecessarily reduced benefits. A public quarterly forecast shall explain reserve assumptions and expected payments.

SEC. 2903. CONNECTIVITY EXPANSION ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Secretary $12,000,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 5 for title VI. Amounts shall remain available for obligation through the end of program year 8 and for liquidation of valid obligations through the end of program year 12.

(b) Allocation.—At least five percent shall be available for eligible Tribal projects and at least five percent for remote and extreme-cost projects. A project qualifying for both categories may be counted toward only one minimum. If a reserved amount cannot be responsibly awarded after adequate outreach and technical assistance, the Secretary may reallocate it after public findings and notice to Congress.

(c) Administration.—Not more than four percent may be used for administration, verification, and technical assistance. Awards shall include lifecycle and continuity requirements. These funds shall not reimburse costs already paid by another Federal deployment program.

SEC. 2904. RESILIENCE AND EMERGENCY ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Secretary $3,000,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 5, to remain available for obligation through program year 8, for eligible projects under titles XI and XII.

(b) Uses.—At least 60 percent shall support next-generation emergency communications and interoperability; the remainder may support critical network resilience, public emergency reception, and qualified smaller-provider security improvements. A reallocation between these categories exceeding ten percentage points requires notice to Congress and a public explanation and shall not reduce the emergency-communications share below the minimum established by this subsection.

(c) Limits.—Funds shall not finance generalized surveillance, content interception, or a new decryption capability. Security assistance shall address documented risks and shall include measurable outcomes. Not more than five percent may be used for Federal administration, testing, and technical assistance. A recipient shall identify ongoing operating costs and the source expected to meet them after the award.

SEC. 2905. DIGITAL INCLUSION AND ACCESSIBILITY ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Secretary $1,500,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10 for eligible device, navigation, community access, and accessibility projects under titles V, IX, XIV, and XX.

(b) Allocation.—At least 30 percent shall support practical disability access and accessible devices or services; at least 30 percent shall support household navigation and affordable devices; and the balance may address documented community access barriers. A single expenditure shall not be counted twice toward separate minimums.

(c) Conditions.—Awards shall use objective need and readiness criteria, prohibit commercial exploitation of participant information, and evaluate sustained use. Not more than five percent may be used for Federal administration. Each annual amount remains available through the end of the second following program year, permitting multiyear projects without creating permanent authority to spend unobligated balances.

SEC. 2906. PUBLIC MEDIA ACCESS ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Secretary $1,000,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10 for title XXI, to remain available through the end of the second following program year.

(b) Safeguards.—Funds shall be administered through the objective allocation and editorial-independence requirements of that title. No amount may be withheld or redirected because a recipient criticizes an official or declines a request for favorable coverage.

(c) Coordination.—The Secretary shall account for other Federal support and prevent duplicate reimbursement. This appropriation is independent of the appropriations or legal status of any preexisting public-broadcasting intermediary. It does not automatically revive a dissolved organization, assume its debts, or transfer its assets. Any use of an existing intermediary shall be through a lawful, transparent agreement preserving Federal accountability.

SEC. 2907. LOCAL JOURNALISM ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated to the Secretary $1,500,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10 for title XXII, to remain available through the end of the following program year.

(b) Administration.—Not more than four percent may be used for Federal administration, audits, and evaluation. The remaining amount shall support verified eligible reporting expense through the objective program formula.

(c) Limits.—An award shall not exceed the statutory per-worker, outlet, and controlled-group limits. Unused authority in one recipient's award shall not permit another recipient to exceed those limits. The Secretary shall publish aggregate distributions by geography and ownership scale while protecting personal payroll information. No appropriation under this section authorizes government control over an outlet's editorial conclusions.

SEC. 2908. WORKFORCE AND SMALL BUSINESS ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated $1,000,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10, of which $600,000,000 is to the Secretary of Labor for title XXV workforce programs and $400,000,000 is to the Secretary for title VIII technical assistance and shared resources.

(b) Availability.—Amounts remain available through the end of the second following program year. Not more than five percent of each agency's share may be used for administration. Transfers between the two shares are prohibited without subsequent legislation.

(c) Credit Limitation.—These amounts do not authorize a loan or guarantee with a subsidy cost exceeding specifically available budget authority. Any credit pilot shall comply with Federal credit law and a separate, clearly stated limitation in its award notice. Agencies shall not represent technical assistance as a promise of financing or commercial success.

SEC. 2909. RESEARCH PRESERVATION AND EVALUATION ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated $750,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10, to remain available through the end of the second following program year, allocated as follows: $350,000,000 to the Secretary for applied research and independent evaluation; $200,000,000 to the Librarian of Congress for eligible preservation and technical studies; and $200,000,000 to NIST for standards, measurement, and privacy-preserving technical assistance.

(b) Limits.—Not more than five percent of each allocation may be used for general administration. Research awards shall disclose methods, conflicts, and dissemination obligations. Preservation awards shall identify rights and access terms.

(c) Independence.—Funds shall not be conditioned on a predetermined research conclusion or used to establish a government rating of lawful political expression. An agency shall not transfer an allocation to an unrelated program merely because another account faces a shortfall.

SEC. 2910. ADMINISTRATION AND ENFORCEMENT ACCOUNT.

(a) Amount.—There is appropriated $1,250,000,000 for each of program years 1 through 10, allocated as follows: $500,000,000 to the Commission; $350,000,000 to the Trade Commission; $150,000,000 to the Department of Justice; $150,000,000 to the Department of Commerce for cross-program administration; and $100,000,000 to the Comptroller General for oversight.

(b) Uses.—Funds may support personnel, systems, technical expertise, public assistance, litigation, audits, and accessible administration necessary for this Act. They supplement rather than replace amounts specifically available for program administration, but the same cost may not be charged twice.

(c) Availability.—Each annual amount remains available through the end of the following program year. Agencies shall publish staffing and expenditure plans. The appropriation does not authorize alteration of judicial independence, appointment rules, or civil-service protections.

SEC. 2911. TOTAL AUTHORITY AND ACCOUNTING.

(a) Total.—The express appropriations in sections 2902 through 2910 provide $150,000,000,000 for household connectivity, $60,000,000,000 for deployment, $15,000,000,000 for resilience and emergency systems, $15,000,000,000 for inclusion and accessibility, $10,000,000,000 for public media, $15,000,000,000 for local journalism, $10,000,000,000 for workforce and small-business assistance, $7,500,000,000 for research and preservation, and $12,500,000,000 for administration and enforcement, totaling $295,000,000,000 in nominal budget authority over the stated program years.

(b) Controlling Text.—The individual appropriations control in the event of an arithmetic inconsistency in a summary. This total is not an estimate of outlays in a particular budget window, net deficit effects, or the value of economic benefits.

(c) Public Record.—Agencies shall report obligations and outlays separately and reconcile interagency transfers. No amount shall be described as fully spent merely because it was awarded or committed.

SEC. 2912. TRANSFERS AND REPROGRAMMING.

(a) Limit.—An agency may transfer no more than five percent among administrative subactivities within its own account when necessary to implement this Act, unless a more restrictive provision applies. It may not transfer money between the major accounts established in sections 2902 through 2910 without subsequent legislation.

(b) Notice.—A material reprogramming shall be reported to the appropriate congressional committees at least 30 days before execution, with the purpose, amount, effect on planned outcomes, and legal basis. Notice does not authorize a transfer otherwise prohibited.

(c) Emergency.—A genuinely urgent administrative reprogramming within the permitted limit may proceed with contemporaneous notice and a written explanation. Emergency authority shall not be used to finance a new substantive program, reduce a protected editorial grant for political reasons, or conceal a household-benefit shortfall.

SEC. 2913. CARRYOVER AND EXPIRATION.

(a) Availability.—Unobligated balances remain available only for the periods specified in the applicable account. Valid obligations may be liquidated according to Federal account-closing law and any express period in this title.

(b) Planning.—Agencies shall plan awards and benefits to avoid an abrupt expiration of essential service. A carryover balance may support continuity within its original purpose but shall not be treated as permanent spending authority.

(c) Notice.—At least 18 months before the final period for new obligations, an agency shall submit a wind-down or reauthorization recommendation. If Congress provides no additional authority, the agency shall stop new obligations in time to honor valid commitments within available funds. It shall not promise future appropriations or shift an unfunded Federal commitment to a household without informed choice.

SEC. 2914. FEES PENALTIES AND RECOVERIES.

(a) Fees.—This Act creates no general industry tax or universal-service assessment beyond existing law. An agency may collect an application or cost-recovery fee only where expressly authorized by another applicable statute or a specific provision of this Act.

(b) Penalties.—Civil penalties shall be deposited in the Treasury as required by law and shall not automatically finance the enforcing agency. Enforcement priorities shall not depend on generating revenue for agency operations.

(c) Recoveries.—Grant recoveries and returned overpayments shall be credited to the original account only to the extent permitted by appropriations law; otherwise they shall be deposited as miscellaneous receipts. Restitution held for injured persons shall be separately accounted for and distributed under the court order. Agencies shall not count uncertain future recoveries as available budget authority.

SEC. 2915. FINANCIAL CONTROLS.

(a) Controls.—Each agency shall maintain controls for eligibility, payment authorization, segregation of duties, reconciliation, improper-payment detection, and audit. A contractor may perform ministerial functions but final spending decisions shall remain with an authorized Federal officer.

(b) Records.—Recipients shall retain financial and performance records for seven years after final payment, or longer when an active audit, litigation hold, or other law requires. Records shall protect personal information and permit examination of material related-party transactions.

(c) Certification.—A responsible recipient official shall certify the accuracy of material payment claims to the best of the official's knowledge after reasonable inquiry. The certification does not create strict personal liability for every subordinate error. Knowing false statements and claims remain subject to applicable civil and criminal law.

SEC. 2916. BUDGET REVIEW AND NO ASSUMED OFFSET.

(a) Review.—The Secretary and Office of Management and Budget shall provide Congress an annual account-level execution report and updated outlay projections. The report shall identify enrollment, award pace, inflation, administrative expense, and material risks.

(b) Scoring.—The Congressional Budget Office and Joint Committee on Taxation may independently assess costs, revenues, mandates, and economic effects. No provision directs them to accept the nominal appropriation total as the complete ten-year score.

(c) Future Financing.—Recommendations for taxes, contribution-base changes, or additional auction receipts shall require subsequent legislation where authority is absent. The agencies shall analyze incidence on households, providers, creators, advertisers, and small businesses. A proposal shall not be described as costless merely because the statutory payer is a large company that may pass some cost to others.

TITLE XXX—CONFORMING PROVISIONS AND FINAL RULES OF CONSTRUCTION

SEC. 3001. RELATIONSHIP TO THE COMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1934.

(a) Supplemental Law.—The duties, rights, programs, and remedies established by this Act are supplemental to the Communications Act of 1934. Except for an express amendment or displacement specified in this Act, that Act, its licensing system, and valid obligations arising under it remain in force. A reference to modernization does not repeal an existing provision.

(b) Express Jurisdiction.—Notwithstanding section 2(b) of the Communications Act of 1934, the Commission may exercise the authority expressly assigned by this Act over covered communications within a State that are part of interstate commerce or substantially affect interstate commerce. This subsection does not transfer general control over local property, local taxation, intrastate services outside this Act, or State governmental organization.

(c) Classification.—An obligation under this Act does not depend on classifying all broadband, streaming, or software functions as telecommunications services, information services, cable services, or broadcasting. Classification under another statute remains relevant to obligations arising under that statute. The same business may perform several separately regulated functions without bringing every function under the most restrictive classification.

(d) No Blanket Forbearance.—An agency may not forbear from an express duty of this Act under a general forbearance provision in another law. A waiver is available only within an express delegation and shall satisfy the conditions, duration, and review requirements attached to that delegation.

SEC. 3002. EXPRESS CONSUMER AND PRIVACY AUTHORITY.

(a) New Authority.—The rulemaking authority over privacy, security, cancellation, billing, consent, and commercial disclosures in this Act is an affirmative congressional delegation concerning the defined covered functions. It does not depend on the continuing validity of an earlier rule adopting similar protections under a different statutory provision.

(b) Prior Disapproval.—Notwithstanding section 801(b)(2) of title 5, United States Code, or any prior resolution disapproving a rule concerning broadband privacy, the responsible agencies may promulgate rules implementing the privacy duties expressly enacted by title XIII. This subsection is the specific statutory authorization for such rules and does not alter the effect of a congressional disapproval concerning unrelated subject matter.

(c) Procedure.—An agency implementing this Act shall comply with applicable notice, economic analysis, small-entity analysis, and judicial-review requirements. The existence of an express substantive delegation does not excuse compliance with a procedural condition. A court's invalidation of a prior rule for procedural error does not by itself resolve the validity of a different rule issued under this Act.

(d) Enforcement.—A violation of a duty imposed directly by this Act may be enforced after its applicable effective date even when a related procedural rule is delayed, if the statutory duty supplies fair notice and can be applied without inventing a missing technical standard.

SEC. 3003. LIMITED AMENDMENT CONCERNING DIGITAL REPLICAS.

(a) Amendment.—Section 230(e) of the Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C. 230(e)) is amended by adding at the end the following:

"(6) DIGITAL REPLICAS. - Nothing in this section shall impair a civil claim expressly authorized by sections 1707 through 1709 of the Digital Life Act for an unauthorized digital replica or a materially false notice or counter-notice concerning such a replica. Such a claim remains subject to the elements, exceptions, limitations, and hosting-service safe harbor in those sections. This paragraph creates no general obligation to monitor information, no claim based solely on a person's decision to decline publication of lawful material, and no exception for a claim that merely relabels an unrelated injury as a digital-replica claim.".

(b) Effective Date.—The amendment applies only to conduct occurring on or after the effective date of sections 1707 through 1709. It does not reopen a final judgment or revive a claim already barred before that date.

(c) Other Protections.—The amendment does not alter the protections of section 512 of title 17, United States Code, for a claim to which that section applies. It does not convert the new personal identity right into ownership of another person's copyright, or eliminate a constitutional defense.

SEC. 3004. BROADCAST OWNERSHIP AND NATIONAL REACH.

(a) Controlling Standard.—Notwithstanding a contrary national television audience-reach limitation or exemption established by section 202 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, a subsequent appropriation provision addressing that limitation, or a Commission rule, the prospective national reach standard and transition in title XV govern transactions and holdings to which that title applies.

(b) Implementation.—The Commission shall revise its rules to reflect the statutory percentage, attribution requirements, treatment of technical distribution methods, and grandfather provisions of title XV. It shall not restore a technology discount that would defeat the statutory method of counting audience reach.

(c) No Collateral Repeal.—This section does not eliminate local ownership review, public-interest review of a transfer, foreign-ownership requirements, competition law, or a valid condition imposed in a completed proceeding. A decision concerning a particular transaction shall apply the controlling law and the evidence in that proceeding.

(d) Prospectivity.—A divestiture required solely by the new national reach standard shall proceed under the express transition provisions of title XV. Nothing directs a retroactive penalty for ownership lawful when acquired or a reopening of a final judicial judgment.

SEC. 3005. POLES RIGHTS OF WAY AND PUBLIC NETWORKS.

(a) Specific Authority.—The obligations concerning poles and attachments under title VII apply to the owners and facilities expressly covered by that title notwithstanding an exclusion from section 224 of the Communications Act of 1934. This expansion does not displace the compensation, safety, certified-State-program, or Tribal protections expressly provided in title VII.

(b) Local Authority.—Except for the specific limitations on discriminatory barriers, unreasonable delay, and exclusionary practices stated in this Act, State and local authority over land use, construction safety, and rights of way is preserved. An agency may not convert a deadline into approval of an application that fails a substantive safety requirement.

(c) Public Providers.—The preemption in section 907 is an express congressional direction concerning State restrictions on local provision of broadband. It shall be read according to its defined scope and shall not be expanded to require a political subdivision to incur debt, operate a network, or accept a grant.

(d) Property.—Nothing authorizes an uncompensated physical taking. A person asserting that a particular access order requires compensation may seek the compensation and review available under applicable law without forfeiting a timely challenge to the order itself.

(a) Existing Rights.—Except for the personal identity right and commercial duties expressly enacted in title XVII, this Act does not amend the exclusive rights, limitations, compulsory licenses, statutory termination rights, or remedial framework of title 17, United States Code.

(b) No Implied License.—A requirement to explain a blackout, provide a refund, export a customer's records, facilitate device repair, or preserve an archive does not itself authorize an otherwise infringing reproduction, public performance, distribution, or circumvention. An agency shall implement the requirement through a lawful method consistent with both statutes.

(c) Access To Records.—Copyright in a record shall not excuse a party from providing accounting information that it is expressly required to provide to a contracting creator, regulator, or court, subject to appropriate confidentiality. This subsection does not authorize general publication of a copyrighted work merely because it was examined in an audit.

(d) Future Recommendations.—Any recommended amendment concerning artificial-intelligence training, collective licensing, retransmission, or preservation shall identify the affected exclusive rights, beneficiaries, compensation method, exceptions, and international obligations. An administrative recommendation has no force of law until enacted or lawfully adopted under existing authority.

SEC. 3007. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND COURT AUTHORITY.

(a) Reviewable Law.—The standards and limits in this Act supply judicially reviewable law. A reference to public interest, reasonableness, or feasibility shall be applied in light of the specific statutory factors and shall not confer unrestricted discretion to alter the basic allocation of rights.

(b) Constitutional Functions.—Nothing prescribes the outcome of a pending case, reopens a final judgment, directs a court to adopt an unconstitutional construction, or authorizes an executive officer to exercise judicial power inconsistent with the Constitution. An agency's interpretation remains subject to the review specified in title XXVII.

(c) Government Speech And Coercion.—The Government may explain this Act and express policy views. It may not evade the prohibition on coercive viewpoint discrimination by describing a threatened licensing or enforcement consequence as advice. Courts shall examine the practical circumstances under the applicable constitutional standard.

(d) Remedial Limits.—A court shall tailor relief to the violation and the parties properly before it, subject to otherwise applicable law. This Act neither requires nor prohibits relief of a particular geographic scope where the governing jurisdictional and remedial statutes leave that question to the court.

SEC. 3008. TECHNICAL CONFORMING REVIEW.

(a) Report.—Within one year after enactment, the Commission, Trade Commission, and Secretary shall jointly submit to the congressional committees of jurisdiction a list of obsolete cross-references, inconsistent terminology, duplicative reports, and administrative provisions for which a technical amendment would improve operation of this Act.

(b) Distinction.—The report shall distinguish a correction that leaves substantive rights unchanged from a policy amendment affecting jurisdiction, eligibility, liability, funding, ownership, or preemption. It shall supply proposed explanatory language for each recommendation and identify any disagreement among agencies.

(c) No Delegated Rewrite.—The report does not authorize an agency to amend an enacted statute, renumber substantive obligations to defeat a cross-reference, change an appropriation, or repeal a right. The Office of the Law Revision Counsel may classify and arrange provisions under its existing authority without changing their substantive effect.

(d) Implementation.—While Congress considers recommendations, agencies shall use lawful interpretive and procedural measures within their authority to avoid unnecessary duplication. They shall not suspend a statutory right solely because they would prefer a different codification.

SEC. 3009. PUBLIC IMPLEMENTATION REGISTER.

(a) Register.—Within 90 days after enactment, the Secretary shall establish a public register identifying each material rulemaking, program launch, report, consultation, and effective date required by this Act. Each administering agency shall verify its entries and provide the responsible office and public docket or program address.

(b) Updates.—The register shall be updated at least quarterly. It shall identify completed actions, approaching deadlines, missed deadlines, judicial stays, and the legal reason for any extension. A missed deadline shall not be recorded as completed because an agency announced an intention to act.

(c) Users.—The register shall provide separate practical guidance for households, small businesses, creators, providers, States, and Tribes, in accessible formats. Guidance shall distinguish a binding statutory duty, a proposed rule, a final rule, and a voluntary model practice.

(d) Legal Effect.—The register is informational. An omission, clerical error, or delayed update does not change an effective date established by law. An agency shall correct a material error promptly and provide reasonable notice to persons foreseeably affected by reliance on its erroneous guidance.

SEC. 3010. REVIEW OF IMPLEMENTATION CAPACITY.

(a) Initial Review.—Within 180 days, each principal administering agency shall identify the staffing, procurement, information systems, adjudicative capacity, and interagency agreements needed to perform its duties. The assessment shall identify functions that can use existing systems and functions requiring a new capability.

(b) Priorities.—The agency shall prioritize statutory deadlines, prevention of material consumer injury, security of benefit administration, and timely deployment of appropriated funds. It shall not spend implementation funds primarily on promotional branding while required application, complaint, or payment systems remain unavailable.

(c) Procurement.—Contracts for administration shall include access controls, audit rights, data portability, transition assistance, and termination arrangements sufficient to prevent dependence on a single vendor. A contractor shall not obtain ownership of beneficiary records or a right to monetize information obtained while administering a public program.

(d) Oversight.—The relevant inspector general may examine implementation readiness and material weaknesses. The agency shall publish a corrective-action schedule without exposing exploitable security details. A deficiency in readiness does not enlarge the agency's substantive authority or excuse an obligation it can lawfully perform.

SEC. 3011. SEVERABILITY.

(a) General Rule.—If a provision of this Act, an amendment made by this Act, or its application to a person or circumstance is held invalid, the remainder and its application to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected, except as provided in subsection (b).

(b) Functional Dependence.—A remedy, penalty, or reporting duty that has no independent lawful object after invalidation of its underlying substantive duty shall not operate independently to recreate that duty. A court shall preserve independently functioning provisions to the maximum extent consistent with congressional intent and the Constitution.

(c) Funding.—Invalidation of one eligibility condition does not authorize an agency to spend an appropriation for an unrelated purpose. The agency shall administer the remaining lawful program if it can do so within the enacted appropriation and statutory allocation. Otherwise, it shall preserve unobligated amounts pending lawful disposition and promptly notify Congress.

(d) No Automatic Revival.—Invalidation of a provision does not automatically revive a superseded agency rule or a provision expressly repealed by another law. The effect of the judgment shall be determined under applicable law and the terms of the judgment.

SEC. 3012. CONTINUING ACCOUNTABILITY AND FINAL EFFECT.

(a) Review Cycle.—At least once every five years, the principal administering agencies shall review whether implementation of this Act is meeting the outcome measures in title XXVI, imposing unnecessary burdens, or leaving a demonstrated statutory objective unmet. The review shall include public participation and independent evidence.

(b) Congressional Choice.—A recommendation for expansion, repeal, consolidation, or additional funding shall identify the legal change required and the consequences of inaction. No recommendation, pilot, advisory vote, or executive directive shall alter a statutory right or appropriation without lawful authority.

(c) No Automatic Sunset Of Rights.—Expiration of a grant appropriation, a pilot, or an agency reporting requirement does not terminate continuing consumer, privacy, accessibility, competition, or expression protections unless the provision establishing that protection expressly states an expiration date.

(d) Effective Date.—Except where another provision specifies otherwise, the general effective-date and transition rules in title XXVIII apply. Administrative preparation, appointments within existing statutory offices, consultation, rulemaking, and establishment of public guidance may begin upon enactment, subject to available appropriations and applicable law.

Research and congressional review annex

This annex accompanies the Digital Life Act model bill. It is explanatory material, not proposed statutory text, and is excluded from the legislative word count. Research was updated through October 9, 2026. The bill is a policy proposal for congressional consideration. It has not been introduced, approved by an office of Legislative Counsel, scored by the Congressional Budget Office, or adjudicated by a court.

Legislative judgment

The draft responds to a recurring structural problem: communications law often regulates technologies and historical industry categories, while households experience one connected set of bills, services, devices, media purchases, and information risks. The Communications Act of 1934 remains the principal statutory foundation. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 amended that foundation and pursued competition and deregulation across formerly separated markets; it did not replace the entire 1934 Act. The proposed Act adds a functional layer of express duties and programs, with limited conforming amendments, rather than attempting a complete recodification of title 47. [R1-R3]

The legislative pattern identified in the preceding research is a cycle of broad statutory language, agency interpretation, judicial challenge, reversal or revision, and targeted congressional intervention. The draft's response is to decide major policy questions expressly: broadband conduct duties, privacy authority, defined digital-discrimination liability, funding ceilings, enforcement routes, and preemption. It preserves the distinction between commercial conduct and editorial expression. This is a drafting inference from the legal record, not a claim that every stakeholder supports the same replacement law. [R4-R9]

Public needs and the limits of the evidence

Deloitte's 2026 Digital Media Trends report draws on an online survey of 3,575 United States consumers conducted in October and November 2025 and weighted to Census benchmarks. Its reported metrics include 41 percent of consumers canceling a subscription video service during the preceding six months. Forty percent of self-identified fans wanted their related content aggregated in one place. These results support attention to switching, clear recurring charges, and fragmentation. They do not establish a public mandate for compulsory aggregation, universal price controls, or any particular appropriation. Titles IV and XVI therefore protect transactions and exit rights while allowing competing business models. [R10]

Pew's local-news fact sheet reports that 80 percent of adults considered local news outlets at least somewhat important to community well-being in its December 2025 survey. Its August 2025 survey found only 12 percent had directly paid or given money to a local news source in the preceding year, while 57 percent believed local outlets were doing at least somewhat well financially. Valuing local information and purchasing it are different measures. The draft chooses limited support for eligible reporting expenses with editorial insulation, but those survey results do not demonstrate majority support for this particular subsidy design. [R11]

Pew's 2023 privacy research found 81 percent concerned about companies' use of collected data and 71 percent concerned about government use. That evidence is older than the media survey and should not be described as a 2026 opinion poll. It supports examining both commercial tracking and government access, rather than assuming the public objects only to one actor. Title XIII pairs commercial minimization and choice with limits on government circumvention of legal process. [R12]

Consumer Reports' 2022 broadband investigation examined more than 22,000 voluntarily submitted bills and documented confusing prices and fees. The submission sample is not a representative estimate of every American's bill. GAO's small-business work separately identified the need to understand actual business connectivity requirements. The draft consequently requires usable total-price and service-level information, specific small-business remedies, and better outcome measurement; it does not convert one study into a universal estimate of market overcharging. [R13-R14]

Availability, subscription, affordability, and effective use remain distinct. Ending a subsidy does not prove that every enrolled household disconnected. Construction funding does not prove that a usable and sustainable network exists. GAO's broadband coordination and sustainability work supports location verification, lifecycle analysis, cost reconciliation, and postconstruction oversight. The household benefit, deployment grants, adoption support, and evaluation provisions address different links in that chain. [R15-R17]

Whose interests are represented

Households receive clearer prices, simpler cancellation, secure switching, outage remedies, privacy rights, accessibility, and a funded low-income connectivity program. These provisions respond to documented barriers, but households differ in willingness to accept advertising, price preferences, media tastes, privacy expectations, and views of government spending. The bill does not claim that "the public" has one position on every tradeoff.

Large network operators receive explicit jurisdiction, notice and review, limits on penalties, protection of confidential information, reasonable compensation for compulsory access, and a technology-neutral deployment framework. They also face substantive restrictions, public obligations, and potential private claims. Industry statements favoring deployment and regulatory stability are evidence of those organizations' positions, not independent proof that a proposed restriction reduces investment. USTelecom, NTCA, and NAB represent different interests; their priorities should not be merged into a single corporate preference. [R18-R20]

Small businesses have at least three roles: purchasers of connectivity and advertising, entrants supplying communications, and creators or sellers dependent on distribution platforms. The draft treats these roles separately. An inexpensive consumer connection may be unsuitable for a business requiring rapid restoration. A rural cooperative may need operating sustainability more than an urban entrant needs construction funding. A creator may value accounting and payment rights without wanting government to dictate recommendation rankings. Title VIII and related provisions address those distinctions.

Media and entertainment companies retain editorial choice, licensing flexibility, legitimate exclusivity, and protection against compulsory publication. Consumers receive rights concerning the commercial promises made to them. Creator provisions address accounting, unauthorized realistic replicas, and contract transparency while preserving copyright questions that require separate treatment. Copyright Office research and the Music Modernization Act framework support treating identity, copyright ownership, licensing, and unmatched royalties as related but legally distinct matters. [R21-R22]

Major policy choices in the draft

The scheduled household benefit is $40 monthly, or $75 on qualifying Tribal lands, with eligibility generally at or below 200 percent of the Federal poverty guideline and specified program pathways. Those amounts and eligibility rules are proposed choices, not outputs of a cost model or demonstrated political consensus. The appropriation is capped, with prospective adjustments when necessary. A benefit designed around enrollment expectations must be tested against likely participation and administrative cost before introduction.

The bill establishes open-internet duties through standalone authority. It does not rely on the validity of the FCC's 2024 classification rule or automatically impose every historical common-carrier obligation. It permits reasonable network management and narrowly bounded specialized services. The Sixth Circuit's 2025 decision is a reason to state congressional authority clearly, not proof that Congress is constitutionally forbidden to regulate broadband. [R4]

The draft chooses a Federal privacy floor, preserving stronger State protections except for expressly displaced requirements. Companies seeking a single nationwide ceiling may oppose that choice. States and consumer advocates may favor it. Counsel should model compliance costs and identify precise conflicts rather than treating either uniformity or State variation as costless.

The national television reach limit is set prospectively at 39 percent without a UHF discount, with grandfathering and transition provisions. This is a new statutory choice. It should not be described as a restatement of the FCC's October 2026 action repealing its national ownership rule. Congress would need a developed record explaining the chosen level, audience measurement, local competition, and reliance treatment. The legal and economic merits of restoring a statutory cap require dedicated hearings. [R23]

The replica right is limited to defined deceptive commercial uses involving a living identifiable individual. It contains expressive exceptions, a hosting safe harbor, notice and counter-notice rules, and a narrow Section 230 amendment. It does not establish ownership of artistic style, resolve the legality of every AI training use, or create a general Federal postmortem identity right. These are deliberate boundaries that an office may revisit after examining creative-industry and civil-liberties evidence. [R21, R24]

The private enforcement scheme requires concrete injury, specifies available remedies, limits duplicative recovery, and permits an election against predispute arbitration for claims under this Act. Civil penalties are sought in court. These choices may improve redress while increasing litigation expense; their expected effects need assessment. Monetary relief is not left to an assumption that general agency powers automatically authorize every remedy. [R8]

Appropriation schedule

The amounts below summarize sections 2902 through 2910. They are nominal direct budget authority, not an official score of outlays, interest, revenues, mandates, or deficit effects. Program year 1 is the first full Federal fiscal year after enactment. No new tax or claimed offset is included.

Appropriation schedule
AccountAnnual amountProgram yearsTotal
Household connectivity$15 billion1-10$150 billion
Connectivity expansion$12 billion1-5$60 billion
Resilience and emergency systems$3 billion1-5$15 billion
Inclusion and accessibility$1.5 billion1-10$15 billion
Public media access$1 billion1-10$10 billion
Local journalism$1.5 billion1-10$15 billion
Workforce and small business$1 billion1-10$10 billion
Research and preservation$0.75 billion1-10$7.5 billion
Administration and enforcement$1.25 billion1-10$12.5 billion
Total$37 billion in years 1-5; $22 billion in years 6-101-10$295 billion

The bill supplies appropriation language rather than merely authorizing later appropriations. That substantially changes budget and procedural consequences. Appropriations and budget counsel should review account availability, rescission interactions, direct-spending classification, applicable points of order, and whether any parts belong in a different legislative vehicle. Existing spectrum receipts already included in another law's score cannot simply be counted again as financing for this Act. [R25]

Constitutional and judicial review priorities

Editorial independence is a governing constraint. Moody v. NetChoice requires attention to the actual functions regulated and the burden on protected editorial judgment. The bill therefore avoids a general duty to carry all lawful speech and separates commercial account administration from ranking and publication. Nevertheless, disclosure, appeal, advertising, and replica provisions may produce difficult applications. A statutory disclaimer does not itself cure a substantive First Amendment defect. [R6]

Children's protection requires specific tailoring. Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton upheld the Texas age-verification law at issue under intermediate scrutiny in the context of sexual material obscene to minors. That decision should not be generalized into approval of mandatory identity verification for every service or every youth-safety rule. The draft emphasizes minimized age assurance, commercial protections, and user controls, while preserving constitutional review of particular applications. [R26]

Administrative authority must be explicit. Loper Bright requires independent judicial interpretation of statutes; policy preferences cannot substitute for a lawful delegation. FCC v. Consumers' Research upheld the universal-service arrangement challenged there, but does not automatically validate every new delegation or private advisory arrangement. The draft supplies factors, ceilings, procedures, and government responsibility for final decisions. [R7, R9]

Court-based penalty proceedings respond to the jury-trial concerns illustrated by SEC v. Jarkesy. The draft also preserves sovereign-immunity limits, ordinary standing, review routes, and proportionality. These provisions are not a guarantee against constitutional litigation. Counsel should examine the interaction between FCC appellate review, district-court enforcement, private claims, emergency orders, and any relevant subsequent procedural decisions. [R8]

Infrastructure access raises property and federalism questions. The draft expressly addresses municipal and cooperative facilities, compensation, local safety review, and public networks, while protecting Tribal consent and sovereignty. Tennessee v. FCC illustrates why a general policy statement is insufficient for some displacement of State restrictions. New express authority still requires analysis of the particular order, property interest, and constitutional claim. [R27]

Privacy rules require attention to prior congressional disapproval. Section 3002 expressly authorizes the new privacy rules notwithstanding the earlier broadband-privacy CRA disapproval. The bill also does not assume that a vacated cancellation rule is currently operative: the Eighth Circuit vacated the 2024 FTC rule in July 2025, and the FTC's rule page identifies a March 2026 advance notice proceeding. The proposed cancellation duties are independently enacted, with new procedural obligations. [R28-R30]

Current initiatives and existing obligations

The proposal should be coordinated with active broadband planning, permitting, satellite, cybersecurity, emergency communications, and youth-protection work. The preceding congressional preview distinguishes introduced, reported, committee-approved, House-passed, and enacted measures. A committee announcement is not enactment, and a bill's status must be refreshed immediately before an office uses its provisions or represents a negotiated agreement.

Existing obligations remain relevant: the CVAA and accessibility standards; the TRACED Act and robocall enforcement; the Broadband DATA Act and mapping; the Martha Wright-Reed Act and incarcerated-person communications; the TAKE IT DOWN Act and intimate imagery; COPPA and its amended rule; ticket-fee rules; and copyright and mechanical-licensing law. This bill preserves those frameworks unless it states a specific change. Its under-18 commercial safeguards should not be mistaken for the current age scope of COPPA. [R22, R31-R38]

Cybersecurity provisions draw on communications-specific hardening guidance and the NIST Cybersecurity Framework, with risk-based controls, incident coordination, and no newly mandated encryption backdoor. Referencing a framework does not make every private revision binding law. Accessibility provisions likewise require practical usability rather than a superficial certification. [R39-R41]

Office routing and introduction work

Office routing and introduction work
WorkstreamPrincipal offices to involveConcrete review product
Communications and broadcastingHouse Energy and Commerce; Senate Commerce; their Legislative Counsel teamsJurisdiction, title 47 amendments, agency authority, implementation schedule
Copyright, antitrust, identity and remediesHouse and Senate Judiciary staffReplica right, Section 230, arbitration, private actions, competition and speech analysis
Spending and administrationBudget and Appropriations staff; CBO; agency budget officesOfficial score, account treatment, staffing needs, points of order
Labor and trainingHouse Education and Workforce; Senate HELP; Labor counselTraining programs, worker protections and existing-law coordination
Tribal lands and public assetsRelevant Natural Resources and Indian Affairs staff; Tribal governmentsConsent, direct eligibility, property rights and sovereign-immunity review
Security and emergency systemsRelevant homeland-security staff; FCC, NTIA, CISA and public-safety expertsIncident reporting harmonization, emergency interoperability and procurement requirements
Revenue alternatives if later proposedWays and Means; Senate Finance; JCTIncidence, tax text and revenue estimates for any separate financing proposal

This routing is an analytical starting point, not an official referral determination. Chamber rules, the final text, and the Parliamentarians determine actual jurisdiction and procedure. A President's role is considered through execution, agency capacity, fiscal administration, and constitutional limits; the bill does not purport to speak for an administration. Judicial analysis tests legal risks and review mechanisms without asserting that judges would approve the result.

Before introduction, the responsible offices should obtain an independent Legislative Counsel conversion and line-by-line conforming review, a current-law and litigation update, CBO and mandate analysis, agency implementation estimates, and structured testimony from households, small firms, creators, providers, disability groups, States, Tribes, libraries, and public-safety authorities. The most consequential unresolved political choices are the appropriation level and financing, Federal privacy preemption, broadcast ownership cap, litigation and arbitration rules, and the precise breadth of the replica right. These choices are expressed in the draft so they can be debated and amended concretely.

Source register

The sources below support the explanatory analysis and informed the policy design. They do not endorse this bill. Survey findings, stakeholder advocacy, judicial holdings, existing statutes, and proposed policy are different kinds of evidence. Statutory text and official opinions are preferred; a reproduced opinion is identified where used. Citations are reference aids and are not incorporated into the operative bill as legal requirements.

[R1] Department of Justice, Communications Act of 1934 overview. Read source

[R2] Telecommunications Act of 1996, P.L. 104-104, enacted text. Read source

[R3] U.S. Code, title 47, chapter 5, 2024 edition. Later enactments require separate checking. Read source

[R4] In re MCP No. 185 / Ohio Telecom Association v. FCC, Sixth Circuit, January 2, 2025. Read source

[R5] Minnesota Telecom Alliance v. FCC, Eighth Circuit, May 6, 2026; opinion reproduced by Justia. Read source

[R6] Moody v. NetChoice, Supreme Court, July 1, 2024. Read source

[R7] Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, Supreme Court, June 28, 2024. Read source

[R8] SEC v. Jarkesy, Supreme Court, June 27, 2024. Read source

[R9] FCC v. Consumers' Research, Supreme Court, June 27, 2025. Read source

[R10] Deloitte, 2026 Digital Media Trends, survey methodology and reported findings. Read source

[R11] Pew Research Center, Local News Fact Sheet, including August and December 2025 surveys. Read source

[R12] Pew Research Center, Views of data privacy risks, personal data and digital privacy laws, October 18, 2023. Read source

[R13] Consumer Reports, broadband investigation, November 2022; voluntary bill sample. Read source

[R14] GAO-21-494, Broadband: FCC Should Analyze Small Business Speed Needs, 2021. Read source

[R15] GAO-25-107207, Broadband Programs: Agencies Need to Further Improve Their Data Quality and Coordination Efforts, April 2025. Read source

[R16] GAO-26-107725, Broadband Deployment: Agencies Should Take Steps to Better Target Underserved Areas and Consider Sustainability, September 2026. Read source

[R17] USAC, Affordable Connectivity Program enrollment and claims tracker. Read source

[R18] USTelecom, Broadband 2025 priorities; industry advocacy. Read source

[R19] NTCA, Federal filings; rural-provider advocacy. Read source

[R20] National Association of Broadcasters, policy priorities; broadcaster advocacy. Read source

[R21] U.S. Copyright Office, Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 1: Digital Replicas, July 2024. Read source

[R22] U.S. Copyright Office, Music Modernization Act implementation. Read source

[R23] FCC, Commission Repeals National Television Multiple Ownership Rule, FCC 26-53, October 2026. Read source

[R24] 47 U.S.C. 230, 2024 edition; conforming amendment baseline. Read source

[R25] CBO, P.L. 119-21 spectrum auction estimate explanation, October 28, 2025. Read source

[R26] Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, Supreme Court, June 27, 2025. Read source

[R27] Tennessee v. FCC, Sixth Circuit, August 10, 2016. Read source

[R28] P.L. 115-22, broadband privacy rule disapproval, April 3, 2017. Read source

[R29] Custom Communications v. FTC, Eighth Circuit, July 8, 2025. Read source

[R30] FTC, Negative Option Rule proceeding, including March 11, 2026 advance notice. Read source

[R31] Twenty-First Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act, P.L. 111-260. Read source

[R32] TRACED Act, P.L. 116-105. Read source

[R33] Broadband DATA Act, P.L. 116-130. Read source

[R34] Martha Wright-Reed Just and Reasonable Communications Act, P.L. 117-338. Read source

[R35] TAKE IT DOWN Act, P.L. 119-12. Read source

[R36] FTC, final amendments to children's privacy rule, January 2025. Read source

[R37] FTC, Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, effective May 12, 2025. Read source

[R38] U.S. Copyright Office, artificial intelligence policy study and reports. Read source

[R39] CISA and partners, Enhanced Visibility and Hardening Guidance for Communications Infrastructure, December 4, 2024. Read source

[R40] NIST, Cybersecurity Framework. Read source

[R41] U.S. Access Board, Information and Communication Technology standards. Read source

Related reading